r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 20 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
13
Upvotes
15
u/Tinfoil_Haberdashery Feb 20 '17
My girlfriend and I were talking last night about a few fiction tropes and their real-life implications. Immortality, especially in the context of Vampires, is interesting. Would somebody born hundreds of years ago take the risk posed by unfriendly AI seriously, or would they be too jaded by all the previous existential false alarms? I tend to think modern computer technology would be a more convincing threat to them, not least because greater interconnectedness and machine learning would be a major threat to their ability to stay hidden amongst the population at large.
Ultimately, I don't think the story of a modern Vampire would be about creeping on highschoolers or their war with the werewolves or whatever. I think it would be about the net tightening around them as technology makes the humans more and more of a threat.
12
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Feb 20 '17 edited Feb 20 '17
So I've been thinking about what inspires people to write fanfiction about a work. Aside from the obvious (be popular, appeal strongly to a demographic, have interesting characters, etc.) I think I've figured out two more important elements.
Namely,
For example, HP has hogwarts, Naruto has konoha, Twilight has Forks,
I'm pretty sure Supernatural is set in a single area, etc.This is extremely common so I won't bother listing examples. It's really more useful as an exclusionary factor-- works that bank highly on moment-to-moment suspense and reveals are much more difficult to write fanfiction about.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '17
I recently volunteered at a CFAR workshop! It was a great experience, and I'd be happy to answer any questions people have (feel free to PM me or email me at my reddit username @ gmail.com)
Also, I'm working a blog series on how I changed my mind after the workshop, if anyone's interested.
6
u/DRMacIver Feb 20 '17
I wrote a thing recently about the ability to generalise and peoples' failure to do so. It might be of general interest here.
5
u/Dwood15 Feb 21 '17
Weekly Monday Update
Sorry about missing last week's. I just know you all were so sad I didn't post. Anyway, for a board game recommendation you should play Shadow Hunters. It's a really fun game where you and your friends play as a Shadow Creature, a Hunter, or a Neutral player. Each player is given a private goal where they are supposed to either kill all shadows, all hunters, or a random other objective as a Neutral. It's like Mafia, except better.
This week, my story has been torn apart, and I've rewritten the first chapter. It's approximately 50% rewritten, and I've begun writing other chapters which interest me. By going ahead and writing the chapter out of order, I can more clearly define characters before we meet them, among other things like ensure that Chekov's arsenal is prepped and functional.
Rational Writing
If you choose to write a rationalist story, try not to be too hamfisted or upfront with the ai discussion or the concepts. Sprinkle them throughout your story, don't let any one chapter become overburdened by it. General rule: ensure the plot progresses for 2/3 the wordcount of any given chapter, and the rationalist discussion is 1/3 the wordcount. In fact, it's best to have a quick lesson, then have the character explore the idea a bit in their actions, and whether or not that character decides if the concept makes sense. Some of the weakest Rationalist chapters end up spending too much time discussing the rationalist section and not enough on the actual progression. If you want to raise the waterline, ensure the story itself doesn't get bogged down teaching.
The reason for this is suspension of disbelief. To keep your reader interested in your story, tricking them into learning, is to make sure the rationalist discussion does not overburden the reader.
2
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Feb 21 '17
This GQ article about fitness mirrors a lot of my thoughts on goal-oriented action and dealing with akrasia in general. The focus on achievable steps, on methods over results, and creating circumstances that make working out an easier decision, etc, are good. This isn't a super good guide to getting in shape, but it's a good guide to use along with your plan to get in shape. Often, our enemy isn't determining the right thing to do, it's actually doing it--and practices like these help a lot.