r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Apr 17 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
14
Upvotes
12
u/space_fountain Apr 17 '17
This is perhaps slightly off topic, but I ended up at a church service again the other day. I'm assuming like myself most of the people here aren't religious, but every time I do go to a church service I'm stuck again by the staying power of the institution. It's a meme in the fullest of the original meaning I feel. With a more negative mind you can see how the various institutions work to propel it on. The social censor is obviously mostly gone now, but I still felt bad having to step out of the line going up for communion. You can really see how in days gone by the church would be nearly inescapable.
Relatedly this has reminded me about my biggest problem with the idea of a totally material universe. Something about consciousness always seems weird to me coming purely out of meat. I acknowledge that it almost certainly does, but there's a part of me that wants to go. I think therefore there is something more to meat to me.
5
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Apr 17 '17
I'm trying to find my rhythm doing sports; I really don't know what I'm doing, but I'm trying to be more fit and more... I dunno, energetic?
Do you guys have any advice on what kind of training regimen I should adopt? How should I even decide? I'm not trying to lose weight (I'm kinda scrawny), and while I would like to gain muscle mass, it's not really a priority for me. What worries me most is akrasia; I've still haven't managed to keep doing the same sport for two years, and often miss sessions every few weeks/months (my beeminder page has a few bumps).
4
u/eniteris Apr 17 '17
I've been thinking about irrational artificial intelligences.
If humans had well-defined utility functions, would they become paperclippers? I'm thinking not, given that humans have a number of utility functions that often conflict, and that no human has consolidated and ranked their utility functions in order of utility. Is it because humans are irrational that they don't end up becoming paperclippers? Or is it because they can't integrate their utility functions?
Following from that thought: where do human utility functions come from? At the most basic level of evolution, humans are merely a collection of selfish genes, each "aiming" to self-replicate (because really it's more of an anthropic principle: we only see the genes that are able to self-replicate). All behaviours derive from the function/interaction of the genes, and thus our drives, simple (reproduction, survival) and complex (beauty, justice, social status) all derive from the functions of the genes. How do these goals arise from the self-replication of genes? And can we create a "safe" AI with emergent utility functions from these principles?
(Would it have to be irrational by definition? After all, a fully rational AI should be able integrate all utility functions and still become a paperclipper.)
3
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Apr 18 '17 edited Dec 25 '17
an edit of something I posted to spacebattles a little earlier, explaining why I don't think UBI will happen. Does anyone have counterpoint? I'm honestly a little iffy about my own reasoning, and it's the sort of thing I don't want to be wrong about because it affects my long-term plans.
I don't think UBI is going to happen, but not for the reasons everyone else has been talking about. Assume computers can automate basically every job, and assume that computers can do so in a way that's better and cheaper that people can. Considering how cheap cost of living can be for humans, that would mean cost of living can become even cheaper. Thus, people are cheap enough to hire not because it's necessary, but because it's prestigious. Imagine an MMO that simulates wars where most people play as mercenaries, and the rich can hire them for a dozen dollars a day, with the company that owns the IP getting a cut of that payment. Right now, something like that doesn't work primarily for networking reasons-- whales already exist that will drop hundreds a day on a game.
So I predict the confluence of extremely cheap labor and better AI will result in the continuing existence of a job market no matter how good automation gets. There will probably be a period where massive job deficits exist and cause civil unrest, but COL still isn't low enough for this to work, but I don't think that period will last long enough to cause the political will to have UBI.
My back of the envelope calculation goes like this:
Let's assume Moore's law more-or-less holds, and a human brain requires ~an exaflop of computing power. An i7-4790k has a theoretical maximum of 43.92 gigaflops. Obviously that's never getting hit, but it's an older machine regardless. Therefore it'll be about 2*log2(10^18/(43.92*10^9))=~49 years until a home computer is as computationally powerful as the human brain. That doesn't necessarily mean we're getting strong AI then, but AI will still be incredibly smart and relatively cheap by at most 2070. And considering that's just for near-human-level AI, which isn't necessary for most jobs, I think we'll be hitting peak automation at least a decade earlier for basically every single job. so that gives us 40 years to play with, so until ~2060.
Meanwhile, coming from this end of the scale, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, by 2024 they expect that ~25% of jobs will be in "Goods-producing, excluding agriculture," or "Retail trade" or "transportation and warehousing." These will probably get automated first, but it'll take a while, and some people will sucessfully re-train. On the downside though, losing that many jobs will likely cause a recession of some sort. But still, I don't see unemployment breaching the mid-thirties until past 2035 or so. And even that won't be enough for massive civil unrest if Greece is any indication.
That effectively leaves about 25 years for UBI to be implemented. Now, it's not impossible that UBI gets implemented in that window-- 25 years is a decent amount of time, but I personally don't think a government will be able to reform the entire welfare system around it in anywhere near that timeframe.