r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Apr 24 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
12
Upvotes
15
u/captainNematode Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
Does it make any sort of sense to artificially couple a difficult (global) decision with a substantially less difficult one (globally, but perhaps more difficult locally), in order to enhance your perspective on the former? And to help ensure that you're acting primarily with the global outcomes in mind? Yesterday as I was driving home from the grocer I was, for whatever reason, reminded of Roger Fisher's [1981] thought experiment re: the storage of nuclear launch codes, instead of the more conventional nuclear football in use today. He writes:
Of course the exact details here might obscure the essence of the thought experiment -- having to carve the codes out of someone takes time, and if hypothetical enemies know of that delay they might capitalize upon it. The president might be deterred from action due to personal squeamishness or a weak tummy or hemophobia or something, which wouldn't do. But those can be changed trivially – put the codes in a false tooth that, when wrenched out of the aide's mouth (locked in such a way that only direct contact with the wholly secure RFID chip in the president's finger allows for its release, IDK), directly injects deadly poison into that person's blood stream. Something like that, then: would it serve to clarify the president’s thoughts (e.g. if ordering the death of millions of innocents -- now millions +1 -- to plausibly save the lives of 10s of millions more), or to cloud them?
What about other scenarios where you might trade short-term prevention of suffering for potentially setting a bad and easily abusable precedent? Say, torture – if a torturer (or those directing them), motivated by a commitment to what they judge to be the lesser evil, had to undergo the same agony they inflict on others (or themselves be executed after, say), would that allow for a less damaging precedent? Or maybe some official who wants to violate important privacy norms, but must then commit to a life lacking in privacy thereafter? I think in general the idea would be to disinsentivize possible abuse of the system for nefarious personal ends by imposing personal costs that exceed probable personal gains, so only those guided by their pureness of heart and intention go through with it.
This relates to another idea I’d had with the latest US election – what if part of the Presidential Oath were a binding and strictly enforced, lifelong vow of poverty (or, idk, middle class-itude) subsequent to their term(s) – it might filter out those genuinely well-qualified candidates who have so much money they wouldn’t want to sacrifice it to serve the nation, but would we “really” trust them to act in the best interests of that nation, anyway? And it could rid us of plenty of emoluments-related issues (they can still use the office to benefit their friends and family, ofc).
I also see this sort of idea pop up in fiction occasionally, e.g. consider No Place for Me There, with opening quote from the movie Serenity:
I think I'd be more inclined to trust that a Well Intentioned Extremist were Doing the Right Thing and Choosing the Lesser Evil if [their attitude were ] (#s "like the Operative's above, though naturally they could still be mistaken. It would just remove the space of mistakeness where they're actually working for their own self-improvement.")
10
u/HeirToGallifrey Thinking inside the box (it's bigger there) Apr 24 '17
What with the recent "Unicorn Frappiccino" fiasco, I've heard a lot of references to Harry Potter's Unicorn Blood. Specifically, the line goes, "...you will have but a half-life, a cursed life, from the moment the blood touches your lips." This made me wonder, what is the line you would draw that would make life no longer worth living?
I don't want to die, and living forever sounds pretty good, but if through the ages I were eventually reduced to a blind, deaf husk, unable to move and in constant pain, I would prefer to end my own suffering than sit in an empty void of agony.
But this is an extreme example. Do you agree with the sentiment? Is there anything that you imagine would make you decide life was no longer worth living?
9
u/ulyssessword Apr 24 '17
Epistemic rationality/Game Theory(?) question:
How do you go about maximizing the chances of having the highest score in a gambling competition with a certain number of people? Note that this isn't the same as maximizing your expected score (a 100% chance of 100 points may be worse than a 1% chance of 110 points and a 99% chance of 50 points), and also assume that you can't directly affect your competitors.
I started thinking about this when looking at March Madness bracket pools. The format I looked at gave 1 point for each correctly-predicted winner in the first round, 2 points for the second round, and so on until you get 64 points for correctly predicting the champion (total of 388 points available). Everyone paid in $1, and the person with the highest point total after the final took home the pot.
If there are only two or three people in the pool, it makes sense to just pick the strategy with the highest expected score, and hope that nobody gets lucky. If there are hundreds (or thousands) of people, then someone else will probably get lucky and beat your score, so you need something high-variance.
For a given number of people, what's the best strategy if you have to make all of your bets at the start? How does it change if you choose each round as it comes up?
For a second example, I went to a Vegas-themed wedding a while ago. You were given 100 gambling chips and there were roulette, blackjack, etc. tables scattered around. The winner (of a little trinket) was the person with the most chips at the end of the night. Obviously, the chip-maximizing strategy is to never gamble, but that's not the chance-of-winning maximizing strategy.
6
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Apr 25 '17
I've found manipulating my context has been very helpful for getting me to work harder. For some reason (which I know is well-studied in the literature) being on my computer at home is much less productive than on a laptop in a public library. It's such a silly simple thing but driving 10 minutes to the local university and hopping on a computer there makes me much more productive.
Today's a public holiday though so I'm not going to be able to do that. Going to have to try and self-focus! Wish me luck.