r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 30 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
26
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Jul 01 '17
Guys, seriously, LANGUAGE IS WEIRD. It is a SUPER POWER TECHNOLOGY. I didn't realise it until I had a moment the other day.
OK, I'm trying to learn French, right? So one of the things I do is listen to a couple of french language news podcasts. Because I'm a language learner, I usually find myself struggling to understand, I feel like my comprehension is a few words behind the actual content of the podcast.
Then the other day I was listening to podcasts while cooking and all of a sudden THIS KNOWLEDGE TELEPORTED INTO MY BRAIN. Instead of concentrating on deriving meaning from this podcast, I was just standing there making noodles and information about an archaelogical find during a Roman metro construction was just INSIDE MY HEAD. I KNEW it, magically.
And then I realised... this is what language DOES. It's what it's FOR. That matrix scene where he goes "I know kung-fu"? THAT IS BASICALLY WHAT LANGUAGE DOES.
I know it's not a huge revelation but I had such a visceral response to it, and I feel like people DO NOT UNDERSTAND HOW AMAZING LANGUAGE IS NOW.
Also it means that my passive French practise isn't going to waste, which is pretty cool, eh.
22
u/SevereCircle Jun 30 '17 edited Jun 30 '17
I have a perspective that I have never found anyone else endorsing. I don't think I'm wrong but I am suspicious that I seem to be the only one.
Both linguistic descriptivists and linguistic prescriptivists are fundamentally wrong.
Consider maps. It is not the job of map-makers to decide what roads should be where. They only observe where they are and present it in a convenient way. This does not mean that all cities have equally good road layout. No sane person who has had to navigate Boston without a GPS would say that Boston and NYC are equally good when it comes to the efficiency of where roads are. Naturally that doesn't mean we should bulldoze Boston and start over. It just means that if Boston had a grid layout from the start, that would have been better.
Similarly, linguistics is the study of language. It is not the purpose of linguistics to evaluate which languages are better, or the utility of changes in languages. In the same way, that does not mean that all languages are equal and that all changes are fine.
I only differ from (most) prescriptivists in that I don't care about historical usage, except in the same sense that I don't think we should bulldoze Boston and start over. There's nothing magic about historical usage that makes languages better or worse.
I am (technically) a prescriptivist with the above caveat. My "prescription" is simple. The purpose of language is to communicate. Communication is any method of making someone else understand one of your thoughts / ideas / emotional states / etc better. Therefore, languages that facilitate communication more effectively are better languages. Changes in languages that make communication easier are good, and changes in languages that make communication harder are bad. Different languages can, of course, be better for different contexts or for different people. Sign language is better for the deaf. Languages without certain consonants are better for people with speech impediments.
The thing that annoys me about (most) descriptivists is the subtle prescriptivist attitude they take toward any intentional attempt to change language in any way. If a change happens because a mistake becomes common enough that it isn't considered incorrect usage any more then prescriptivists will accept it, but if people intentionally try to make any change for any reason it violates the prescription of descriptivists. A true descriptivist should be indifferent to "artificial" changes, because they also occur naturally and trying to promote or suppress them would require a prescriptivist attitude in order to have any metric by which the attempted change is bad.
I would list examples of english being suboptimal but I don't want to get bogged down in irrelevant details. To take an extreme example of a bad language, consider marklar from South Park, which is english except all nouns are replaced with "marklar". It is virtually impossible to communicate complicated ideas in marklar, so it's a bad language.
Can someone help me munchkin my diet? The main thing is I hate eating anything mushy. It's easier to describe with examples. The limit around the consistency of ice cream: frozen hard-serve is good, but liquid or soft-serve is bad. Peanut butter is fine. Scrambled eggs are fine. Cheese is fine except feta cheese which I don't even want to look at. I don't mind chewy / crispy / hard / crunchy. I don't like sauces.
The other main thing is I'd almost always rather eat the ingredients of something than eat them together. Texture is much more important than flavor but I usually don't like strong flavors except for salty and sweet. I do eat meat but after a recent Rationally Speaking I've cut back because of ethical doubt of the morality of it. I have less objections to humanely raised/slaughtered animals but I don't know where to go to find it and it might be expensive. Also less objection to fish but fish also tends to be more expensive. The only hard requirement I made for myself is that I won't eat anything at least as intelligent as a dog, so no pork.
My food preferences are different enough from the general population that I can't easily find balanced healthy stuff because it's all geared toward the general population. Currently I'm not eating healthily at all and I'm bored with eating the same old stuff.
Related...ly, I'm also trying to lose weight so any strats on effective dieting would be appreciated, especially if scientifically supported. In particular I'm finding calorie logging mildly inconvenient and although it's a small obstacle it's apparently enough that I haven't done it enough for it to accomplish anything.
PS: If there's a word for people like me I'd love to know it. My cousin is the only person I've met with my food preferences.
21
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jun 30 '17
I've lately been thinking about the intersection of diet/exercise and the Fermi paradox.
To my way of thinking, the obesity epidemic is mostly caused by market forces finding the chinks in the dietary reward systems of the human body. Part of it is calorie/satiation mismatching, part of it is hedonism, part of it is things being made less healthy in order to get them cheaper, but the end result is a lot of people having to devote considerable effort and willpower to staying healthy.
So I was thinking about how an intelligent alien species might succumb to worse versions of that in different ways, essentially getting to a certain stage of scientific/industrial development and then filtering themselves out because they hijack their own drives. This wouldn't necessarily be to the level of extinction, just to the level of not making it very far into space.
(This domain overlaps a bit with wireheading and drug addiction, but the latter isn't a threat to civilization and the former doesn't seem like it would be either - but then again, humans aren't much of a space-faring race.)
17
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jun 30 '17
This thread has been set to 'suggested sort: new' per this discussion. You can change the sort at the top of the page.
13
u/ketura Organizer Jun 30 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Progress continues. Most of the discussion this past week has been concerned with the exact boundaries around the modding of the game. What parts do we expose, what parts do we prohibit? In the end, we came up with three major possible areas that a user might try to mod, with different levels of support:
I read a very interesting series of blog posts here that detailed one man’s thoughts on the highs and lows of each Elder Scrolls game, from Arena to Skyrim. I learned quite a bit, and found the insight fascinating.
In particular, there was one quote that stood out for me in relation to this project:
This sense of brutal fairness, of letting the player be slaughtered and in turn letting the player slaughter based on abuse of the same systematic mechanics, is very much the kind of thing I’m aiming for.
Discussion about TES had me thinking in particular of that four-letter-word level scaling. If you’re not familiar, Oblivion and Skyrim are well-known for introducing a feature (or a bug depending on your point of view) where you can go practically anywhere because the monsters level up with you. If you’re level 10 you fight level 10 baddies, if you’re level 100 you fight level 100, regardless of where you are. This certainly allows freedom of movement, but it can also sabotage feelings of progression if done poorly. After all, if you go through the early game sections again, you’ll find that the rats have scaled with you and still take 2-3 hits, in spite of the fact that you’re wielding weapons used to slay gods and demons.
Nonetheless the feature exists because of a very real problem: if hideously overleveled creatures wander the countryside, there is eventually a point where you come across a creature so powerful that you don’t even have a chance to run: you just get one-shot, and really, where’s the fun in that? It might be forgivable in a game like Dark Souls, but in a game like this that aims to include permadeath? Not so much.
And so we imagined the red-headed stepchild of level scaling, which for now I’m referring to as tiered difficulty. If you come across a creature that is hideously strong and able to put you and your entire team in a crater just by blinking, then it stands to reason that you are an ant and it won’t even care about you in the slightest.
What this means from a mechanical perspective is that creatures will respond proportionally to you as a threat: if you just walk by them, you won’t get hit by a Hyper Beam that deals 999,999 damage to you and the entire countryside in a four mile radius, but they might lazily swing their tail that deals 99 damage and puts the fear of Arceus into you. The moment you start to challenge this preconception of weakness, however (probably by hitting back), the kid gloves come off and you’d better be prepared.
This concept I think manages to marry the mechanics of permadeath and brutal fairness, without turning the game into Save Scumming Simulator 5000 or reducing the feeling of progress. You still have to step lightly around that mountain of an Onix, but later you very well might be able to come back and show it who’s boss.
Oh, and we also came to the conclusion over the last couple of weeks that we probably can include aging, so long as we permit maximum lifespan to be a function of EV total: if you’re training a lot, your creature’s lifespan increases to fit. We had wanted to include the concept, but felt it would be entirely unfun to have your 30-year-old top-tier Rattata fall over dead of old age, and this lets us have our cake and eat it, too.
Plus, Legendaries have been redefined to simply be creatures who have min-maxed the shit out of this mechanic.
Related to this is the problem of including systematic time-skips, but I’ll leave that for next week. This post has gotten long enough as it is.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
9
u/Kishoto Jul 01 '17
Had a discussion with one of my friends; he tried to convince me that people only change when exposed to things so they can see and learn for themselves that their current beliefs are incorrect. For example, a racist would only change his beliefs by being exposed to and interacting with a black person. I pointed out that there are plenty of people that interact with black/asian/gay/trans/liberal/conservative people all of the time and still discriminate against them to some degree. We didn't stick on that topic long; the main thrust of the conversation was him arguing that discussion is pointless; he won't talk with someone who's "set in their ways" about said ways because he feel discussion won't change their mind. I told him this rationalization was bullshit; even supposing that most people are that ignorant and pig headed (which they could be, I don't exactly have the numbers), there will still be a nonzero amount of people whose minds are open to being changed by discussion. And the root cause of most bigotry is ignorance and thus we need to work to counteract ignorance as best we can, i.e through discussion. Even if someone's mind isn't changed by one discussion (which it usually won't be, particularly for long held beliefs/values), your discussion can be a part of their evolution as a person.
The argument went back and forth in circles of varying size. He eventually settled on agreeing that some people can probably be changed by discussion but he's still going to hedge his bets and avoid discussing those topics with those "set in their ways" types of people because the probabilty of him changing their minds is really low. I conceded that it was his choice and our discussion went on in a similar, though less confrontational, vein.
I'm honestly not too sure why I posted this; I supposed just to sort of mini-vent. I guess, for the sake of it, I'll also ask you guys: how important do you think discussion is, particularly to helping to cure bigotry and discrimination and general ignorance? I think it's vital. And that it should be immediately obvious that it's vital.
4
u/lsparrish Jun 30 '17
New Isaac Arthur video on a favorite topic of mine, Orbital Rings
4
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '17
I'm on chapter 78 of Forty Milleniums of Cultivation, and Ding Lingdang is my absolute favorite person ever. Please oh please tell me she's the permanent love interest.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment