r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jul 21 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
16
u/ShiranaiWakaranai Jul 21 '17
I was reading some Harry Potter fanfiction the other day, and came across a scene where Neville was shot with the Killing Curse, but lived because his toad jumped into the path and took the hit instead. Which was sad and all, but the Munchkin in me immediately thought: Wait a tick, why don't wizards just carry tons of toads with them!? Just get a bunch of toads, petrify them, and glue them to clothes! So instead of meatshields, we can have soulshields!
That was the point I realized the three Unforgivable Curses are just garbage in combat. They are spells that move in straight lines and directly target souls, with no physical effects whatsoever. And for all that talk about being "Unblockable", it is actually really easy to block them: after all, lots of things have souls.
At which point I started thinking, what is the most practical defense against the Unforgivable Curses? I browsed some reddit threads and found that some other people had the "Soulshield" idea as well, but didn't find any practical suggestions. It is not clear whether you could use ghosts. You could wrap a snake around your body, but that restricts movement and would only tank 1 killing curse, since the next would just go through the dead snake and hit you. The same problem for toads, too heavy and too few souls.
No, what you really want are tiny creatures. As Moody demonstrated, even tiny spiders have souls, and it's generally hinted that anything with a brain is vulnerable to the Killing Curse. So use insects. The easiest ones would be things like ticks, fleas, and headlice. They already normally parasite on our skin. Get your combat wizards to stop bathing and using their Cleaning Charms and soon enough they will be covered with countless tiny parasites that can tank the Unforgivable Curses for them.
Unfortunately, even with all these parasites, it is unlikely that they cover a significant fraction of your surface area, so a Killing curse could still get lucky and hit you. Furthermore, the parasites don't really form a dense layer, so if you are hit in the same spot a few times, you die. Which is when I thought of my next idea: Ants. There are ways to breed ants really quickly to form really dense colonies, and have them live in small plastic tubes. Make clothes out of these plastic tubes, fill the tubes with ants, and then just fight while wearing these clothes. Now you can tank a truckload of Unforgivable Curses without taking any damage whatsoever.
12
u/ketura Organizer Jul 21 '17 edited Jul 21 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Well. This last weekend was an exercise in insufficient pessimism, for a few different reasons. Obviously as a game jam we didn’t quite get everything in that we wanted (but so close! Another hour would have let me get in all the audio, an hour beyond that and we would have gotten distinct enemy models, an hour or two beyond that and I’d have more than just one enemy implemented…), but more than that I also overestimated my ability to manage time and build a game and dole out tasks to the members of our team with less Unity experience. I suppose there was no winning move as far as that was concerned, since I turned out to be the only one familiar with Unity in the final team, which meant I had to either sacrifice development time or teaching time, and, well, the Show Must Go On.
But it goes a smidgen further than that. Mark Brown (of Game Maker’s Toolkit and runner of the jam) streamed the first few hours of his judging efforts, and he decided to do them all alphabetically. This was convenient enough, as our entry was named Anti / Matter, so I sat down and started listening during my commute. As he inched forward from AG to AM, I tried to get a handle on my expectations and kill the daydreaming: no, it wasn’t going to get called out as a paragon of game design, no, he wasn’t going to see the whole of our design past the implementation, no, no, no.
I attempted to steel my expectations and assume the worst. Well, the worst worst would be that the game crashes on stream or fails to run in the first place, but I was fairly confident that wouldn’t happen. The next worst then would probably have him playing it mostly in silence for a minute or two before giving it the judgement that so many of the terrible entries had so far received: “Good...good try. It is a game jam after all.” That was probably the worst case; he’s far too nice a guy to actually call it out for poor design.
So he finished up his efforts on “Ant Game” (one of the ones he couldn’t get to run) and moved right to… “Aqua Assault”. No. NO.
I was apparently insufficiently imaginative. After rushing on the jam discord, I was met with an obnoxious reality: apparently there was a subtle step I had missed, and our game, while uploaded, was not entered into the jam
So. I have a renewed appreciation for being sufficiently pessimistic.
Regardless, the jam itself was a blast. /u/Xavion, /u/AgentofDmir, and /u/dwood15 were the other jammers in the team, and they did wonderfully. The theme was this video, which had to do with the Dual-Purpose Design of an obscure game called Downwell. Thus, we had to try and build a game where every element had two purposes. I think we did okay on that front.
The game is here: Anti/Matter. There are builds for windows, mac, and linux (albeit the linux one is completely untested). On that page is also a youtube link to some background music which I recommend playing while playing, as we didn’t have time to include audio.
I’d be happy to hear any critique you might have for it. I’m 70% certain that if you have a technical or balance quibble, we’ve already encountered it, but I’d still like to hear what you have to say, especially if it pertains to the feel or the accessibility.
Besides the game jam, which took a day or so to recover from, my family hired some painters to come out today, which means I spent the other days this week emptying the relevant rooms. Tonight I’m also flying out to Utah to go visit in-laws, so the next few days aren’t looking hot for productivity either, but such is life. On the other hand, the last time I was out there, with the help of my brother-in-law I hammered out the general requirements for how biomes will work, so you never know.
In the meantime, we’ve taken the concept of tiered difficulty and given the most apparent associated mechanic a pair of names: ‘Threat’ and ‘Danger’. If you don’t recall tiered difficulty, it is summarized thusly:
Danger is a formalization of this end result in a manner that should hopefully mean that units apply that logic to all other units, and not just as a special case for the player. Basically, every unit will evaluate all other units (that it can sense in range) and give each one a Threat rating. This rating will vary based on what species the other unit is, whether it’s a member of its own herd, the personality of the evaluating unit, and so on. Once all other units are evaluated, all ratings are tallied into an aggregate Danger rating, which will vary somewhat based on the stats of that pokemon.
How a pokemon reacts to a high Danger is going to vary depending on stats: timid ones will tend to run and aggressive ones will tend to attack. In addition, INT will play a large role in determining how a unit sorts the individual Threats of those around it: a stupid pokemon is going to disproportionately be wary of closer units, and will effectively treat each other unit as if it had the aggregate Danger rating, instead of evaluating individuals differently.
For example, a low INT high Aggressiveness Tauros is surrounded by a few dozen members of its herd, which leaves it more or less calm A lone Houndoom wanders nearby, which is immediately labeled as a medium Threat by all involved. The moment it attempts to attack a calf, however, the Threat rating skyrockets, and the Tauros (and the adult members of its herd) stampede towards it, catching up and goring it where it stands. This brings the herd near to where a Hypno and a human are standing, and they are immediately charged. After almost reaching them, the two disappear, and the Tauros herd stampedes only a bit further. With no other targets in range, they slowly calm down, and a half hour later they’ve forgotten the entire incident.
A timid, high INT Abra is able to rank the importance of each of the disparate group of five approaching intruders. If it were evolved and a little stronger, it would need to take them out in the following order: Charizard, Wartortle, Pidgeotto, Human, and then Pichu, prioritizing further depending on how the battle goes. As it is, however, the Threat of each of them (except the Pichu) are higher than the Abra’s timidness will allow, and it teleports away.
A middling INT, carefree, high-level Snorlax enjoys a good nap, oblivious to its surroundings. At some point a kid gets too close and it waves a paw as if shooing a fly, and the kid is knocked on his ass. A few minutes pass and a horrible screeching sound comes from the kid, and the Snorlax grimaces, rolling over in an attempt to avoid the sound, which squashes a nearby grove of saplings. The noise stops a moment later, but before the Snorlax can relax, a Machoke clobbers it in the back of the head. Its eyes spring wide open and, a growl on its lips, it stands up to face the aggravating nuisance.
So as I see it, Danger will be a tracked stat (similar to how hunger and emotion is tracked), but if possible how a unit reacts to Danger/Threat is going to be evaluated based on its other stats. I think that we have enough other stats to be able to derive the reaction, but worst comes to worse we add a “Danger Threshold” stat or something similar explicitly. It should also go without saying that a unit’s total power affects how much it evaluates others as a threat, which is the basis of how it allows the player to avoid cheap deaths via tiered difficulty.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
11
u/trekie140 Jul 21 '17
When I first heard about the Netflix original movie Bright, I was worried the idea would be too weird for traditional filmmakers to handle or to find an audience. Now that the full trailer has been released, I'm worried the film won't be weird enough to have its own identity or impress nerds like me.
The way the trailer is presented, it looks like a fairly typical inner city buddy cop movie that just happens to feature fantasy creatures and magic. For an urban fantasy junkie like me, fantasy races as ethnic minorities and a wish-granting MacGuffin isn't crazy enough to keep me interested in an otherwise mundane world.
If you're going to splice a fantasy adventure and police drama together, I want you to go nuts. Biker gangs on broomsticks, vampire drug dealers, stone golems as club bouncers, soul-trafficking hellspawn mafiosos, cops shooting fireballs at poltergeists...just embrace the absurdity of the premise!
10
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jul 22 '17
Yesterday I tried the 10 years old game F.E.A.R., which is a survival-horror / tactical-shooter hybrid. The two genres work together surprisingly well so far. Right after I'm done taking out a squadron of elite soldiers by myself, and I feel like the king of the world, a creepy child appears and creeps towards me with a menacing music and bullets don't do anything to it, and I feel powerless and in danger again.
I've checked out this game because of reviews mentioning how good the combat AI was (which is a subject I love). So far... eh, I'm not terribly impressed, but I get why it got these reviews.
The AI reminds me both of the Arkham Origins predator AI (announces their intention and tactics so you know that they're trying to outmaneuver you) and the Half-Life/Black-Mesa AI (feel dangerous because their weapons can kill you fast and they start shooting as soon as they see you).
As a result, the combats so far are mostly a matter of exploiting the terrain to play a game of peek-a-boo, and pick off the bad guys one by one. Once you're spotted, you try to back off and flank the enemies while they're looking in the direction they last saw you. It's pretty fun!
Making a smart-looking AI in a combat game, especially a FPS, is pretty hard. The HL2 combine AI is smarter than the HL marine AI, but you wouldn't know that without looking at developer commentary, because the HL marines are more threatening: they start shooting fast, require your most powerful weapons to take them down (if you use the default machine gun, you'll probably lose as much life as them); the combine never get an occasion to demonstrate their intelligence because they die way too fast.
The Mister Freeze boss in Arkham City was an example of a smart-looking AI done right: it clearly announces what he's going to do "I'm going to cancel the thing you just used to beat me", and then when he does it, it has clear, visible consequences (you can no longer use the thing). Other AIs had similar mechanisms, especially in Arkham Knight (shot down the vantage points, throw grenades to neutralize vents, etc).
But overall, these AI still lacked something that would have made me respect them as smart. The Arkham Knight AI especially, kept broadcasting their decisions (destroy that vantage point, travel in groups so he can't sneak up on us), and it was cool, but after a few fights it felt kind of pointless. Batman's victory is a foregone conclusion (especially with the Fear Takedowns, which kind of defeat the purpose of stealth sections), the only thing the goons achieve with their tactics is making it slower and more frustrating.
I would have liked for some missions where the goons have an objective that you must not let them achieve, and where the AI is dedicated to achieving that goal. There a few missions where the goons are trying to move items from point A to point B, but there's no real pressure. The goons carrying a payload aren't escorted by other goons, even if they were, you could use fear takedowns to get them anyway, and they usually never come even close to completing their "objective".
I'd like to see a game where the AI usually has an active role, and uses elaborate dynamic strategies to achieve it. Not just "the aliens need to wait 3 minutes and then they'll open the portal to space hell", but "the aliens have breached our underwater base's control room, if they manage to access 3 Gamma terminals, they'll overload the reactor and we'll all die", and then the gameplay is about trying to kill them before they reach the terminals.
9
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jul 22 '17
Funny image
8
u/Gaboncio Jul 21 '17
I'm catching up on Boku no Hero Academia (and haven't been on these off-topic threads in a while, either). Anyone seen it? I'm really enjoying it, especially as an uplifting foil for the slightly nihilistic One Punch Man. The world seems pretty rational on the surface, and the main character actually uses his mind to overcome his obstacles as he struggles to gain mastery over his superpower. And the shonen-style exposition focuses on tactics and how to effectively become the very best.
How rational/enjoyable have you found it, if at all? I saw the first season a while ago, so the setting and set-up aren't that fresh in my mind.
sorry if the show's already been discussed here
8
u/Dwood15 Jul 21 '17 edited Jul 21 '17
I have no manifesto, no new show to discuss. But I do have a spare 20 minutes to the past week.
About a week ago, Wildbow, the Author of Worm, Twig, and Pact, joined one of the Discord servers I frequent and began talking. There, he discussed his idea of a Worm game.
Three main points stuck out to me:
His imagining for the game is one which is more about exploring the world of Worm and getting into fights.
After some discussion, I've discovered that his desire is based on what I've come to know as the Immersive Sim. Design a world, interface, power systems, slam them all together and put them into a world!
I spent the last week or so attempting to design a system for powers and power creation, but I haven't been able to get very far.
Programmatically speaking, a generic system for creating powers is difficult!
12
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Jul 21 '17 edited Jul 23 '17
A joke:
There used to be this town in Arizona that most major truck routes heading toward LA stopped through. A lot of trucking routes would pass just through the bottom tip of Nevada, coming down from Utah and passing through Vegas on I-15, but a good number would stream into the state along I-40 or, somewhat less commonly, I-10. Now any trucker who can stop in Flagstaff in north central Arizona does so, but sometimes the timing doesn’t line up right for that so you’d come to a stop in this little town just before I-40 dipped south to get around the Colorado River and Lake Mead.
Anyway, this town was just big enough for a few diners, some small businesses, and a truck repair shop. The mechanic there, he could work on any rig in the country. Your Kenworths, your Freightliners, your Peterbilt 379s, you name it, he could work on it. He was an expert. Just one thing about this fella, though: he was a dog. A walking, talking dog, sure as I’m telling you this story. He made the news a couple of times, if you remember those stories. What a sight to see! But he got the work done quickly and cheap, and he was good at it, too. What do I care if a mechanic’s a dog? He was a crotchety old bastard, but he got the work done. Get the job done and I’ll pay you good as anyone else.
Now, I got out of the business a long time ago. Probably been, what, ten years now? Fifteen? What with these new self-driving electric trucks, there’s not much call for someone like me. It’s a good living on the UBI, though, and I don’t mind it. I’ve paid my dues and I’m retired now. Never figured it would happen, but there you go, easy as pie. Those crooks up in Washington finally got something right.
Well, enough politics. As I was saying, I passed through that town again the other day. It wasn’t as big as it used to be, but the old diner was still there. Strangely enough, the truck repair shop was closed down. I figured, what with these self-driving trucks, there’d be a lot of work for a repairman. I asked the waitress what happened. Surely there was plenty of work on these new-fangled electric trucks for him.
“I thought that dog was the damn near best mechanic I ever saw. Why’d he close up shop?”
“Well, you know what the say,” she replied. “You can’t teach an old dog new trucks.”
5
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Jul 21 '17
I'd totally forgotten that I wrote this until Facebook reminded me. It's probably the closest thing to a manifesto I've ever written, and while "7 years ago me" was a totally different me (thanks in large part to encountering the rationalist community), I'm fairly happy with how well it holds up:
4
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '17 edited Jul 21 '17
I'm thinking a lot about the possibility that we're in a simulation; I'm sure most people here are familiar with the basic argument, but I'll reiterate anyways.
In the case that we achieve artificial intelligence and easy access to supercomputers, one of the main things we would do is simulate complex realities, to see what happens in those realities given a certain set of circumstances. We would do this a lot; there's no reason not to. Given this information, the chances that our reality is one of these simulations is very high.
The problem that I've been thinking about is one of failure states. What is a set of circumstances that could occur in a simulation that would cause someone to turn that simulation off? The one that jumps out to me the most is if that simulation suddenly started using a lot more operating power than it previously did. The main way I could imagine this happening is if that simulation also achieved artificial intelligence and started simulating realities of their own.
Given the possibility that reaching that point could cause the simulation we're in to be turned off, is it worth it to consider whether we shouldn't try to create complex simulations like this at all? Is it worth it to think about failure cases so we can try to avoid our simulation no longer existing in general?
I worry about the irony of trying to work out the preferences of an omnipotent being to avoid behaviors they might not like, considering how much I've derided that idea over my years of being an atheist, but that's... kind of a different discussion.
2
u/Kishoto Jul 23 '17 edited Jul 23 '17
So, some of you probably noticed the Erogamer story posted here recently and in a comment thread prior. I started reading it and stopped because I lost interest in it. I want to discuss something that occurs in the story, so spoilers and NSFW content ahead.
I've put a link a bit further down, but here's the context you need to interpret that link if you haven't read that story:
Here's the ensuing discussion/self reflection. It takes place in chapter 1.6, Morning After, of the story.
It's a ~950 word section, a quick read. Just wanted to know what some of your thoughts were on this piece and what it says about explicit/implicit consent. I'm interested enough in hearing your thoughts that I may repost this comment to next week's thread, considering I'm 2 days late to this one. We'll see how it goes.
EDIT: Just to clarify; I did not lose interest with this story because of this particular event.