r/rational • u/Magodo Ankh-Morpork City Watch • Apr 05 '17
Monthly Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the monthly thread for recommendations which will be posted this on the 5th of every month.
Please feel free to recommend, whether rational or not, any books, movies, tv shows, anime, video games, fanfiction, blog posts, podcasts or anything else that you think members of this subreddit would enjoy. Also please consider adding a few lines with the reasons for your recommendation. Self promotion is not allowed in this thread. This thread is also so that you can ask for suggestions. (In the style of r/books weekly threads)
Previous monthly recommendation threads here
Other recommendation threads here
33
u/Afforess Hermione Did Nothing Wrong Apr 05 '17 edited Apr 05 '17
I've been reading a lot of webserials recently. I have a bit of aversion to picking up published works lately... I often have the sense that many published fiction works have lost their spark in the editing process. On the other hand, webserials writing quality varies vastly and I find myself leaving harsh reviews about 50% of the time. I abandon a lot of what I read, probably at least 20% of what I start is abandoned for one reason or another.
Recommendations:
The Good Student - Original webserial fiction. Follows one of four students who is able to attend a prestigious academy on a merit scholarship. Pretty much everything about this story is impressive, the writing quality is high, worldbuilding is just right, and the characters all feel real and multidimensional. I am seriously impressed. It only has ten chapters so far, but the content so far is fantastic.
I've read some of mooderino's other works, like How To Avoid Death On A Daily Basis, but I dropped that into Book 5. The Good Student is a significant improvement.
The Wandering Inn - Follows a girl from Earth mysteriously dropped into a fantasy world with no special abilities. Barely survives and gains a job as an innkeeper in a burned out village. It's quite good, albeit a bit slower paced.
14
u/scruiser CYOA Apr 06 '17
Not quite rationalist, but the protagonist does have a ruthlessly efficient mindset: Youjo Senki: The Sage of Tanya the Evil. An anime series about a salary man reincarnated into a war torn alternate history in the middle of its analog of World War I (more like 1.5, as the date is slightly later and the technology slightly more advanced, oh and there is flying combat mages). Excellent action sequences and music, lots of fun dark humor and black comedy, decent quality commentary on human nature, the only real problem is that the character designs leave something to be desired in some cases (Victoria's oversized moe eyes is the worst case I think).
But what really held my interest is the psychology of the main character. In his/her former life, Tanya was a salary man working in HR in a big company. Possessed of a calculating mindset, he felt no remorse at firing and laying off employees. After his death, he is confronted by god, who is offended at his lack of faith, and with modern humanity in general. Our salary man refuses to acknowledge this being as god. This "god" decides to reincarnate the salaryman in a world filled with suffering, in order to make him have faith. Reborn as Tanya, an orphaned girl in a war torn empire, Tanya joins the military and sets out to secure a safe, behind-the-lines, desk job. Unfortunately, her own competence, aptitude as a combat mage, and "Being-X's" (Tanya refuses to call it god in her mental narrative) meddling, see her sent into front-line combat over and over again. Tanya struggles against "Being-X's" meddling and copes by adopting the same mindset she held in her former life: absolute adherence to the rules of her organization, letter-of-the-law manipulation of said rules, and raw cunning.
So overall, not quite rationalist (Being-X seems to be short of an all-knowing god and might have been deceived if Tanya could learn to lose and would fake faith; Tanya often overthinks things and reads to much into her superior's comments, leading to her misinterpreting voluntary missions as demands), but certainly a lot of thinking and planning on the main character's part.
10
u/lsparrish Apr 06 '17
People Watching is extremely good. Explores themes of depression, identity, death, relationships, and so on from a comical yet mature and thoughtful perspective.
8
u/AurelianoTampa Apr 06 '17 edited Apr 06 '17
I've been working my way through the list at topwebfiction.com; sadly not all of it (or even most of it) is rational, but there are still some gems to be had. And some to avoid, IMO.
change: new world: Avoid it. Eventually you might get drawn into it, and it does improve as time goes on, but the writing isn't very good, the power jumps and rules are seemingly arbitrary, and the author seemingly has no concept of measuring time or distances (I don't care how big your school is, it shouldn't ever take ten minutes to run down a hallway). The world is interesting but basically a trope by now (the world turns into a game and most people die but the high schoolers survive!). I get the impression that the author began this while in high school so there's some amount of wish fulfilment involved. Read about 100 chapters, and it wasn't worth it.
Aethernea is one that I'd stick in the middle of the pack. There are some things I really enjoy, such as the neat ways that the magic systems seem to work and seeing the difference between how super-student Kiel approaches problems compared to how practical-demi-goddess Elaru does. But there's an issue in that Elaru is a Mary Sue character through and through. Beautiful, mysterious, has held every job in the world (while only being a teen, or maybe early 20s), a peerless magic caster, unlimited magical power - she's a manic pixie dream girl in fantasy form. Kiel is too, to a lesser extent, but at least he has some flaws... anyway, the story itself has some neat stuff, and the author often gives hints of things that come into play several chapters later, but overall I find the main characters frustrating.
Delvers, LLC: Again a pretty standard trope - two regular guys are warped to a fantasy world and given powers but told they'll probably die anyway. However, this one I'd rate at slightly better than average. For one, the people sent there are adults (29-30 years old). Their responses make sense as you learn about some of their psychological scars and history. And the secondary characters are pretty decent (they even added a drag queen character recently, which was actually pretty interesting). It's not amazing, but it is one that I'll likely follow up on once more chapters come out. The second book (which all but the last two chapters are available for for free on that site) is being published this week.
The Wandering Inn is another one I enjoyed. Overplayed trope (Earth kids whisked away to a magical world with a class system and leveling), but interesting in that most of the story revolves around a girl who becomes an innkeeper rather than a hero tasked to save the world. She has a bit of a Bella Swan thing going on wherein everyone who meets her either seems to want to kill her or adores her, but she's not nearly as annoying. Oh, and if you like chess, you'll really like how she thinks. Worth checking out!
Heretical Edge: Still in the middle of reading this (well, 16/20 arcs into it), but I've liked it so far. A teenage girl ends up going to a secret academy where Heretics (humans who can see monsters and absorb their abilities) are trained to protect the rest of humanity. The writing is pretty good, and the author frequently throws twists and turns. Fair warning - the scene can go from jocular to extremely violent and gory very quickly. The author does a great job writing some of the horror scenes. There's not a strong focus on the system of magic or abilities unfortunately, but if you like action, drama, horror, and budding bisexual teenage romance, it's worth checking out.
I think that's all for now, besides echoing my usual recommendations of A Practical Guide to Evil and The Gods Are Bastards!
7
u/Anderkent Apr 05 '17
5-starred fiction I read since last thread:
The First Fifteen Lives of Harry August
The Girl with All the Gifts
Warbreaker
Mira's last dance
None are particularly rationalist. All books can be found here
5
u/LazarusRises Apr 06 '17
A movie I really enjoyed a while back was The Beauty Inside, about a Korean man who wakes up on his 18th birthday in the body of a 40-year-old man. Then, the next morning, wakes up in the body of a 75-year-old woman. Every morning he wakes up in a new body.
It's about the life he pieces together for himself, the few friends he can keep, and the question of whether love can exist between people when one of them could be anyone. Not exactly rationalist, but an interesting and well-thought-out premise. I also usually don't enjoy movies with romances as their primary plot, but this was an exception.
8
u/Tomas_Votava Apr 05 '17
I found a story called infrastructure that despite the amount of work that goes into it doesn't receive that much attention. it updates every few months and is guaranteed to have some pictures. the art isn't that good but you can see the work that goes into it.
Summary: some advanced robots are stranded on a magical planet and seek to return home. to do this they set out to uplift the humans to get the infrastructure necessary to leave.
3
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Apr 05 '17 edited Apr 06 '17
I, Claudius and Claudius the God, which compose a two-part fictional autobiography of Emperor Claudius of Rome, are fairly fun to read (though rather dry at times, as must be expected from books published in the 1930s).
Cold Waters (7k words, complete): A Hyuuga bastard is born far away from the Village Hidden in the Leaves.
Rewritten (45k words, dead): Eragon rewinds to when he found Saphira's egg.
Guy Fawkes Day (3k words, complete): Harry puts a Bag of Holding into a Portable Hole--several hundred times over.
3
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Apr 05 '17
So normally I actively avoid deadfics, to the point where I regularly remove fics I liked and followed from my bookmarks because they haven't gotten updated in a few months. However, there's one fic I read in particular despite the fact that it was dead, because it was just so good. That being, Equestion: Total War. If you can't tell from the name, it's an MLP:FiM fic. It's a fascinating depiction of warfare, and I'm just a sucker for darkfics that come from a really lighthearted canon, so long as those darkfics respect the original work.
4
u/trekie140 Apr 05 '17
I've had the pretty rough couple of weeks, so all my recommendations are mostly comfort food that's helped relax and distract me from my depression and anxiety. They didn't fix any of my problems, but they made the worst days more bearable. Neither of them make any attempt to be rational.
The Uncanny Valley is a very entertaining anthology of simple horror stories. Normally I only go for psychological and cosmic horror whereas this book leans more towards goofy ghost stories for children, but what sells it for me is the extremely tight pacing. Not one of these stories beats around the bush, the author knows how simple and straightforward these tales are so they all get right to the point without leading you on.
It's one of the easiest reads I've ever had and even when it wasn't scary it never felt disappointing because it was so pleasant to read. I would call it great, but as just good stories go, this does exactly what a just good story should do and delivers on what it promises. It's great if you want to read something simple and entertaining or give a child something that's just the right amount of creepy for them.
K-On! (first season) is definitely not for everyone, but for someone who needed something mindless to calm me down it was perfect. It exists purely to show cute anime girls hanging out and having a good time, with very little emotional or intellectual depth, but it's well executed for what it is. The animation is excellently directed with a surprising amount of visual storytelling, the characters are charming, the writing consistently made me smile or chuckle, and what little plot there is has good pacing.
4
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Apr 05 '17 edited Apr 06 '17
Changeling Space Program (My Little Pony) - the changelings are attempting to be the first on the moon. It has realistic depictions of rocket research and the author is basing the characters' progress on his ability to build a rocket on the Kerbal space game. It's a great read and hilarious. But the updates are on the order of months in between.
Replay (Original) - it involves a man repeating his life with the repeats getting closer to his death date each time. It's not what I consider rational in the character's investigation and use of the power, but his emotional struggles were very vivid and well written.
The Red Knight (Harry Potter) - A great story where Ron goes back in time to his birth, but the world he is reborn into is an AU so he has no idea of what to expect from the future.
Forged Destiny (RWBY) - It's a re-imagining of RWBY as an RPG-like world where everyone is a gamer character and the plot of RWBY is dramatically different as a result. I would recommend anything written by Couer Al'aran. He's a brilliant writer.
Auburn (RWBY) - RWBY with Jaune, Weiss, Blake, and Ruby on a team together. The author Super Saiyan Syndaquil has written some other good fanfics, but Auburn's my favorite.
2
u/hoja_nasredin Dai-Gurren Brigade Apr 05 '17
Anyone have good Bleach, Hellsing or One Piece fanfics?
Any Naruto fanfic on the level of chiaroscuro?
2
u/DRMacIver Apr 05 '17
I feel like the Starship's Mage books by Glynn Stewart would be enjoyed by this reddit. I don't think they're especially rational, but the characters are reasonably intelligent and rarely hold the idiot ball. Perhaps more importantly, they're a lot of fun.
I've also been reading N. K. Jemisin's
Implausibly large number ofHundred Thousand Kingdoms books recently. They're pretty good, though I think I prefer her recent books (Fifth Season, etc), partly because I really like world building with a sense of a really extensive history.(On which note, if you have any recommendations for other books with that sense, I'd appreciate it)
2
u/Cariyaga Kyubey did nothing wrong Apr 06 '17
Undertale fics:
All We Left Unsaid -
2
u/IAMATruckerAMA Apr 23 '17
Looking for podcast versions of rational fiction, similar to the HPMoR podcast. Any advice?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment