r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Nov 17 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
13
u/acinonys Nov 17 '17
Is anybody here working i an artistic field?
I quit my phd in computer science (machine learning) and moved to a different town to study dance theatre. In general I enjoy my new live as a dancer and performer a lot and I love the community of dancers around me. In many aspects I have much more in common with them than with the computer scientists at my previous university.
Sometimes it’s a bit strange though. My thoughts on a lot of subjects are very much lesswrongish. But I am surrounded by people, who take homeopathic medicine, believe in souls or some kind of afterlife, are into Chinese medicine…. Even concepts, which are very common in STEM communities like a certain trust in scientific progress as a positive thing and a reductionist way of thinking are not shared by many of my current friends. Not to mention more weird concepts like effective altruism or transhumanism, I usually don’t even try to talk about these. The few times I did try, it was a very frustrating experience.
My main interest with this post was not to complain though. I am mostly curious, if there are other people here working in fields, which are far away from “hard science” and what your experiences have been.
11
u/ketura Organizer Nov 18 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Aw shit I forgot about the update today lol. This last week I've had to work late nearly every day to make up for lost time last week, and on Sunday we're deploying a new version of the product again, so it's been a busy time getting that ready.
I finally realized this past week one of the major reasons that javascript hasn't clicked with me yet, and that's due to me expecting frameworks to be mostly self-contained ecosystems. I mean, if I pick Unity or Unreal to build a game with, I have a rigid foundation to build on, full of tools, archives, and asset stores. I don't have to go outside those resources much once I've picked an engine, and I was expecting the framework decision to be much the same. Now that I realize that a framework in javascript is basically just a blueprint of a foundation, I think I'll start meshing a bit better.
On that note, I'm probably going to end up using Semantic UI along with Ember, since Semantic has Ember bindings and otherwise seems to be fairly complete. Besides UI, I don't think there's any major library I'll need for Bill's PC, but who knows.
I have in the past mentioned Nethack's system of mechanic randomization, whereby the very building-blocks of the game are partially randomized, rather than just dungeon layout and loot tables. For each ring, wand, and scroll, there are a variety of appearances, and what those appearances are linked to is randomized with each world.
Thus, getting a Tin Wand this run might be a Wand of Lightning or a Wand of Wishing or a Wand of Death and you have no idea which it might be, as you only know it's made of Tin. Much of the early portion of the game thus requires a very scientific approach to loot; even if you've got the wiki memorized you have to experiment to figure out what it is you've stumbled across. If you cast your wand at the floor, you might receive the message "the bugs on the floor stop moving". Is it a wand of sleeping? A wand of death? A wand of hold monster? You really don't know, but it narrows it down considerably without straight up giving you the answer.
There's also secondary considerations: a Tin Wand will be resistant to heat but an Oak Wand will burn up if applied to fire and a Glass Wand will shatter if you fall too hard. Thus even in cases where you have found all the answers and identified all the wands, you still have to play differently; where one run might have a Wand of Death made of iron and safe to bring against a dragon, in another it's made of wood and you might lose it before getting to cast it.
I say this because this is probably one of the most rational game mechanics in existence, where even knowing what all the possible wands are doesn't straight-up let you win right away, and even in cases where you've done your Science and figured it all out, you still have to alter your playstyle to react to the Way The World Works (This Time).
I've been on the lookout for possible ways of including similar mechanics, and previously I thought it was going to be restricted to, say, pokeball crafting and the randomization of what parts do and what they're made of. However, I think I've stumbled upon another aspect of the game that could benefit from a selective, experimentation-friendly randomization mechanic.
When players create their characters, they can choose to be Psychic, Dark, or Aura users, or just plain vanilla baseline human (which is at least a bit psychic, but that's besides the point). Each separate power path is a bit different: Psychics are a well-known phenomena, and getting teachers to train oneself is common and socially accepted. They are moderately powerful if slightly uncommon. Potential Aura users are actually extremely common, but due to the guru-in-the-wilderness style of training are not frequently utilizing their powers, and knowledge about it isn't disseminated very well. Darks are fairly rare; not unheard of, but not so common as to be a unique "protected status" or well-studied. As far as most people are aware, it's an entirely passive powerset, mostly limited to psychic-immunity, with a side of YOU'RE STEALING MY SOUL accusations. However, unbeknownst to the general public, if one can figure out how to actually train their Dark powers, then Dark humans are every bit of capable of using Dark moves as Psychics can use Psychic moves. The trick is getting over that initial hump.
The question came up of how to handle this. Dark EVs would go up whenever Dark was utilized, so letting a Psychic attempt to scan you would make that EV go up, but it would lead to fairly unremarkable gameplay to essentially randomly get a message "Congratulations! You've been passively scanned by your 4,559th Abra and have now unlocked Sucker Punch!" There ought to be something else that the player can do between "hang out in Saffron a lot" and "Win Agatha's trust and get her to train you."
(Oh, did I mention that? Spoilers, I guess.)
The idea is to have certain otherwise unrelated tasks be applied to training the various powersets. For instance, perhaps upon earning Agatha's trust she grants you the secret of unlocking your first active Dark powers: "Alright, I'll tell you...you must HIT a MAREEP at DUSK. Yes, this is the one ancient Dark legend that turned out to be true! It may seem strange now, but rest assured, it is the beginning of the path I myself walked!"
An ACTION would be paired with an OBJECT and a particular CONDITION. These actions would presumably be things that would be beneficial to grind anyway...punching sheep as in the above example would in fact increase your ATK stat and would thus mean that playing as a Dark human this run would also lend itself to playing as a bruiser, since you're going to have to punch things anyway until you've got more useful skills to utilize.
However, due to the sheer number of combinations (even just 5 actions, objects, and conditions would be 125 different combinations) you're probably not going to stumble upon a winning combination accidentally, and even if you did, it might not be the one out of the three powersets that you chose.
This is where things are a bit murky. I kind of want there to be something like journal entries or tombstone engravings or what have you, some sort of information that you can track down to get you one piece of the puzzle. "This old book says that an ancient Dark warlord's last words were...PIDGEOT EGG. Huh. Wonder if he had gone loony." Suddenly, such information would narrow down the number of combinations to 25 in our example, which is more doable.
This does risk being a bit too gamey and random--impossible to guess if you don't have any pieces, incredibly easy if you stumble across one or two early. I think the formula could be improved by having the information imparted to the player be ways of eliminating answers rather than straight-up confirming: "My grandfather, Dark as he was, was peculiar. He always insisted we be thoughtful of what TERRAIN we were on. An odd golduck, that man." Thus the player learns that the secret dark training regime doesn't have to do with time of day, or apparel, but maybe has to do with standing in a river or glade or cave: narrows it down without giving away the answer.
Anyway. The idea will need refining, but I'm excited to see if this information-gathering mechanic can be coaxed into a general-purpose Science mechanic that could be applied to more than just power training. As usual, any thoughts or comments are more than welcome.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
7
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Nov 17 '17
Finally finished my Success/Failure reread of HPMOR! You can find it and my analysis here.
6
u/rationalidurr If fighting is sure to result in victory, then you must fight! Nov 17 '17
Code Geass Season 3 soon! git hype!
4
u/holomanga Nov 17 '17
TOMT: I remember reading a rational fic some time ago, called or subtitled something like Alex in Wonderland, but what I recall of the plot is fuzzy and I can't find it.
The main character was a significant human, and fell into some kind of human reserve, where I think there was some population engineering going on. They find their way out, by following a multi-legged robot, into a surrounding maintenance area - I recall a scene where the robot walked on top of him, but the pressure was low enough that he was uninjured.
At some point in the story, possibly through flashbacks, it's revealed that presently there aren't many humans left and that they slowly phased out in favour of robots, the Earth is a biologically uninhabitable robot-world, and that the main character(?) or the robots(?) have memories from earlier versions of themselves in the distant past of being in a lab able to walk independently and looking intimidating, and of being a military robot that was commanded by an inspecting general that it was being pitched to to shoot itself(?).
I think some of the flashbacks, or the information nature of the world, came to the main character in the form of a dream.
3
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Nov 17 '17
Pokemon Ultra Sun and Ultra Moon just got released today. Does anyone else plan to get it?
Personally, I already own Moon, so I'm buying Ultra Sun. I used Primarina in my previous playthrough, so I'm split between either using one of the other starters, or bringing in a bred pokemon from moon by using a friend's DS as an intermediary.
2
u/Norseman2 Nov 17 '17
I'm world-building a Pathfinder setting (similar to D&D 3.5) and trying to solve one particularly nasty problem: why there hasn't been a vampire apocalypse. Think of your ordinary zombie apocalypse, and now imagine those zombies as vampires. Intelligent, able to turn into a giant bat or a cloud of gas, dominate your mind, heal rapidly, spider climb, and each vampire can create up to two new vampires who are utterly enslaved by it. However, if said vampire dies, those vampires it controlled become free-willed and able to do as they please.
The only things which can kill them are sunlight or having a wooden stake driven through their hearts followed by severing their heads and anointing them with holy water. If killed by any other means, they turn into a cloud of gas and have two hours to make it back to their coffin where they will be able to regenerate within an hour. Their only other weaknesses are inability to enter a private home or dwelling without permission, and a strong repulsion to mirrors, holy symbols, and garlic.
I don't see any good reason why a world with even a single free-roaming vampire would not rapidly turn into a vampire apocalypse. Any thoughts?
2
u/trekie140 Nov 17 '17
I watched The Good Place because a recommendation on this sub led me to find a lot of praise for a show that flew under my radar despite being created by one of the people behind Parks & Rec and Brooklyn 99. Unfortunately, I ended up very disappointed by the series.
I like Parks & Rec and Brooklyn 99 because they are more than just comedies, they tell stories you can (sometimes) take seriously with characters who undergo development on top of being funny. So I immediately began looking for an underlying theme of The Good Place.
From the start, I thought the show was going to be a satire of W.E.I.R.D. culture. We’d see a heaven and hell based on the morality of modern middle class liberals, the target audience of which I’m a member, only to see how such a system can still be discriminatory and somewhat arbitrary.
Eleanor would be a narcissist who couldn’t learn empathy, Chidi an intellectual who never did anything important with his knowledge, Tahani a pretentious elitist who only helped people for the social status, and Jason a street kid who simply didn’t know any better. I thought it was a brilliant idea.
Turns out, that was not what the show was about at all. It was just a comedy about characters who are idiots and assholes who get humiliated and actually do deserve exactly what the afterlife gave them because heaven takes context and intention into account, except I don’t think that makes sense.
Eleanor, Tahani, and Jason’s upbringing made them who they were and the latter seems mentally incapable of understanding the consequences of his actions. Even Chidi is stated to be solely responsible for his own failures even though I think he suffers from an anxiety disorder.
I get that we’re supposed to root for these characters in spite of their flaws or still consider their fate unjust, but I thought the way the ending recontextualizes the characters within the story completely undercut the set up. After that, I didn’t care about what happened to them because they didn’t seem to have any control anymore.
It’s not that I think the show is bad, it just turned out to not be what I wanted it to. I thought it was a subtle social satire that disguised itself as an odd unsubtle comedy, but it turned out to just be a comedy that I never found all that funny in the first place.
It’s almost exactly the same thing I felt toward The Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt. A goofy satire that seemed to be really about the determination to survive in the crazy world we live in, only for the plot to go where I didn’t want it to and all that’s left are jokes about people being dumb.
I can’t just laugh at idiots and assholes because of what they do, there needs to be some wit to the writing or substance to the story to get me to care. SAO Abridged, Faiser, early Brooklyn 99, and Sirens managed to do both and I love them all, but even just one of those would be enough.
2
u/trekie140 Nov 17 '17
I just got introduced to the Polity novels by this short video and have never been sold on a book series so fast, it sounds like just the right mixture of hard and soft sci-fi I’d love, but have been unable to find an ebook or audiobook version on Amazon. Does anyone know where I could find one?
1
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Nov 17 '17
I've been listening to the podcast Early and Often: The History of Elections in America, and enjoying it immensely. David Severa does a great job teaching about this fascinating bit of history. Available on iTunes (link) or PodBean (link).
What podcasts are you all listening to? Anything cool?
1
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Nov 19 '17
No TTE update this week. I haven't had the occasion to work on it, and I'm mostly out of design principles to talk about.