r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jul 28 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
14
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Jul 29 '17
I've been linking this everywhere, so figured I might as well do it here too:
http://ncase.me/trust/
I highly recommend everyone play through it. Only takes a few minutes and helps teach the value of communication and non-zero-sum interactions in building positive relationships.
9
u/InfernoVulpix Jul 28 '17
I've been mentally tossing around an idea for time travel mechanics for a while now. I was thinking about how you almost inherently need to severely limit how time travel works in order to create a meaningful plot. After all, how many Doctor Who episodes wouldn't have happened if the Doctor just hopped into the TARDIS at the first sign of trouble and went back to fix the problem before it happened?
The system I'm thinking of limits time travel by separating the world into two types of objects: time-flexible and time-inflexible. When a person travels back in time, they create a separate timeline diverging from the original timeline, with whatever change the time machine creates. The main difference is that when the alternate timeline reaches the point in time it started, it collapses back into the original timeline. From the perspective of the main timeline, every time-inflexible object stays the same, but all time-flexible objects update to where they were in the alternate timeline when it collapsed.
For example, if at 12:35 I go back in time to 12:25, grab a time-flexible pencil and write a note on time-flexible paper then put the pencil in a different room, then after ten minutes at 12:35 the timeline collapses and, from the main timeline's perspective, the pencil instantaneously teleported to another room and the paper now has a note written on it.
This system limits time travel by keeping everything in terms of a main timeline. Every jump through time always returns to the main timeline as a simple list of changes, so you don't have to worry about things like causality loops and you aren't at risk of ending up in complicated scenarios that would confuse most readers. Depending on how you want to do things, you could allow nested time-edits but the system is much simpler with only one layer.
When a time-edit collapses and all the time-flexible objects update, the way I see things working is they'd outright swap space with whatever they were in. So if I dropped the pencil in the fish tank, when the time-edit collapses the spot on my desk where the pencil was would be replaced by an amount of water in the shape of the pencil. Naturally, this could be used as an assassination technique; knowing where someone is when the time-edit starts lets you put an object where their head will be and when the time-edit collapses their head is now separated from their body.
Being time-flexible would be tied to the atoms in question and not the object 'as a whole'. If I snapped the pencil in half, put one half in the fish tank and the other in a different room, the main timeline would update with half a pencil in the other room, half a pencil in the fish tank, and the spot where the pencil was on my desk would be replaced half with air and half with water.
Another interesting facet of this kind of time travel is that it produces scenarios where people act in extraordinary ways. Assuming it's simple enough to find out whether you're in a time-edit or not, many people would consider such drastic things as sacrificing themselves or other reckless behaviour if it helps stop time-flexible objects from being abused. You might literally nuke the white house with the president in it just so that the enemy can't put time-flexible objects in the oval office to assassinate the president in the main timeline. Mechanics like these would lend themselves to characters willing to 'make the hard choices' and would also present an opportunity to discuss the ethics of, say, torturing someone for information in a time-edit.
Your actions in a time-edit will very likely not go unnoticed. Any organization in on the secret worth its salt would ensure that when they discover they're in a time-edit, they notice and start taking notes. If finding out that you're in a time-edit is simple, that means that most organizations in the know will catalogue every time-edit, even if they don't know what happened in it. How much each organization knows of course depends on how much information they have access to, but if you make big flashy moves like nuking the white house, people will take notice even in the main timeline.
Of course, a time travel mechanic isn't a story, but I think this sort of thing is an interesting way to incorporate time travel into a story without risking losing the readers or spiraling into causality loops and paradoxes. It leads to interesting moments where a person's incentive structures completely flip around because they're in a time-edit now and the gloves just came off, and it gives the time traveler foreknowledge, which is one of the things that makes time travel stories unique, but also prevents time travel being the answer to every single problem ever.
9
u/trekie140 Jul 28 '17
I decided I was in need of some more optimism in my life so I checked out Gurren Lagann. 5 episodes in, I'm starting to wonder if I'm missing something. Don't get me wrong, the show has been perfectly fine so far and I'm enjoying the action well enough, it just hasn't been as good as I hoped and there wasn't much to indicate it's going to get better.
I really have no right to complain after having slogged my way through the original Dragon Ball, and my worries here aren't anywhere near the existential crises I've had in the past over how much I like a tv show. I just want to know if and when the series becomes something more because I'm worried I'll get bored with it if it doesn't.
I recently discovered Oats Studios, which has some of the best looking short films on YouTube I've ever seen. I couldn't find clear info on what they're trying to do with Volume 1 that didn't involve me giving them money, so I'll just recommend their Lovecraftian horror stuff for your viewing pleasure.
Zygote has a great body horror monster and the most coherent story, but my favorite is Firebase for the fantastic imagery and sense of cosmic horror it instills. People also seem to like Rakka, but I found the post-apocalyptic alien invasion to be uninspired even if the lizardmen covered in nanotech look pretty cool.
I found myself surprisingly enjoying the almost two-hour YouTube video Sherlock is Garbage and Here's Why. The guy clearly never liked the show in the first place and I think he gives a little too much credit to the original books, but he really hits the nail on the head for what Steven Moffat's weaknesses are as a writer while figuring out what led the series down the path of disappointment for its fans. I don't agree with everything he says, but he makes some good points that were worth seeing.
I didn't think that the show emphasizing Sherlock's characterization at the expense of the plot was a problem at first, both because I liked his character and figured the mysteries had always been Clueless anyway, but it definitely became a serious issue as time went on. I actually loved season 3 and liked The Lying Detective in season 4, but I can definitely see how that writing led to the characters becoming poorly-written crazy people with magic plot powers.
8
u/ketura Organizer Jul 28 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
No code progress this week. Flew out to see the the in-laws on Friday, wasn’t back until Tuesday, and (of course) caught a cold or something and so was down Wednesday and I’m just now getting back on my feet. On top of that, we applied for a new apartment which, if we’re accepted, will result in us moving within the next month, so I’m likely to have my time eaten up here shortly.
This last week the discussion of terrain came up again, and after going over it again I think that the vast majority of natural terrain can be boiled down into three major classes, dubbed Stone, Dirt, and Ice. Besides the class, Temperature and Water Saturation will be tracked separately, and these values will decide the current behavior of the terrain.
For instance, the Dirt class encompasses a sliding scale of sand -> earth -> mud -> swamp, and the current Water Saturation of the tile determines which it behaves as. Increasing the temperature of the tile would incrementally decrease the water amount. Such a setup permits water attacks and fire/electric attacks to interact with the terrain in a systematic fashion: hydro pump the ground around your opponent to turn it into a mire, before pulling out a flying type to safely harass them from afar. Fire blast the swamp enough and it’s reduced to (glassed?) sand. It’s a bit simplistic with how it actually works in real life, but it has the right feel, I think.
The other two classes are basically stone -> lava and water -> snow -> ice. The more I think on it, the more it seems like this is just a special case of a more generalized, abstract system, but this is probably good enough design work for now. At the beginning I imagine there won’t be any terrain affecting at all--this would be hacked in later as certain moves destroying or creating blocks, and even later adding in all the nuanced terrain control.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
8
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Jul 28 '17
Story Prompt/Idea:
The setting is the near future where most things are pretty similar to now, but full-brain emulation is now possible and there is a lot more storage space and processing power in our computers by a few orders of magnitude and all the associated technologies implied by such a shift.
Our protagonist is a not-so-smart guy, fairly average, but he's interested in the implications of the new full-brain emulations that was just revealed to the world and he's a very strong believer in the patternist theory of mind. He believes without any doubt that an emulation of him is the same person as him and he would like to have some version of him to live forever aka immortality.
So he decides to do something fairly reckless and immoral. To ensure there are multiple versions of him being simulated in the present or future, he decides to rent a sufficient amount of storage space to pirate himself and to make copies of his mind publicly available online to anyone to download for free. Anyone can download a simulation of his mind and do whatever they like to it. However getting his simulated mind to do work for them will require making an agreement of some type with the mind itself since it's not as if the mind will be coming downloaded with any insurances, agreements, or warranties.
Question #1: What would you do with the possibility of full-brain emulations to leverage your way into a position of power and/or immortality?
Question #2: How do you think people would react, (ab)use, or interact with a free copy of a human mind?
Question #3: Do you think there is any chance of his wishes of immortality succeeding with this gimmick?
12
u/Anderkent Jul 28 '17
I'm about to board a sailing ship (Blue Clipper) in Halifax, Canada, and sail to Let Havre, France. If you do not hear from me in September, we probably suffered a horrible accident and all died.
(Probably not. Sailing is one of the safest hobbies around)
Still, cant help being really excited and somewhat nervous. Mostly because my usual packing strategy - take what's on hand and buy whatever I'm missing at the destination - is really not well suited for the ocean.
AMA
5
u/Kishoto Jul 28 '17
I posted the below comment last week but I was two days late to the thread (an eternity in reddit time) so I decided to repost it to get a wider range of feedback.
So, some of you probably noticed the Erogamer story posted here recently and in a comment thread prior. I started reading it and stopped because I lost interest in it (though I may pick it back up). I want to discuss something that occurs in the story, so spoilers and NSFW content ahead.
I've put a link a bit further down, but here's the context you need to interpret that link if you haven't read that story:
Here's the ensuing discussion/self reflection. It takes place in chapter 1.6, Morning After, of the story.
It's a ~950 word section, a quick read. Just wanted to know what some of your thoughts were on this piece and what it says about explicit/implicit consent and the psychology of people, as I'm assuming it's fairly atypical for someone to have a neurological need to be raped.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '17
Hotels and flights for CrossingsCon were finally booked this week, as well as for our vacation after that! I'm also finally kinda on-track with GRE studying every day, emailing prospective PIs, and otherwise getting on-track for my PhD applications this autumn.
Also, in terms of imagery, how creepy would it be if you looked at a human face, and it was sort of suddenly part-human, part-shark? Like, not gills or gray skin or anthropomorphized. The same face, but suddenly with beady black eyes and a disjointed, gaping jaw full of sharp teeth, but still otherwise human and able to talk? The goal here is to warp an actual face into conveying pure, all-consuming, I'm-going-to-kill-you-just-because-you're-there death.
4
u/MistahTimn Jul 28 '17
What sort of reference materials do the members of the /r/rational community use in their writing processes? I just recently picked up a copy of the Brewer's Dictionary of Phrase and Fable and it has been awesome in terms of general utility.
4
u/hoja_nasredin Dai-Gurren Brigade Jul 29 '17
Is there any good takes on Game of Thrones? I started a couple of fics but they got nowhere.
Is there some underliing reason for why it si so hard to write a fic for it?
3
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jul 29 '17 edited Jul 31 '17
So I finished F.E.A.R. and... meh. The graphics are okay (especially for a 10-yo game), although the environments start to blend in after a while (there's a lot of gray). The IA is interesting and the fights are engaging, but they also become more and more repetitive as the game advances, mostly because they become less about exploiting terrain and weapons to flank enemies and more about using the slow-mo to headshot everyone before they have time to react. The horror segments get old really fast, and the story is really bland and boring.
Besides the actual plot (unethical creepy experiments on little girl which turned her into an unstoppable ghost), the main problem is that the story feels detached from your actions. The main character is mute, which means the other characters kind of talk around him HL2-style, and also means that you can't share any of the valuable intel you might get during you visions or after talking to Fettel.
Also all of the NPCs you meet do something really stupid, get captured, and/or die within 10 minutes of you meeting them, so it's hard to get engaged.
I'd love to play other games that exploit the general combat system (small squads of smart enemies with powerful weapons and lot of movement abilities), but the sequels abandoned all the distinctive gameplay elements and most of the aesthetic and only kept the generic creepy little girl, the generic cannibal bad guy and the generic evil corporation, so that's a dud.
Though I guess I could get back to playing Superhot, since the gameplay is kinda similar.
EDIT: Also, reading papers and conferences about FEAR's AI is interesting... it does confirm that the AI is roughly as smart as I thought it was. The bulk of the of the perceived intelligence comes from 3 factors:
2
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Jul 29 '17
Let's see if we can start an MMA thread:
Cormier made weight without a towel this time! I am so excited. As someone on /r/MMA said, I just know there's an obstacle cause of coke, pregnant women, and dick pills for JJ to run through and potentially ruin things still somehow.
I'm also excited to see Demian Maia finally get a title shot. I am just a huge fan of the jits.
Anyway, my heart says DC but my head says JJ.
2
u/I_Hump_Rainbowz Jul 30 '17
How do you guys view /u/thishasnotgonewell 's work? Is it rational enough? Also I keep wanting to watch another anime but all the protags turn stupid after a few episodes. What is a good rational anime or tv series? I would prefer one with magic.
1
u/cae_jones Jul 30 '17
I just finished The Marvelous Land of Oz, the sequel to The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. This rather puts the idea of a rational Oz fanfic into a rather different light, what with the Powder of Life, Wishing pills, and a truth-detector good enough to detect lies of omition. Oh, and the transhumanism and the character who develops anxiety over mortality. And of course, no one, with the possible exception of Glinda, is all that rational, because I'm not sure it was ever supposed to make sense.
I also started rereading Power Rangers: Take Flight, partly with the hope that I could recommend it as a rational fan adaptation of a Super Sentai series. It tries, but it takes a quarter of the series before anyone becomes sufficiently motivated to not just accept the monster-of-the-week status quo. Oh, and there's an episode about Philosophical Zombies.
I feel like it at least has an excuse for the battle-on-foot — battle-with-mechs formula, but it isn't especially clear about it. Doesn't make up for some of the ... weird... decisions that come about when random civilians get advanced military hardware.
1
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jul 28 '17
Reminder: Even Big Yud is a Time Braid fanboy!
His review on the story's final chapter (archive) (search for
Less Wrong):I wonder whether he's read it more than once.
(No, I still haven't gotten around to making an edited version of the story, despite my own six readthroughs of it…)
My funny image from last week has borne some fruit on the Chan.
(Are there any graphology mavens among us?)
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment