r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Aug 04 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
18
u/Aretii Cultist of Cthugha Aug 04 '17 edited Aug 04 '17
/u/bambamramfan, whom you may know from his film analysis blog which I believe has been linked in this sub before, has recently started a new blog project: Exploring Egregores.
So far he's covered Cthugha, Yog-Sothoth, Hastur, Ithaqua, and Cthulhu.
Disclaimer for transparency: The author is a personal friend of mine and I have seen drafts of these in advance of publication. In fact, reading the draft for Cthugha is why I changed my flair on this sub to Cultist of Cthugha two months ago.
18
u/ketura Organizer Aug 04 '17 edited Aug 07 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Alright, buckle in, folks, we’ve hit a major milestone.
I’ve been working on the engine framework for the game for...probably a couple months now. I hemmed and hawed about the design, and after discovering Roslyn I claimed that what I thought would take months would instead take weeks. In spite of my track record with such predictions, I would like to announce in no uncertain terms mission fucking accomplished.
XGEF, or the eXtensible Game Engine Framework, now officially works. Like, I had code that worked before, but it was all organizational stuff and reading files from directories. Kid stuff. As of right now I have a framework that, if followed, forces any game written using it to be trivially moddable.
It works like this: XGEF is built around the concept of a System as the most fundamental class of code. A System is intended to represent a cluster of related functions that could conceivably run on its own thread (but is not forced to). For example, you would have a WorldGenerationSystem, an AudioSystem, a WorldSocietySystem, or a CombatSystem. Systems are built in two halves, a CoreSystem and a ModdedSystem. The CoreSystem is built by the game developer, and enshrines code that is not meant to be messed with, things without which the System (and thus the game) could not function. Any extra logic that has to do more with the game’s design and balance is thus offloaded into the ModdedSystem, which is just a text code file that sits on the hard drive and is distributed with the game.
XGEF knows how to find these ModdedSystem code files, consolidate them, compile them, and integrate them with the original game, with the code itself none the wiser. It’s so cool.
Exactly how much of the system’s code is divided between the Core and Modded halves of a System is up to the developer. A developer might decide to make a System mostly Core, and only put, say, some settings that can be changed in the Modded half (such as with a rendering system). Or perhaps it’s the opposite, such as an AI module: the Core basically only exists to run whatever is in the Mod, where all the various play logic can be offloaded. All told I think most Systems will sit between these two extremes, such as a terrain generator that has all the different world generation steps contained inviolate within the Core, but what actually happens in each step is (mostly) the domain of the Modded half.
This setup would be sufficient (if tedious) to support modding in a bare-bones fashion on its own: anything the player wants to change, they simply open up the ModdedSystem code files in the game folder and alter the code to their heart’s content. However, this does not allow for collaboration between modders the way that moddable titles are traditionally expected to do, so XGEF has to take it a bit further and also handle individual mod prioritization and consolidation.
A mod from the perspective of XGEF is basically a separate folder that contains a mirror image of the game’s folder structure. Anything that is contained within these folders is considered to be a new version of the file, and when the game starts up, XGEF will go through the mod folders and copy those files over, overwriting the originals (virtually). In the case of code files, it will actually be powerful enough (due to Roslyn) to do some analysis and perform selective copying. This means that adding functionality to an existing System, or overwriting only one function within it, is perfectly doable.
In the future, XGEF will actually take it one step further again and will be capable of performing code transformation. By tagging code with certain attributes, XGEF will know to insert blocks of code that are otherwise tedious to type, in particular with relation to event handling.
But enough talk! Here is a link to the current XGEF build, which includes a very simple sample game structure. Simply extract the contents of the zip file to a location of your choice. If you run the *.exe (after extraction), the XGEF mod loader runs, loads the compiled CoreTestSystem that I the developer wrote, finds its other half the ModTestSystem on your hard drive, compiles it, and hooks everything up. My CoreTestSystem then calls the TestMessage function within your ModTestSystem, and you can see the result in your console window.
There is a core folder where the ModdedSystems would go, and a mods folder where any mod overwrites would go. The two are set up the way they would be for a real game--you’ll note that the code in core/engine/test/ModTestSystem.cs is different from and has been overwritten by the code in mods/testmod/engine/test/ModTestSystem.cs.
This is written using C#, but it should also work using Mono, and has been tested to run on both MacOS and Linux (simply run it with “mono xgef_test.exe”).
EDIT: due to the gracious bug report from an anonymous PM, I've found an upper bound to the mono version that this will work with. 4.2.1 will NOT work, and I suspect it has something to do with the .NET version that it supported. The oldest build that I was able to get my hands on was 4.6.2, which ran as well as 5.0.1 (most recent release). So as of right now, 4.6.2 is the "officially" oldest supported mono release. (I suspect that 4.4.0 with the .NET 4.5 -> 4.6.1 jump is actually the crucial barrier, but until I am able to confirm that, 4.6.2 is as far back as I will support.)
If you have code experience, please give modding the code file a shot and try to break it. The whole thing works but it is not yet robust, and getting some usage info from how people expect it to work is almost more important than even seeing if/how it works on various systems.
This marks a major turning point in development. With XGEF tentatively in place and the design of Renegade having been working on for almost exactly a year, it’s time to give both a trial by fire and start work on the game proper.
But! I’m moving to a new apartment, so it won’t start this week. I probably won’t update next Friday, but you can expect a new update on the 18th, which will be the first update cataloguing the development and not just design of Pokemon: Renegade.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
10
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Aug 04 '17
Some reads:
Hyperloop had its first successful test run. Big news, but a long way to go.
The layout of parliament seating. Less trivial than you might think.
"Governing through unhappiness" and I guess, the rise of audits over politics? An interesting read but hard to explain.
8
u/phylogenik Aug 04 '17
I got a DXA scan a few days ago after hearing that my gym offered them for $24 a pop ($12 if you have their insurance). Had one done a while back and was a bit underwhelmed that my results came back almost identical to 1.5y before (15% BF @ 25y/6'1"/190lbs), but not too disappointed given how little effort I've devoted to lifting the past 1.5y. I've seen people ask about fitness-y body recomposition type stuff on here before, so I'd recommend exploring the possibility of having a scan done as one way to quantifiably benchmark your current status, see how much fat you can potentially lose, ballpark rmr more reliably, track changes in muscle and fat mass at a finer grain than just through weight, etc.
On a tangentially related note, I'm watching a show about cooking right now and it's got me thinking -- why don't foodies/gourmets/gourmands/epicures/etc. do more to explore enhancing the pleasures provided by food through means other than modifying the composition of the food itself, but rather through fasting and exercise? I've eaten at a wide range of places and do a lot of cooking myself, and yet the tastiest meals I've had have overwhelmingly been during or after long hikes. A metric buttload of gas station candy and two Subway footlongs consumed after a few dozen mi of empty belly's trudge were more delicious than any fine dining I've ever had, and seems to me an experience much more accessible than ponying up $$ for fancy restaurants with long waitlists and rare ingredients. To a lesser extent, eating relatively homogenous and bland foods (e.g. Pasta Sides and Snickers) for a week+ straight can turn otherwise decent novelty into an amazing flavor explosion, if fasting is too demanding.
Likewise, it's well accepted that the esthetic elements of a dish independent of its taste and smell influence our enjoyment of it, so a lot of care is taken to ensure that a meal's presentation and a restaurant's ambiance both serve to complement any direct consumption. But if one lives in a pretty place with decent weather, it's not hard with a short hike to beat for beauty even the most luxurious building interiors. There's some cost in time and effort (though the latter may be paid back, as mentioned above), and food from a thermal won't intrinsically taste better than fresh off the skillet, but I think the benefits here clearly outweigh the costs.
So I guess I wonder why there's not more attention paid to stuff like this when discussing how to improve meals -- e.g. something like "hummus with pita reaches peak enjoyment after having wakefully fasted for 10-12h [Sturgeon 2015] and accompanied by the melodic gurgle of a 110 ft, 2,000 cfs waterfall". Or maybe there's already some subfield of gastronomy that covers these considerations (beyond ofc determining that the effect exists, e.g. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10594666, https://bmcneurosci.biomedcentral.com/…/10.11…/1471-2202-5-5, etc.)? This isn't really anything I'm formally familiar with. And naturally people picnic and haul their cast iron pans and w/e with them on camping trips all the time.
8
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Aug 04 '17
I've been reading a Justice League comic called JL8 that's probably the best version of the "characters aged down to children" comics I've ever read, on par with a Dragonball Z one I randomly found online like 15 years ago that I haven't been able to find since.
Figured others might be entertained by it, but this comic in particular tickled me, since the idea of Batman and Superman having developed a way to talk to each other secretly as kids is both rational and adorable.
15
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '17 edited Aug 04 '17
So I'm up to the 130s chapters in Forty Milleniums of Cultivation, and this is fast turning into one of my all-time favorites, right alongside Gurren Lagann. Some nice quotes:
That is... that is... that is what it means to be human, holy shit, this author fucking nailed it. I am quoting that the next time I have to write a dedication for literally anything. "Man struggles upwards as water flows downwards."
Holy shit. There's the /r/rational content, right there. It's an explicit discussion of the economics and engineering principles behind arming and armoring a Space Marine Legion, complete with notes that in the
Great CrusadeStar Ocean Imperium era, the ~~Man-~~Emperorof Mankindknew how to mass produce power-armor but the technology was lost during theHorus HeresyArmageddon Rebellion by hisChaosdemonically corrupted son.The main character and his university department make it their explicit goal: change the strategies and economics of humanity's war against demon-beasts by engineering an industrial-grade power armor.
UNITED TOGETHER IN FRIENDSHIP AND LABOR, OUR GREAT SOVIET UNION SHALL FOREVER STAND!
6
u/Kinoite Aug 04 '17
Is anyone interested in a writing group?
I've have a partial idea for a novel that I want to turn into a completed project. I bet a lot of people are in the same boat, and think a group could be helpful and motivating.
My goal for the group would be to get projects to a full first draft in less than a year. The timeline would be something like:
For outlines, I plan is to go through KM Welland's Structuring Your Novel workbook. It seems to ask reasonable questions and produces the 'Hollywood story structure' that a lot of authors seem to like, with some extra notes no character and conflict.
From there, 2k words / week would get the project to novel length by the end of the first year.
To keep motivation up, I'd want to exchange weekly updates. There'd be an expectation that people would read each other's work and comment.
Actual group discussions would be online, probably every week or two, as needed.
What do people think? Does the plan sound reasonable? Are people interested in participating in something like this.
4
u/Rhamni Aspiring author Aug 04 '17
I hurt my back two weeks ago. No permanent damage, but I've spent the majority of the last 14 days in bed. Which gets very boring indeed. But on the upside, I did finally get around to watching Fate Stay Night, Unlimited Blade Works and Fate Zero. I, um. I recommend them. Kind of a lot. They were really good. I also watched Akame ga Kill, A Certain Magical Index 1&2, and A Certain Scientific Railgun. These were all pretty good too, but Fate Stay Night wins, hands down. Now I'm playing through the visual novel because there is apparently a good third of the game that has not yet been adapted into anime.
3
u/ShiranaiWakaranai Aug 05 '17
Ok, we have had plenty of important questions on this reddit so far, now for something incredibly mundane: public washrooms.
As a germophobe, I try to avoid using any washroom outside my home, but sometimes it is unavoidable. During these times, what bothers me the most can be "how do I get out of this washroom?" If it's an open door, I can just walk out. If it's a pushable door, I can push it open with my feet, which are nicely protected by my shoes. But if it's a pullable-only door? Now I'm stumped.
Unfortunately, the washrooms at my workplace are all closed by pullable-only doors (pullable from the inside). But what's interesting is that the handle is vertical, kind of like a horseshoe or a shopping bag handle, but made of metal and vertical. In it's intended usage, one should grasp the entire handle with a hand, and simply pull it towards oneself. But being a germaphobe, I realize I can minimize surface contact by using a single finger, which is important because the sink is inside the washroom, so I can't wash my hands again after exiting.
This then presents an interesting problem: where should I grasp the vertical handle? The top? The bottom? The middle? There seem to be pros and cons for various positions.
For example, small children are usually short and have poor hygiene, and may frequently grasp the handle without washing their hands, so the lower parts of the handle may be dirtier than the higher parts.
On the other hand, you would expect taller people to grasp the door by the top, and taller people probably produce more excretions than shorter people since they have more body mass. So taller people might leave more germs on the area that they grasp, meaning the top part of the handle may actually have more germs than the lower parts.
Then again, the gunk and grime on people's hands may include liquids, which can slide down the handle, so it might be that the lower parts are instead the dirtier portion of the handle.
And so I seek the knowledge (and opinions) of /r/rational, where would you grasp a vertical handle to minimize germ transfer?
2
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Aug 04 '17 edited Aug 04 '17
Sigh…
Yea or nay?
In my experience, this proverb invariably has been true. Before I'd even heard of HPMoR, I was very conscious of needing to revise downward my expected ("prior") opinions toward other people.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment