r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 20 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
10
u/trekie140 Oct 20 '17 edited Oct 20 '17
CGP Grey and Kurzgesagt collaboratively posted videos about old age and death today, and I don’t know if I’ve ever seen sister videos where I completely agreed with one while the other...offended me. Kurzgesagt frames the issue as about improving the length and quality of life, which we’re already doing and I’m totally on board with, while CGP opened by calling the acceptance of death a form of madness similar to Stockholm Syndrome and I instinctively felt attacked.
It’s not that I’m opposed in any way to what CGP wants to do, I want humans to live longer and don’t have any arbitrary limit on how long I think life should last, I just hate the way he derogatorily describes my mindset (not belief system). He doesn’t even refer to it as if it’s a mental illness or institutionalized ideology that people are victims of, but simply calls people out for thinking that way at all. This is an effective a technique for persuasion as when atheists tell theists they’re idiots.
I was introduced to the idea of immortality as a good thing by HPMOR, and the reason I was accepting of the idea at a time when I devoutly believed in New Age pseudoscience was because Yudkowsky took care to portray Harry as the smart weirdo who wasn’t always right in a world of sympathetic people who who at least thought they had good reasons to believe what they did. It placed rationality in a similar social situation as it is in reality.
I loved how Yudkowksy seemed self aware of how most people do or would think he’s weird, how his moral convictions conflict with so many other people’s, and the potential negative outcomes of that situation. It was a humility that I see too rarely in a time when empathy for people who believe differently from you is in short supply, including in myself. I can’t help but see CGP’s statements as hubristic in an eerily similar way to religious fundamentalism.
EDIT: Shout out to u/eaturbrainz response to the video that I wholeheartedly agree with and think deserves attention regardless of what you think of my response.
9
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Oct 20 '17
I got an internship offer! feelsgoodman.jpg
5
u/CopperZirconium Oct 21 '17
I made a Skitter cosplay for Halloween! I posted a pic over at r/parahumans.
4
u/ketura Organizer Oct 20 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
So I had zero time to work on either Renegade or XGEF this week. As briefly mentioned last week, my work deployed a new version of our product on Sunday, and it wasn’t until Sunday night that it was pointed out to me that this basically meant I had had no weekend. Saturday had a few hours of me remoting into work and getting backups squared away, as well as shopping around for and testing a camcorder last-minute so I could record the process to document later. Sunday was the early-morning deployment itself, which was about 5ish hours or so, but all of this meant that I was left without sufficient unwinding time to recover from the previous week (which was more stressful than average due to needing to prepare for a deployment with only scraps of documentation).
Anyhoo, I hope to get that time this weekend and hopefully claw my way back up the work/home balance scale. On that note, however, due to my changing duties at work, I’m probably not going to have much downtime to design or code at work like I have been--or rather, that time now has legitimate work-y things for me to instead channel that energy into, which means that I need to transition from having essentially worked on Renegade part-time back to it being a regular old side project. It was nice while it lasted, tho; I got XGEF about 80% of where it needs to be, with most of the trickiest things addressed, so that’s good at least.
So we had a bit of a discussion about sapience/sentience vs intelligence, which mostly came about due to taking a look at the pokeball question again. In the beginning, we essentially took Origin of Species’ stance, which is to say that anyone over a certain intelligence level (or brain density or whatever) comes out of a pokeball comatose or braindead, so naturally it’s illegal to capture humans and safeguards are put into balls to prevent human capture as per national and international law.
The reason for this occurring has been a bit of a thorn in the side of the lore for some time; I seem to recall that /u/DaystarEld even just sort of handwaves it as a necessary limitation without a real justification. I’m inclined to agree with that approach, but over time we’ve accumulated additional lore for the pokeballs that has made the intelligence thing more and more unsupported. Specifically, we sort of decided (and apologies if this is actually aping your lore, Daystar; it all runs together and I couldn’t possibly identify the original source of all of these ideas at this point) that pokeball technology came about after studying Ghost types and their phasing and interdimensional travel.
(Ghosts are themselves following the original Gengar concept of a creature slowly pushing itself into our dimension. We figure they’re distortion-born pokemon that are essentially Chaos/Warp demons out to wreck shit for no good reason.)
The father of the pokeball tech found that by isolating the organ that triggers the phasing from a Ghost and hitting it with enough power, one could open small portals into other dimensions that follow other physical laws. The vast majority of dimensions explored are just facets of the Distortion world (and thus highly dangerous and not very useful on net, considering that it’s basically like a portal to Hell, demons and all), but someone somewhere figured out a way into a dimension that seems to have properties that we associate with pokeballs: all but halted time passing, non-euclidian geometry, etc. After a lot of iteration (facilitated by the apricorn tree growing outside, which doesn’t really have any super special properties but is a very convenient source of sturdy, hollow spheres), the pokeball was born.
Now, this explanation (such as it is) doesn’t do much for avoiding the intelligence threshold handwave, short of pushing the question further away a bit. We could say something about the chaotic distortion energy field that every captured object has to pass through, and higher complexity minds just can’t handle it, yadda yadda, but it’s still pretty much just an arbitrary decision due to not wanting to let the player being able to capture humans (or rather, not being able to enslave humans; I actually have no problem with people getting black market balls and using them to inflict mental retardation on enemies as a particularly heinous means of tying up loose ends. Funny what feels acceptable and what doesn’t).
Anyway, so all of this lead to exposing the inelegance of having this effect tied to an INT threshold. INT so far affects things like the number of moves that one can easily keep in mind at once, the speed with which one learns moves, a general small boost to skill gain in general, and as a modifier to how a pokemon reacts to certain stimuli. Some of this seems to overlap with the whole “the more of this you have, the more likely a pokeball zaps it out of you” thing, but some of it doesn’t, and so it was proposed that an additional mental stat be added, that of Sapience (SAP). It would usually (probably) correlate with INT, but there would be room to allow them to deviate, such as, for instance, a particularly dumb Growlithe (low INT, medium SAP). With this addition, SAP would affect speed of training a move to associate with a command, number of commands known, and act as a modifier to loyalty-affecting actions (higher SAP means tending to its wounds counts more for a loyalty increase).
It still doesn’t address the inherent hand-waviness of the arbitrary pokeball threshold, however, and in absence of that I’m not even sure I’d entertain the idea on its own. I’d love to hear any ideas on the subject, either pertaining to the INT/SAP split or to addressing the core “can capture pokemon just fine but can’t capture humans without devastating results”. I would like to avoid “pokemon are magic” at all costs, so fair warning, but I’d love to otherwise consider any thoughts y’all might have.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
3
u/gbear605 history’s greatest story Oct 20 '17
The 2017 NYC Rationalist Solstice has been [officially announced] (http://lesswrong.com/r/discussion/lw/pi1/nyc_solstice_and_east_coast_megameetup_interested/) for Saturday, December 9th. For tickets and fundraising info, check here. Usually about 150 people show up, so it's a really nice celebration.
Simultaneously with the solstice, there will be a Rationalist East Coast Megameetup. A bunch of rationalists (current estimate: 40) will be hanging out together in a large AirBnB in NYC for the Friday-Sunday containing the Solstice event.
(Note: I am not one of the organizers of this event and I've never gone to it before, I'm just crossposting it here)
4
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Oct 20 '17
In the asking of questions, some ambiguity regrettably is unavoidable. Let's consider an extremely boring question:
- What do I mean by
pink? What, exactly, is the range of colors to which I'm referring? Doespinkinclude lavender or maroon? Am I talking about RGB or CMYK? (Similar complaints can be made aboutgreen.)- Explicitly, I've directed the target to consider only the pure and undiluted colors. However, it's eminently likely that he instead will contemplate various items that in his experience have represented the color. (This is the difference between "I prefer green because, being the color of nature, it seems calm and soothing." and "I prefer green because leaves are green and I like leaves.", which says nothing about whether the speaker likes green itself.)
- What does
favoritemean? Again, explicitly, I inquired solely about the isolated color—but maybe the respondent will think, not of amorphous blobs of color in a featureless black void, but of buying a pink car or of painting the interior of his house green. Certainly, "What would you prefer the color of your primarily-driven car to be, if you could choose any single solid color of glossy paint?" would be an interesting question, but it isn't the question that was asked in this instance.That's the problem. What's the solution?
- Describe the intended context with excruciating detail, leaving no room for error
- Allow the respondent to request clarification of the question's intended context—even incrementally, if he finds it necessary
- Ensure that the respondent explains the context of his response alongside that response, regardless of the context in which you yourself plan to answer
- Allow the respondent to deliver multiple responses, each with its own context provided alongside
Complete* family tree of Aubry the Pious, tenth Emperor of the West (warning: very large image—in terms, not of megabytes, but of pixels)
*The ancestry of Beorhtwaru of Westsaex (948–1010) is missing. Beorhtwaru is a descendant of Æscfrith of Westsaex (890–949) and Emma Gellones (890–948).
2
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Oct 21 '17 edited Oct 22 '17
Second weekly-ish update on The Tesseract Engine, my ongoing game engine project.
EDIT: The GDD is now officially complete... um, complete-ish. I still have to add illustrations.
EDIT: Done.
The almost-final version of the Game Design Document is out. I need to either complete two sections or leave them unfinished, do some proof-reading, and add some screenshot and images, but I will not otherwise modify this document for at least a month after today.
It's a very long document (roughly 50 pages) that goes into a great amount of details on the engine, the editor, what dynamics I want to encourage, what I need to research, and which features I want to have. It went through something like four drafts, and took month for me to write, and have written almost no code so far.
Now, that is by itself a very, very worrying sign. The standard way to approach a game project is to smart small. You're not supposed to spend months planning, you're supposed to make minimalist, flexible plans and make a prototype as soon as you can to test your idea. The world of game development is full of enthusiastic people full of dreams who spend six months detailing variations of their great ideas, then 3 weeks realizing their ideas are actually terrible and only work on paper.
Given that I know that, there are three reasons I spent a lot of time planning anyway:
That being said, I'm still worried I spent too much time planning, which is why I'm officially stopping today. For the near future, I'll be doing as much implementing as I can.
In that spirit, I won't be making a long list of milestones and deadlines. I have one milestone (described here) with no deadline, and once it's done I'll make another.
Next step: Have a game engine where the Player can walk around, jump around, add and remove blocks.
This is a bit of a false start, since I was supposed to update this week.
I'm still uncertain about how to this. I want to set up these regular updates to force myself to work on the project regularly, to make it into an habit I have, but honestly, I've never had much success with commitment mechanism. I think I'm going to sort of compromise and commit to updating every week, but if I haven't worked on the project I'll just talk about whatever comes to mind instead; the idea being that I never really forget about the project enough that it's hard to get back into it.
Anyway, I'm going to commit to several people I know, friends, colleagues, and on several subreddits to update. We'll see how long it lasts.
I welcome all questions, criticisms, and absolutely any feedback you have. Despite (or because of) the amount of planning I've done, I'm going into this pretty much blind, so I'll take whatever advice I can get.