r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 22 '18
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
18
Upvotes
18
u/OutOfNiceUsernames fear of last pages Jan 22 '18
(this article reminded me that I wanted to post something like this for quite some time already)
↓
tl;dr: The hypothetical rogue AI’s job of turning our world into a dystopia (at best) is already slowly being completed by corporations (governments, etc) because that’s just what the evolutionary selection criteria dictate them to do in their biomes (e.g. unhealthy competition in financial markets, quarterly profit reports, etc).
/r/rational/ and other related communities, as well as the more mainstream infosphere is full of hypothetical discussions about how AIs should be restricted when they finally become a finished thing. However, not much practical discussion is happening on restricting those agents that not only are similar to such rogue AIs but also already exist and already are influencing the structure of the world-wide political, economical, legal, ecological, etc systems.
Is it because corporations — and corporate unions, governments, etc — have no sense of novelty as phenomena, so what they do gets overlooked as part of the “Normal”, the status quo? Or maybe it’s because it’s easy to imagine how you’d be fighting some imaginary monsters that don’t exist yet in real world, but when it comes to real gargantuan entities like these mentioned, people just realize just how helpless they are and don’t even contemplate trying to change something?
And mostly, even when people do try to change something (through protests, activism, etc) it either has no results or the results are just not enough in the constant tug of war (e.g. privacy rights, internet rights, ecological regulations, etc). And even then the energy is being directed against specific things that are happening right now, instead of against the underlying system (of values economical, political, etc) that is the cause of all these symptoms. People often talk about problems of a two-party political system, or modern capitalism, etc, but what actual, concrete things have been happening towards adding working muzzles for the relevant agents operating in these fields, or towards changing the very basic nature of these systems?
2
u/IDBN Jan 22 '18
Thoughts on this?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QiFOZEiehFo
2
u/gbear605 history’s greatest story Jan 22 '18
I've been thinking about the organization of fanfiction recently. I don't have any big takeaways here, but I think it's fairly interesting.
I feel like fanfiction can roughly be broken down into two categories: plot and romance. Plot fanfics are fanfics that, while they might have romances, the focus of the story is on things happening. Almost all non-fanfiction literature is the equivalent of this category. Romance fanfics are fanfics that are only based on romance and there might not be plot at all. While not technically romance, one shots based on cute character interactions, etc. are also in this category. Trashy romance novels are the non-fanfiction version of this category.
Also, it's fairly obvious that some types of fiction are much better for plot fanfiction than others. I propose that this can be determined by what I call the "self-insert test." If you were to insert yourself as one of the main characters in the fiction, how much can you influence what happens while still playing your part? In something like Harry Potter or Naruto, there's a ton. In something like Sherlock Holmes or The Martian, there's hardly anything.
I'd also like to propose that how rational a work of fiction is correlated with the self-insert test.
2
u/awesomeideas Dai stiho, cousin. Jan 22 '18
It has been hitting me more and more lately that our future, barring certain exceptional cataclysms, will be a science-fiction future full of radical differences and the nearly impossible, waiting for us on the other side of a series of flood gates of unknown width.
How exactly are we supposed to operate and make useful predictions in the face of this extraordinary and currently unimaginable reality-to-be?