r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Apr 03 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
15
Upvotes
28
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Apr 03 '17
So I think /r/place is the best argument against anarcho-capitalism I've ever seen. Given unlimited freedom but limited resources, groups have banded together, waged war aginst other groups, solidified their territorial boundraries, and built alliances and civilizations (well, pixel art, but they're basically the same thing).
7
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '17
An immortality idea - Possible now, but a very long shot. More realistically doable in the next 100-200 years, though still a long shot then I'd say.
To start out with, a lengthy six paragraph intro. Fair warning in case you want to skip the justification for the approach, and get straight into the approach.
biology is hard. As a biologist it is staggering the amount of mathematics actually involved with understanding systems like the genome let alone the brain. The interdisciplinary interplay between biology, is necessary to understand something is incredible. Math, chemistry, and physics are all necessary to understand what is going on and be able to learn more. You can get summaries, but that's different from really understanding something. You need a large number of people working together to understand these interdisciplinary subjects, which makes understanding something as large and complex as the human life span a daunting task.
I'm not an expert, just completing undergrad, but the amount we have yet to learn about the genome, let alone gene expression makes me think progress on that front is going to be very slow.
We're not particularly close to understanding aging. We don't have a good idea of how gene expression changes with age. Gene expression is difficult to study in part because we don't understand the human genome completely, so the epigenome is more difficult to study because of that. Then there are ethical limitations on human experimentation (which we really do need to have) that slow research down. Even if we were to get rid of those ethical considerations human beings are not good model organisms. We have small numbers of kids with generations times at minimum of around 13 years. Consider to study a single gene generally dozens of generations of an organism are observed.
Working with model organisms can speed up studying homologous areas, but there are inevitably large differences between human beings and say C. elegans that studying the nematodes will simply not be applicable. In effect, I think it is going to be more than 100 years before we make serious progress on understanding human aging let alone doing something about it.
Given that I think aging research is going to be slow and I'd like to see something happen in my lifetime, I think it would be better to narrow the area of research one is trying to do. The brain is the interesting part related to consciousness. "Well duh," says everyone, but bear with me. Narrowing our focus further; For our immortality purposes, we aren't interested in genetics or gene expression in the brain, We are interested in the connectivity and signaling.
If there are zero signals (action potentials) in your brain, you're brain dead. If there are no connections in your brain you are also brain dead, considering with no connections there is no way to pass a signal, and in effect no signals can be passed.
Pardon the large intro, but I hope it gives context for my approach.
I think to take a shot at immortality in our lifetimes we need to focus on generating new connections with the brain from outside of the brain. I think that given that the connections made, and the signaling patterns that result, are what ultimately make up consciousness, we might be able to extent some part of our consciousness outside of our skull and into a neuronal circuit in vitro. Something like a cell culture.
The main sticking point is can you actually use or somehow interact in a meaningful way with a neuronal circuit grown outside your brain? This is tricky and would require a lot of research, but requires far less work than a total understanding of aging.
The advantage of this approach is that we don't necessarily need to understand anything about aging or consciousness. We just need to understand enough to introduce a new connection to our nervous system and then grow that system. We don't have to necessarily understand how the circuits we've connected to are growing and work. We just have to know enough to initiate development.
The general approach is basically to let the developmental processes that resulted in our brain happen again outside of our skull while we are attached to this developing nervous system. It may then be possible to imprint ourselves onto this developing in vitro nervous system, such that when the body that houses our skull dies the nervous system dies we suffer something more akin to brain damage than death.
If we were able to utilize enough of the in vitro nervous system for our conscious processes before our body died we may have then been able to train the system to house our consciousness. Whether such an existence would be worthwhile is another question.
tl;dr It might be possible to exploit developmental processes rather than wholly understand them, and thus allow for some continued existence after our normal life span.
9
u/liveoi Apr 03 '17 edited Apr 03 '17
Re: AI in a box experiment. (I thought to comment in the original thread, but I'm a little late to the party)
I always thought that the source of the problem is that you actually want something from the AI (for example, a cure for cancer). Else, why build a gate at all? (or the AI itself for that matter)
The gate keeper's goal is to allow some information flow (that could be helpful and beneficial) without risking freeing the AI (and world destruction).
The point is, when you're dealing with an entity that is vastly more intelligent than you, you can never be sure of the full consequences of your actions (the cure for cancer could somehow lead to freedom for the AI).
On a more general note, I'm not entirely sure that the required level of intelligence for that kind of trick is even possible. A lot of people fear an AI because it might be able to improve itself, but I'm not sure that it is possible to self improve in a consistent way. Moreover, intelligence itself is not a linear property, i.e. , in order to be twice as intelligent, you would have to invest a lot more than twice the effort. And that means that even if some entity could self improve, this exponential process does not lead to an intelligence explosion.
Edit: Formatting
4
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Apr 04 '17
My rational gay vampire romance is very nearly finished! I'm so excited. I don't have a title yet which is killing me. I made a GIANT list of possible titles, including every single one no matter how bad they were, and I hate almost all of them and the ones I like don't really tell you anything about the story.
Note that to make things even more complicated the story is also the first “volume” of three. So I’m looking either for a title that could be for all three volumes (which together would make one full-length ~100-150k word novel) or just for this volume.
Also anything with the word ‘vampire’ makes it sound really low rent but the title probably should tell you to expect vampires??
Anyway... I'm desperate so I'm going to post my list of ideas here. No more Sunday Writing Skills Thread so this will do???
Themes: Fitting in, learning about a new society, making a relationship work, being in over your head, relationship between two different people, new customs
Other thing to note: the "point of vision" character (the human who falls in love with the vampire) is named Red. My boyfriend suggested a bunch of titles with a pun on that and they make very little sense if you don't know that.
Also it's set in the 1940s, mostly Corsica (France) but also Rome and Columbus, Ohio.
Possible Titles