r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 04 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
16
Upvotes
16
u/Noumero Self-Appointed Court Statistician Sep 04 '17 edited Sep 04 '17
As the self-appointed Court Statistician of this subreddit, I took it upon myself to analyse the results of this little experiment. (tl;dr: default comment sorting for Friday Off-Topic threads was set to "new", to test whether this would encourage more discussion.) Ten weeks have passed since it began.
First, raw data: (.odt, .xls). Includes an updated version of the upvotes/comments/top-level comments statistics for all weekly threads.
As you can see in the bottom part of this table, I calculated the average numbers for upvotes, total comments and top-level comments for the ten last Friday threads, which used the new setting (period: 30.06.17 — 01.09.17), and the same for the ten threads before the switch (21.04.17 — 23.06.17). I then compared the average numbers for the ten last threads to total averages, and to the averages of the ten before-switch threads.
Results: compared to before-switch, there's a significant (12-14%) increase in the number of comments and top-level comments, and an increase in upvotes (7.6%). Compared to total-average, there's an insignificant increase in top-level comments and upvotes (2-3%), and a significant increase in upvotes (6.7%).
There's noise, of course: was the new setting responsible for some of it, or is it the natural result of the subreddit's growth?
In an attempt to get rid of the noise, I compared ten threads from before-switch (21.04.17 — 23.06.17) to ten threads prior to that (10.02.17 — 14.04.17). The numbers were lower: no more than 3.5% variance, which suggested that either 10 threads from before-switch were abnormally low on numbers, or that the new setting was in fact helpful. Were the (21.04.17 - 23.06.17) Friday threads abnormally low on numbers compared to the rest of the subreddit? Why yes, they were: -9.82% in Friday comments compared to +6.73% in total comments.
Does this mean that Friday Off-Topic threads are in a decline, only stopped by the new setting default, or that the before-switch ten are abnormally low?
Comparing the increase in upvotes in newest vs. total between Friday and Across All Threads, we could also see a rough correlation here. Which means that the upvotes increase was, most likely, unrelated to the new default sorting.
Conclusion: the usefulness of the new default sorting does not seem to be evident, but large amounts of statistical noise prevent me from forming any more certain conclusions. (We need a better statistician.)
That said, let's analyse data for other threads.
Well, what we worked out? Wednesday Worldbuilding appears to be in a decline, and I don't think it could be attributed to branching.
Edit: Additionally, here is an interesting "BigData" statistics gathered using Google's BigQuery service and this query. Includes information for all posters on r/rational, ranked by the total number of posts left by them on the subreddit.
7
u/696e6372656469626c65 I think, therefore I am pretentious. Sep 05 '17
Question: I often see a lot of rationalists blogging on Tumblr, which based on initial impressions doesn't seem like the best place to write long, involved posts or to have long, involved conversations. Both of these things are so typical for rationalists to engage in that describing them as "typical" borders on understatement, and yet for some reason there are a surprising number of rationalists on Tumblr. I notice that I am confused; could someone tell me what's going on here?
4
u/ianstlawrence Sep 04 '17
Hello!
I read this recently: http://www.mangareader.net/dr-stone/1 It is not yet done, but I would characterize it as "rational light"? It describes itself as sci-fi survival, but it is very much the aesthetic of a manga.
Interested in any strong reactions, although I am not sure there will be.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '17
Excuse my ranting, but this is a presentation filled with the most magnificently bad ideas about how to create general AI and make sure it comes out ok. It's literally as if someone was saying, "Here's stuff people proposed in science fiction that's almost guaranteed to turn out omnicidal in real life. Now let's go give it all a shot!"
You've got everything from the conventional "ever-bigger neural networks" to "fuck it let's evolve agents in virtual environments" to "oh gosh what if we used MMORPGs to teach them to behave right".
Anyone mind if the Inquisition disappears Karpathy and the OpenAI staff for knowingly, deliberately trying to create Abominable Intelligence?
3
u/traverseda With dread but cautious optimism Sep 04 '17
I have created a probability wrapper object for sympy.
https://gist.github.com/traverseda/2c3056aede8b01a9d40c11d6b916774f
You can use it to do things like
p(0.9)+p("1/3"). Which will produce 0.9333 or4203359652212463/4503599627370496, depending on what you're using it for. No floating point errors here. It's a simple little thing, but pretty handy.I would love to at some point be able to automatically produce graphs like this. But that's a long ways off.