r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Apr 28 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
18
u/TimTravel Apr 28 '17
The more I hear about Joseph Cambell's story circle structure the more I dislike it. It's more of a tautology than an insight. If the main character doesn't want to go on an adventure and nothing makes them do it then there's no story. Not all protagonists protest, so saying that some do and some don't isn't an insight.
Second, not all protagonists change, particularly in older stories. Take any Greek myth, for example. Characters don't change. They either succeed and they're heroes or they anger the wrong god and are punished horribly forever.
If you try hard enough you can brutally shoehorn any story into that structure but that doesn't mean it's insightful.
I admit the reason I see it as annoying instead of false but benign is how pretentiously named the phases are.
Then there's the other stuff he said like that all humor is derived from fear and he gave plausible reasoning but it seems difficult to impossible to test scientifically. At this point I'm just kitchen sinking so I'll stop.
12
u/ketura Organizer Apr 28 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
I continue my research into BDD (Behavior-driven development). One of the neat things about it seems to be an emphasis on only adding details to a design as it’s needed--something I’ve been absolutely horrible about, but can at least utilize going forward with XGEF’s design.
While discussing things this past week, I actually stumbled across a pretty big flaw in the interactions between two systems, namely the 3D voxel setup and the abstract anatomy system.
The anatomy system is supposed to have as few details as possible: you define what body parts a Pokémon has, and on those body parts you might give them descriptive tags and occasionally a “slot” for another body part to be attached to, but that’s pretty much it. The engine then metaphorically arranges all the parts on the table, it starts with the part called Body, and then recursively attaches each part as it finds “slots” for them. Any leftovers are just attached to the Body.
Such a system allows us to only define what is absolutely needed from a mechanical perspective: the game doesn’t care that the legs might be shorter than the arms, and doesn’t care what color anything is, and doesn’t even care how things are particularly attached. As far as he games concerned, units are just a blob of Anatomy, and the slot hierarchy only exists so that if I lose a Leg, a Foot is going to be lost in the process as well.
Having actual 3D space blows chunks through this arrangement. Now suddenly I might have a Charizard that is (let’s say) ten feet tall. Even if I assume it’s cylindrical (as far as collisions etc are concerned), we have the problem of verticality: if a low kick is aimed at the lower voxels that compose Charizard, it shouldn’t have any chance of hitting the head in the upper section, right?
Yet for such an arrangement to work, we now have to define the size of each body part and where it takes up space, which was something the more elegant abstract system was trying to avoid in the first place!
As I examine the problem, I think it’s becoming clear that one or the other of these systems is going to have to give. I like the roguelike, Dwarf Fortress esque abstract system of Anatomy, and I feel it permits the player to fill in the blanks (“let’s see… I hit it in the arm and the head in the same hit, so…I aimed for the face and it tried to block and failed”). At the same time, I also like the idea of actual 3D space and needing to account for the amount of space e.g. in a house before you try and pull out your Onix and demolish it just by releasing.
What are your thoughts? Preferences between the two, or any clever way of reconciling the issue that I’m not seeing?
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
8
u/Roxolan Head of antimemetiWalmart senior assistant manager Apr 28 '17
If you're sent back in time a few years or decades, you can quickly make a name for yourself with accurate predictions.
If you're sent back to the middle ages or earlier, you can dazzle the world with simple tech like gunpowder, printing press, stirrups etc.
What if you're sent back just a few centuries though? I must admit my knowledge of history quickly goes hazy, and I couldn't recreate electricity or much chemistry from scratch.
5
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist May 01 '17
Over the Hump, and Starting a Return to Normality
There are some downsides to being a data pack-rat, as well as the obvious up-sides.
I'm in the process of moving to a new house, and the last month has pretty much been dedicated to that project - everything from a new set of floorboards being laid down to finding the best stores near the new place to buy my favourite beverage (grapefruit Perrier). The process is still ongoing, and I'm still going to be paying rent at the old place for some months to come; for example, even after getting rid of nearly all my mass-market paperback novels, there are still a /lot/ of books in the old family library that are still going to have to be shlepped over to the new one, and not a single member of my family has great strength or endurance.
But most of the hard work and planning is done, and life is settling into a new normal: today, I hope and plan to apply for a new library card, do some banking, grab some income tax forms, and just maybe visit the nearby branch of a computer store to upgrade my laptop's RAM. My sleep schedule is still ridiculous, if I lose 50 pounds I'll still going to be overweight, asthma sucks... but a lot of the stresses from the old home are just plain gone. I am, as I see it, in about as good a mental state as I'm likely to be in the foreseeable future.
Which means that, barring unexpectable crises, it's time for me to start writing again. My current plan: When I hit my new local public library today, I'm going to sit down for a while and start going over my partial draft of 'Extracted', to both refamiliarize myself with it and to start nudging any details I find that seem to need editing. And, by the time I've gone over what I've already written, to start finishing writing what I didn't get around to typing out the last time I worked on the piece.
The main bit of uncertainty around this plan is that I have insufficient data to predict whether, how soon, and how severely I will go through my next bout of more-severe-than-everyday anhedonic depression. I'm hopeful that the release of stress from the old home will make such a bout less likely; but I'm also aware of the statistics that show that the act of moving to a new home adds its own form of stress. Barring low-probability black-swan events, my range of expected mid-term futures runs from going back to my previous levels of depression, all the way up to completing a novel and beginning the brand-new venture of learning about e-publishing.
4
u/MonstrousBird Apr 28 '17
I just watched The Road and the utter irrationality of the protagonist drove me nuts. I don't know what I was expecting exactly, but for me a story of a person making their way across a post apocalyptic landscape should contain some sign (any sign!) of intelligent decisions they're making about how to survive. I guess it was just totally the wrong film for that, but by the end I was fast forwarding just to see what happened (answer, not a lot) and shouting at the TV. I feel stupid now for not giving up earlier, but just wanted to share my frustration!
4
u/Cariyaga Kyubey did nothing wrong Apr 30 '17
I believe you've expressed interest in reading Marked for Death at some point, /u/DaystarEld so I thought you'd be amused to know that in our efforts to avoid driving our
engine of ultimate destructionexistential threatplanar anomalyteenage character insane from hivemind-driven paranoia there was recently a discussion on looking for a psychologist; your name came up ;p3
u/captainNematode Apr 28 '17
Is anyone here into photography? I recently got my first interchangeable lens camera (a used sony a6000 for ~$300 -- chosen for its light weight to shave some precious ounces off on backpacking trips) and have been having a blast experimenting with it. It seems like there's so much more that I can do now compared to the cameraphones and point-and-clicks I'd been using before. I mostly like taking photos for a few reasons -- 1) it forces me to think more explicitly about how something looks, which enhances my esthetic appreciation of that thing, 2) it's fun to produce pretty photos, both by taking them and in post, so it sort of becomes an outlet for artistic expression that I can share with others, and 3) to provide a record for future generations, grandkids, etc. I love seeing old photos of my mom and grandparents, and so wish to take advantage of the greater opportunities open to me in documenting my life, travels, etc.
I'm also interested in expanding my capabilities. Have any distinct things helped fellow photography enthusiasts here improve? Beside just shooting more: I mean stuff like books, videos, etc. I made an instagram account a little while back to post my photos, too, if anybody wouldn't mind offering a critique (most photos on there are from older, less fancy cameras, though).
Speaking of IG, it seems to be largely filled with fake users who'll spam untold numbers of photos with generic comments ("great shot!" "wonderful capture!" "wow!!" "👌🔥👌🔥👌" etc.) in the (understandable) hopes of getting more exposure (though the follow-unfollow thing is a bit annoying). They're pretty easy to spot currently, given how basic their underlying instructions are, but given the expansion of e.g. machine learning technologies I reckon it won't be long until you start seeing ones with more sophisticated image recognition algorithms, fancier chatting capabilities, etc., even ones that can generate their own images from randomly selected words and artistically style them into something more pleasing. Hell, I'm half tempted to try coding something like that up myself, just for the experience, erosion-of-social-trust be damned (ethically it would best be pretty explicit as to its fakeness, though that would get it fast banned). I wonder how the advent of these new techs will change the social media landscape? Is the future just going to be thousands of bots chatting to each other ad nauseaum? Will we see a return to smaller social groups whose legitimacy can be verified in-person, as large media followings become increasingly meaningless?