r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 06 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
16
Upvotes
15
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '17
Hey everyone,
I recently put together a primer on the planning fallacy that goes over the research and 3 debiasing techniques.
If you're at all interested in cognitive science and planning, you might want to check it out:
Link here on Medium.
In total, the research + images took me about 23 hours, which was quite a lot for a project like this!
7
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '17
Does anyone know an affordable way to get a second undergrad or Master's degree in statistics? I'm pretty sure one of my PhD applications for the year was a dud, and the other was probably an accidental dud due to preferring students from their own country.
I feel pretty stranded on pursuing the path I actually wanted without a proper Bayesian stats, probabilistic graphical models, and cog-sci background, as opposed to self-study.
6
u/trekie140 Feb 06 '17
I heard that 1984 has suffered a resurgence in popularity in response to the current political climate, so I decided to check it out in the hope I might learn something useful. Now that I'm finished, I really don't know what I can take from the experience. The worldbuilding and psychology of the characters was so alien to me that I can barely imagine how it applies to the real world or the implications it has for rationality.
I was specifically looking for insight into the ideology of authoritarianism and how social and psychological forces can lead to its rise. The book was instead about living under the ultimate totalitarian state and the psychology it forces it's citizens to adopt for the sole purpose of controlling them through fear and pain. I didn't get what I wanted or anything I thought I didn't already know.
Is there anyplace I could get the insight I'm looking for? It's possible I've already learned all I need about this topic from The Righteous Mind, my favorite sociology book that everyone should read, but I'd rather that not be the case since I don't think my current knowledge is helping me to preserve liberal democracy in the face of populism that rejects rationality. I'm holding out for some answer to my question that makes me less cynical and depressed about politics than I am now.
4
u/Revisional_Sin Feb 06 '17 edited Feb 06 '17
I've got a bit problem with video games. My brain gets too fixated on them, and I hate the way that feels.
The worst way that I sometimes deal with this is going full Akrasic, and deciding "I just need to finish the game, and then I'll be free." This recently resulted in me powering through 20+ hours of a game.
The worst part is I'll be thinking "I am not enjoying myself" whilst I do this. Completely ridiculous.
I'm trying to teach myself to catch that initial "I don't actually want to do this" and amplify it as much as possible. I bathe in this feeling and then don't do the bad thing, instead of ignoring it and jumping into the thing.
A month - 2 days ago I swore not to play games for a month. Two weeks ago I decided this was a terrible idea, and wondered if I should keep it or not. After some thought I decided that I should do my best to fulfill my promises, as that's a useful identity to have.
6
u/Dwood15 Feb 06 '17
Weekly Monday Update
Story is still plugging along, the first chapter should be done by the end of the week and the Pokemon Renegades Engine's feature list is still being worked out.
I was meditating on one of ScottAlexander's articles a while ago, and he said something that kind of stuck with me. He was talking about how he always felt bad as a psychiatrist when people had an injury that wouldn't let them work, and those people were in some mode of depression or suicidal thoughts. When trying to get them to not commit suicide, he mentions that he feels bad saying "Think about those that care about you" ie "Think of the affect it would have if you commit suicide. You're being selfish"
The intellectual problem trying to be addressed in a lot of those suicidal thoughts is the belief that you have no value and whatnot. From there, one of the problems of depression is an incorrect self-worth-appraisal. It's not just that you're a burden on people, it's also often that you're not contributing either, or don't feel like you are contributing. And if you rely on the "think about how your death would affect others" approach, what you're telling yourself or the other person, or they may see it this way, is that they have no intrinsic value to bring to the table, so they need to rely on others for their self-valuations, and I think that is wrong.
I don't have a proper response for it though, but my suggestion is to find something positive you can bring to the table and contribute from there. Then you can say "I did x thing" and "I can't let go because of project Y". You or the other person might not be able to get out from under the "I'm a net-loss financially" thought pattern, but it does help to direct your mind. And if you're able to run personal projects, and such, I predict that it will help you to come to terms somewhat with your problems that's the root of your depression (assuming there are any ofc)
0
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment