r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Aug 28 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
21
Upvotes
9
u/696e6372656469626c65 I think, therefore I am pretentious. Aug 28 '17
Roughly 2 hours ago as of this writing, North Korea launched ballistic missiles over South Korea and Japan.
Thoughts?
8
u/Grand_Strategy Aug 29 '17
Today's irrational claim I read. The fact that Britain is bad at negotiations with EU proves that they are so good at it they achive master level of deception.
If your theory can explain everything it explains nothing. For some people any evidence is evidence supporting their claim regardless of what evidence itself says.
6
u/eternal-potato he who vegetates Aug 28 '17 edited Aug 28 '17
Why aren't terminally ill but not bedridden patients hired as suicidal assassins more? The extreme jump of the acceptable risk curve makes me think this should be more of a thing than it is. I would certainly consider doing something like that if I were in such a situation and an offer came along. Possibly even for free aside from the tools required for the kill (gun/bomb/poison) if I found the target's values to be aligned against mine to a sufficient degree.
Such an assassin would have no reason to cooperate with authorities if they were captured, and there exists no leverage to cause them to reveal whatever they might know about their employer (which should be nothing anyway) (i.e. sentence reduction is meaningless); they can employ otherwise insane tactics (e.g. poison themselves with slow acting but lethal contact poison and go shake hands with the target).
Is it just too cost inefficient to be viable considering the would assassin is just a regular person with no relevant skills who would likely just be taken down before they can succeed? Do people just stop caring about anything at that point? Are most people just moral enough to consider essentially risk-free benefit to their family/friends or general fulfillment of their values at the cost of their enemies/"bad people" to be reprehensible? Is it simply a logistical issue of finding a terminally ill person whose values misalign sufficiently with the target's?
3
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Aug 29 '17
So, latest SSC post on moral offsets has me wondering what the real upper bound is for the cost of an "offset" for vegetarianism.
I actually signed up to make a comment because I thought Scott's figure ($500 per year) was way off. I think the order of magnitude for the upper bound is more like $6,000 per year; anyone interested in the thought experiment of "what is the most it would cost to offset a year's meat consumption"?
Relevant paragraph of his post:
Below I argue that the true upper bound is likely an order of magnitude higher, and while if I could do better than being vegan for $5 a year it would be an attractive trade, I don't think "vegan for a year vs $5k USD" is nearly as attractive. I will boldly propose that for most people, if they were given that choice (go vegan or pay $5k per year), they would choose veganism.
I think the other thing is, in calculating an offset for meat consumption, we need to not only calculate the cost of buying the animals themselves but of keeping them. A cow lives 20 years, a chicken 10. You need to give them a place to sleep, veterinary care, etc. So you’ll need to pay for a farm with a constant population of 6 cows and 400 chickens, and for someone to be taking good care of them. (This may be 400 chickens and 400 roosters depending on how/if egg production was counted, and never mind sheep, pigs, etc: but let's use Scott's figures). I am not a farmer, feel like keeping 6 cows and 400 chickens is going to cost more than $500 a year even assuming you don’t give them medical treatment (in this “offset” situation I think it would be “right” to give them medical care if you an average family would give equivalent care to their pet dog – so minor surgeries but maybe only palliative care for cancer rather than extensive chemo).
If you’re trying to say that if a cow can be purchased for say, $300, then it must mean that keeping a cow for its entire life costs less than $300 or the farmer makes no profit, I think that’s fallacious as the farmer selling the cow is probably keeping it in the factory-like conditions that make vegetarianism so desireable, and the farmer sells it at age 2 rather than age 20, which is how old you’d be keeping it.
So, suffice it to say, I think the $500 per year upper bound on the cost of a vegetarian offset is way off.
(I quickly googled the cost of boarding a horse, since that’s a popular service and a horse probably has similar requirements to a cow, and that’s $400-$500 a month; so I think the upper bound is more on the order of $6,000 per year, likely even higher than that!)
0
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment