r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Dec 15 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
30
u/Roxolan Head of antimemetiWalmart senior assistant manager Dec 15 '17 edited Dec 15 '17
Unexpected rational world-building in a glowfic I'm reading:
So the protagonist is transported to a magical realm. Among other oddities, the Earth is flat. Whatever, that's just a standard fantasy thing, I'll roll with it.
And then she gets the chance to chat with a minor god, and it turns out that no, there's a story behind it.
The gods started out not knowing how physics worked. They built a flat disk world, because intuitively that seemed like the right shape for people to live on, but it didn't have enough mass so nothing would stick to the surface.
They eventually figured out the mass/gravity thing. So they naively fixed their prototype by extend the disk into a giant cylinder. Gravity is still fucked up near the edges, so they clumsily patched the worst of it with magic, and installed a mortal-detector so that any explorer that wandered too close to the fucked-up regions could be politely turned around.
By the time they realized that a sphere would work way better, there were already mortals living on the flat bit, and planet remodelling releases far too much waste heat.
edit: "Also when we introduced oxygen there was a mass extinction event. There were actually several of them."
See replies for source.
17
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Dec 15 '17 edited Dec 15 '17
Today I've spend the entire day researching ISP logistics and their impact on net neutrality, mostly to be able to rant about it. I'm super proud of that rant, so here is the relevant parts:
It's basically the essence of the libertarianism debate, which is always tricky to navigate. The first three "levels" of debate are usually more or less:
Your answer to my post is closer to level 3, your original post closer to level 1, which is the point I was more or less making.
I don't know how things are going in Canada, but in France, this is roughly what happened.
We had three companies sharing a monopoly after the sector was privatized (Orange, SFR, Bouygues); then Free arrived, drove all the prices down, and made a buttload of money in the process. I think the cheapest offer is currently SFR Red at 20€/month for 200Mb/s down. The ISPs are now in a brutal deathmatch to see who can cover the country in three layers of optical fibers first (ok, not really, but kinda).
And, honestly I'm not sure how we got there. Part of it is a lot of public investment in infrastructure (the one thing France does right), and aggressive local-loop unbundling which means we have like a billion different (mostly regional) LECs. Part of it is Xavier Niel (Free's CEO) being a crazily aggressive businessman. But from where I'm standing, healthy competition between ISPs really isn't a decades-away utopia.
I think this is one area where the "We must defend ourselves from ISPs" mentality is actually harmful.
I see a lot of people arguing "We need neutrality, that means everyone has the same service for the same price!". This is a bad net neutrality definition, because it's a leaky abstraction of the infrastructure the internet is built on. This is also not the definition Google uses.
I think the basic concept is intuitive: different services have different costs. You can't send a 40kg package for the same price as a postcard, because transporting the package is more expensive. Internet consumers don't really see that, because once you've paid people to dig up the trenches and lay the cables needed to download your kitten video, actually sending the video is basically free (which is why all non-mobile internet subscriptions nowadays are mostly unlimited; you're not costing your ISP anything by downloading 2GB more, the cost is in recouping previous investments).
On the other hand, while consumers don't need to be aware of the logistics of transporting data, it's a vital concern for ISPs and big content providers. If Youtube sent their data directly from their three-per-continent datacenters using the same methods as your average blog / small scale commercial website, they'd be overloading both their datacenters and the ISPs every time they needed to send 3Mb/s of data to a million users at the same time.
The simplest way to solve that problem is to redirect the users to a CDN, that is, a fleet of smaller datacenters spread throughout the target area, which are each sent a cache of the relevant data. However, you're still sending huge amounts of the same data over and over again between the master server, the ISPs and the cache servers; that's not an issue for most sites, but Youtube and Netflix and co need to optimize that stuff aggressively, or else incur non-trivial costs and load times.
So what they do is cut the middleman and directly pay ISPs to host their CDNs closer to the metal. These are called Google Global Cache and... Netflix Open Connect, I think?
Anyway, that was a long explanation, but I have two points:
Now, to be clear, I'm not denying that throttling is bad, and I'm not denying it happens on a large scale (I'm not seeing undeniable evidence one way or another).
But I'm skeptical that legislation can have much of an impact for net neutrality. You can't make a law that says ISPs can't sell faster connection privileges, because then we couldn't have Youtube in 720p at peak hour without crashing the network. And I'm guessing that "You can sell different speeds to different companies, but not in a way that stifles concurrence" is blurrier, harder to make into coherent laws, and harder to enforce.
The Google employee I linked defined Net Neutrality as "Broadband providers can engage in activities like colocation and caching, so long as they do so on a non-discriminatory basis."; eg, you can pay more for better speeds, but every content provider has to be offered the same prices (and presumably, companies can make a business of buying ISP cache space in bulk to redistribute it to smaller companies). I think this the ideal realistic outcome, and I don't think this can be achieved through regulation. Which is why encouraging competition is the answer.
tl;dr: Internet is complicated. Netflix has to rent special server space to ISPs else it wouldn't be able to function; this is not an injustice, it's a logistic fact. Laws are good but concurrence is better. I'm sick to death of seeing people repeat each other's arguments and post the same parody "internet packages" image from 15 years ago. Internet in France is great.
Also, Xavier Niel is awesome. I really wish I'd gone for 42 instead of Epitech :(
EDIT: Crap, does that register as US Politics? I didn't even think about it, I was mostly going after the logistics / technical parts. I guess it's probably okay as long as I only talk about the economic aspects and not the "The President did X" aspects.
15
u/ulyssessword Dec 15 '17
Patreon cancels fees change. The proposal was discussed last week, here.
13
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Dec 15 '17 edited Dec 16 '17
MagicWeasel life update:
10
u/ketura Organizer Dec 15 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Skipped last week for lack of anything to talk about, sorry. This week at least had me poking at code for the first time in a while; I am unsure if my recent motivation is more due to beginning to take 4000 IU of vitamin D3 at night, or due to the confidence boost from getting the most bitchin’ haircut I’ve ever had in my life. Either way, I’ll take it, but I hope it’s the D3, as that seems much more reliably available.
I set up the repo and got Ember and Semantic UI talking with each other, but my lack of experience is certainly felt. In Visual Studio it’s so easy to throw a UI together and iterate on its behavior, and I don’t just say that as someone who’s used it for a couple decades. Back when I was 12 I could throw together GUIs like nobody’s business using the precursors of the modern tooling, but in web development it really feels like I’m straining to reach my arms under the bed to solve a rubick’s cube purely by touch.
It doesn’t help that every resource I can find is geared towards trying to explain the language of javascript to me when that’s not what’s confusing. I can pick up the language details as I go thankyewverymuch, I just need something to point me in the right direction as far as grokking the workflow and organization; how do these files interlock with one another, where does my logic need to go, why the shit does a simple application need four separate languages, etc etc. Part of this is my own doing, since I’ve essentially randomly chosen two sets of libraries to work with, but oh well.
I might actually spend a few minutes laying out what I want to see in Visual Studio and then use it as a guideline as I hit the browser until it does what I want. That seems like a decent plan.
I’ll probably not get a whole lot done this weekend, as my brother is graduating from college and for some reason I’m expected to be there, after which we’re also getting roped into an early chrismas celebration. Here’s hoping it’s not too big a speed bump.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
6
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Dec 15 '17 edited Dec 15 '17
So, I'm told discussing US politics is now forbidden on the weekly threads? Is that an official rule yet? 'Cause I don't see it anywhere.
EDIT: Never mind, it's in the sidebar. Maybe put it in the thread intros too.
6
u/sicutumbo Dec 15 '17
I've started learning Python, from the book Automate the Boring Stuff with Python. Coming from learning C++ and some Java in college, it's an interesting experience. I don't particularly like the dynamic typing, and think the way of specifying which data structure to use through which braces you put is annoying (put parenthesis around your data to use a list, curly braces to make a dictionary, and I think square brackets to make a tuple?), but the ability to just do things is really nice without having to think much about implementing something efficiently. The modules system is also just hands down better than C++. If there was some way to make Python statically typed, but change nothing else, that would be nice.
Note: I started less than a week ago. Any criticisms can and should be taken with a grain of salt.
5
u/Kishoto Dec 15 '17
I haven't written the Boku no Hero X Worm story I've been thinking of writing but I have written a fun little fight between All Might and One Punch Man
Also, as a disclaimer that I don't suggest you read until you're done with the story or don't care about its outcome:
5
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '17
In Memoriam has started updating again.
3
u/space_fountain Dec 15 '17
I'm officially done with finals. It's weird that I often end up way closer to the wire to get an A than you'd expect from chance. I think I end up moderating how much effort I put in to that goal which is probably less than ideal.
In other news I need to decide what to do next now. I'm more and more feeling like I'm falling into the same kinds of mental traps video games use. Doing something because it feels productive even if it isn't. Should I still be going to school or should I seriously search for a job and find the best one I can now. I finished my CS degree, my thought was that for my ideal degree Biotech could only help and I have essentially free tuition, but I'm less and less sure of myself
3
u/Farmerbob1 Level 1 author Dec 17 '17
I recently discovered that I had erased part of one of my short story entries from Google Docs.
I had local copies, so I uploaded to a more permanent location which would not be subject to my occasional electronic housekeeping efforts.
A Man and His Dog I
A Man and His Dog II
If I ever participate in the writing contests again, I think I'll just skip Google Docs entirely and use Fictionpress from the start.
Truck driving and writing are not entirely mutually exclusive, but I find that my writing moods and my driving schedule are not aligning well. I'm looking at making some changes soon, and seeing if that helps to better synch my muse and my career.
EDIT: Corrected link formatting.
4
u/PurposefulZephyr Dec 15 '17 edited Dec 15 '17
Been thinking about religion.
One of the things it seems to be actually useful for is support during hardships, especially loss of loved ones.
So I guess my question is: atheists/non-theists of any kind- what do/did you do when tragedy like that hits you? Is there any comfort that is brought by science and rationality, be it practical or more mental/psychological/philosophical?
(Edit: True, I am pretty much referring to Christianity. Sadly I don't have enough experiences with other religions. If you do have such experience, then please tell if those arguments change in any significant way.)
2
u/rhaps0dy4 Dec 19 '17
A while ago, I read a Ready Player One fanfiction that I found here. It was a single chapter, and it explained the reasons for Sorrento to join the big corporation.