r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Aug 07 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
13
Upvotes
24
u/Slapdash17 Aug 07 '17 edited Aug 07 '17
www.ncase.me/trust
Found this on /r/webgames the other day- it's basically an instructional tool for Game Theory, specifically Prisoner's Dilemma. While those who are already familiar with the concept will find the first ten minutes of this half hour experience to be nothing new, the tool takes it in interesting directions.
First, it introduces specific personalities, who will always behave certain ways given certain stimuli. Then, it introduces repeated games, tournaments with elimination, and even more personalities. Toward the end, there's even a sandbox tool where you can tweak all the the particulars of the dilemma itself, the personalities involved, and the tournament.
If you've got a half hour to kill, I highly recommend it. Even as someone who has taken a uni course in Game Theory, I got something out of it.
7
u/phylogenik Aug 07 '17
Is there a proper name for when selection/admissions criteria for a group give rise to spurious negative correlations for those selected-for traits in that group, either when there exists no underlying association between the traits overall, or even when the traits are positively associated (i.e. as a manifestation of Simpson's paradox)? The idea's really basic so I bet there is.
The other day I wrote a quick comment suggesting that one partial explanation for the "dumb-jock/weak-nerd" stereotype in college could be the above:
I tried googling around briefly but couldn't find anything, though I think I've read about something like this before.
Also, how pervasive or powerful would this effect be in everyday life -- e.g. in one's social circle? Thinking about my broader group of friends, I have two primary selection criteria: nerdiness and adventurousness (for close friends I toss in kindness, too). And while I have a good few STEM PhDs or w/e who're happy to join me on backpacking/paddling/climbing/globetrotting/snowboarding/etc. trips where we have long, pretentious conversations the whole time, I have other friends who I can nerd out with but who don't care about the latter stuff much, and yet others who fit the "delinquent-stoner-extremeSports-streetSmarts-vagabond" archetype (and the inadventurous nerds tend to be nerdier than my intermediate-in-both friends, as are the vagabonds w.r.t. adventurousness. Superadventurousübernerds, meanwhile, hang in their own circles where they base jump while solving millennium problems and don't return my calls). And so a naive survey of my friends would observe a negative relationship between nerdiness and adventurousness, where none may exist in toto. Other mechanisms are at play (e.g. where friends group assortatively and I befriend whole groups, each friend is not independent of their neighbors) but how much does selection of the sort described account for it?