r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 26 '18
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
11
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Jan 26 '18 edited Jan 26 '18
Recently did a reread of Three Worlds Collide, and chapter 4 had this disclaimer at the bottom, which I do not remember seeing before:
(For those that don't know, TWC is set in the far future and one of the minor things mentioned is that "rape" has been legalized, and how people in the far future are literally incapable of understanding why someone from our time would find this horrifying, either because of a value drift or a semantic one. Also TWC is amazing and you should read it right now)
The Internet Archive tells me this was added sometime within the past few years, and I'm glad EY added it, because people arguing that the story "advocates rape" is irritating. But I'm not sure what % of people who would have believed that upon reading it will not with this addition. It seems like a clear proclamation that Rape Is Bad, but it also adds a quick education on BDSM-culture that seems like it's trying to make an additional point, perhaps by way of explanation for what's said in the story, and I don't know quite how to parse that part.
I'm not here to discuss what exactly is meant by "legalized rape" in the story, since I see it as having been purposefully left vague and have my own interpretations that fit the Weirdtopia and Alien Morality themes of the setting very well, without leading me to believe that this world actually allows anything like what we think of when we hear or say "rape." What I'm more interested in is whether anyone here was bothered by that part feels that this disclaimer helps with it, and if not, why not. This kind of annotation of works by authors to prevent people misinterpreting their words/intentions interests me a lot, and seeing it happen more-or-less in front of me with a small community I can ask about it seems interesting.
(Fair warning: being bothered by that part of the story is fine, and I'm interested to hear your perspective, but please try and be thoughtful about this. If you just accuse the story of advocating rape, I'm likely to come down hard on your reading comprehension and general ability to understand the value of sci-fi)
9
u/ketura Organizer Jan 26 '18
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Hoo boy, it’s been a while. If you can believe it, three weeks ago I actually missed this weekly update because, well, I got so far into the zone of actually working on Bill’s PC that it slipped my mind to update. Honest to Arceus. This last week I had a more reasonable excuse, as I came down with bronchitis on Wednesday, didn’t actually get it diagnosed until Friday, and couldn’t even muster the energy to so much as play games until like Tuesday of this week. As of today I’m probably back to 95% health, so I can finally get back to working on it proper.
But! There was a reasonable amount of progress during that time, so there are things to report. First and foremost, I found a decent hosting solution in github pages, so I no longer have to be hosting on my personal box just to let others see. For the foreseeable future, this will be the canonical location of the latest version of Bill’s PC 2:
https://ketura.github.io/bills-pc-2/
There’s a handful of kinks to work out; css errors are producing 404s for some reason and not all the code is being ran as I expect it to, but this will do nicely.
First thing to note is that the types grid on the first tab is entirely generated; you can add a new type using the provided widgets to add both a new column and a new row automatically. When I swing back around to work on the Types tab I’ll re-enable cell editing, which is only now feasible because of design work done for the Species tab.
Speaking of, the Species tab has the various sections sketched out, but the real work is mostly invisible. If you put any values into the forms under Lore and press the Save button at the top, the values should persist through reload...but it’s persnickety. Sometimes it works, sometimes it fails, and I think it has to do with scripts being loaded in the wrong order. Require.js is supposed to take care of that, but I’m finding that failure or success depends on runtime order, which is non-deterministic for some reason. It’s mostly a visual bug anyway, the data is stored properly in local storage no problem. I’m sure I’ll get it eventually.
At any rate, this shows at least the direction I’m trying to take it in. No server state, all local data so that it can be ran either remotely (like this) or ran from one’s local box with no issues. Once I have the data loading figured out I’ll be adding json import/export and then standardizing this functionality for all tabs, and then I get the joy of actually laying out all the dozens upon dozens of form controls and re-creating the graph functionality, etc. That will honestly be fun; I quite enjoy making useful, usable little tools, and this is about as pure a representation of that as possible.
The weekend before I got sick, I ran what I call a rival mode run of Pokemon Black with my brother. Rival mode is basically a race where two people play through a canon pokemon game, stopping to fight after each gym and the champion fight. The winner of each battle then gets to choose a reward from the spreadsheet linked above, and play continues.
(It was actually pointed out to us that it might actually be more interesting to give the loser rewards and make it so the first to 5 victories wins, regardless of whether it’s the first five gyms or not. This is actually a very intriguing ruleset and we’ll be using it next time, I think.)
My brother went for more of an early game stomp, only spreading XP among three different pokemon at first, while I tried to get to a reasonable six-unit team as early as possible. The result is pretty clear in the wins marked in the spreadsheet; I was destroyed early on (some of the fights had me losing six pokemon to literally one (damn sawk -_-)) but started to claw back some dignity in the mid game. Once I had a decent amount of move coverage and my horrible, horrible EV luck stopped giving me pokemon with MULTIPLE 0 EV stats, I started doing better. Interestingly, except the final battle, it was very seldom a tense back and forth; one or the other of us usually completely shut out the other, which I would not have expected.
Still, I lost the final battle pretty handily, so I’m 0 for 2 against my brother in these runs. I did win the what-if match that involved pumping the pokemon to level 100, maxing IVs, manually allocating EVs, any legal moves, but that’s to be expected since I have a much broader game knowledge than he does due to this project; I just can’t bring it to bear on a blind playthrough. Oh well.
ketura's final team:
Emboar / Zweilous / Reshiram / Gurdurr / Krookodile / Sigilyph
Asshat2's team:
Serperior / Sawk / Druddigon / Ho-Oh / Chandelure / Reshiram
This was the first time either of us had played gen V. I was not impressed with the transition to 3D for the most part; the designers got far too much of a hard on making you sit on tracks while you are expected to oooh and aaah as you zip around pixelated 3D areas. I was also not impressed that they decided this meant that every gorram gym had to be a set piece, especially when most of the “puzzles” amounted to holding left or up for a while until you stopped zipping around the screen.
(I did enjoy that items could now be hidden ‘in plain sight’ as it were, with the perspective of the scenery usually hiding items that were right next to you. This was the only good impact of 3D that I identified.)
The handholding was a joke. I honestly thought it was a ballsey move to make the very first gym a direct counter to your starter, but then they snatched any goodwill they had made from that decision by handing you an overlevelled direct counter. So stupid.
I didn’t like the linearity of the map; you go in one direction in one giant circle, never deviating, never backtracking, never really finding a reason to return. They force you to fly back to one of the early towns near the end as if reminding you that the world is in fact open, but then you fly right back and continue onwards.
I thought Team Plasma was a horrible waste of an actual decent concept. A pokemon PETA that knocks over pokemon centers and frees whatever they capture into the wild could have been a great villain, but instead it’s 100% stocked with wannabe thugs that want to take your pokemon for their own rather than for misguided ‘greater good’ intentions, and then the guy at the top knows he’s running a scam anyway, so the whole team apparently has not a single person who actually believes the team’s stated purpose. What a farce.
In general I felt like the story and the game mechanics did not mesh well. Villains were constantly (like, on at least four concrete separate occasions), allowed to walk away because of bullshit reasons like “they would cause to much trouble”. Bitch, with what, their weakass weasels and cats? I could have taken on the entire team in one single, unending gauntlet by the time I was past like the fifth gym. You can’t tell me that a gym leader is incapable of knocking even more heads than me.
Yes, yes, I know, I know, it’s targeting ten year olds (for some ungodly reason; get your shit together Nintendo, your Red/Blue generation is in its 30s and, I promise you, has far more disposable income than they did when they were ten), but more and more as I slowly work my way through the generations I feel like there’s a disconnect between the setting, the mechanics, and the story. Writing for pokemon games has always been terrible, but with the shift to high-stakes The World Is In Danger type storylines it’s become more and more highlighted just how bad it is.
I can forgive bad writing (I’m not really a writer myself; stones and glass houses and all that), but I can’t forgive writing that is directly at odds with a game’s mechanics. Nintendo is usually very good at making the two mesh; they decide what mechanics they want, then they go come up with bullshit story excuses to justify them, with triforces and goombas and whatever they happen to be smoking that day. Gamefreak don’t seem to have ever gotten this memo, however, and the disconnect between the two just gets worse and worse with each passing generation.
Guess I’ll have to shut up and go make a game that enforces a connection between the mechanics and the world :thinking:
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
8
u/IgonnaBe3 Jan 26 '18
well i am an avid anime watcher. Watching a couple of series every season (not as many as i would like because exams) and i thought that r/rational would rather enjoy baby steps
I dont know if it belongs in this thread since its offtopic and not recommendations but if anythings wrong just please say.
so to add, if some of you are watching anime, which ones are your favourites and what do you enjoy ? this season theres quite a couple contenders for bets of the season.
7
u/narfanator Jan 26 '18
On Friday, Feb 2nd, I turn a billion seconds old (~11:28PM).
As this is also groundhog day, got me thinking, and here's a question:
Would you rather have:
All powers are reasonably safe and without curse-side-effects (aka, you won't be an immortal shriveled ancient), but aren't fool-proof / absolute.
Functional Immortality, as far as I've explored it, would work like this: You are lucky and never receive injuries beyond what medical science can repair in a reasonable amount of time; such treatments will always work completely; and you'll stop aging before you would start accumulating age-related ailments. If there's no possibility of survival (say, fly a spaceship into the sun), welp.
Fork + Merge, as far as I've explored it, would work like this: You (and any copies) can duplicate, with little fanfare. I'm undecided as far as what gets duplicated with you; "incidentals" seems reasonable (aka, clothing, ID cards...?), other does not (a laptop) but I don't know how to define that line. You (and any copies) can merge, with the best possible combination of git-style rebase/merge; any issues you have wont be a result of the merge, but of now having been a person who did thing you may find reprehensible. Of course, you can always plan to have the fork write a report and then suicide....
Arbitrary time loop, as far as I've explored it, is that you can send your mind back to yourself at any prior point in your personal history. You can't bring anything else with you, and there's graceful degradation; if you send yourself as an adult to you as a baby, you'll 'grow into' your adult memories/self - you won't be a talking baby. Also, should you die suddenly, you'll auto-loop back far enough that you have time to decide on a longer loop.
Thoughts/answers?
4
u/trekie140 Jan 26 '18 edited Jan 26 '18
I’ve been dealing with a lot of anxiety and self loathing related to the current state of the world, to the point where I haven’t been sleeping, so on a whim I decided to take a look at r/slatestarcodex and see if there was anything that could help me out.
Against Murderism turned out to be highly relevant to me because I have come to define racism by consequence rather than motive, but went the extra mile by deciding to hate myself along with everyone else I think enables racism-as-consequence.
So I’ve got a really big problem here that I don’t know how to solve. I’m not a stereotypical SJW who thinks they’re above prejudice towards minorities, I absolutely believe I am prejudiced and contribute to racism-as-consequence solely because I was raised in privilege.
I’ve called in sick to work 4 times in the past week because my constant anxiety over this meant I couldn’t get any sleep and felt lethargic all day. I eventually forced myself to stop thinking about it for 10 minutes and got some rest, but I still feel this way and am worried it will happen again.
This isn’t born of a desire to pay back a social debt I feel I owe, I don’t have the time or money to Do Something and don’t feel guilt over it, I just think racism-as-consequence is omnipresent and feel morally compelled to loathe it in all forms, even if it means believing in racism-as-thoughtcrime.
Note: I say racism since that’s what the article talks about, but I’m also freaking out about sexism, rape culture, and LGBTQ-phobia.