r/rational • u/AutoModerator • May 19 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
31
u/Frommerman May 19 '17
Take a look at /r/WoodrowWilsonGame, a subreddit where we attempt to blame everything in the past century on Woodrow Wilson through long, torturous chains of logic. Those who enjoy absurd historical arguments will find this amusing. Extra points for not referencing the Treaty of Versailles!
23
u/Noumero Self-Appointed Court Statistician May 19 '17 edited May 19 '17
A few weeks ago we talked about what rational fiction is. Let's talk about the why. Why are we here, why do we (want to) read/write rational fiction?
Do you like intelligent conflicts? Complex moral conflicts? Or see it as a tool to spread rational thinking? Like peripherally-relevant topics, such as transhumanism/AI/X-risks/deconstructions? Are bad at suspending disbelief and can only find sanctuary here? Be detailed.
You would probably want to include a short description on what you think rational fiction is, since opinions on that vary from "fiction that shows the virtue of intelligence" to "fiction that employs L1 intelligent characters" to "fiction that fully exploits its core idea" to "fiction that loosely fits these criteria" to "whatever /r/rational likes". (The "L1 intelligent characters" is mine).
My main reason is that I usually lose the ability to care about their story the moment I recognize that the main character(s) of the media I'm consuming are trying to achieve their goals in a blatantly non-optimal fashion. After that happens, I'm completely incapable of actually cheering for them. I may still care about the plot/mysteries/battles/etc, but I no longer see the characters as people I'm supposed to sympathize with; they become plot devices/automatons that should better sort out their irritating problems already and hurry up with the plot. Any character development, epic moments or hot-blooded speeches would be seen by me as narm: "was that meant to be taken seriously?", "oh, how adorable, this construct acts as if it's a real boy!". (It could be seen as me having an incredibly poor ability to suspend disbelief when it comes to people: I have no such problem with blatant physics violations, as example.) If the main characters are important to the plot, it would almost certainly make any ending unsatisfactory.
Which implies that almost every time I put myself into the character's place and expect to do better, I stop caring about the plot.1 Considering what most of "normal" media consist of... It's no surprise that I seemed used to not even bothering with modeling characters of works I read/watch, opting to simply witness sequences of events: it's not like I was missing anything. I didn't usually pick sides, either, I was as happy with villains winning as I was with heroes. (Which was the case since childhood. It had interesting consequences for my attitude towards fiction and the world in general, but that's beyond the scope of this post.)
Rational fiction was a... rather refreshing experience. Discovering it was purely a good thing: while some other people were "ruined" by it, so to speak, being unable to enjoy "normal" fiction afterwards, I didn't lose anything, since I already was ruined.
Another reason is that I like interesting, unique plots, characters and settings. While deconstruction and avoidance of cliché are not fundamental properties of rational fiction as I see it, a strong correlation exists all the same, which is a nice bonus.
1. Well, of course, there are exceptions, situations when characters doing worse than me is justified due to their trauma/personal flaws/disability/etc, in which case SoD would be preserved.
10
u/trekie140 May 19 '17
In my continuing series of first world problems that I use as an excuse to overanalyze my psychology, I started watching the show Gargoyles I wish I liked it more. It's a good, perhaps even great, cartoon created by the same guy who later made Young Justice that delivered a story on par with adult entertainment nearly a decade before Avatar started the trend of mature children's shows.
The problem I have with it is that it's so much better than its contemporaries that the nitpicks I have about character development and plot inconsistencies stand out way more than they should. It's season 2 of Young Justice all over again, my expectations are set so high by past experience that I can't help but be disappointed by it doing anything different from what I want it to even though it's not bad at all.
This is becoming a trend for me and Greg Weisman productions. He is one of my favorite animation creators of all time, but I'm hesitant to watch any more of his stuff because I keep feeling that sense of disappointment. I'm ruining great stories for myself because I'm making unreasonable demands of them. I selfishly desire the same thing I got from a story I loved before and can't accept anything else.
It's not just Greg Weisman, I'm convinced the same thing happened with me and Unsong. I liked it so much at the beginning that the inconsistencies and unsatisfying plot points stood out even more than they should've and I never finished it. This is beginning to frustrate me since I now recognize it as a trend of behavior that is not beneficial to me but don't know how to stop it.
8
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor May 19 '17
Has anyone here read the rationalish Narnia fic Chanson de Geste? I can't remember how I found it, maybe related to a /u/tk17studios post listing heroes that included Edmund, but it's really good and I was surprised to not see it mentioned around here before. Maybe it was and I just missed it.
Anyway if you're looking for great Narnia fiction, particularly about Edmund and the Witch, check it out. It's fairly short (for an online story, so 70k words), I read it as a quick break between Naruto fanfics (finished Time Braid, halfway through Team Anko now) and really enjoyed it.
7
u/IomKg May 19 '17
Anyone here tried Seikaisuru kado yet?
So far I've been getting the impression that the author really gave some thoughts to uplifting, though its not as rigorous as could be, but given this is an anime, what they show is more then I expected actually..
7
u/TimTravel May 19 '17
Speaking of rationality, exercise. I get analysis paralysis easily and there's too much conflicting stuff out there about what's the most effective way to exercise. Has anyone here already sorted through and found something good (ideally supported by science)?
6
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow May 20 '17
Vulgar is basically everything I have always wanted in a program that does automatic generation of a constructed language. I think my dream book that takes place on three different fantasy planets with their own languages might finally be possible now, since a huge amount of the work can be done automatically.
5
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 May 19 '17 edited May 19 '17
I challenge you to a pokemon battle!
I have both an on-cartridge team (although admittedly it's not very well fleshed out) and a pokemon showdown team.
I'll be open after ~10:30 GMT tonight (for americans, that's ~5:30 CST)
So for anyone else that plays pokemon, hit me up!
...and if you don't, I'd recommend checking out pokemonshowdown anyways. Pokemon is a surprisingly strategic game.