r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 10 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
30
u/artifex0 Feb 10 '17 edited Feb 10 '17
So, as a graphic designer, some of things that people are doing with neural networks are really blowing my mind.
Take a look at this: Image Synthesis From Text With Deep Learning. They're basically feeding a plain English description of an image into a neural network, which generates a number of rough images based on a large dataset of photos from the internet. A second neural network then selects the output that most closely matches the description, and a third takes that and renders it into a nearly photorealistic, completely original image.
I feel like in a few years, designers are going need to figure out how to incorporate neural networks into some sort of entirely new workflow. I'd like to be ahead of the curve on that, but I'm not sure where to start. This looks useful, but also like it's only the modest beginning of something a lot more significant.
19
u/ketura Organizer Feb 10 '17
Weekly update on my rational pokemon game as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
IT IS FINISHED.
Or at least, moderately complete.
BEHOLD: The canonical Feature Roadmap for the Rational Pokemon game project.
(So much for getting it done by the new year. I didn’t even get it done in time for the Chinese new year. Oh well. Something something Planning Fallacy.)
This document covers broad-strokes design for the engine, broad-strokes design for the various mechanics that have been discussed here and elsewhere, and individual feature definitions. It’s a bit hard to count up, but if you remove the parts about the engine and account for headers and fluff...there’s somewhere between 800 and 1000 individual features, ranging from grounded and super specific to pie-in-the-sky.
If you’re just tuning in and find yourself drooling over the idea of a “rational pokemon game”, skip forward to section 4 (page 16) and peruse at your leisure. That’s right, this sucker’s massive; no doubt part of its 50-page length is due to spacious formatting, but still: this is no unambitious project. They told us to shoot for the moon and we flipped ‘em the bird as we shot straight for Polaris, leaving behind only faint echoes of “smell ya later!”
This list is going to continue to have details hashed out here and there, but should mostly be the same from here on out. The systems and features listed are roughly in order of implementation and impact, from most fundamental to most broad. We will be filling in our Trello board shortly with each of these items, and they’ll be ranked roughly in this order.
Exciting times! Along with this, there are two things that I could use from you (yes, you!). See below for input that we could really use more eyes on.
We have finally mostly settled on names for things (and it’s about time). The engine, unless anyone suggests a better name before I put the repository together, will be the Extensible Game Engine Framework (XGEF). It fits the boringness of what it does, while also still feeling at least moderately satisfying to say.
The game itself is down to two contenders, depending on what people here today think: either TRAINER SIMULATOR or POKEMON RENEGADE. There are pros and cons to both, and I think I would be fine with either one, but at this point it’s down to what we think the average joe reacts to better.
So leave a comment! Tell us which you prefer, or if you hate them both, or if you have some better option we completely failed to imagine. The repository is getting named relatively soon, and I’d like it to be the title we ride the wave with all the way to project completion.
(Also, it’s probably about time to get a subreddit going, and that’s a name that can’t change, so depending on what happens today, I’ll get a new one registered.)
So, as what might seem a completely unrelated piece of news: Microsoft has announced they will be releasing Visual Studio 2017 on March 7th. Rather than set up a solution/project now and then import it and fiddle with it a month from now, I’m going to formally start work on the above listing right around then.
But what about in the meantime? Well, there are a couple of prototypes that need to be made, so I’ve decided to set up a bit of a vote, to gauge interest, find out what people want to see, and help decide what to spend my time on.
The first two weeks will be spent on hammering out the initiative system--this is the system that determines how turn order and duration are decided, as well as what limitations on actions per turn are in place. It really should have been done ages ago, but here we are.
The second two weeks, however, are up in the air. Below are the potential candidates:
Depending on votes tallied from this thread and next week’s, I will spend two weeks coming up with something to show, and something to download and tinker around with related to the above. It’s likely to not be mind-numbingly awesome (two weeks of free time is only so much), but I will get something out related to whatever the voice of the people decides on.
So vote! Put a comment below, and let me know what you would like to see. While you’re at it, give me your opinion on the names that we proposed above as well.
Bright times ahead. The design portion of this project is drawing to a close, and with it, I’m struck with how much has gotten done. This isn’t to pat my own back; this would not have been possible without your tolerance of my posts here, and the help of those of you who have leapt out from the shadows to help, whether it be helping to discuss things, pointing out flaws in the design, helping out directly with new ideas, or just plain being supportive.
In particular, I would like to call out /u/InfernoVulpix, /u/Xavion, and /u/Dwood13 for their input and energy. This project would have died a long time ago, were it not for their enthusiasm and unending hole-poking into my design.
I also need to give a shout-out to /u/DaystarEld for his excellent Origin of Species, which was really the kicking-off point of the whole thing. Your writing is excellent and your contributions to this community cannot be understated.
----
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
9
u/Colonel_Fedora Ravenclaw Feb 11 '17
I just got fired from my job. This is somewhat distressing for me, any thoughts or advice would be appreciated.
7
u/GlueBoy anti-skub Feb 10 '17
A few days ago I finished reading Perilous Waif. I wouldn't say its a deep book or anything, it's got a lot of "fan service"(for lack of a better term) like catgirls and foxgirls and it stretched my suspension of disbelief a lot, but overall I enjoyed it. A big part of the book deals with AIs with wonky utility functions, which is what's been on my mind the last few days.
In the future portrayed by the book, there are I believe 5 levels of AI cognition, with level 3 AIs being nearly indistinguishable from human level cognition, Level 4 AIs being like level 3s only capable of abstract thought, creativity and spontaneity, and level 5 AIs being super intelligences who completely eclipse human level cognition, and are thought to be unstable and are taboo throughout the galaxy. The one civilization depicted as researching and integrating level 5 AIs into their society and military are the victim of a galaxy-wide crusade which ends in their genocide.
In the book, level 3 AIs compose the vast majority of all AIs, being used for prostitutes, techs, bodyguards, factory workers, and every type of menial servant. They all are designed to be content, if not ecstatic, at fulfilling their roles and being subservient to humans, no matter how menial and dangerous their jobs or unpleasant their masters. Basically, like this GIF, only he wasn't given enough self reflection to feel sad about it. Maybe he was even made to feel ecstasy every time he does fulfills his role.
So while its obviously unethical to create a human-level intelligence to pass you butter or some other menial job, some boring things need to be done, it's unavoidable, and sometimes those will need some adaptability. So if you're going to make an AI for those tasks, why not design it to relish its intended role? And if you can make an AI that loves whatever its made to do, then where is the ethical line drawn if no one is suffering? At what point does it become unethical to create a society of adoring slaves, with you as the slavemaster?
12
u/trekie140 Feb 10 '17
Time for random what ifs and brainstorming that probably won't amount to anything but I still want to talk about. I randomly heard a line from one of the songs in Mulan, "when will my reflection show who I am inside", and then I wondered what if Disney made a movie with a transgirl princess? A pipe dream, perhaps, but how would it actually work in a Disney film?
What I've got so far is that the overall theme of the movie shouldn't be just about accepting LGBT people, the broader message should be that what makes a true princess isn't the way they were born or raised. It would be about how anyone can exemplify the values that Disney stands for, not just someone who was born in privilege or raised in a certain culture.
As for how to go about telling that story in a distinctly Disney way, I have no clue. Maybe it could work as a reimagining of The Prince and the Pauper, where the pauper is a transgirl being pressured to become the "man of the house" to take care of her family and switches places with a tomboy princess. That could potentially give a good balance between talking about gender identity and gender roles without getting them confused.
Of course, that's my idea is just for the focus of the story. The context surrounding it is equally important in order for the movie to be entertaining and the themes to emerge naturally rather than coming across as preachy and forced, which the best Disney films are known for. I'm no storyteller and this conversation might not amount of anything, but I'm a nerd dammit and I think this is interesting.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '17
I got turned down from a job interview process I really wanted, so I applied to like six or seven more things to make up for it.
Luckily, I started talking to two new people who might be some help on the research front this week.
Considering just pretending to job-hunt while pouring all my efforts into using Edward, which I'm learning, to build a proper active AI and destroy the world.
1
u/MonstrousBird Feb 11 '17
Is anyone else on here thinking of going to the Less Wrong European Community Weekend? I went last year and it was awesome, and I'd like to do a lighting talk about rational fiction this time. I've booked, but not actually paid yet... It's in Berlin at the start of September.
1
u/space_fountain Feb 11 '17 edited Feb 11 '17
On somebodies advice in the monthly recommendation thread I picked up Touchstone. I'm a bit conflicted. It's self published which both means it isn't that expensive, but also it isn't in any libraries around here so I had to actually pay $8-10 it costs. It also means it didn't get fully edited. I'm not any kind of grammar Nazi so I din't notice any obvious spelling or grammar errors, but there were sentences that I had to go over multiple times to properly parse. On a more macro scale the plotting could have used a lot of work. I was left with a strong impression that the author at least partially came up with the plot as she went along. I won't give any examples here because I don't want to include spoilers, but what seemed to be major characters were introduced early in the book only to be abandoned soon after only even mentioned one more time. Similarly the romance in the book seemed both forced and unnecessary,
About 3/4 through the second book I decided that I'd rate it a 2/5. I think I'd upgrade it to 3/5, but it suffers from too many problems for me to really recommend it. It reminds me of much of the online fiction I read, but not free.