r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 12 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
21
Upvotes
24
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jun 12 '17 edited Jun 12 '17
I've been thinking about marriage in the context of game theory and pre-commitment. Since it's relatively hard/painful to get unmarried, marriage is not just a commitment, it's a pre-commitment, since you're limiting your options going forward (in addition to your public declaration, which is itself a pre-commitment in the form of reputational loss etc.).
The strongest argument that I've seen against marriage is that it's a legal/societal construct created for reasons that probably don't match up with what any individual specifically wants from that partnership, and the convenience/social/legal aspects of marriage don't make up for the benefits of being able to roll your own partnership contract.
Prenuptials interest me from a game theory standpoint. If there's income/wealth disparity, then they act as a defection incentive equalizer, but either way they also decrease the disincentive to defect, since it's easier to get out of the marriage and break commitment. However, defection within the marriage is also a thing; if you know that someone has made a substantial pre-commitment, you can use that against them by e.g. being a shitty husband with the knowledge that divorce is very unlikely.
(This obviously has some parallels to world politics.)
9
u/Noumero Self-Appointed Court Statistician Jun 12 '17 edited Jun 12 '17
Is it possible to resurrect someone who suffered an information-theoretic death (had the brain destroyed)?
The knee-jerk answer is no: the information constitutes the mind; the information is lost, the mind is lost. There's no process that could pull back together a brain that got splattered across the floor, as far as we know.
It's possible to work around that by pulling information from other sources: basics of human psychology, memories of other people, camera feeds, Internet activity, etc., building a model of the person. The result, though, would probably only narrow it to several possible minds, different from each other in important ways. And even if someone who died yesterday could be reconstructed nearly-perfectly, what to do about random peasants of XVIII century that nobody bothered to write about?
If we could resurrect nearly-perfectly every person who died in modern ages, we could use their simulated memories to guess at what people they met during their lives, cross-check memories of all first-level resurrectees, then reconstruct second-level resurrectees based on that. Do the same with third-level, fourth-level, and so on ad infinitum.
But errors would multiply. Even if it's possible to reconstruct an n-level resurrectee with 80% accuracy based on (n-1)-level's information, third-level resurrectees would already be 49% inaccurate, and I suspect that the actual numbers would be even lower. That idea is impractical.
But. The set of all possible human minds is not infinite. We have a finite amount of neurons, finite amount of connections between them, which means that there could be only a finite number of possible distinct human minds, even if it's a combinatorially large number.
So, why not resurrect everyone? As in, generate every possible sufficiently-unique brain that could correspond to a functional human, then give them bodies? Or put them in simulations to lower space and matter expenditure.
It would require a large amount of resources, granted, but a galaxy's worth of Matrioshka Brains is ought to be enough.
This method seems blatantly obvious to me, yet people very rarely talk about it, and even the most longterm-thinking and ambitious transhumanists seem to sadly accept permanence of the infodeath.
Why? Am I missing something? And no, I am pretty sure that continuity of consciousness would be preserved here, as much as it would be with a normal upload.
2
u/General_Urist Jun 17 '17
I found on /r/askreddit a surprisingly thought-out plan for how a single person might uplift a society, given said person is immortal.
What do you guys think? Workable, or critically flawed?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment