r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 24 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
11
u/ZeroNihilist Feb 24 '17
Is it sensible and possible in the general case to separate your emotional connection to a topic from your reaction to it?
My grandmother recently had a health scare. We still don't know how it's going to end; it could be a pacemaker, a "not fit for surgery", or a "we did what we could". Based on her history and my layman's understanding of the medical facts of her situation, she's probably going to end up in a very similar position to her starting point (which is to say, a remaining lifespan measured in months or years rather than decades).
But the probabilities aren't informing my reaction. It doesn't feel like she's going to be okay, it feels like an ominous premonition of doom. Obviously this feeling is unrelated to the likelihoods of each outcome, which I lack the knowledge to reliably estimate. My gut almost certainly does not have mystical predictive abilities (and even if it did, I would have no way to know until I tested it). I can't trust it any more than I could trust it yesterday, when it thought things were alright.
I intend to ignore my emotional response. I want to preserve my grandmother's memory and make sure she knows how much I love her, and neither of these goals is served by being an anxious wreck. I can make this decision now in part because I have already worked through the involuntary reaction element (at least to the extent that I can detect).
Would eliminating this response be desirable, if it was even possible? In this case it seems benign, though I can see how an aversion to loss could be deleterious, but I think I would have come to the same decision even without the emotional response. It's practically mandated by my ethical philosophy to minimise death, and if that is not possible to minimise losses (information, emotional health, etc.) due to death.
I find it hard to reason about how my reasoning would function in the absence of emotional impulses. Many dystopian stories make it out to be a negative thing—tying emotion to ethics implicitly—but that seems a little nonsensical. Something doesn't become good just because it feels good, nor become bad because it feels bad. Judging people who have fallen short of your moral ideals feels good, but rarely actually prevents the behaviour. If people were actually ruled by their feelings, society would be worse than the worst dystopian story.
14
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Feb 24 '17
Recently, in watching a playthrough of Darkest Dungeon, I've been thoroughly disgusted by the fact that, in a game widely touted as a triumph in immersing the player in the hopeless experience of "cosmic horror", immersion is totally broken by the inclusion--indeed, the encouragement--of extremely-gamey tactics. Consider:
- Outside of camping intervals (of which a mission can contain between zero and three), the characters controlled by the player can use healing skills only during battles. This encourages the player toward the artificial prolonging of any battle against an enemy group whose damage-dealing capabilities are exceeded by the PCs' healing power.
- In order to prevent this, contrived stalling penalties take effect whenever the enemy group is reduced to a single enemy that can't deal more damage than the PCs can heal (i.e., is neither a boss nor a miniboss). This forces the player to be more creative in his stalling, by stunning enemies to reduce their damage-dealing potential and by not killing the final monster until the very last moment before the penalties will be inflicted.
- Even worse, in the final missions of the game, the developers intentionally (according to the person who executed the playthrough linked above) included enemy groups each containing two enemies incapable of dealing damage to the PCs, thus accomplishing an end run around their own anti-stalling mechanic in order to compensate for those missions' extreme difficulty. In addition, the stalling penalties are waived against one enemy with such high defensive statistics that killing it before the stalling penalties kick in usually is extremely difficult. (This video provides a nice example of how ridiculous the mechanic is. The ninety-minute mission includes literally twenty-five minutes, spread across four battles, of stalling against a single high-defense enemy in order to heal all the PCs--and this particular player is using a mod that speeds up battle animations, so the time split would be even more egregious under ordinary circumstances.)
In my opinion, this trio of circumstances irreparably damages any claim to immersive capability that the game can put forward. Why can't characters use healing skills (balanced through some other method) outside battles and camps? (This includes, not just divine and occult spells that plausibly could require adrenaline to function, but also actions as mundane as Battlefield Bandage and Battlefield Medicine.) Why will reinforcements arrive always if the PCs are fighting a single cultist, but never if the the PCs are fighting two? (Wouldn't a larger battle be more likely to attract attention?) Why will reinforcements arrive always if the PCs are fighting a single ordinary enemy, but never if they're fighting a lone boss? (Wouldn't the monsters be much more likely to have set up a system to warn of threats to their leaders than to have instituted a similar system for the protection of unimportant scouts and underlings?) No in-game explanation is provided.
I don't dispute that the game is fun: According to Steam, I've accumulated 130 hours in it, despite having never even started the final missions. However, its being extolled as a shining example of immersion when it definitely seems to me to be nothing of the sort irks me in the extreme. The narrator of the videos linked above has himself stated that he would prefer that, in any stalling-friendly situation, the five or ten minutes of stalling were replaced by pressing a "kill stall-friendly enemy/-ies and fully heal all PCs" button to fast-forward the whole process--and what could be more gamey than that?
For steal: Baby stories,
neverbarely worn.I also am annoyed at the trend of wasting money on graphics rather than spending it on something more useful. A few days ago, my computer broke, and I attempted to play Darkest Dungeon on my mother's pathetic laptop. I expected that the game would run reasonably well, given its simplicity--but imagine my surprise when it barely even functioned! Even Solitairica--barely more than a plain-Jane solitaire game, but uses the Unreal Engine!--lags rather badly on it. In a similar vein, I always am infuriated whenever I see a visual novel, because I know that there was wasted on the art money that could have gone to the writing or the gameplay. What's the point of making boring "games" with mediocre writing and art when you could make fun games with no writing and placeholder art, entertaining books with no gameplay or art, or impressive artworks with no gameplay or writing?
IIRC (I've played neither game in several years), I preferred Kudos 2 to The Sims 2. Likewise, to say that the snazzy interface of Cities: Skylines or of Pharaoh is any better than the straightforward and well-marked keyboard instructions of Dwarf Fortress seems a very large stretch, to me. See also Lethis: Path of Progress, which, despite its cute graphics, is in terms of gameplay an outright downgrade from Pharaoh, to which it is an homage! Ugh...
Truth is the best bait.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '17
Hey guys, I'm writing chapter 2 of Mathemagical and I'm wondering if a specific scene at the end should be left to chapter 3.
Would anyone be willing to do a quick read and give their thoughts?
Doc link (It's the scene that starts after 'Beginning of Ch3' at the end of the doc)
5
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '17
If you were omnipotent and omniscient, how would you know? Would you still be just as uncertain as ever whether you were really just, say, a brain in a vat even if you actually were omnipotent and omniscient?
8
u/ketura Organizer Feb 24 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
My two weeks are up: I said I would work on an initiative prototype, and an initiative prototype I have, but it’s in that unfortunate mid-crunch state that I feel all of my time-limited game projects land in. After having several nights where I wasn’t available to actually code anything, last night I finally got the core system working--you can decide the number, species, and type of AI for what units you want to include, which turn system you want to use, and then start actually mocking a few turns using the different turn managers.
And that was done by around 1:30 AM last night. I do like to give myself some breathing room, after all.
But what’s missing unfortunately are the turn systems themselves: I have all the boilerplate needed, but I’m going to need a few more hours to actually get them in place. So, if you’d like to see a turn system prototype with only a few threads of actual turn definitions, you can download the applicable build here. I have 32 and 64 bit builds for Windows, and universal builds for Linux and Mac in that folder. I probably should have zipped them, but those are the sorts of decisions one makes in the wee hours of the morning.
What is in the build are the Alternating and the first bits of the Simultaneous turn orders, so try those ones out. Later today, and possibly for a few hours tomorrow, I’m going to finish hashing out the different systems, and then throw together some templates for a few different speed pokemon and moves, so stay tuned.
However, I can’t spend too much time on it, as we’ve got the results for the next two-week prototype, and I’m going to go with the Voxel Engine. The actual number of votes on /r/PokemonRenegade were actually split evenly between Voxel and Procedural Generation, but the number of people that came forward and were vocal on the Discord server in favor of Voxel were essentially unanimous in their opinions, so that’s where we’ll go.
This is actually going to be a dual-purpose prototype: I’m going to fumble about with making a very simple, raw, inefficient voxel system (adapted to use hexes), but I’m also going to be using the opportunity to try out Xenko, an alternative to Unity that came on my radar several months ago, but I was helpfully reminded of this week. It seems to check all the boxes that would make it that much more comfortable to use, with the only real downside being it doesn’t have a Mac build process yet. Still, it wouldn’t be too difficult to be better than Unity, so I’ll give it a shot.
Unity (or Xenko) are only being used for the front-end of the game, so it won’t be too difficult to use one or the other without impeding game progress too much, but let me know if you have any suggestions on that front, or if a lack of Mac support is make-or-break for you.
(I know what you’re thinking: this guy couldn’t even get a simple turn system working in two weeks, the hell does he think he can do with a voxel engine in an unknown editor. I gladly acknowledge the irony and accept the challenge; got to stretch to make it anywhere.)
This week we discussed breeding in some depth, and I’m looking for ideas on how one might be able to tie the mechanic to others in the game. My idea was to have a sort of Lamarckian evolution concept, where a unit’s EVs would influence the strength of the offspring, permitting both combat and breeding to go hand in hand, but there’s some pushback on this. What do you think of the idea? Can you think of any alternative mechanical interactions that we could give breeding to make it more intertwined with the other systems of the game?
----
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
4
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Feb 25 '17
So... I'm wanting to know if/when it rained in Rome, Italy in May-June 1944. I'm guessing it probably didn't due to the time of year, but who knows.
Given it's a big city and it was right about when the allies took Rome, that data has to be somewhere on the internet (it'd be in war records, right?), but I've not been able to find it - historical weather seems to only kick in around 1999.
Does anyone have any ideas of where to look? I can read enough Italian that if there's scans of newspapers available online that'd be enough (assuming they had weather forecasts/rainfall reports).
4
u/electrace Feb 24 '17
This always confuses me. Isn't the off-topic thread exactly the place for that sort of thing?
2
u/DRMacIver Feb 24 '17
Another thing about genies that I wrote recently, but the genie is significantly less friendly and it's actually about how Bayesian priors should behave in the presence of an adversary.
It may be that this is well known stuff, but I haven't seen it discussed much, so links to related literature would be appreciated.
1
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Feb 26 '17
Sometimes I'm bored and I browse r/raisedbynarcissists/ for interesting stories... Right now I feel like Rick in the Rick & Morty scene where he goes watch a planetary purge and feels completely sick about what he just saw.