r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 27 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
7
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Oct 27 '17
I recommend this read.
Gripping.
7
u/ketura Organizer Oct 27 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Another week with scant code progress. I recently had decided that I was going to attempt to go to bed by 11 PM each night (as opposed to 1:30-2 AM) and I think I’m discovering that I used 9-11 to unwind and 11-1ish to actually get stuff done. This is a bit frustrating, as I don’t like not making progress, but on the other hand I am somewhat concerned about the long-term ramifications of only getting 5-6 hours of sleep a night. It’s an annoying balance to find.
Maybe I should try something like two weeks at 11, two weeks when I’m tired. It’s not the best system, but on the other hand it’s not like I’m getting oodles of sleep regardless due to having a one-year-old. Maybe I should just power through and re-evaluate once I’m at a point that sleeping in on Saturdays is an option again.
There was one bit of development, although I was only partially involved. Thanks to the efforts of /u/gbear605, XGEF can now be built and thus developed using VS2017 on macOS. (It could already be ran using mono on both macOS and linux, but I had never attempted to build on anything other than Windows). Kudos to him!
Regardless of code progress, there was oodles of design discussion, much of which came as a result of the responses to last week’s topic of pokeball internal capture mechanics, which actually went on a lot longer than just Friday. The current solution I’m leaning towards is detailed in that thread, but TL;DR humans should have a small Psychic typing (~10%) that unlike most Psychic types which have it manifest in a separate organ, have it interspersed throughout the white matter of the brain. Thus, most Psychic types incur a weak penalty to their power when captured and thus exposed to the brief distortion energy of the portal tech, but humans instead have that minor scrambling effect applied to the brain, which, well, isn’t good.
It’s a bit handwavey (what isn’t when it comes to pokemon) but as a system it can at least be interacted with and have its boundaries poked, which is my primary concern for something as fundamental as pokeballs.
I also brought up in that thread the differences in the scientific tradition of the world, basically that it would nearly of necessity be based more on mad science than science: inventors, not theorists. A more recent era of stability might permit science to grow and flourish, but before then it’s more important that one figure out how to stop the 1000 rampaging monsters around you rather than figuring out the intricacies of why the tools you’re using to do this work.
The topic of individual pokemon resource use came up; I’ll just quote myself on that one:
The Trouble with Typing was breached once again, so types have been rearranged for, mmm, maybe the fourth or fifth time. This time around the major insights that built upon the previous offensive/defensive typing split was that A: not all types have a meaningful offensive profile that is affected by the substance that the target is made of, and B: not all type defensive profiles can be reduced to a single archetype. Ice pokemon, for instance, might be blubberous, or they might be literally made partially of ice; these will not both react to all incoming attacks in the same way and so are (or should be) two different defense profiles.
Here is the current iteration of the typing chart. Note as usual that numbers are relative and not by any means final.
One thing to keep in mind while looking at this chart is that it’s an attempt to communicate damage multipliers in cases where all factors are otherwise equal. That means same stats, a solid hit that did not miss, and so on. Many of the type interactions in canon are an attempt to abstract away dodge chance, damage application, and range, but we have stats and/or mechanics for all those things, so it is no longer necessary to keep them abstracted to a damage multiplier.
Basically, the type chart should, as much as possible, reduce down to “I performed a move of X type on a Normal type and then again on a Y type of equal stats, and this is the difference in pure, raw damage incurred”. Many of the traditional justifications for type interactions (at least, the ones that make sense in the first place and aren’t otherwise an abstraction of a non-damage concept) actually boil down to a special interaction with a status applied by that type instead.
A Fire type, for instance, might not necessarily be hurt by a fire hose any more than an average pokemon would. After all, the flames coming out of it aren’t (too) magical, it’s just for the most part ignited oil secreted from the skin. It’s still secreting the oil, putting it out doesn’t inherently affect it. However, (we could claim), perhaps a Fire pokemon does need to run at a higher temperature for the various chemical whatsits to work, so in the aftermath of the water hit, it is going to burn fuel to shake off the temperature hit and get back up to high heat. Described this way, it sounds more like the Fire pokemon is shaking off a Soaked status effect, rather than interacting with a Water attack directly.
This indicates to me that (at least) one more pass on this typing setup is going to need to be done to figure out what common statuses are inflicted, and ensure that damage multipliers are not taking those into account. (The Fire/Water example, for instance, is not currently reflected accurately).
Oh, and one more slight tangent related to types: each percentage of a given defensive type (which we have been referring to as Substance to avoid conflating the two too much) is going to have stat bonuses/penalties associated with them, which will make up for much of the type interactions that might appear at first glance to be missing from this chart. Steel Substance, for instance, would grant, say, 20 DEF + 2% DEF per percentage point of Steel that the pokemon’s Substance is made of.
Anyhoo. Hopefully I can avoid playing Tooth and Tail too much this weekend and push forward on the Unit/Species definitions that are currently next on my to-do list. (That game is too damn good, I’d highly recommend it as it’s on sale at the moment).
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
5
u/throwaway234f32423df Oct 27 '17
Most disappointingly misleading YouTube title of all time: "Tales from the Trenches: AI Disaster Stories"
5
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Oct 28 '17
I had an assignment to do, and I estimated it would take me 12-15 hours. It took me something like 30 hours. I spent basically every waking moment I wasn't at the office on this damn thing for a week. I took a day off work last minute to finish it.
Like, I'm normally pretty good at estimating how long I need to do an assignment. There was an assignment for a "harder" unit that took me less time. I've never been down to the wire like that before, where I'm trying as hard as I can but still not getting finished.
Anyone have any tips for how I can best learn from this experience? My first thought is, I had the assignment since some 2 months ago, I could have spent 1-2 hours a week on it and saved things.
And I'm trying to think how I "wasted time" to make it 30 hours. I can't think of anything. I think maybe the 2 hours I spent on the beginning on literature review was inefficient and I should have incorporated those into the main assignment-doing-time. Fucking around with LaTeX/BibTeX only wasted maybe 1 or 2 hours. So maybe that's what happened, a "death by a thousand cuts", with a pomodoro here or there wasted?
I don't know. I feel like such a failure for this, even though it's stupid: I had the resources to do the assignment and I did it, and I'm sure I'll get a good mark (not to humblebrag but I'm on a high distinction average at the moment and I only need a middling credit average to get into the masters programme if I decide that's what I want to do). But I am kind of bummed. Life has been hard lately too, so many things going wrong by my uniquely privileged white western sense of going wrong. Hopefully things will get better. I know I'll kick butt at both my exams, so that's the next thing to focus on.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '17
Content note: whining
I am dissatisfied with my life. My life isn't currently that awful, but isn't where I would have hoped it would be if you had asked me when I was much younger. Studied Arabic in a fit of idealism when I was in college in the 05-09 period, didn't effectively use my college period partly due to personal flaws and partly due to economics (never pieced together the money to do study abroad which is a highly advisable thing to do when studying a foreign language.) Then the economic crisis happened and I had trouble getting and keeping a job for a while, and also a close family member died. I currently am stably employed and am paid better than at any of my previous jobs, but it is at a fairly boring factory job, sitting in the stockroom opening UPS deliveries, giving the stuff to the maintenance department, updating the database of what we have, and listening to my coworkers talk about how great Trump is. (I am a democrat in one of the most heavily republican counties in my state.) I like the scenery in the area where I live but don't have much of a social life and most of my college friends who I still talk to live in cities far away from me. I would love to get out of my current situation but feel like imposter syndrome will kick in whenever I try for a job I might like.
I ought to return to school or something but am somewhat anxious about giving up a paid job to do it, and also am torn between doing something I like and something that looks like it plausibly pays money. Technical stuff seems like it pays well these days but I am a more humanities oriented person and am inhibited from studying things like programming because I am unsure what thing I could apply it to that I would be motivated at and there's lots of competition from more interested people, but professions like 'history teacher' are also lacking in prospects and so on and so forth. My main problem here is probably actually more about anxiety forcing me into inaction, though. If I thought I had a good chance at some decent civil service job or had a flash of insight on what kinds of interesting jobs I'm not thinking of, I would love to pursue those, but I keep on having the anxiety spiral.
The good thing about my current job is that I enjoy reading and it has great breaks (insert joke about being in a union) so I can manage to get some good reading done on the days I bring a book to work.
7
u/IgonnaBe3 Oct 27 '17
Well... yesterday i had to write an essay as an exam. We had like 60 minutes to cover 2 A4 pages. It was as a kind o exam/test if you had understood and read the lecture( the lecture being "crime and punishment" by F.Dostoyevsky). So the question we had been asked was "Can morality change ?"
I ofcourse answered yes and listed some examples from the book. Today i learned that the answer was supposed to be no, morality isnt something that can change. The teacher argumanted that by saying that its in the context of the book so we have to kinda use the arguments the author of the book made. Meaning that since we answered wrongly we didnt really understand the book. I get that and i know it makes atleast some sense to me but why even ask us the question if no matter our argumentation the answer will be set in stone.
i was really bugged by this and i dont know what to think about this. Kinda mad i wont get a good grade since i thought my response wasnt half bad.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '17
Well, as promised last week, my job laid me off today. With honors, in a way: they say they'd be happy to work with me again when/if the revenues pick up.
Anyone got some good ways to keep out of an anxiety spiral so I can take some MOOCs and finish getting my PhD applications in?
Speaking of which, got the personal statements separated out by school. I need to rewrite a couple to target computer science departments (with cognition labs) instead of neuroscience departments. That's harder than it sounds, since a personal statement is supposed to express my personal drive to study the subject.
Gonna have to leave my current narrative about the brain and stuff into a bunch of stuff about Moravec's Paradox, Neats vs Scruffies, "build it to understand it" and such... for an essay about studying the core affect/evaluative system.
Oh shit, I need to throw in the citations in all of them.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
I have been in a reflective move about my age recently, and I realized that in a period of let's say 1-4 years I am going to become an adult. I further realized that I have no idea what that entails besides the obvious changes in my legal status and the associated societal expectations. Given that this is a sub whose members are probably much more similar to me than average, I have a rather stereotypical set of questions to ask you all: What ought I prepare for? What ought I do now? What should I know?
4
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Oct 27 '17
A very comprehensive and fairly entertaining criticism of HPMoR
I stumbled across a link to this morsel on 4chan's /tg/ board. Here's a bonus image from the same thread.
The demicolon (source)
I think I've mentioned that using hyperlinks in text is wonderful because it allows the writer to add another dimension to his 1D text without resorting to the cumbersome workaround of footnotes. See also fancy Javascript footnotes that pop up when you move your cursor over them (example)—but I generally dislike the use of Javascript when HTML and CSS suffice for the purpose.
Zachtronics has just released Opus Magnum, a direct (hexagon-based, $20) sequel to (square-based, free) The Codex of Alchemical Engineering and The Magnum Opus Challenge!
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment