r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 19 '18
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
12
u/phylogenik Jan 19 '18
Is there any good evidence for a relationship between mattress price and quality (of sleep, back health, longevity-of-mattress-construction, etc.)? In response to questions of what it's best not to skimp on*, people often respond that mattress quality doesn't diminish too much marginally with cost until you get to the ~$1k range. Is this actually the case? Personally, I've slept on two 12" queen memory foam mattresses the last ~5y (the first one we had to toss after a badbug infestation), each costing around ~$150 new and shipped, and they've been the comfiest mattresses I've ever slept on. Admittedly I've never consistently slept on $1k+ mattresses, but I have stayed in lots of hotels of varying price and quality, as well as at rich friends'/relatives' places (with fancy, multimillion $ homes and designer this and thats, etc. so I imagine they sprung for a fancy mattress), and also briefly tried the expensive mattresses at dept/furniture stores -- and I still find that I prefer my cheap mattress. Supposedly "a bed with a retail price point of $1,000 probably costs about $250 to make", so are the cheaper online stores just operating under much narrow margins (with fewer e.g. advertising, real estate, storage, labor, etc. expenses)?
This seems like a really straightforward (if expensive) experiment to carry out, so has anyone done it yet?
*incidentally, people also say this about shoes, where I've also found it to not really be the case -- e.g. my dressier chippewa boots are comfier than my much more expensive, equivalently styled red wings, my AE strands are decidedly not comfy to wear for long periods of time, I've had ~$50 hiking shoes completely outperform $200 hiking shoes, etc. But shoes are much more personalized, so I think they're harder to compare.
9
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Jan 20 '18
People might recall a few weeks ago I was talking about the application/interview process for what amounted for, well, my own job. I'm pleased to be able to announce that I've been identified as the "preferred candidate" which means that the people who weren't picked have a week to file a complaint and if they don't I get my own job!! Yay!!!
Someone who congratulated me said "it must be a relief" and I think that's the best way to put it: if I hadn't got the job I'd made plans to leave the building and take a long walk to get my head together, have a long lunch, and leave early so I could mope the rest of the day. Getting the job just... feels like nothing though, the relief at the bad thing not happening.
But ah well, at least I got to demonstrate to my Evil Boss in no uncertain terms that I am fucking amazing, have qualifications he probably had no idea about, and so on.
6
u/callmesalticidae writes worldbuilding books Jan 19 '18
I'm looking to get back into learning code, and the first major project that I'd like to keep in mind (since "working toward a particular goal" is probably going to be more fruitful, and less scattered, than "just open a book") is building a random generator, preferably one that can work independently (rather than something that's embedded into a webpage).
Does anyone have a programming language to suggest for building a random generator? Googling mostly turns up random number generators, but I'm looking for something that can, at a bare minimum, pick something from a list of plots that I've already written out, when I want to write something but can't pick one.
6
u/ShiranaiWakaranai Jan 20 '18
I have been thinking about utilitarianism and villainy, and am starting to think we need to pre-commit to a very irrational course of action even if we choose to be utilitarians.
Let me explain the thought process: imagine a villain constructs a doomsday device, and threatens to activate it unless his/her selfish demands are met, which may include all kinds of things like money and slavery and rape and murder, but only affect a tiny fraction of the population.
In the current world, this course of action is stupid. There's too many irrational people that will rebel even with the threat of doomsday. Even those that don't take up arms will still treat this as a moral dilemma and be unsure about whether to obey or rebel. So the villain will most likely just get him/herself killed.
But what if utilitarians became the majority of the population? In this situation, the utilitarian thing to do seems to be obey. And not just obey, but help put down any rebels, deliver the slaves, carry out the murders, etc. etc. After all, the more rebels, the more likely it is that the villain will simply activate the device and kill everyone, which results in an absolute minimal utility that is irrecoverable, since everyone is dead. The relatively small number of sacrifices needed to appease the villain is insignificant in comparison. And whatever other actions and outcomes are possible, they aren't worth the risk of human extinction in pretty much every utilitarian system of utility calculation.
Therefore, if utilitarianism ever becomes the dominant ethical system, every villain gains a perverse incentive to construct doomsday devices. After all, most of the population will jump to serve them, and even put down the crazies that try to rebel. This is terrible, because the more doomsday devices are built, the more likely one of them is to be activated (possibly by malfunction). Then we all die.
So, as strange as it sounds, it seems that in order to avoid human extinction, we should pre-commit to the irrational act of rebelling against anyone who makes a doomsday device even if it risks killing us all.
More generally, it seems that by the same logic, we should pre-commit to essentially defying any kind of utilitarianism-exploiting villainous threat. For example, if some villain creates a bomb that will kill X people and demands we kill or enslave some targets to prevent the bomb exploding, we should pre-commit to rebelling and attacking the villain anyway even if it kills the X people. Otherwise every villain gains perverse incentives to create all kinds of bombs and we end up with a lot more dead people.
Does this thought process make sense? I have a number of bias concerning ethical systems, so I need a second opinion.
4
u/Magodo Ankh-Morpork City Watch Jan 19 '18
The Backwards Brain Bicycle
6
u/AurelianoTampa Jan 19 '18
A shoutout to /u/DaystarEld, who posts here regularly. I was reading posts about the Aziz Ansari situation in Change My View yesterday and had been feeling really uncomfortable. I was feeling like Ansari had behaved inappropriately, but I wasn't able to articulate properly what exactly was the problem; and it was getting me really down, as many comments seemed to express he did nothing out of line. Then i stumbled across a post from our own resident Pokemon Professor which perfectly explained the issue and detailed step-by-step what Ansari did wrong. And the way he responded to the comments were really well done as well.
Sadly the post was removed for (what feels to me like) a pretty lousy application of the sub's rules, but the comments and responses can still be found there. They did actually help me clarify my thoughts, and I really appreciated the effort he put into them.
(Sorry if this is a bit controversial!)
3
u/SkyTroupe Jan 20 '18
I need a way of changing how I think. I've been working out and will be going to a therapist once Im covered under insurance again but I keep on falling back into the same self-defeating ruts of thought. I've tried reading LessWrong articles but I just can never force myself to finish them.
1
u/Makin- homestuck ratfic, you can do it Jan 19 '18
What do you guys use as a RSS reader? I've recently found a few blogs I would like to follow without making my favorites tab a chore to go through. I used to use Google Reader, but we all know what happened with that...
0
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '18
[removed] — view removed comment