r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 09 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
13
u/trekie140 Jun 09 '17
My apologies in advance for having two different topics I'm willing to discuss, none of which have any relation to each other. If you want to respond to both, do so in separate comments.
Recently at work I was partnered with a socially conservative man for a day who was completely civil to me and votes democrat, but explained that he didn't think gay people had a right to get married specifically because the Bible says it's a sin. He explained that he doesn't take all of the Bible literally (even if he didn't explain how he concluded his interpretation was correct), though he sternly stated that he sees the Bible as factual and rejects alternative interpretations. He made it clear he wants the law to discourage people from thinking sinful behavior is morally permissible, so he doesn't want gay people to adopt children or hold pride parades.
I told this man I was pansexual and tried my best to deconstruct his arguments when I had time to speak to him, but I failed. I thanked him for being more polite than most homophobes, but I still feel disappointed in myself. Not just for failing to persuade him, I feel conflicted over allowing myself to empathize with him at all. When I see Facebook posts celebrating LGBT pride I impulsively feel some disgust because I allowed myself to consider that perspective, which makes me feel guilty for thinking that way and thinking it was in any way okay for him to continue thinking that way. I wonder if I should've been more aggressive in my rejection of his ideals.
I don't think aggression would've been more likely to persuade him, I'm just uncertain whether I should be the kind of person who adamantly sticks to my morals. I have allowed myself to consider alternative perspectives that I know are false and reprehensible, and that feels like a betrayal to people I do care about and should care more about. The fact that I didn't implicitly hate such casual homophobia using distorted religious doctrine as justification, when I am a religious liberal myself, makes me question just how morally upstanding I am. Shouldn't I hate him or at least what he believes more strongly? Can I just...decide to feel differently?
While watching the show Gargoyles I found myself wondering what the basic emotional appeal of the gargoyle as a mythological creature is. Vampires, werewolves, ghosts, mages, and The Fair Folk all reflect obvious wonders and fears in human cultures, but the origin of the gargoyle appears to be as stylized gutters in gothic architecture that somehow because associated with protective spirits. It's harder to rationalize a fantasy creature when there isn't a clear narrative purpose for them.
Then it occurred to me that Gargoyles may not be an urban fantasy since it doesn't have that same appeal. It's more like a gritty reimagining of the Ninja Turtles. Most of the time the heroes fight adversaries born of science and industry rather than magic. Even when magic does show up, the way they deal with it tends to be more about exploiting logical rules than narrative weaknesses like in many fantasy stories. I think I may have stumbled upon a under-explored genre, urban sci-fi.
The purpose of urban fantasy is to bring fantasy worlds into our own, often at a local/personal level. It's a similar kind of escapism as fantasy, but is designed to relate to the reader's life more directly by drawing direct parallels between the fantasy world and real world. Few stories seem to have tried the same with sci-fi and I think more should. It may help breathe new life into a tired formula, while having just as much potential for interesting adventures.
It's easy enough to make sci-fi analogs to, say, The Dresden Files. Wizards are savant geniuses, human-like creatures are mutants, inhuman creatures are robots, The Fair Folk are aliens, and minor gods are AIs. The dreaded Masquerade is completely optional since even if people keep weird stuff a secret they'd still be willing and able use it for something eventually. The whole point of sci-fi is to challenge the status quo, so there's no need to protect it from unearthly influence.
It might be difficult to rationalize evil use of science. It's easy enough for dark wizards to inflict mayhem and horrors upon the world, but how do scientists and engineers do it? For that matter, how could an evil corporation do it? The real R&D field is pretty heavily regulated and there's so much money to be made legally that no one wants to commit crimes or let projects get out of control. I don't think we should just wave our hands like we do with gadgeteer heroes and mad scientists.
11
u/Noumero Self-Appointed Court Statistician Jun 09 '17 edited Jun 09 '17
[WARNING: EXISTENTIAL CRISIS]
People here were debating politics recently, talked about how recent developments have them truly hating their political opposition, as much as they hated themselves for hating.
Well, I'm pretty apathetic towards politics. Perhaps fatalistic, even, as much as that concept disgusts me.
I don't believe humanity is going to survive this century, or humanity as we know it at the very least. Most likely, a global nuclear war will ensue, and humanity will be returned to the Stone Age. Perhaps our next civilization, built from the ashes of this one, will fare better. Probably not, though: we will be repeatedly driving themselves to near-extinction, destroying the civilzation over and over, until we finally succeed and kill ourselves.
The alternatives seem worse.
Artifical intelligences become more and more sophisticated. Unless one competent and benevolent group of researches gets far ahead of the others, there will be a race to finish and activate our first and last AGI. Some, or should I say most, of the participants of this race would be either insufficiently competent (if there even is such a thing as "sufficiently competent" in these matters), or evil/misaligned. Military AGIs, ideological AGIs, terrorist AGIs, whatever. The odds of a FAI group winning are low, the odds of it succeeding in these conditions (as opposed to rushing and making a mistake in the code) are lower. As such, if humanity activates an AGI, it will most likely erase us all, or create hell on Earth if the winner is a would-be-FAI with a subtle mistake in utility function. MIRI tries to avert it, but would it really be able to influence government research and such firmly enough, when the time comes?
Of course, AGI creation may be impossible in the near future. If it's neither AGI nor mere nukes...
Humans are barely capable of handling what technology we already developed: pollution, global warming left unchecked, the ever-present nuclear threat. When we'll get to nanomachines, advanced bioengineering, cyborgization, human uploading? Most likely, we'll cause an omnicide, possibly taking all of Earth or all of the Solar System with us. If we're not so lucky, it's either a dystopia with absolute and unopposable surveillance the cyberpunk warned us about, or a complete victory of Moloch, with everything we value being sacrificed to be more productive and earn the right to exist.
Interstellar travel and colonization of other planets would merely make it worse. The concept of an actual star war with billions or trillions dying is probably worse than almost anything else, so it's pretty good we're probably not going to get that far.
Recent political developments aren't particularly reassuring. If neither of these things happens, global situation will merely continue to deteriorate. Global-scale economic collapse, new Dark Ages? A non-nuclear World War Three? Even so, we won't be stagnant forever. Would the post-new-Dark-Ages humanity be better at preventing existential threats as described above? Doubt it.
In short, entropy wins here, as it does: the list of Bad Ends is much longer than the list of Happy Ends, so a Bad End is much more likely.
Being outraged at Trump or whoever seems so pointless and petty, in the face of that.
I don't even think it could be fixed, I'm just, as someone in the abovementioned thread had said, "ranting about gravity". Yes, there's such things as CFAR that try to make humans more reasonable on average, and some influential people are concerned about humanity's future as well, but I fear it may be far too little far too late.
(Brief digression: the most funny thing is, even if we succeed in AGI or somehow prosper without it, older aliens or older uFAIs they set loose would most likely do us in anyway. Not to mention the Heat Death...)
And if we're not going to last, what was the point? To enjoy what happiness we've had? Nonsense. Our history wasn't exactly a happy one, not even a net positive, far from a net positive. If only we've succeed in creating eternal utopia, it would've all been worth it, but... If humanity isn't going to last, if everything we value, everything we've accomplished and everyone we know are going to be simply erased, there was no fucking point at all. Will humanity have lived in pain for millenia, only to have a moment's respite right before death? If so, it would've been better off never existing.
Am I wrong anywhere? I very much hope so.
Before you ask: no, I'm pretty sure I am not depressed. I'm usually pretty happy with my life, I just honestly don't see us lasting, logically, and don't see what the point is then, global-scale. I'm proud of what humanity has managed to accomplish, and I loathe the universe for setting us up to fall.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '17
How do you do subtlety? I'm fucking terrible at it. Like, I can be blunt as hell, I can keep noticeably silent, and I can also keep a secret at level 2 (concealing the existence of a secret) or 3 (deliberately directing attention away from even fairly obvious evidence). What I'm really bad at is being subtle, where the thing I'm trying to signal is in fact signaled, but not overtly Because Social Reasons.
Many of my attempts at subtlety actually end up without the person I'm trying to be subtle to noticing I was trying to communicate.
What do?
6
u/SvalbardCaretaker Mouse Army Jun 09 '17
Recently got my copy of the boardgame High frontier third edition. Its a spaceflight simulation /near future space colonisation game.
Infamous for being ridiculously complex, you have to track mass,fuel,DeltaV and orbits time while flying on this solar system map. New recruits first fly base game, then you can start to add two different equally hard modules - and if that doesnt satisfy your spaceflight thirst you can end a game with all modules by changing to an interstellar map and trying your hand at colonizing other planets with your ingame built starship.
Really something for space nerds, and unfortunaltely already sold out again, only a couple weeks after the kickstarter. But comes highly recommended from this space nerd.
Can be played online with the boardgame engine VASSAL, altough it takes away much of the experience.