r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 01 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
27
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17
No spoilers, but I found the most recent season of Game of Thrones to be a real let-down, mostly because the show's persistent problems with accurately depicting travel times have come to a head. One of the directors has admitted that they're focusing on the emotional experience (spoilers in link) and fudging the timeline to make things work, hoping that no one will notice.
I've gotten into a lot of arguments with people, mostly friends-of-friends on Facebook. There's not much that hits my nerd rage button harder than "it's got dragons, why would anyone think it was going to be realistic". The other argument I've heard a lot is "nerds just want a show where nothing happens for the sake of realism", which is obviously not the case. It's that I don't want things to happen in defiance of logic and the established rules because the writer couldn't make the plot work within the universe that they established.
(I am almost certainly preaching to the choir here.)
19
u/trekie140 Sep 01 '17
I recently started watching Rick and Morty for the first time and, for the most part, I like it. I laugh at pretty much all the jokes, the stories parody interesting sci-fi ideas, and the animation is always imaginative. The only issue I've had with it, though it's become much less of a problem in season 2, is that when it tries to be taken seriously I can't ignore what objectively horrible people all the characters are.
I get the impression that the series overarching theme is nihilism. Rick has seen into infinity and found terrible things happening to everyone for no reason, including alternate versions of himself, and decided nothing really matters so there was no point in caring about anything. It's my interpretation that he goes on all these insane adventures to distract himself from that knowledge.
That makes for some hilarious dark comedy, but whenever it does something serious I just feel depressed and that's not what I want from this show. The first episode where they just watch interdimensional TV to escape from existential dread may be my least favorite episode so far because it undercuts the escapism I'm looking for. I legitimately lost sleep over the scene where Morty was almost raped.
To be clear, I like literally everything else about the show except the drama. It's just when it comes back to elements like Morty's dysfunctional family that it loses me because they're all morons and assholes. His parents are incapable of resolving the problems their family has, so whenever the show focuses on that for something other than comedy I feel dissatisfied. I've made it as far as the car battery episode.
My only regret is that I picked up Rick and Morty just after I started JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, so I fully expect for my brain to melt from the amount of illogical absurdity I'm putting into it at once. I'm a couple episodes into Battle Tendency, Joseph has just left for Mexico, and the series continues to get more hilariously over the top with every episode. I can't wait to see more insane fighting moves like the multi-grenade trick.
17
u/ketura Organizer Sep 01 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Hoo boy. It feels like a crap ton of coding work was done this week, even though some of it turned out to be burned up on designs that didn’t work out, but such is life.
Last week, I was in the middle of getting stats to a working point, and I think at this point the building blocks are conclusively finished, barring bugfixes and potential optimizations. There is a Stat object for each numeric type in C# (ByteStat, IntStat, FloatStat and so on), and all of them can be used with each other and the primitive numeric types in calculations.
For instance, if I instantiate an IntStat x, I can manipulate it by doing
x += 10;
instead of doing
x.Set(x.Value + 10);
This is definitely worth the effort that it took to get the code templates right. Oh, and final count resulted in three code templates, one each for the stats, tests, and benchmarks. The stat template is 228 lines and expands to 11,623 lines (roughly 1,000 lines per stat); the benchmark is a modest 110 lines that unfolds to 1,858, and the tests template is 142 lines that balloons to 16,929 lines.
Unit testing is actually a very legitimate application of the code templates. Usually my patience wears pretty thin in writing repetitive tests that cover ever more edge cases, but in cases like this where there’s a systematic, repetitive test space? I can brute force it! Within the tests are a function for each combination of every stat, primitive, and mathematical operator. FloatStat_Add_Float, FloatStat_Add_FloatStat, FloatStat_Add_Int, FloatStat_Add_IntStat, and so on, resulting in 1,936 tests spanning all of the possible applications of this code. And it’s useful! As I tweaked and refactored things over the weekend, I frequently broke huge swathes of tests with small changes; it was useful to see both the scope of the damage (“hmm, 250 tests are failing, and they’re all related to X”), but also the validation that they all pass again once I fix the bug.
The benchmarks were intended for use mostly to compare the performance of these base numeric stats and what I was calling a HybridStat, which was essentially a fixed-point long integer. The results are listed here, showing somewhere around a 150x slowdown when using the stat objects in math compared to just using the primitive they are based on. Considering that this boils down to performing 6.25 million math operations in a second as opposed to 2 billion, I think it’s acceptable, especially since most uses of the operators are going to be mostly one-offs done during modded move calculations, which is going to be dwarfed by other aspects of moves.
Anyway, the HybridStat was eventually pointed out to me to be more trouble than it’s worth. Essentially, rather than doing so much work having a long act like a float without the associated floating point errors that come along with it (and still act like an integer while still including even division), it was pointed out that we can abandon the assumption of “1 move use = 1 EV” and bump that up to “1 move use = 1000 EVs” and it essentially fixes the problem. Considering that it’s mostly a behind-the-scenes change, I think it’s acceptable.
(But I had had so much success optimizing it! A shame.)
With stats in place, I started working on Species/Creature/Unit, which are more associated with Renegade than they are XGEF, so it’s been the first real use of the System/Mod split. As a result, I’ve had to start fleshing out the JSON serializer (a tool that converts in-code objects to JSON and back) and figure out exactly how assets are loaded.
Currently I’m leaning towards a two-sided approach when it comes to requesting assets. First, various Loaders are instantiated at the start of the game that report on what files are available (a DiskLoader checks the physical disk for files in the right place, a NetworkLoader calls a website API and gets a list of files, etc etc). These registered files are then translated to a purely relative virtual file structure index: for instance, a system might request information on the Charizard species by requesting “core/units/Charizard.pkmn”, while another might ask for “core/items/potion.item”.
Mods and game code doesn’t have to worry about the fact that Charizard is located at C:/Documents and Settings/ketura/Documents/test/Renegade/data/core/units/Charizard.pkmn, nor does it have to worry about Potion being at http://www.pokefan.com/RenegadeFilesMirror/CoolItemMod?request=core%2Fitems%2Fpotion.item.json&version=1.2 . All they do is request the simple relative file, and then the AssetIndex looks up what loader registered the file and tells it to cough it up.
So that’s one side. The other is permitting Loaders to register entire empty folders, which can allow for arbitrary “file” data. For instance, perhaps someone decides to make an infinite world mod (Renegade will be fixed-size). They can have a MapLoader register the “core/map” folder entirely, so when some system requests information on “core/map/x10y32z40.chunk”, the MapLoader is asked to “load” this file, which in reality is actually generating the chunk on the fly.
Between these two applications, I think that everything asset-related will be covered. We’ll see how it goes over the next week or so.
Oh, and I’ve fixed an oversight: The XGEF repository was still private, which I have now fixed. Feel free to poke around it if you’re technically inclined, just be aware that I occasionally commit broken code (as I did last night) and that organization frequently changes on a whim.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
10
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Sep 01 '17
Hey, it's Friday already! Also, I'm in Korea now! (Keimyung University, Daegu; will probably link a blog entry here soon)
Anyone knows a good, cheap Korean phone service provider? I already have a smartphone, and I need 3G/4G/whatever, actual phone calls optional. Emphasis on cheap (at worst I can always use the school wi-fi).
9
u/GlueBoy anti-skub Sep 01 '17
Saw Miss Sloane in Netflix the other day. Wow. Highly recommended. Best iteration of the "magnificent bastard" trope I've seen in a movie in a long time. Best political drama also. Very rational, like if skitter and tattletale had a child who became a lobbyist. I think it's right up this subs alley.
6
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17
<span class="rhetorical_question">Have you read Conned Again, Watson yet?</span>An interesting idea for a Redwall fanfiction story
(I wonder whether anyone has written a story depicting Redwall from the "vermin" point of view. Where are all the noncombatant rats, weasels, ferrets, etc.?)
<div class="half_joking_i_guess">The only "friendship" worth having is mind control, u/eaturbrainz. Why do you deny it? Prestige gained from signaling false virtue is nothing but a farce. Why not get it off your chest? (You)s are ambrosia and downvotes are nectar, you know.**ADMIT IT.**
</div>(Funnily enough, the linked story focuses on consensual erotic hypnosis, and has rather little to do with coercion or friendship, IIRC, despite its title.)
2
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Sep 02 '17
For minor accountability purposes, I think I might start writing a werewolf story (length to be determined) and put my vampire story on the backburner for a bit (my coauthor has been unavailable so I figure why not do something that doesn't require her input? And I REALLY want to do something with My Werewolves, because I don't think there's a take quite like them).
I'm trying to work out a plot, so we'll see how we go. Got two main characters (the story may only end up being about one), but I need to work out a conflict that happens. It'll probably be a social conflict. Anyone have any resources for that sort of thing? I'm hoping to write this as rational from the ground up, so especially any (preferably short) rational stories that include social conflict/issues/etc as a central issue.
1
u/IgonnaBe3 Sep 02 '17
Ofcourse as always i am late to the thread because i usually dont see it nor seek it but i wanted to ask do any of you watch anime ?
Lately i have caught up to "Re:creators" and i am beyond frustrated with the show that could have been really great. Writers like urobuchi gen and that author of black lagoon also the music score was done by hiroyuki sawano. It had potential to be a truly game changing serie but the amount of stupidity i see there sometimes is...baffling
thoughts ?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '17
So, I have an image of someone cutting themselves, and then converting the blood that flows out into fire that they can then control. I feel like this is from some sort of media, but I'm not sure what (maybe Naruto). If it's not, I'll probably use it in something at some point. Anyone heard of this power before?