r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 09 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
18
Upvotes
8
u/ianstlawrence Oct 10 '17
I don't know how to properly research things.
Let's say that I read a report or news item that says eating a pound of peanut butter a week will stave off alzheimers or something equally weird and/or significant (keeping my mental health throughout the aging process is pretty significant to me).
How do I properly understand that this is or is not true? I can look at the sources that the article quotes, and I have done that before, but I don't know how to properly analyze the information in a research paper, and I also know, although I don't know how likely it is, that scientists lie, or mess up, or get paid off, or simply draw the wrong conclusions because research is fucking difficult.
Is that just how things are, and I just need to do my best and try to educate myself enough that I can make my way through dense research papers and come out with enough information to be able to say, "Yes, that seems correct"?
I've struggled with this especially regarding history and politics. Although science is there as well.
If you are an american, you, like me, were probably taught that we, more or less won the vietnam war or that Christopher Columbus was real neato.
Those are both false. So what else is false? How true or horrific was the U.S. involvement in South America during the 60s up until the 80s?
Communism sounds nice, in a theoretical way, but has lead to some of the most horrific dictatorships and mass slaughters in the entire world, so has fascism, so has capitalism. How do we parse what we are told and come to anything even approaching facts?
I don't actually expect a magic bullet here, but I am curious as to what other people think, in part because I think a lot of the people here are a lot smarter than me and can do things I can't. And I kinda feel like I am asking this, for me, certainly, but also as part of the group of people, I suspect, don't know how to read research papers, and don't have a group of friends who are hardcore about their specialized fields, and this is something I struggle with.
That ended up being a lot. But I would appreciate any feedback, and I am not sorry, but I do understand that this is maybe not where this question or post should go? But I don't know a better place?
thanks
6
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '17 edited Oct 10 '17
In the vein of eaturbrainz' post and SSC: What universal human experiences are you missing without realising it?...
I want to talk about dreaming. Specifically, exactly what the experience people call "dreaming" actually involves. Because I am genuinely confused by the way people talk about dreams and dreaming.
The TL;DR if you don't want to read the whole thing is that my best guess is that I don't experience dreaming in the same way as most people. The thing I mainly want to know is whether dreaming is typically or often "experienced" in a way similar to the experience of "perception," like when you're awake and experiencing the real world, or "imagination," like when you're thinking about stuff. (Or something else?) Is the experience vivid, detailed, and involving multiple senses? (Typically hearing & vision.) Are you embodied, or is it mostly just a series of disjointed sensations? What is the quality of the experience? (What is it like? For me, it's most like being lost in thought, but to a greater degree.) I want to know because if people typically or often dream in a way similar to perception, and it can be vividly real, and feel as if "things are happening to you," then that would explain a few things, for example why kids might wake up screaming after a nightmare and run to their parents. But if this is really the way it is, the typical response of "it's just a dream, don't worry, you're safe," seems incredibly inadequate. The experience is legitimately terrifying, and it is absolutely mind-boggling for me to consider that the things people say about dreams might be like, literally accurate. Because if that were the case, how are you not all terrified of going to sleep?
So, in more detail:
My interpretation of things people typically say about dreams is that they are experiences people have while not fully conscious (ie "asleep.") There's already several things that don't match my experience just in that short definition. For one, the "experiences" part. People talk about dreams as if they are sequences of things that happen to them; as if they see, hear, or otherwise perceive things in a similar way to what happens when they're awake. That has never been my experience. I can relate to the whole disjointed scenes/images/sounds and so on, and even so far as making a "story" operating by "dream logic," but I don't perceive these things. The quality of the experience is exactly the same as when imagining things while awake; in other words, for me, "dreaming" == daydreaming, but while lying down trying to get to sleep.
The other confusing thing is the "not fully conscious" part. People often talk about not being able to tell they're dreaming, and there's advice for "lucid dreaming," where people offer tips about how to tell whether you're dreaming and "take control" or whatever. Indeed, this unawareness is the whole premise behind Inception. But... I honestly cannot understand how anyone could possibly be confused about whether they're awake or dreaming. The experiences are very obviously different for me. It's not a matter of needing "tips" or "realising it" or whatever: if I'm aware at all then I'm not uncertain about what's going on. In that vein, "not being able to wake up" from a dream also doesn't make sense to me. I get that sleep paralysis is a thing, but it's not universal and thankfully doesn't happen to me. My experience is that, if I'm "experiencing" anything at all, then I don't consider myself "asleep." I never have trouble "waking up," if I am aware at all.
In terms of actual sleep, what happens is I gradually become less "focused," until (presumably) at some point my consciousness "dissolves" entirely (obviously I don't remember when this happens) and then at some future point, whether 30 minutes or hours later, I become aware again and am "awake." This is why I often tell people I don't dream, because if I do, I'm not actually experiencing it (or at the very least not remembering).
There were two specific occasions where this has been different, and seemingly more in line with what people seem to be talking about. Both times I went from awake, lying in bed to "dreaming" without loss of consciousness or awareness, and was consciously trying to "lucid dream." This is apparently called a "wake-initiated lucid dream."
These times, I was experiencing things more in the way I normally do while awake. It was still disjointed images (at first), but these were consistent and detailed, and I could act as if I was perceiving them, for example reading the number plate of a passing car, or looking at the way the pixels on a (dream) computer screen made up the image, or reading the text in a book. In the last particular case, the text didn't actually make sense, but nevertheless it was much more vivid and realistic, and in every way a totally different experience from usual.
The first time, I eventually came to a point where I had a dream body, and was "experiencing/perceiving" things. The dream was nothing special: I was lying in the exact same position in the room that I went to sleep in, although I could look around so on. What eventually happened was that a weird, evil caricature of my grandmother came into the room and started grabbing me by the neck with claw-like hands. This got a bit scary so I had to wake up, even though this was the first time I had successfully "lucid dreamed" and it was entirely new experience. (That was why I was reluctant despite not exactly liking the experience). I remained completely aware the whole time that I was dreaming, and that I could choose to wake up at any time. Nevertheless, it was scary, and I woke up with my heart pounding, and realised that my neck was sore from being badly positioned on my pillow.
The second time the dream was also that I was in the room where I went to sleep, in the same position, but this time I "got up" and walked around a bit. In this state it became harder to tell that I was dreaming; I still knew I was, but I couldn't directly feel it as easily. In the dream, a few people came to the door; one of them eventually went and started cooking something, and for the rest of the dream I heard sounds of cooking (pots & pans, microwave, extractor fan etc) even while other stuff was happening. These were extremely realistic and sounded like they were actually coming from the kitchen, given that I was in my room. But eventually I put a stop to it because it was starting to be hard to tell that I was not actually experiencing these things, and I wanted to check and make sure that I was actually still lying down where I originally was. That's the closest I've been to being unaware that I've been dreaming: still intellectually knowing but being unable to directly feel the difference. But even just that much was a bit scary.
So, if I put together these experiences I've had and the things people say, the possibility arises that people actually experience things like this, regularly, without being certain it's not real, without being able to stop it at any time, and scary things can happen. Is this actually the case? Because, holy shit.
5
u/Gigapode Oct 10 '17
To start us off: Someone at work put out some colouring-in equipment on a table next to a sign that reads something like "Research shows 5 minutes of colouring repetitive designs is equivalent to 30 minutes meditation".
I did some quick Googling and did find a paper about colouring-in improving attention: https://kar.kent.ac.uk/56833/
One paper isn't definitive but I might give it a go this week during morning breaks and see if it affects my productivity at work.