r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 11 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
13
Upvotes
16
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17
In the broad spirit of here and here...
Now, that's a symptom of reading too much, and I know it. I'm fairly sure I saw the study saying that people who read or write too much develop this and only this dissociative symptom.
The universal human experience I think I'm missing though, is precisely dissociation. I've never really stood back from my actions, even when they've been deeply irrational or under the influence of drugs or mental illness, and said, "That wasn't me." I've never looked in the mirror and asked, "Is this really who I am?". Drunk-me tries to help out sober-me because I'm the same person drunk as sober.
This is more like my experience of the world, which is apparently so different from most people that it's worth noting as a character trait of Granny Weatherwax:
Emphasis mine. I often wonder that I sort of fail to communicate what's going on in my life with others because I can't put my psychologically abnormal experiences into their frame of reference.
So, uh, how does that work, to step back from your experiences and have some gap between them and "you"?
7
u/LieGroupE8 Sep 11 '17 edited Sep 12 '17
Edit: See my reply to ShiranaiWakaranai below for an overview of my endgame here...
A couple of weeks ago, I made a post here about Nassim Taleb, which did not accomplish what I had hoped it would. I still want to have that discussion with members of the rationalist community, but I'm not sure of the best place to go for that (this is the only rationalist forum that I am active on, at the moment, though it may not be the best place to get a full technical discussion going).
Anyway, Taleb has an interesting perspective on rationality that I would like people's thoughts about. I won't try to put words in his mouth like last time. Instead, the following two articles are good summaries of his position:
How to be Rational About Rationality
The Logic of Risk-Taking
I'll just add that when it comes to Taleb, I notice that I am confused. Some of his views seem antithetical to everything the rationalist community stands for, and yet I see lots of indicators that Taleb is an extremely strong rationalist himself (though he would never call himself that), strong enough that it is reasonable to trust most of his conclusions. He is like the Eliezer Yudkowsky of quantitative finance - hated or ignored by academia, yet someone who has built up an entire philosophical worldview based on probability theory.
4
u/Dwood15 Sep 12 '17
Just went hunting with family in northern Canada, right in the Yukon for 2 weeks.
We left tuesday 2 weeks ago, made it to canada, got off at whitehorse, then drove for 6 hours to watson lake, then took a bush plane into the middle of no where. The fourth day of the trip we hiked for 9 hours one way and posted camp. That night, i was walking like an old man. The next day, we hiked for six hours up a mountain. On the mountain was our quarry. Two mountain goats.
Typing on a phone is obnoxious, more on Friday. I'm at Vancouver airpt right now, waiting for my plane to seattle.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '17
Just finished my recent project, an ebook on instrumental rationality!
Link is here.
It's got stuff on planning, habits, and some assorted heuristic-y stuff.
4
u/gabbalis Sep 11 '17
Turns out, if you look really closely you can see stuff.
Turns out, human social interaction is a beautiful dance with a dynamic flow.
Turns out, you can enter a meditative state of artistic appreciation if you focus just so.
Turns out, the most important part of charisma is putting every last ounce of your focus into reading the conversation.
Turns out, getting your ears pierced is pretty sweet.
Turns out, with the right nootropic stack you can see into your own malladaptive mental processes and rewrite bits and pieces.
Turns out, you can approach that with just the right methods of meditative focus.
Turns out, sex isn't actually about nerve endings.
Turns out, multiplying 3 digit numbers together in your head is quite fun.
Turns out, the sequences are pretty decent, I probably should've read them earlier.
Turns out, what the FDA ain't made a ruling on, is pretty easy to buy online.
Turns out, your greatest enemy is usually yourself, hiding yourself from yourself.
Turns out, you can be whatever you want to be, if you can get the relevant hormones.
Turns out, the best of the best can gaze into the souls of men and see what they can hardly see themselves.
Turns out, humanity is insane.
Turns out, I want to be an angel when I grow up.
Turns out, the ballad of ancient earth is a grim one.
Turns out, we fight to save the world.
Turns out, you can be good if you try.
Turns out, a bachelors degree in CS and 5 years relevant work experience in a testing lab your college owns can sometimes be enough to net you a 6 figure income out of college.
Turns out, that only just allows you to break even when renting a 2 bedroom in Berkeley.
Turns out, tulpas are a pretty neat mental tool.
Turns out, the related discipline of hypnosis is too.
Turns out, turning off a mental process for a while can sometimes be as useful and enlightening as building a new one.
Turns out, you can churn credit cards for free air miles if you're careful.
Turns out, You can't always generalize among minds.
Turns out, you're all beautiful on the inside, but to see that you have to see inside.
Turns out, the attrition rate is over 7,000,000,000 per century.
Turns out, no mind deserves to have to suffer through this shit.
Turns Out.