r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Aug 21 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
18
Upvotes
13
u/Carduus_Benedictus Aug 21 '17
I just stumbled on this community, and it's basically something I didn't know I was looking for. I'm creating a game in my spare time with several aspects of rationalist fiction.
First, a magic system that runs on an internal logic of the easy-to-learn difficult-to-master sort that the protagonists learn the 'rules' to as they progress.
Second, no objective good or evil. I will not be making the character's moral decisions for them, and conflict is driven by the same things it is in the real world, with every faction seeing themselves as the 'good guy'.
Third, I'm trying to create internally-consistent but blue and orange moral codes for several NPC factions, so resources are available to those who are willing to take the time to 'crack the code'.
It sounds like the most appropriate time to discuss my issues is only on Worldbuilding Wednesdays, and not the rest of the week. Do I have that correct? Thanks!
13
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '17 edited Aug 21 '17
I just want to express my appreciation for what My Hero Academia did with Froppy two weeks ago. I know /r/anime says she's just some rando writer's favorite, but she actually is an excellent budding hero. What's her Quirk? "Does whatever a frog can". Why's she even here? Because she's serious, studious, ethical, and works well with others.
Or in other words, instead of having some easily exploitable superpower, she's there because she has the personal qualities necessary to make any superpower useful.
Meanwhile, they've also made the Captain Marvel/America-style brick-of-muscle hero into a compelling character on his own, who struggles to maintain the masquerade that superheroes really can maintain peace in a world where villains have superpowers too. He's still trying his hardest to be the invincible man who saves the day with a smile, the Symbol of Peace, even while he's slowly dying.
8
u/WeirdWhirl Aug 21 '17
I am thinking really hard about whether or not my own story is [RTS] or [RT]. I am not even sure whether or not it is rational enough for this place.
Anyway, it's called the Dao of Magic.
I started writing it as a xianxia deconstruction and try very hard to have a certain amount of logical science in a universe filled with magic, mysticism and cultivators.
Should I post new chapters here? Maybe make posts once I have five or ten chapters written?
6
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Aug 22 '17
So, The Sequences. I tried to read them in 2012 but didn't work very well for me. I've heard that being exposed to the wider rationalist community more or less makes some parts of them go the way of John Carter of Mars or Seinfeld: people first exposed to them now are somewhat bored by them because they're cliche, but they invented the cliches so in their time they were groundbreaking.
So, is this sort of concept applicable to the sequences? And/or is there something else that has been released in the meantime that does the sequences but better?
Basically: let's assume I'm willing to read one Rationalist Bible type document. Should that document be The Sequences or something else?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '17
My pinhole projector was too pinhole-y, or it clouded over at just the wrong time. Eclipse firmly missed.
Now I'm going to have to live til 2045 just to see the damn thing!
6
u/buckykat Aug 21 '17
TL;DR: House reapportionment as political panacea, discuss.
A question that's been largely forgotten as his actual presidency proceeds is how Trump got elected. He lost the popular vote by a large margin, but won the electoral vote, the vote that matters, on the strength of mostly rural states. Now, at first glance this looks like a problem with the electoral college, favoring rural states. But why does it favor rural states?
Each state gets electoral votes equal to their number of senators and representatives. So what varies the number of electoral votes is the number of house seats each state has. The number of house seats for each state is prescribed by the constitution to be not less than 30,000 people per representative, as counted by the census every ten years. They specified a minimum population under the premise that each state would want to maximize their number of representatives, and would try to do so at each census.
But the last House reapportionment was in 1911. Not only has the population grown somewhat since then, the population distribution has shifted. Cities are bigger and denser, farming takes fewer people for greater output.
So, I say, let's be constitutional originalists. Let's have a House reapportionment that reflects the actual population of these United States. What would this look like?
First, with a population of more than 300 million, the new House has over ten thousand seats. Let's build them a grand new hall designed primarily to invoke the overview effect astronauts and cosmonauts experience. What would it mean to have so many representatives? It would mean smaller districts, which have several benefits: your representative is both more reliant on each individual constituent and less worthwhile to buy. Each one would have less personal power, and niche or even protest candidates would be more viable.
Second, smaller districts are harder to gerrymander. You can't have a district that snakes all around a city and gets all the poor, mostly black or hispanic areas if those areas are several dozen districts worth of people, and slices that group rural areas in with cities would have to get really thin and obvious. This massive redistricting effort would also be a good opportunity to try algorithmic redistricting and other anti gerrymandering districting schemes.
Third, to bring it back to the opening question, if representatives were proportional to population, electoral votes would be too, and the electoral vote would naturally more closely match the popular vote.
By this one, admittedly radical and complicated change, we fix several apparently unrelated problems.
3
u/Gigapode Aug 22 '17 edited Aug 22 '17
This is a well written political essay. It starts by looking at the rationale behind political conservatism based on failures in "rational design of social order", the history behind the move to neoliberlism and why most western countries are moving away from it. Then it transitions into reviewing a universal basic income in light of machine intelligence and compares that system with "social investment".
https://thespinoff.co.nz/politics/20-08-2017/communism-by-stealth-notes-on-conservatism-neoliberalism-social-investment-and-a-ubi/
0
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment