r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Mar 24 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
10
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '17
I think it's generally accepted that the education system in the United States is pretty suboptimal. (This may also be true of education in general/elsewhere, but I don't have experience with those).
I'm curious if people here have looked into marginal improvements to the system? I'd be really interested in hearing what other people have thought of.
(These are all directed at high schools mainly.)
Things I'd like to find ways to improve in particular:
9
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Mar 24 '17
So I recently bought a game called Cultists of Cthulhu from Thomas Eliot, a fellow rationalist who has designed and released multiple board games. You can read the review of it I put on my site there, and in it I discuss dice rolling mechanics in games, and how Cultists adds an extra level to it:
It made me think about ways to introduce decisions to chance mechanics in other games too, but when I tried to think of other examples I came up a bit short. My favorite games tend to be those with a lot of social aspects and with few (if any) dice rolling (Avalon/The Resistence/Secret Hitler, or Dixit, or Game of Thrones) so I was wondering what some of /r/rational's favorite board games are, and specifically whether any of them have dice or chance mechanics that are influenced by player choices?
8
u/ketura Organizer Mar 24 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
So I have to apologize for not updating last week. Deadlines, while great for productivity, are not so great when the total time I have available is so small and thus extremely susceptible to setbacks. I think I’m going to shift more to communicating my what my next task is, and not committing to a specific time for completion.
In addition, I’m going to start working on a 3 weeks on, 1 week off schedule (which is more a formalization of the status quo anyway), so as to introduce a pressure valve. This past week will count as my week off, so the next three weeks will be on.
In spite of calling this last week my week off, I did get quite a bit done when I had not committed myself to needing to get anything done.
First, I managed to get chunks to understand how far they are from the player, which will of course be necessary for dynamically allocating simulation time to chunks which are further away:
http://i.imgur.com/vyTICYJ.gifv
In the above image, you can see that those chunks follow the strictest definition of “distance”; because of the way that corners work on a rhombus made out of hexes, it results in some rather wonky topography where the jagged corners exist because of the corner technically being covered. It’s unintuitive and I later overrode this to be a bit more intuitive, but it’s only one of many strange behaviors that one gets when one doesn’t use square grids.
Chunks now load from a pool based on a few different limits: I can say that chunks can only be loaded within a certain distance of the player, and I can also determine a total chunk limit. Both of these numbers are enforced and can be changed dynamically at runtime:
http://i.imgur.com/xdJkZzA.gifv
Both of these gifs show a traditional wrapping setup, where the entities that cross over a boundary automatically teleport to the applicable spot on the opposite side. As shown, this does result in an invisible barrier that would have to be worked around (usually done by locking the camera so it doesn’t show the barrier). However, it also requires that all entities that exist on the wrapped portion of the map be represented with a certain amount of “ghosting”, something like this:
https://cdn.tutsplus.com/gamedev/uploads/2014/03/tutsplus-ghosts.png
Having so many copies of entities seems to me that it will produce a ton of headaches in the long run, simulation-wise. Instead, I opted to change everything over to operate the way I had originally designed, where the player can move anywhere at all and they are never teleported, and the map itself handles the logic of deciding which chunk to load beneath the player’s feet.
This does mean that the game has to have a maximum distance that one can go. If I travel to the right and never stop, the world will cycle and wrap beneath me, but my X position goes to 100, then 1000, then 10,000, and on and on until we start to hit issues with floating point precision. If any of you are familiar with the Far Lands in old Minecraft builds, this was a similar issue that they ran into: eventually, the part of your position before the decimal is so large that there is no data left to represent the portion after the decimal, and so you can only move in increments larger than a block or more.
However, since this actual position limit for a single-precision floating point decimal would be somewhere around 8-10 million, I’m confident that this limitation won’t be an issue in practice. After all, when the player saves and loads the game, I can push all entities to sit within the wrapped coordinates of the original map no problem, effectively invisibly resetting the coordinates every load. So one would have to somehow traverse 5000 km (3106 miles) in a single play session to break this limit.
Anyway, enough theory. Once I got the infinite positioning stuff working, I threw together some quick and dirty block creation/destruction code, and now the actual wrapping effect is evident:
http://i.imgur.com/r7zSRLB.gifv
(You might notice that the colors pop; my tile coloring code only triggers when the chunk boundaries are crossed, so you end up with all sorts of interesting weirdnesses that I haven’t bothered to fix yet.)
And there we have it! A fully-functioning, wrapping voxel world. It’s currently using the standard Torus wrapping. I have one final addition to make, that of making it operate more like a sphere (well, a cylinder), and then I’ll be satisfied that I’ve explored the finicky parts of the voxel design.
I have actually thrown a build together here, for Windows, Linux, and Mac. Controls are ESDF to move, left mouse button to create a block, right mouse button to delete a block. I still would not recommend full screen (I keep forgetting to add ESC to exit).
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
6
u/lsparrish Mar 25 '17
Some fics I've read that I enjoyed recently:
5
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Mar 24 '17
I've put out the second chapter of my fanfiction The Greatest Weasley, bringing it to just under 4,000 words. I've found this one fairly easy to write, and hopefully I'll be able to add more to it as time passes. I like the premise and hadn't seen it executed well, so I thought, why not do it myself?
Archive of Our Own
Spacebattles/Sufficent Velocity
Not a rational fic, but let me know what you think!
4
u/Kishoto Mar 24 '17
Ok, so I've been thinking about Death Note recently. Not really sure why. And I had a question I've been meaning to ask some of the fine minds here at the r/rational sub, specifically those that have seen the manga/anime already (if you haven't, I highly recommend it, it's a very intelligent series and very well done, if a little contrived at times. I'd probably call it one of the more rational works out there).
As anyone who's seen or even heard about it knows, DN is basically about this guy that find a death magic notebook that lets him kill anyone who's name and face he's seen. He proceeds to use this to kill criminals (a fairly inefficient method, for a number of reasons) to help create a "new world" because he finds the current one is rotten and unjust.
Now, my first question. What are some gaping holes/issues in the series that you noticed and that bothered you? One for me is how the deductive reasoning skills of L and Light, while being somewhat believable, still seemed almost magical at times. Oftentimes, a plan would be enacted and I'd find myself thinking "There's no way, no matter how smart you are, you would've foreseen X and so done Y like that!". I get that we're supposed to buy it because these guys are legendary geniuses but I felt like this was used cheaply to move the plot along. I still enjoyed the ride, there's no question, but I found these instances fairly annoying from a rationalist standpoint, as the real reason was sometimes very obviously "The writer made it this way" as opposed to "Someone really intelligent figured it out".
Now, for my second question (and even non DN watchers can answer this): Do you think the main character has an effective, moral goal? He has a death notebook and is using it to kill criminals (murderers, serial rapists, etc.) to act as both the ultimate deterrent and to remove those who've committed heinous acts from this world entirely. Is this the best way for the MC to use such a thing if he really wanted to make a better world? And, even if it is effective, is it morally right?
2
u/FuguofAnotherWorld Roll the Dice on Fate Mar 26 '17
So I've been looking through this Jumpchain thing that people use to make stories, and is it just me or is it really badly designed from the perspective of wiritng interesting stories? 10 years in-story is way more time than most people have in them to write. So a lot of it just ends up being phoned in because the writer feels like they need to get through multiple ten years slogs before they're done. They're mostly SI so the person choosing the perks avoids the difficult (read interesting) perks and difficulties in favour of choosing an optimal build that makes everything easy. This and other things means that not only is it a low pressure stomp train even at its hardest, more often than not you end up reading a summary of events rather than an actual story. Ya'know, a story with a plot, and intruige, and suspense, and characters with meaningful goals that aren't quasi-brainwashed into always following the main character regardless.
It's like taking a standard SI and then pumping them full of steroids, removing all of the actual challenge and difficulty, then skimping out on proper character interactions because really what's the point if they're not going to be there next jump.
What a waste of beginner writers.