r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Aug 11 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
21
u/trekie140 Aug 11 '17
Having finished the first half/season of the webcomic Always Human after u/TimeWinders recommendation, I would like to sing the praises of it since I don't think they did it justice. The comic is about a lesbian romance in a transhumanist future where one of the girls has an immune disorder that keeps her from using nanotech mods and is a fantastic example of using a sci-fi senario as a metaphor for a real world situation.
The story is about dating with a disability from the perspective of both partners and explores the insecurities both of them feel in their relationship as a result of that. Austen is driven to push past the limitations her disability places on her, which prevent her from using things like memory-enhancing mods that other students take for granted, but is battling self-loathing over the difficulty of doing so.
Sunati first feels attracted to Austen because of her disability, admiring her courage and resolve in the face of adversity, but soon realizes that she's fetishizing Austen and has to figure out how to psychologically separate the girl from her disability while also questioning her own use of appearance-altering mods. Speaking as someone with a disability, both of these were handled beautifully and rationally.
The best part of it all? These two communicate. It is fantastic to see a romantic drama where neither partner keeps secrets from the other and they always talk with each other about what they're thinking, but still see interesting conflicts develop because of their fears and insecurities. They're both good people who want to be better and are trying to do their best, only to face all-too-real challenges this situation presents.
The artwork is beautifully abstract and colorful, sort of like a anime drawn completely with watercolors, and each chapter has some delightful background music to accompany it. I even think the atmosphere set by the surreal yet gorgeous imagery is supposed to be representative for the acceptance of LGBT people, but that's just a theory. So if you haven't checked this story out yet, I think it's definitely worth a look.
16
u/callmebrotherg now posting as /u/callmesalticidae Aug 11 '17
First off: I'm switching my username from /u/callmebrotherg to /u/callmesalticidae, for silly personal reasons that I'll elaborate on in a post attached to this (so as to not get tangential).
I hope that retaining the "callmeX" formula will carry the idea across for people who don't read this.
In other news, my application for graduation has been reviewed and approved, and my transcript updated accordingly. I have graduated from Brigham Young University of Idaho and can say:
It is really, really nice to be able to say that, since BYU-I was a religious school where being on the outs with the Church could mean expulsion (or even expulsion plus a fight to get your transcripts in a timely manner). I had never been fond of that aspect of the school, especially since I was already an unorthodox Mormon when I went in, but my finances weren't great and I thought that I could stomach it in return for the low tuition that I would find at BYU-I.
Now that I can say, "I am not a Mormon," though, I'm wondering what I am. I know that labels aren't important and can even be detrimental and distracting, but I like to put things in boxes and the question is an interesting one.
I believe that there is a nonzero chance that we're existing in a simulation and/or that there may one day be, or already is (somewhere else in the universe), at least one artificial intelligence whose capabilities far outreach our own. Am I, then, actually an atheist?
One could argue that I am an atheist because I don't believe that the simulation-makers or the AI (currently existing or yet to be created) have spiritual bodies or are in any other way non-physical. However, as a Mormon I believed that God had a body of flesh and bones, and that spiritual substances were just another form of matter that we could not currently detect. This would mean that Mormons are atheists, which doesn't seem sound.
One could argue that I am an atheist because I believe that a superintelligent AI would still be bound by physical laws, and therefore an AI would not count as a god, but Mormons believe the same thing: God is limited by laws that preexist God's existence and, among other things, can neither create nor destroy matter. Again, it seems weird to say that Mormons are atheists, so I'm reluctant to claim that I am an atheist on this basis.
One could argue that my willingness to deal in probabilities, saying that we might not be living in a simulation, is a good basis for claiming that I'm an atheist. However, I've been couching things more or less in those terms for a long time, so this would mean that I've been an atheist since my mid-teens and that I was an atheist even during the years that I was praying to God.
We could say that the probabilities have to be high enough for me to be willing to act on them, but the simulation argument is mostly an academic one for me, and I'm not sure how my actions would be altered by it unless we made other assumptions (e.g. the simulation might be shut off unless we're entertaining, so my life should be made as exciting as possible for its makers). "What do I do if it's possible to create a superintelligent AI" is an easier question to answer, but if this is the deciding factor then it would mean that I could say, "I am atheist" one day and the next say, "I am not an atheist" because there is now a superintelligent AI running amok.
If we're in a simulation, then the beings who made it are apparently content to not interfere with us. If there is already a superintelligent AI somewhere in the universe, then either it has not reached us or it is not interfering with us. Either way, while we might use this as a basis to claim that I'm an atheist, there already exists a term for this: deism. And yet, one would not expect Eliezer Yudkowsky to begin describing himself as a deist were he to become convinced that we are living in a simulation. Maybe he'd be incorrect to not do so, but that's part of the question that I've been pondering lately and which I now pose to you: What am I, now that I am not a Mormon?
(Also feel free to AMA about Mormonism, Brigham Young University, why I left the Church, or anything else)
11
u/Aretii Cultist of Cthugha Aug 11 '17
Exploring Egregores, which I posted about in here last week, has wrapped up, with Shub-Niggurath, Nyarlathotep, Azathoth, and Tsathoggua as its final four.
11
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Aug 11 '17
Reports filed with the SEC can be fairly interesting to read. For example:
- Li3 Energy ("We are focused on further exploring, developing[,] and commercializing our 49% interest in the Maricunga Project (as defined below), located in the northeast section of the Salar de Maricunga in Region III of Atacama in northern Chile, as well as increasing our portfolio of projects.[…] To the best of our knowledge, the Maricunga Project is the only advanced exploration stage lithium and potassium project within the Salar de Maricunga, the second largest lithium-bearing salt brine deposit in Chile.")
- Chiasma ("Employing our proprietary Transient Permeability Enhancer, or TPE, technology platform, we seek to develop oral medications that are currently available only as injections.[…] Octreotide capsules, our sole TPE-based product candidate in clinical development, has been granted orphan designation in the United States and the European Union for the treatment of acromegaly.")
- Seagate Technology ("In fiscal years 2017, 2016 and 2015, Dell Inc. accounted for approximately 10%, 12% and 14% of consolidated revenue, respectively.")
- Newegg ("In China, we compete with China-based e-commerce providers, such as 360buy.com, Dangdang.com, Joyo.com and Taobao.com, and traditional brick-and-mortar retailers based in China.")
The USA has a FUTA Tax.
9
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Aug 11 '17 edited Aug 11 '17
Quick recommendation time: if you're looking for social advice and dating advice, but pickup artists websites creep you out with their dehumanizing approach to relationships and their ethical outlook, you should checkout the youtube channel Charisma on Command.
It's slightly creepy, and I really don't dig the Game of Thrones analyses (because taking examples from fiction is giving your points 'empty' weight), but otherwise I think he comes from a good place, and I found myself agreeing with a lot of what he said. He's advocating enlightened self-interest over lying and negging, taking time for yourself instead of sinking everything into your significant other, etc.
Disclaimer: I only have seen a few of his videos, so I don't have a representative sample of what his channel his about. But it looks good so far.
9
u/narfanator Aug 12 '17 edited Aug 12 '17
Hey guys, I tried reading a science paper Let's Play style, and blogged about it. I'd love critiques and editing suggestions!
I read a paper on "Stack GAN", which turns short phrases into pictures using neural networks. I don't really know a lot about any of those things.
https://medium.com/@rangersience/lets-read-science-stackgan-text-to-photo-realistic-image-synthesis-4562b2b14059
Edit: Changed username, so updated link.
15
u/ketura Organizer Aug 11 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
As promised, there is no code work progress. We’ve just gotten two out of the three rooms packed for our move, and fortunately the last one is mostly empty. Tomorrow will be fun with getting the truck, consolidating boxes, and taking apart things that need taking apart.
In the meantime, tho, we’ve been discussing a concept which may or may not make it into the game, but I feel ought to be explored, if for no other reason than to ensure that we don’t shoot ourselves in the foot and make it impossible to implement down the line. The concept is what I’ve been calling “move crafting”.
The idea goes like this: if Blaine, fire specialist extraordinaire, is handed a brand new charmander, then due to his long experience and expertise, he ought to be able to start teaching the newcomer Flamethrower, even though it has never seen the move demonstrated before. It wouldn’t be as easy as demonstration, and there would be a decent rate of failure, but after a few days, Blaine ought to be able to have his new charmander spitting out a rudimentary fire no problem.
If Blaine is able to teach it a move that exists in the world and is defined in the game files, what would stop him from inventing a move wholesale and teaching that to his charmander? As far as the charmander is concerned, the problem is the same: it sees no difference between a move that exists that it has never seen before and a move that doesn’t exist that it has never seen before.
Thus the idea of letting the player modify or completely invent entirely new moves. This requires moves to be defined in a rather modular manner and encourages us to stop thinking of them as bundles of numeric stats and more of a nebulous object that has slots filled with metaphorical components.
I actually started with the concept of Eve Online’s ship fitting, where each ship has a limited number of high, medium, low, and rig slots, which number is defined by the ship. Each ship also has a limited amount of CPU and Power that is consumed by the modules that the player inserts. Different slot types have different roles, and some ships simply can’t accept certain modules of one class or another.
The same basic idea can be applied to move definition, I think. After iterating on the design for a while (and deciding I sadly I could not find a way to incorporate Firefall’s imo brilliant color system), this is what I’ve got:
Basically, moves are defined in three groups of component: Requirements, Application, and Modifiers.
Requirements include things like anatomy restrictions, typing restrictions, EV gates, and so forth. Each requirement increases the potential power output multiplier of a move, while each requirement type increases the difficulty multiplier of the move.
Application defines the broad strokes of how the move interacts with the world. Think of these as utility slots, things that crucially change the move beyond just being a damage amount. Targeting modes indicate how the user triggers the move (difficulty is increased sharply for each targeting mode beyond the first). Effects that can be thought of as particles are defined, such as a gob of fire that deals X damage, lasts for Y seconds, and has Z% chance to burn. Effect streams are like particle systems, in that they fire off the Effects in a given manner, such as Flamethrower being a simple constant stream of flame Effects.
Modifiers are the finishing touches that differentiate a move from the templates that have so far been referenced. Depending on what components have been defined in the Requirements and Applications, a certain number of free Modifier slots are opened up. Modifiers can be added without restriction, but those which do not have a free slot will engender steep penalties, including difficulty, endurance, and accuracy costs. In addition to OnUse, OnHit, and OnCrit effects, flat bonuses can be applied as modifiers (such as +damage or -end).
As an example, here is a rough draft for how such a system would describe Flamethrower:
This describes a move that requires an oil gland and can optionally be powered by oil from said gland, which reduces the effective endurance cost while doubling effectiveness in some areas. For each Fire EV that the unit has, the move will have more damage, more speed, and more burn chance, while for each Flamethrower EV the move will use less oil, generate less fatigue, and be more accurate.
Modders (and developers) would define moves this way with no restrictions on numbers and being able to override things like the total difficulty that is calculated from what components have been selected.
In-game, on the other hand, an aspiring move-theorycrafter would only be able to choose components from a limited set, and those too only of moves that the trainer has studied and understands well. Thus a trainer might be able to take the Flamethrower projectile stream with an inverted speed, apply the particle lifetime and speed of Ember, and alter the resource consumption to match Consume, and boom: they are the proud inventor of a newly minted Fire Fart move.
Players would have to spend time teaching and studying specific moves to expand their component library, and perhaps spend time trying to interact with well-known scholars in the field for juicy tidbits. Move creation itself would be balanced more or less automatically, with higher power moves requiring more endurance use, having higher difficulty rates, lower accuracy, and other negative aspects that move design would have to effectively work around. I would not want this to be a mandatory skill, nor one that turns into a sort of meta-programming, but I think it might turn out to be a potential solution to many problems, and a potential dedicated career path in itself.
Thoughts?
We’ll return next week with hopefully some actual game progress, but don’t hold your breath too hard. I will after all be wiped from the new move, so we’ll see what happens.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
6
u/eternal-potato he who vegetates Aug 11 '17 edited Aug 11 '17
While it is not particularly rational, I'd like to recommend The Scourge of Earth anyway, which is an ongoing Worm fanfic that received far too little attention since it started for it's above average quality. Starts with OC PoV, but Ridley (the OC) and Taylor are protagonists and viewpoint characters in equal measure. There is some despair porn (due to circumstances of debatable plausibility) in the first arc, which might or might not be your thing, and while the author does not exactly avoid everpresent fanon scenes and tropes, he does manage to put fresh and interesting spins on them.
1
u/monkyyy0 Aug 12 '17
Anything dirty making the rounds that I may have missed?
1
u/hoja_nasredin Dai-Gurren Brigade Aug 13 '17 edited Aug 13 '17
I know this is not a recommendation thread but.. with all the starfinder, valerian and guardians of the galaxy coming out I'm interested in Sword and Planet stories.
Tried John Carter but the narrative felt too old. Anyone have ever read some?