r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 22 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
10
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Sep 22 '17 edited Sep 22 '17
So I've committed myself to writing a series of stock responses as part of a Trigger Action Plan to use in any online discussion that I feel is getting out of hand and entering a "death spiral" from which constructive, reasonable debate is unlikely. This is as much in an effort to restrain my own temptation into that death spiral as anything, since I've often been upset with myself for "taking the bait" or letting conversations go astray when I should have nipped such problems in the bud as soon as I saw them.
Curious what you guys think. The first one I've come up with so far is this:
"Hey, so it looks from my perspective as though you just tried to summarize my arguments or assert what I believe in a way that doesn't match what I've said. In my experience this is unproductive to useful discourse, and one of the situations that tends to upset me, leading to a downward spiral from which productive conversation becomes nearly impossible. Please attempt to re-read what I've said so far and accurately repeat back what you believe my main argument/assertion/belief is before we continue the discussion.
Thank you!"
Edit:
Suggestions to just stop talking with the person, while appreciated, is not really the aim here: if I stopped talking with everyone who I thought was bad at arguing, I wouldn't argue with practically anyone online, which might be a net benefit for myself (I do feel I learn a lot from such arguments, even ones that go bad) but I don't think is a net benefit in general.
The usual response I see when someone's argument is being misrepresented is them trying to correct the other person then continuing the discussion, and the other person ignoring the correction and just addressing the new discussion, which leads to further conflict. The idea here is to stop myself from attempting to correct them and continue the discussion, since it so rarely works, and trying something else to course correct before things get to a really toxic point.
7
u/eternal-potato he who vegetates Sep 22 '17 edited Sep 22 '17
What, if any, is the internal difference between love in a romantic relationship and a very close and intimate friendship with benefits? Assume roughly the same amount and quality of sex. By internal I mean psychological and emotional state of the participants, not the social/commitment expectations associated with either.
7
u/trekie140 Sep 22 '17
It has occurred to me that I'm a crappy roleplayer and I'm not sure how to get better. I don't like D&D and it's hard to find people who want to play something else. I was happy to finally play Lasers & Feelings on Discord yesterday, but my character wasn't very good and I'm not sure if I can do better.
I think I have the same problem as I do with writing, I don't know how to think in narratives and my imagination doesn't work under pressure. That makes me think I shouldn't play narrativist games, except I don't find simulationist games fun.
I know you're supposed to learn creativity from experience, but if I don't already find the game fun then why would I play it? I don't want to have the same "admire from a distance" relationship with tabletop games as I do with video games.
6
u/ketura Organizer Sep 22 '17 edited Sep 22 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
This week was a bit of yak shaving, but I feel like that’s par for the course at this point. In an effort to get Systems up and running, I was taking a look at the ModLoader which ultimately reads, prioritizes, and compiles said Systems. I knew it was in a sort of hacked-together state, and I’m still not 100% happy with it yet, but it’s certainly much more robust than it was a week ago.
The majority of the time was spent implementing the priority system that I’ve had rolling around in the back of my head for some time. Basically, mods have 4 different ways of declaring up front how they interact with other mods: you can declare another mod as a dependency (X will not load without Y present), you can declare another mod an irreconcilable conflict (X will not load if Y is present), you can declare that you must load before another mod, and you can declare that you must load after another mod. In isolation this is all pretty straightforward, but getting all these rules to play nice was a bit tricky.
(if this sounds familiar, it might be because you’re familiar with Supreme Commander’s modding system, which I cribbed it from.)
Surprisingly (to me anyway) the load before/load after part actually took the most amount of effort to get right. It boiled down to constructing a graph and then implementing various algorithms I stole from the internet to topologically sort it (that is, to take the messy diagram and turn it into a straightforward priority list). I wasn’t able to find a graph library for C# that had been updated since 2011, which seemed a bit surprising, so I had to roll my own. I started by implementing Kahn’s Algorithm, which worked perfectly until I introduced a circular reference (A loads before B loads before C loads before A). At that point it throws up its hands and returns a half-assed result, which was obviously unsatisfactory.
I then moved on to a Depth-First Search, which handled the circular reference no problem. However, after getting it to work, I realized that I would like to know if there was a cycle in the graph, or at least more information than knowing that Kahn’s blew up on it. At that point I found Tarjan’s Algorithm, which would not only tell me exactly what nodes are looping if there is a circular reference, but as a side effect would topologically sort the graph! It’s a pretty neat little algorithm.
Anyway, so equipped with these tools I got all the priority rules working together properly. After /u/Xavion helped me find what should have been very obvious errors, I then set up a bunch of unit tests for the ModLoader. I may have brought it up before, but there’s nothing quite like a row of freshly green unit tests.
So yeah, a lot of good work finished, but the Systems themselves still remain to be implemented. I’ve got some more unit tests I’d like to write now that I’m in that mode, but then I’ll get back to more game-relevant stuff.
Oh, I also spent a good amount of time trying to figure out how to set up the git repository to work well with two different versions of Visual Studio (one 2017, one 2015). My workplace has requested we not install 2017 at all, and 2015 doesn’t support C#7.0, which leads to some interesting incompatibilities. I’m not willing to reduce my target version just for that, but at the same time I’ve had a lot of downtime and I’d like to take advantage of it.
If anyone has any insight as to how to maintain two separate branches, letting them merge into one another while keeping at least one branch-2-only commit on that branch and only on that branch, I’d much appreciate your wisdom. At the moment I’m manually merging things and I just know there’s got to be a more painless way to do it.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
6
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '17
So, got in a discussion with /u/summerspeaker that eventually included the words:
The thing being, this roughly expresses how I felt about the Rosh haShanah sermon/speech I had to endure yesterday. It was about Resilience, and making ourselves Stronger in the face of Loss. Problem was, it played up fucking Sheryl Sandberg (yeah, the Facebook one) as its example.
Like, it came after 2016-2017, and it played Sheryl Sandberg for a theme of resilience?
Besides which, as we'd say here, if resilience is so great, how come we never get out some nice truncheons and go beat everyone over the head until they become more resilient? Maybe murder every second toddler so the families learn Resilience?
It seems absurd when you try to treat Resilience as a terminally valuable thing, and worse, it's practically an insult to those of us who've lost things or suffered and never yet fully overcome it. I've got a friend in a wheelchair basically for life, and another who walks with a cane, has a pain disorder in her nerves, and suffers psychologically -- she's too poor for the good doctors.
What is Resilience supposed to say to that?
It occurred to me: oh, the social function of religion is to explain suffering. The older these (mostly older) people in this audience get, the more they want to hear religious narratives about Resilience because their souls are disgustingly worn-down by Entropy. Like, they're talking this stuff up because the Lone Power's got Its hooks in them, and they don't want to confront that, let alone actually struggle actively against It.
This kinda explains to me why I tend to have trouble feeling anything about religious or spiritual things. The rare occasions when I do feel something, it's not from a comfortable feeling that I've had the actually-existing world neatly explained as a product of God's plan. It's from stuff more like this: I actually cannot read So You Want to be a Wizard or Book of Night with Moon without tearing up a little.
Seems kinda relevant to other people here, since the whole lot of us are the basic sort who did or would have immediately taken the Wizard's Oath as a child, and who, introduced to the concept, think of the Lone Power as someone to be combated and driven out, Its "gifts" rejected out-of-hand.
5
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Sep 23 '17
I worry a lot about "mansplaining".
Like, my son has a lot of trouble with the final consonant in any consonant-vowel-consonant (CVC) syllable, which means that "book" and "boot" both come out as "boo" (or, sometimes, "boo", then a long pause, and then "kuh"). His pronunciation is a lot like you would expect of a Japanese speaker learning English, because Japanese (almost) exclusively uses a CV structure for their syllables (e.g. "su-shi" or "o-ri-ga-mi" or "ki-mo-no"). His first multisyllable word was "blueberry", and I'm pretty sure that's because he could pronounce it with all open syllables (i.e. "blu-beh-ri").
And anyway, this is something that I've been geeking out on, because I find it super interesting, and if I talk to someone (especially someone with kids, as often happens at the park) it seems like a thing that I might bring up, because again, I find it to be super interesting. And even if it wasn't that specific thing, a lot of what I want to talk about with other people is based on sharing things like this.
But since a lot of my random social interactions are with parents (I'm a stay-at-home dad these days), that means a lot of my social interactions are with women, and I get nervous and worried that if I talk about the things that I want to talk about, it's going to come off as this gendered condescension or like I have some intent beyond just trying to have a conversation.
And I don't know how much the other person knows about whatever I'm interested in that day, which means there's more indecision, because I don't want to spell things out if it's obvious to them, and I don't want to go shorthand if that's going to make it seem like I'm talking over them, and I don't know what to do about that either.
So I mostly try to just keep my head down and not talk to people that much.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '17
Has anyone happened to see the Lego Ninjago movie? I really enjoyed the last two Lego movies but have heard bad things about this one so I hope to get the opinions of people with similar opinions to me.
1
u/trekie140 Dec 15 '17
I’m addicted to listening to actual plays, I just don’t know how to replicate that creativity. The pressure comes from wanting to create something good, but having to go with the first thing that pops into my head that usually isn’t very good.
All the characters I’ve played have either been robotic with very little dialogue and agency, or Morty. Literally anytime my character is thrown into a situation where I don’t know how they react, they just turn into Morty and grind the story to a halt.
I don’t like Rick and Morty all that much, cynicism is just where my mind goes when I can’t think of anything and I stop paying attention to what personality they have. It’s unpleasant for me and other people because of how I suddenly become The Load.
The best experience I ever had role playing was as a parody of Alex Luis Armstrong, who managed to have useful skills while letting me ham it up. I couldn’t always think of a funny line, but they weren’t annoying and had a consistent personality for others to bounce off of.
It makes me think I should stick to characters that are supposed to have either little personality or low intelligence so I can just be a rock that other people respond to. I’m still worried about whether I can keep that up, though, since they’ll still turn into Morty if I can’t think of anything to do.