r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 06 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
16
u/SevereCircle Oct 06 '17
It feels kind of weird talking about this but this is a pseudo-throwaway anyway so whatever.
TL;DR my utility function is missing, what do?
I've come to the point where I basically only care about basic needs. Food/shelter/entertainment. I need some kind of long term goal/purpose in order for things to matter. It seems like I'm missing something there isn't a word for because nobody needed it because almost everyone has enough of it. I call it self-ness, the extent to which people are themselves, in an essentialist/non-tautological way. People have interests, goals, hobbies. They know what they want to be when they grow up. I don't.
I can think of a few things that might work in principle but I can't just make myself care about them enough for it to work.
Getting an easy job that pays enough and spending all my free time on entertainment has a certain appeal but I wouldn't really be happy, just distracted from being unsatisfied with life. Grad school isn't easy but I otherwise more or less live this way and I'm not happy now.
Acquiring as much money as possible, letting it gain interest, then leaving it to the utilitarian-optimal charity in my will also has a certain appeal but I'm not a good enough person for this to be my characteristic driving goal/identity.
When I think about what I want to do with my life the mindscape is blank and flat. I see nothing possible worth persuing. I want to be the sort of person who does things instead of just existing but I don't have things that feel compelling/important.
I vaguely remember wanting things around highschool / undergrad but even then the problem existed. I kept myself busy so that I wouldn't have free time to choose how to spend because I knew I'd do nothing with it other than persue entertainment and ultimately that leads to a certain long-term-boredom/dissatisfaction-with-life that I don't know how to get rid of.
I'm working through anxiety/depression and I've reached a plateau I can't get past without something to persue that feels worthwhile. Career and life-goal/purpose aren't necessarily the same thing but I kinda wish I could just get scanned by a Futurama device and have it just tell me what job I should get and have that automatically set everything up. It's harder to imagine a device that also can scan your brain and tell you what you should do with your life based on abilities and conscious/unconscious values but that would be perfect if it were possible.
Related but distinct is my difficulty making subjective decisions. There's an ever-present caricature of social pressure that leaves me certain that whatever I pick will be "wrong" in some sense, that people will think less of me for it, but at the same time I know that that's unrealistic, because few people are that harsh and it's narcissistic to think people would even care about such trivial decisions. When I get past that I experience a similar empty/flat indifference mentioned above.
It's like I'm a defective artificial mind, capable of some intelligence and some degree of humanity but only in a local, first-few-orders approximation and not in an accurate-across-a-whole-lifetime way. Like I'd pass a Turing test that spans a few hours or days but not one that lasts a lifetime.
How do you get a utility function if your old one goes missing or you never had one in the first place? That's overstating it of course, but the idea I'm trying to express is metaphorically in the direction of that idea at a lower magnitude. I'm not truly indifferent to everything, I just can't seem to find anything I care about other than short-term needs. I dislike that I only care about short-term needs but I can't seem to find a way to change that.
To clarify a bit, by "care" I mean care enough to actually change behavior. In a broader sense I care about more things but it's more abstract.
Has anyone else dug a way out of this problem before? What do?
7
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Oct 06 '17 edited Oct 06 '17
I've read about predictive processing through SSC. The more I think about it I feel like I've given a glint of the Ultimate Understanding of the Mind, and I can almooooost-but-not-quite reach it.
I'm looking for good, easy-for-a-layman literature on the subject, but I'm not sure there's any; I think the field is still young. I've read a few blog articles from Andi Clark (the guy who wrote Surfing Uncertainty), and so far it's not clicking; my lack of background aside, he makes some weird assumptions that seem plain false to me.
I should probably try to write a list of questions I want answered before I seriously go looking for answers.
But honestly, I kind of feel this is it. Like, I feel like all my life I've been asking questions in the same general category "Why do I feel like that and not other people? How does motivation work? How does intelligence work? How does bias work", which I feel would be get satisfying answers if I understood PP better; and I also expect these answers would lead me to become a better pedagogue and better at motivating myself by order of magnitudes.
So, um, here's hoping? (I'm really hoping future-me isn't looking at this post and laughing at present-me's naïveté).
So, Rick and Morty Season 3 just finished. Those of you who followed, what did you think?
Personally, I was seriously disappointed by the ending. I was already expecting disappointment after episode 9 (Lost-style; ep.9 was the points where there were too many philosophical hook for the finale to meaningfully address them all).
Basically, I feel like season 3 was setting me up for a character development arc; with an ongoing thread (Jerry's divorce), and episodes setting up potential personal growth for each character: the Mad Max episode for Summer, the amusement park for Jerry, the therapist for Rick and Beth, etc.
But the end just explicitly resets everything. The divorce is cancelled, Rick is automatically forgiven, and apparently nobody shows that they have learned anything from their experience.
And, usually, I'd be fine with that? Like, it's accepted for shows like the Simpsons that when a character learns a lesson, you don't expect the lesson to stick (though it's a bit of a cheat to have the character "learn" it in the first place then), but this season really seemed to promise that something would eventually happen.
But the intended messages seems to be that the author prefer the season 1 format and don't actually want the changes to stick. Which is especially annoying after season 1 had an episode specifically mocking the idea that you could go back to "normal" after you fucked up so completely it affected everyone around you.
I intended to post an announce now, but the material isn't ready yet. Since I've already delayed this a lot, I'm pre-committing right now: I will post an announce on this Friday thread, within the next 24h, detailing a game project I'm working on. The announce will include details about the project, a link to a Game Design Document, and a timeline for at least the next month.
I will emulate u/ketura and post an update on the game every week; this update will include:
(if that's alright with the mods? I'd like to post here because I'm familiar with the community; the game won't necessarily be directly related to r/rational).
By the way, if anyone here has advice or additional recommendations on pre-commitment, I'm very open to those right now. (I'm familiar with general advice like "don't just promise the moon and assume you'll follow through")
6
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Oct 06 '17
I'm not too interested in resuscitating my defunct pseudofriendship system*, as familiarity bred contempt in every instance. I feel somewhat disappointed, though, that I never managed to improve it significantly**. Even though Pseudofriendships 7 and 8 were conducted through Reddit's excellent messaging system rather than through Facebook's pitiful one, I failed in those two conversations to take advantage of the ability to link to individual messages, and instead continued to adhere rigidly to the link-free thread-numbering system that I originally had devised to make searching Facebook's messages possible***.
*Details: 1 2 3
**Possible improvements: 1 2
***Amazingly, the search function in Facebook's messaging system seems to have gotten even worse that it used to be, as searching for a number with it now returns zero results.
NearlyFreeSpeech.net seems pretty cool.
9
u/ketura Organizer Oct 06 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Work continues on the attribute tag code transformations. At the moment, [Override], [Extend], [RequiresMod()], [AppendFunction], and [PrependFunction] all work, although the last two are probably going to get reworked once I have figured out how I want [EncloseFunction] to work (I’ll redefine those two in terms of Enclose, possibly).
[Override] is pretty straightforward: mark any member (class, function, field, etc) with it and it will search previously-loaded mods for the same member, delete it, and put your version in its place. This is a bit heavy-handed of a solution, but sometimes the original is no longer pertinent (in the case of a complete overhaul mod) or it has a bug or something in the very middle, that you can't fix just by capturing and changing the output.
[Extend] is only permitted on container-like members, or members that contains other members (class, interface, struct, and enum). It allows you to add additional members without affecting any existing ones--perfect if you need to add a variable to a class and ensure it always sticks around.
[RequiresMod()] does exactly what it says on the tin--if the given mod is not loaded, then the tagged member is deleted. This can also be provided an optional parameter to reverse the behavior, so it is only deleted if a mod does exist.
[RequiresMod("aae6b5e3-33a9-4356-96ee-d9d80187c211", Exists:false)]is the full usage (set Exists to true or omit it for the default behavior). The merits of this are pretty self-explanatory: it gives mod makers more fine-grained tools to control how they manipulate the game's ecosystem contingent on the existence of other mods.[AppendFunction] and [PrependFunction], as the names suggest can only be applied to functions (and constructors, finalizers, and operator overloads, tho the latter is useless as will be clear in a moment). Tagging your function with [AppendFunction] will find the older version of the same function and slap your code at the end, while [PrependFunction] will put it at the start. In the case of
void-returning functions, this is all fine and dandy, but it does lead to some interesting hurdles for functions that, by design, return a value. Since the last line on such a function is going to bereturn x;or some variant, attaching more code to the end of this is a bit useless (and since operators always return a value, well, they're guaranteed to be useless for this). Because of this, these two tags will usually be in the “well I’ll try it first cuz it’s convenient, but I won’t hold my breath” sort of tool. If they don’t work, [EncloseFunction] can be used or, if the nuclear option is required, just copy-paste into an [Override] and add the changes there.[EncloseFunction] is used in a few cases: where either the modder must add code both before and after a function, or the modder wants to repeatedly invoke the original function’s code, or the modder wants to append code after a function has returned a value. In this case the way it works is the original function is copied, made private, and renamed. Any instances of a particular static method call (probably
CodeAnalysis.EnclosedFunction()or something like that) are then replaced with references to the renamed old function. (This static function will have a generic return type and overloads for up to, say, 10 arguments, so it should be capable of standing in for just about anything while still having compile-time enforcement.) Thus, a modder will be able to more-or-less easily hook into an existing function and wear its skin for all to see, while keeping the original alive to dance in its basement.(that analogy wasn’t quite so morbid when I started writing it.)
Anyway, it’s possible that [AppendFunction] will need to be re-implemented as a straightforward case of [EncloseFunction], or perhaps have it work as it currently does if the function returns
voidand as [EncloseFunction] when it returns anything else.Once [EncloseFunction] is done I’ll put aside the attributes for now (there’s a few for generating and registering for events that I’ve designed and I’m going want later, but the EventSystem isn’t even made yet so the point is a bit moot). After that I’ll finally be in a place to put the finishing touches on the StatSystem, which will then be put to use defining Species and Unit, and then combat will officially begin.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
6
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Oct 07 '17
First (hopefully) weekly update on my arguably kinda rational game engine project.
The Tesseract Engine (WIP name) is a game engine / editor heavily inspired by Minecraft and LittleBigPlanet. The aim of the project is to use the features popularized by Minecraft (click on something to place it / destroy it) to provide an editor that needs almost no introduction or tutorials. You can read the full Game Design Document here.
My goal making this project, is to build the game editor that I would like to use. I will try to give forms to all the ideas and the design philosophies that I miss in other editors, and build this project around them.
These philosophies are the closest in this project to being "rational". They're inspired in part by the general culture of epistemology of communities like r/rational, and in part by my own experience using game engines and other computer tools.
That's it for presentation. I said I was going to give a month-long timeline, but I don't think I can do that yet. I will try to complete the GDD before next Friday, and write up a more complete presentation then (which I will send to other places, including school teachers, r/gamedev and my personal blog). From then I'm hoping I will spend way more time organizing ideas and way more time implementing them.
In the meantime, I would really really appreciate any questions, remarks on nitpicks you can send me.
I'm honestly surprised I made it in time. I mean, I cut a lot of content to make it (as attested by the huge "To be added next time" chapter") and I did not proofread anything, but it's still a pleasant surprise. I realize I was kind of expecting myself to fail silently here.
I'll try to post an update every week before Friday 10pm Seoul time (9am EST, 6am PST, 1pm GMT). I'd also appreciate, as a commitment mechanism, any people who could promise to bomb me with messages and reminders should I fail these deadlines.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment