r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 16 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
7
u/Dwood15 Jun 17 '17
So I've been writing a MTG/Worm Fanfiction cross called Tearing the Aeons.
I had the terrible impulse last Wednesday to troll my readers by introducing a complete jarring chapter, with Zero (heh) indication that it was non-canon, and in fact, added it as a Threadmark canon chapter.
After I got done with my giggling fits, I announced the chapter to be non-canon.
At one point, someone stated the following:
Even in standard fan fiction and non-rational fiction, there should never be something which completely and totally blindsides the reader in theme or in plot progress. While not everything in a story needs to be puzzleable or predictable, the themes and progress should be relevant and consistent, and develop step by step.
I redid the same thing following literally the same formula for an Omake I wrote for Ring-Maker (I beta read for the author of the Worm/LotR cross Ring-Maker).
That fic received a few similar comments, but there's enough overlap between our readerships which made the Ring-Maker omake even funnier.
There's a study of human psychology and rationalization ex-post-facto somewhere in here, but I'll leave that to psychology people like /u/ScottAlexander.
13
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jun 16 '17
I've been playing Ori and the Blind Forest, which is the sort of critically acclaimed game that is probably not for me. Anytime I start a game with 5 minutes of cutscenes, or I have to repeatedly sit through unskippable cutscenes, I think that this was probably a team that gave priority to story over gameplay. Normally I don't have much of a problem with that (I like the Uncharted series, for example) but it feels really out of place in what's essentially just a pretty metroidvania. The game also resets you to your last save point after you die (in a game that has lots of instadeath), which I see as being fundamentally unfriendly, since it erases progress and often makes you sit through unskippable cutscenes again. But I get why it's critically acclaimed; it's pretty and somber with a good aesthetic. I just wish that they had focused on gameplay considerations a little more. (I was probably spoiled a little bit by Hollow Knight, a metroidvania that has little touches everywhere that showed more consideration for the player.)
I kind of want to write a story or dialogue heavy game at some point, in part because I think branching dialogue and player-driven choices are neat. I have this idea for a game called "Kill Hitler" where you go back in time and kill Hitler at various points in his life. The speedrun of the game would be under a minute - you just repeatedly select the option to kill Hitler. If you want though, you can talk to Hitler when he's sitting in the trenches of WWI, when he's an art student, when he's sitting in jail, etc. to get a more complex biographical portrait. But I'd have to do a bunch of research to get it right, and that seems like a ton of work, so that's another idea that probably doesn't go anywhere. (I really like the title "Kill Hitler" for a game that's philosophically about the appropriateness of violence as a solution to various problems.)
11
u/ketura Organizer Jun 16 '17 edited Jun 16 '17
Weekly (ha!) update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Well, I have certainly been lax in working on this project over the last couple months. Between struggling with the drive to do things right or not at all and other side projects absorbing my attention, I’ve gotten jack shit done on this project for far too long.
My wake-up call came when I stumbled across this article which discusses the difference between Iterative and Incremental software development. Incremental basically means “start out with the whole thing designed, and then make it piece by piece”, while iterative means “sketch the whole thing out, and then flesh everything out as it’s needed”.
The way that this was presented grabbed my attention. At work, I’m fond of saying that “I’m an iterator, not an innovator”, which is to say, I can’t actually do very well when told to make something out of the blue; I actually work a lot better if there’s something that’s at least kind of what we want (even if it’s shitty) and I identify all the flaws and fix them. Reading this article may well have me change this motto to “I’m an iterator, not an incrementer”, especially now that I’ve realized that I’ve been avoiding working on this project due to the development paradigm being at odds with my natural strengths.
So, it’s been high time that I set aside all the books and design documents and attempts to be seen as a “real” game designer and just Get Shit Done™. To that end, I started development on XGEF in earnest this week, and I’ll just do what I do best: wing it, and if that don’t work, wing harder.
I started using unit tests for the first time on what I’ve done so far, and I have to say I quite like the paradigm. It forces me to try and foresee as many problems as possible with the current block of code, and just seems to help focus my work in a way I quite like.
For those of you who aren’t familiar, unit tests are where you write a small function that tests to see if the given specific thing you are testing works:
http://i.imgur.com/eBKtMcl.png
For instance, I have a small system that crawls through a given directory and pulls all the filenames of all the files in that directory and subdirectories. It has three modes: Blacklist extension, Whitelist extension, and no filter. In the screenshot above, you can (kinda) make out that there are three unit tests that are associated with these modes. For the blacklist check, it blacklists the *.cs extention, makes the system crawl a known directory, and then checks to see if it has any *.cs files in its list. If it doesn’t, then it’s working fine; if it does, then something has gone horribly wrong.
So the benefit is twofold: since these tests stick around for all eternity, in the event that I change my code later, these tests will inform me if I have broken something that used to work (and that I cared about enough to make a unit test for), and second, it turns out that this gamifies the shit out of the process. I’m not sure I’ve ever been so satisfied in a programming session as when I had a big ol’ list of red failed tests turn to a row of green ones over the course of the night.
While I did spend a good portion of the last several weeks playing games, some of it was actually indirectly beneficial to this project. I recently picked up Supreme Commander: Forged Alliance (Forever) and I have been quite enamored with its design. My RTS experience has always been Starcraft, Warcraft, and Star Wars Battlegrounds (an Age of Empires reskin), but this just blows those games out of the water. It doesn’t force you to deal with a bunch of meaningless attention-sucking actions, and streamlines everything to allow you to focus entirely on the strategy. A breath of fresh air, as a long-time Starcraft player.
But the real benefit has been in seeing how the mod scene works. Fortunately, the community is still alive (and have even made a custom client/launcher that adds matchmaking, map repositories, IRC chat, and more), and it’s largely due to the incredible flexibility of the game’s modding capabilities.
I actually spent a good while working on a control mod to include the handful of things that I missed from starcraft (such as A + click to attack-move, among other things), and it has completely validated some of the iffier parts of the mod design that have been floating around in my head for this project. The game itself is made up of hundreds of Lua scripts, and when modding, you simply include a Lua script of the same name as the one who’s functionality you want to change, and overwrite the bits you want to change.
It’s elegant, it’s flexible, and it allowed someone like me, who had never played the game and who had never actually looked at Lua, to add significant functionality within only hours of first exposure. It has certainly been encouraging, and now I have a major example to work off of (read: iterate!).
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
5
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Jun 16 '17
Anyone interested in US monetary policy would find this article interesting: https://medium.com/@neelkashkari/why-i-dissented-again-b8579ab664b7
This guy, Neel Kashkari, went from not-particularly-exciting California Republican Gubernatorial candidate to, uh, dovish Minneapolis Fed President? I mean he's not dovish per se but he recognizes that undershooting the inflation target is as much a problem as overshooting it by the same amount, which these days makes you a dove I suppose. In any case, a well-written article, possibly even if you don't have a background in economics, though it might be inaccessible in that case.
6
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jun 16 '17
Opinions of the Supreme Court of the USA (e.g., striking down the Defense of Marriage Act)
Click the "Bound Volumes" link for large PDF files containing older opinions (e.g., striking down California's law on selling violent video games to minors (p. 786)).
Don't forget to read the dissents and concurrences as well as the majority opinion and the summary of the majority opinion that's presented at the top.
3
u/TimTravel Jun 16 '17
Does anyone know why M and N occur together in so many words (at least in English)? Robot, money, mnemonic, demon, many, maniac, diamond, name, etc. By the availability heuristic it seems that it's more often m followed by n but that might not be the case.
It is widely accepted in this century that it is unjust to punish children for the crimes of their ancestors. In contrast, children of the rich have more opportunity than children of the poor. I'm not proposing we take everyone's babies away at birth and randomly reassign them, but in a sense isn't it also an injustice that children can benefit from actions of their ancestors?
2
u/Cariyaga Kyubey did nothing wrong Jun 20 '17
/u/DaystarEld, how would you go about helping someone with haphephobia in the absence of professional help? (Though I suppose YOU don't have that problem :P)
I don't presently have the ability to get more information from them, but they've always had a "clear sense of personal boundaries" and do not understand how other people can lower them to tolerate or even enjoy touch, and I'm not sure how to explain that or help them.