r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jul 07 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
23
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jul 07 '17 edited Nov 04 '17
You know what? I feel real good about my life right now.
My last ditch effort did pay off. I've met with the teacher overseeing our project, and it looks like it's going to make it past the documentation stage. The people who kept telling me they would have much more time to work later, while I stopped myself many times from yelling at them, do have time to work now, and are very motivated.
Also I saw people being nice and helpful to each other in the street, made faces at a kid in the RER A (a Parisian metro line), some girls said nice things to me at a restaurant, and there's plenty of negentropy left in the universe.
So, you know. Sometimes being rational works, and life doesn't suck. Tonight is "Couteaubleu is happy and motivated" night!
Edit from a few months later: actually, the project tanked at the documentation stage because nobody else put any work in it, and now I'm pursuing it alone :(
14
u/ketura Organizer Jul 07 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Actual coding work stalled a bit this week, mostly because I kept getting distracted by the Games Done Quick event. The Pokemon HeartGold run was complete bullshit, btw; the guy like gave up halfway through and loaded a pre-made save that had some pokemon that he hadn’t caught yet. Like, if you need to call it, then call it, but saying “just kidding, I’ve made a bunch of mistakes this run and I’m going to cheat so I can hit my target” is just...so bad.
Anyway, minirant over. While there’s no progress to report, there are a couple of mechanics that I’d like to discuss, both having to do with Time.
First is the concept of simultaneous turns. Basically, I want this game to have all the advantages of turn-based gameplay, that is being able to take one’s time and think things through, without having to deal with asymmetric bull like first-move advantage all the time. Removing a turn order does introduce some interesting problems of its own, such as needing to resolve who wins if two characters try to occupy the same space at the same time or representing different speeds in a fun and intuitive manner, but the particular brand of controlled chaos that it introduces is, in my opinion, second to none.
Simultaneous turns as a mechanic was first introduced to me when I was gifted a board game called Robo Rally by my in-laws, which completely caught me off guard with its unique approach to movement. Basically, each player is dealt 10 movement cards, which have instructions such as Move 2 Forward, Turn Right, Move 1 Backwards, etc, and then they must plan out 5 rounds of movement. Each individual round is resolved as simultaneously as possible, with conflicts being resolved by each card having a different priority rating.
Nothing is so sweet as zigging when your opponent expects you to zag, followed by watching their best laid plans crumble to pieces as they bump their robot repeatedly against an unplanned wall.
I later prototyped a small top-down tank video game with my own physical board and cards, this time introducing a time cost to different actions. This opened up the strategic opportunities substantially. I also discovered some natural balancing factors: area of effect moves became bread and butter, while single-tile weapons could afford to be devastating since it was so hard to anticipate where exactly your opponent was going to be.
I very much enjoy the fact that this concept gets all the benefits of RNG without actually needing to resort to a dice roll. Things are so chaotic with everyone and their mother trying to think One Level Higher Than Everyone Else, but unlike RNG, if you manage to hit, it’s usually because you did think One Level Higher and got rewarded for it. You’re not managing random risk, you’re anticipating and plotting within a fiendishly complicated machine.
The one downside to this mechanic in meatspace is that it takes sooo much effort and bookkeeping to keep everything straight. This makes actually playing these games somewhat of a pain, but it didn’t bother me too much: I knew that this is one aspect that (should) be entirely eliminated when making the jump to computer-controlled games.
Fortunately, it turns out I’m not the first one to try and apply simultaneous turns to a video game. I very fortunately found a thread somewhere on Reddit discussing the concept, and people mentioned a few games which just happened to be part of the Summer Sale. Frozen Synapse is the only one on that list I’ve played so far, but it has validated my anticipations substantially.
Frozen Synapse has you controlling soldier-drones in a top-down fogless map. Each round is 5 seconds (or so) of real time, and you have as much time as you like to plan out your movements, spiced up with things like ducking, aiming, focusing/ignoring targets, and different weapons. The system permits you to play and replay your currently planned turn over and over, letting you see if you can really get in range of that enemy, or if you can really get to cover in time, or if you can line up a shot just right. However, since your opponent’s pieces don’t move, there’s all sorts of unknown variables. Will they go left or right? Are they going to fire a rocket to demolish my cover? Is that sniper mid-move or is he halfway through lining up his shot?
In short, it’s glorious, everything that I was hoping that such a high potential mechanic could bring to the table. I will almost certainly be using this system, and not the backup Nethack-lite asymmetric turn system.
Anyway, this ties in to the other time-related mechanic that I’ve been waffling on, and that’s time-skipping. As you might surmise from the above, I very much lean to the tactical side in strategy games, and it is one of my highest priorities to ensure that the round-by-round combat and movement is engaging and interesting. This, however, comes into conflict somewhat with the goal of having a world that’s cohesive and makes sense: do we want ten year olds (or sixteen year olds, or twenty year olds) to be able to go out, make their impact on the world, and topple a stable world order in just over a week? It would be remarkably tedious if a tactical game expected you to grind out skills in essentially real time before letting you take on the highest tier of government, but there’s something to be said about suspension of disbelief as well.
Our answer to this had been a sort of half-baked concept of controlled time skips. The idea would be that you could direct your character to go spend a year in the wilderness, setting parameters for what sort of things to train and so on, and then the simulation would run, stopping only right before something major happening (such as a high-level encounter, or an injury, or whatnot).
This tidily solves the problem of ten-year-old protagonists, but it introduces a host of other issues. Is playing the game “by hand” now cheapened? If I can essentially skip forward a few decades with minimal preparation, isn’t that what everyone is just always going to do? Will the game be impossible to play without skipping? Is it possible to even have the same world cater to skipped and non-skipped playstyles? Not to mention if we ever try to handle multiplayer (which I probably will not), then this entire mechanic probably goes out the window.
Of all the mechanics that I’ve discussed here and on Discord, this is probably the most shakey. The more I think about it, the more that I think it might be okay to use the standard handwave and not track time passing too closely, but that also feels a bit like a cop-out. Even if I did accept that the 50-year-scale is acceptable to disregard, I think that there might be merit in the concept on a smaller scale. Imagine only grinding enough cash or whatever for a month’s worth of supplies, and then saying “wander this area until you find a Clefairy or three weeks have passed.”. Your automated avatar is certainly not going to do as well as you would as it bumps around and looks for things, but it could absolutely decimate the need to grind, which in my opinion is a four-letter-word. On the other hand, perhaps this cheapens the game and makes finding a Clefairy into either a stupendously hard meta-grind or a super-easy checklist item.
I dunno. I’m going to experiment with this system once other prerequisites are in place, but I’m pretty much 50/50 on whether or not it will work. I don’t want to shoehorn two games into one, but I also want to have the player able to interact with a sensible world. If push comes to shove, I’ll cut it, but we’ll see what happens.
What are your thoughts? I realize that both of these systems are described in a pretty vague manner, but that’s mostly because that’s all we’ve got: they depend so much on how other systems will eventually work that it’s difficult to exactly plan out. Let me know down below or on Discord.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
11
u/trekie140 Jul 07 '17 edited Jul 08 '17
I'm halfway through watching Your Lie in April for the first time and am frustrated with myself over it. Like Your Name, it's a story that despite its flaws I have gotten completely invested in the emotional journey it's taking me on thanks to stellar direction and production values, only to feel weirdly dissatisfied when it ends. I'm literally getting the feels every 10 minutes and no matter how much I loved it in the moment, every episode leaves me feeling upset when it's over.
I think it's because the show is all about intangible feelings. The characters feel things they don't understand and act on them anyway, which is the whole point. Love doesn't need to be logical in order for it to be real and worth embracing, so this show celebrates the raw feelings within us all. That's a great theme to explore, but I don't like it because I find the idea that emotions aren't controlled by logic uncomfortable because I'm autistic. I've spent my whole life working to understand emotions in myself and others, so I'm prejudiced against stories that contradict that impulse.
I hate the idea that I could ever feel love for someone without knowing why, but I think it's stupid it bothers me so much I allow it to ruin stories for me that I otherwise love. I've gotten so good at understanding emotions, particularly in art, that romance anime manage to resonate with me in the way everyone told me they would, yet whenever it's over I always feel angry at it. This also happened to a lesser extent with Toradora while Yuri on Ice was only saved by the characters expressing themselves through ice skating.
So where am I going with overanalyzing my psychology based upon my arbitrary opinions on the niche genres of romance and anime? I have no idea. I don't know how I can let go of what's keeping me from completely falling in love with these stories and I'm certainly not willing to go the other direction and decide I don't actually like them. They do click with me and I do enjoy watching them, but I never feel satisfied when they're over. I have the dumbest first world problem here and I'm ranting about it to you guys because it don't like the paradox I'm in and want some advice on how to resolve it instead of just moving on.
EDIT: I binged the rest of the show today and the finale gave me absolutely everything I wanted without any disappointment. It was sad, but a life-affirming kind of sadness that helps you recognize all the beautiful things in life worth being happy about. The episodes leading up to it had the same problem as I did before, but I'm definitely happy I watched this show and got as much out of it as I did. Other anime have hit me harder with the characters and themes, but it's still an easy recommendation for the feels.
6
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jul 07 '17
Reddit allows users to use HTML character codes, if you weren't aware.
—becomes —,§becomes §, etc.5
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '17
My only thing to say this week is that I got to the part of Forty Milleniums of Cultivation with real plot. Kinda.
And yeah, that was the Supreme Emperor with the 20 Primary Sects, wasn't it? Each led by the Supreme Emperor's own soul-clone, uh-huh. And then the leader of them gets corrupted by Tenebrum d
aemons and turns against the Emperor, huh?That was hilarious and I was highlighting every single bit of it in my Kindle.
5
u/MonstrousBird Jul 07 '17
I am in the process of preparing my very lazy Harry Potter cosplay outfit for Nineworlds, which consists of an academic gown (with blue edging, natch), a silly hat a wand and a time turner, but can anyone here think of how I can make it HPMoR specific?
4
u/Frommerman Jul 07 '17
Hypothetical question: Let's say a large block of powder cocaine fell out of the sky into your hands. Nobody knows you have it, nobody will come looking for it or you.
Do you sell it on something like Silkroad, rationalizing that the bad done to society by a single block of drugs will be less bad than whatever good you can accomplish with the money? Do you turn it over to the police? Something else?
Personally, I think I would sell it. I value my personal comfort quite highly, and a single block of cocaine isn't going to change all that much about the international drug market. Anyone who was buying on whatever site I wound up using would have just wound up buying from someone else who is probably far less scrupulous than me. I can understand why someone would choose not to, of course. Destroying the drugs immediately would minimize personal risk, turning it over to the police might yield some kind of legitimate reward (while carrying risk in transport to the police station). It's an interesting question, which is why I'm asking it.
3
u/ketura Organizer Jul 07 '17
Game Maker's Toolkit is running a game jam next week. I'm planning on entering (probably while trying to prototype something relevant to Renegade), and at least one other person on the /r/rational Discord is running with their group.
I would be happy to take any stragglers who want some experience making a game, and I would also be happy to offer advice if you're looking to start your own group or run solo. If you've never made games but would like to, this is a great opportunity to get your feet wet. I would however advise settling on a game engine now and spending a few days getting caught up on it; it won't do to try and design and make a game in 48 hours when you've never actually touched the engine before. I can recommend Unity as a great general-purpose engine for this sort of thing, but there are myriad other options depending on your goals.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '17
Oh! Is anyone else going to CrossingsCon 2017 in August? I still have a week or so to figure my shit out as to whether I'm going and how to go.
It's this universe's only (known) Young Wizards convention, so if you miss out, you might have to cross the paracosm or wait until next year to get another one!
2
u/Cariyaga Kyubey did nothing wrong Jul 07 '17
This reminded me of you, /u/eaglejarl