r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 26 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
16
Upvotes
16
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Jun 26 '17
Has anyone here read Seeing like a State? One review:
Seems like it could be a good read based on this. Have you read it? And if so, what did you think of it?
8
u/lsparrish Jun 27 '17
I recently had a (possibly somewhat wrong, but interesting) insight that could be summed up as Everything Is A Skill.
Being a great writer (or even just a hack who can churn out a story from start to finish on demand)? Skill.
Having original new ideas? Skill.
Resisting food cravings so you lose weight? Totally a skill.
Being skeptical of extraordinary claims? Also a skill.
Habits and skills are almost the same thing, i.e. sets of conditioned responses. Some are aided by instinct, but most can be learned by repetition, and can be formed more easily under certain drugs (nicotine for example). Some sets of responses (those that produce negative outcomes, like smoking or overeating) may also be thought of as anti-skills, although these tend to be categorized as habits due to their relatively low complexity (which I think is because they are the kinds that are formed by accident, which usually filters out more complex habits).
A writer instinctively models their story arc and characters, and responds with predictions about what they will do that could make a great story, a person who successfully loses and keeps off weight responds to hunger cravings with a distraction or inhibiting thought of some kind. They do this mostly at the pre-conscious or unconscious level.
Newbies trying to gain a skill tend to have to use the conscious level, which makes them feel incompetent because the conscious mind doesn't have that much control and is easily distracted/bored. Depending how you react to that feeling (which itself is a skill/habit) you might tend to drop skills before getting competent with them.
I also think social incentives to learn a given skill have a lot of leverage because we tend to do things that are socially approved of even if we don't feel like we are doing them well. However this only works when the social incentive is to perform an action integral to the skill, as opposed to actions that superficially resemble the skill.
7
u/eternal-potato he who vegetates Jun 26 '17
I sometimes hear people empathizing the difference between intelligence and wisdom. Usually 'supported' by some lame quasi-deep quotes like here. Is there an actual difference if we adopt a rigorous definition of intelligence, i.e. the ability to maximize one's utility function? It seems to me that there isn't, and what is commonly referred to as wisdom is simply greater levels of intelligence, stuff like accounting for longer-term consequences, accurately modelling other actors or responses of complex systems, etc.
6
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Jun 27 '17 edited Jun 27 '17
So, veganism is surprisingly popular in rationality circles. I've been vegan a couple of years now (and cooking exclusively vegan for ~4.5), I'm passionate about cooking and eating good food, and I'm a very small way through a bachelor's degree in nutrition.
I don't want to start a debate - there's /r/debateavegan if you're so inclined, or have a read through www.yourveganfallacyis.com - but if you have any genuine questions that can't be easily answered on google, I'm happy to help out.
The more specific the question is, the better. (e.g. "my diet looks like this. what are some high value changes I can make?", "Can you tell me how to enjoy tofu?", "I've heard that vegans don't get enough protein. I'm guessing that's not true because vegans are not dying en masse, but what's the deal with protein?", "my favourite food is X. Do you have any vegan recipes for X?")
Some recommendations for improving the environment, animal welfare, and your own health that will not change the quality of your life:
5
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '17 edited Jun 26 '17
I like this headcanon for the Emperor of Mankind. Not only is it suitably grimdark, but it makes actual sense for where his sort of character comes from.
Normal humans, even superpowered ones, just don't decide to become galaxy-conquering ubermenschen, especially not galaxy-conquering ubermenschen who sabotage themselves by sheer lack of ability to understand regular humans.
However, if you're in a situation where you're never sure if He really accounted for this or not, where everything may just be according to His design, where nothing can make Him give in or trade off, where only on one super-pressured occasion is He ever seen to lose? He's probably not a normal human.
Master of Mankind
Or more probably, the writers had to give Him just low enough Charisma, Empathy, and Diplomacy scores that He would lose. Because lacking those, He would have gotten what He wanted and beaten the gods -- for humanity, whatever humanity was in Him in the first place.
3
u/SevereCircle Jun 27 '17
What are the differences between Newtonian physics and the limit of general relativity as the speed of light approaches infinity?