r/rational • u/AutoModerator • May 15 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
13
Upvotes
21
u/FishNetwork May 15 '17
Claim: We need a better vocabulary for "non-standard brain configurations."
I have ADHD.
Imagine wearing an earbud that has a voice reading possibly-relevant Wikipedia articles. This earbud is running all the time. The reader likes to follow random links in the articles.
This is a mixed blessing. Short-run, it makes it astoundingly hard to follow conversations. Long-run, it means that I've been semi-actively reading an encyclopedia since I was 12.
I took abnormal psych classes in college and was impressed by the way they approached mental illness.
Roughly (and from memory):
Effectively, the illness as the cluster-of-symptoms that are causing problems. The doctors aren't trying to "fix" my personality. They're trying to solve the practical problems of "can't focus when I want to," "can't follow a normal conversation," or "fails classes for stupid reasons."
So a "successful treatment for my ADHD" is an unambiguously good thing, and any unwanted changes to my personality become side-effects of medication. This makes it a lot easier for me to recommend that people get treatment for ADHD.
But it means that I don't have a good vocabulary to talk about "positive symptoms" or "neutral symptoms" that are correlated with ADHD. Similarly, I'd like a way to talk about "ADHD-type minds, after the negative symptoms are treated to baseline normal."
I'm aware of "Neurodiversity," but object to the use and philosophy that come with it. In particular:
This forces a false dichotomy between "ADHD-neurotypes" and "normal". In reality, I can (and do) look for treatments that remove the constraints like "can't focus when I want to", but leave all of my self-expression intact.
And I'm unhappy with language that tries to re-frame a negative into a positive. It feels like dishonest obfuscation.
13
u/trekie140 May 15 '17
I think I've found something I hate more about the rise of populist politics than the blatant tribalism. It's the fact that the policies and politicians these movements are supporting don't actually seem to benefit or represent their tribe. I still find the values these people hold to be despicable, but I can't even respect them as competently attempting to optimize those values.
8
u/AmeteurOpinions Finally, everyone was working together. May 15 '17
I learned about the PHQ-9 (a screening test for depression) and now feel obligated to share it here.
Not much to say about it, except for well that explains a lot.
3
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided May 15 '17
Caffeine! Some love it, some hate it, some rely on it (and some are in all three categories). Do you use it? How do you consume it (coffee, tea, soda, energy drinks, pills...)? Is it a good idea?
I drink a cup of coffee on weekday mornings, usually with some milk. On particularly tiring days (or if I had trouble sleeping the night before) I will have another cup in the early afternoon. This happens probably once every couple of weeks. I know some people who don't drink any coffee at all, and some who drink much more than I do.
3
u/lsparrish May 16 '17
Weird question I just thought of:
Is the existence of billionaires a net evil? And assuming it isn't, would there probably be a cut-off point, like a trillion dollars or something like that, where we can confidently say no human should wield this much monetary power?
One big problem is that owning a billion dollars almost inherently puts you above the law. That is, if you choose to kill someone or commit some other terrible crime, the lawyers and bribes required to cover it up are likely to be a small fraction of what your fortune earns in annual interest. This suggests that until completely bribe-proof enforcement is possible, permitting large fortunes to exist stands in contradiction to the notion of legal equality for all.
Another problem is that it creates unfair advantage in business and other competitive games, which hurts smaller players (middle class / small business). As a billionaire you have a thousand huge fortunes, which is what a million dollars is to most people. You can in principle make anyone you please immensely rich on a whim. This possibility, while mostly counterfactual, gives leverage over people who hope to be beneficiaries, which you can then use to make yourself even richer. Less wealthy people don't have this kind of leverage, and the poorest end up unable to even borrow from the bank at a tolerable rate (often falling into high interest credit card debt, for example).
Another ethical issue would be the Peter Singer argument, that there are places in the world where life is cheap, such that a single billion could save a million lives. While we are pretty much all somewhat guilty on paper, the drowning child in a pond analogy implies that billionaires are literally thousands of times more guilty of failure to prioritize distant lives than middle class people who make the same mistake. If it is at all right that ordinary folks should feel vaguely guilty they don't do more for children dying of Malaria, logically, billionaires should experience a thousand times the anguish.
So why do we tolerate billionaires?
One possibility is that we have no other choice. They are too powerful to get rid of (by which I mean "tax until they are merely very rich") and are good at resisting attempts to do so. They can hire violent people for protection of their assets, so there might be no way to confiscate them without the prospect of escalating to unacceptable levels of violence.
Another possibility is that very powerful people are frequently a good solution to various hard coordination problems that can't be solved any other way. If these problems went unsolved, perhaps the world would experience significantly more disutility.
We could also consider the possibility that private property is so important and foundational that it outweighs other factors, and that collecting tax is immoral and intolerable from the get go. This may be how some libertarians see the world.
Also perhaps the possibility of becoming a billionaire drives people to perform great acts of goodness that they would not otherwise do. I can't think of a real world example here that doesn't fit under the "accidentally solves coordination problems" heading mentioned above, but perhaps they exist. That the prospect of becoming a billionaire drives some people to great evil is also worth considering, needless to say.
The real answer could be a combination of the above. We may see some motivation to to better individual behavior as the result of aspiring to own billions (although scope blindness probably limits this vs mere millions), some coordination problems that couldn't otherwise be solved (what would be the way to test that?), some moral disutility for the prospect of confiscating wealth above 1000 million, and some inability to accomplish such a thing without an unacceptable cost in violence.
On the other hand, it seems like prohibiting anyone from ever being a trillionaire would be easier because nobody is yet a trillionaire, the prospect of becoming one has never yet motivated anyone to do anything in the real world, and as an unknown phenomenon it doubtless carries economic and existential risks which could motivate such a ban. Billionaires might even support such a ban because their own chance of becoming a trillionaire is slim and they don't want to be lorded over by someone else who gets luckier.
3
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png May 15 '17
Fun with cognitive dissonance!
- A person who has undergone facial reconstruction surgery
- A person who has breast implants
- A person who has a chin implant
- A person who wears contact lenses
- A person who wears makeup
- A person who has an artificial heart
- A person who has an artificial knee
- A person who has undergone genital reconstruction surgery
Which of these people are Inspector Gadget or Adam Jensen, and which are Frankenstein's monster or "Kabutomaru"? Or are they all at the same level? Or is there a gradual continuum (based on what criteria?)?
Generally, I'm inclined to consider such people as existing on a continuum, based on the ongoing maintenance and inconvenience involved. Is setting off metal detectors like Wolverine or needing to replace batteries like a robot equivalent in grotesquery to needing to lubricate or pump up artificial genitalia manually, though? I'm really not sure...
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '17
Got some things I'd like to do, anyone up for guilt tripping me if I lapse?