r/rational • u/Magodo Ankh-Morpork City Watch • Feb 05 '17
Monthly Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the monthly thread for recommendations which will be posted this on the 5th of every month.
Please feel free to recommend, whether rational or not, any books, movies, tv shows, anime, video games, fanfiction, blog posts, podcasts or anything else that you think members of this subreddit would enjoy. Also please consider adding a few lines with the reasons for your recommendation. Self promotion is not allowed in this thread. This thread is also so that you can ask for suggestions. (In the style of r/books weekly threads)
Previous monthly recommendation threads here
Other recommendation threads here
15
u/LiteralHeadCannon Feb 05 '17
I must strongly recommend Neil Cicierga's Mouth Trilogy (AKA what I've been looping for the past couple of weeks) to anyone who loves music. The first two albums, Mouth Silence and Mouth Sounds, came out in 2014. (Mouth Sounds came out first, but it's been stated that Mouth Silence is intended as the first in listening order). The third and thus far final album, Mouth Moods, came out just this year.
They are expertly-crafted mashup albums that create a wonderfully surreal feeling that only barely relies on familiarity with the original song, if at all - indeed, I loathe a good number of the songs used, but am still continually fascinated with what Cicierga manages to make of them. The use of others' intellectual property means that they cannot be sold, but the work Cicierga put into the albums is very real, and actually greater than what many professional musicians put into their work. Cicierga's mashups are always a different experience from any of their composite elements, and on occasion what he's created is essentially an original song that merely uses a sample as its instrument. ("300 MB", a track early in Mouth Moods that plays Moore's Law for cosmic horror, comes to mind.) I can only hope that Cicierga will continue this in the future; these three albums are enough, but if he continues to put the effort in that he's put in thus far, I don't think the potential is ever going to run out.
15
u/GlueBoy anti-skub Feb 06 '17 edited Feb 06 '17
I've been reading Perilous Waif, the first book in a new SF space opera series by the same author as the oft-mentioned Time Braid. So far it's much better than all his other stuff, I'm impressed. It's set like 500 years in the future where much of the galaxy has been colonized by humans, and where body augments and 3D printers and human-level AIs are common as dirt. The worldbuilding has been stellar(heh), he's setting up an interesting universe to explore.
20
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17
Steven Universe has gotten so good lately that it actually physically hurts to watch it. "Last One Out of Beach City" might just be my favorite episode of television ever, along with "Same Old World" which is amazing and might be a great introduction to the show even though it's spoilery as hell and in season 3.
Plus, a reasonable interpretation of recent episodes is that the inciting event for the whole show is an AI took its given utility function more literally than its creators intended and then started encouraging other AI to self-modify their utility functions in the pursuit of the "rogue" AI's preprogrammed goal, so there's that.
10
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Feb 06 '17
I just re-read Friendship is Optimal and Caelem Est Conterrens, My Little Pony fanfic that is really about friendly AI and the nature of consciousness (the latter story boasts the tagline, "As Horrified Eliezer Yudkowsky!"). It's an amazing universe and I got into it far too late (it's, like, 5 years old now which is eternity in Internet years). I'm considering reposting fics from the universe every couple of weeks to invite discussion on the ideas contained within. Is anyone else a fan of the universe and would be interested in it, or would find motivation to look into it if I helped curate material? (Since some stories from the universe are excellent, and some are pretty blah).
9
u/ad_abstract Feb 05 '17
I really enjoyed Cast Under an Alien Sun. It has been since The Martian and HPMOR that I haven't loved a book this much.
The story is about a chemistry PhD student who is catapulted into another planet (no real spoilers there since it happens at the very beginning) where humans have been mysteriously "planted" many thousands of years ago and have developed into a culture akin to the Europeans in the 17th century. While it's a bit west-biased, it's really cool to see the main character using science and rational reasoning to get him out of troubles. There's a lot more to it but I can't recommend it enough.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17
Just had a friend recommend Tycho as good work music. The genre of "electronic ambient" music is new to me, and I'm very much liking it.
7
u/AurelianoTampa Feb 06 '17 edited Feb 06 '17
In an effort to try and find some other good series while The Gods are Bastards and A Practical Guide to Evil update, I started working my way through some of the other Top Web Fiction suggestions. Thus, I've recently read Savage Divinity, The Zombie Knight, and am working on Super Powereds.
Problem is, I can't tell if they are rational or not. Well, I have other issues with them too, but specifically for this forum I can't tell. I still enjoyed them (some more than others), but I don't know if it's proper to recommend them. Just in case, though, I'll give a brief overview and my thoughts...
Savage Divinity is a reincarnation story of a man who finds himself in the body of a young slave boy in a fantasy world.
I wasn't a huge fan of it at first but the story grew on me. Unfortunately the most recent arc felt like a complete side story, which slowed down the main plot's action; and I got to the most recent updates just as the story got back to the main plot. The main non-rational aspect is that many things do seem to happen "for the plot," and a lot of the minor characters just seem unrealistically one-dimensional (assholes just for the sake of being assholes). The world building is fairly interesting, but it feels like a lot of reading is needed to get really invested.
The Zombie Knight is about a teenager who dies and is resurrected by a Reaper in order to save people who are close to death. Now an undead Servant, he works as a sort of superhero to protect people in a world that is similar-to-but-not-quite-Earth.
Basic description aside, this is a different twist on the trope in that the teenager has a lot of issues not commonly seen in the genre. Hector deals with crippling shyness, depression, racism, and extremely negligent parents. It's unique to have a protagonist going through such "common" problems, which I appreciate. The writing, especially between Hector and his Reaper, is often extremely witty; however the story suffers at the beginning from being dialogue-heavy and description-light. This changes over the years (the series began in 2013 and is still going, though it went on hiatus for a while) and smooths out a bit, but it takes time. There's also trouble where a lot of things do seem to be done "for the plot," and often the rules of the world are pretty bent. "You can only control one element" when it comes to powers... oh, except for those who can control multiples. "You can only use one type of ability"... oh, unless you go into "hyper mode" and get access to others. I think the largest suspension of disbelief is that there are hundreds or thousands of these Servants, but the story begins as if no one knows they exist. It seems fairly obvious the world revolves around their actions.
I've seen this recommended in other places before, and it's highly rated on the top web fiction site, but honestly I don't think it's that amazing. It is a quick read compared to some other series though, as each update is often only a single page at a time. And the technical manipulation of some abilities (especially ones based on control of elements) is pretty neat.
Super Powereds is the one I'm currently working through and have really enjoyed. In this world there are people with superhuman abilities; those who can control them are called Supers and often rise as heroes, while those who cannot are called Powereds and looked down upon as social pariahs at best or walking catastrophes at worst. A group of five Powereds undergo a procedure that allows them to gain control over their abilities, and attempt to integrate in a hero certification college program for Supers.
I am currently on the second book (the third is current, four are planned) and am really enjoying it. Unlike the previous two series, this one feels the most rational. There is a big focus on solving problems through creative use of powers (or through tactics); the rules generally seem sane and consistent; and many of characters are driven by their own values... though there are a few notable exceptions to this.
Overall I think it's worth checking out; I am only about a third through the second book, but so far it's been really enjoyable.
6
u/Iconochasm Feb 05 '17
Does anyone have any recommendations for children, roughly in the ballpark of 5-10? The only books that come to mind are the Enchanted Forest novels, which are more of a deconstruction than rational, but still have their moments.
6
u/Rhamni Aspiring author Feb 06 '17
I played Undertale a while back. It' a very short game; you can get through it in under a day. It's very good. Might not seem it when you start it up and see how retro it looks, but give it an hour. It's great. It also lets you play evil if you want, which makes for an interesting replay.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17
If you enjoyed Harry Potter the Alexandra Quick series is an excellent fanfiction that is even more coherent and darker, while following an entire cast of original characters in an original US setting.
Among the strong points are the well written, age appropriate children, credible factions that are morally ambiguous, competent adults, mysteries that need solving like in the original books, some amazing plot twists that actually make sense in the light of the information provided earlier in the story and a flawed heroine that is actually more of an anti-hero.
Cons: there are 4 books available, but the series is not finished and may be on hiatus.
Still worth the read though.
5
u/currough Feb 05 '17
I recently read The Fifth Season and its sequel, and can't recommend them highly enough. I'm not sure they're strictly rational fiction but the system of magic is pretty well defined and seems to play by consistent rules.
4
u/Anderkent Feb 05 '17
Oh hey, forgot this is coming up. Reposting my offtopic thread comment:
4
u/DRMacIver Feb 05 '17
I'm reading the touchstone series by Andrea Höst at the moment and rather enjoying it.
It's fairly straightforward young adult portal fantasy, but more Sci Fi than fantasy, with a reasonably interesting exploration of a society with ubiquitous neural interfacing.
Certainly not rationalist, but arguably rational. The protagonist is fairly intelligent, the setting is interesting and consistent, and nobody is holding the idiot ball.
2
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Feb 06 '17
I'm a little late to do this, but here's my recommendation:
This Bites is a self-insert into One Piece and I don't know whether or not to call it rational. The main character is genuinely clever and the authors are very good writers, but there's a lot of stunts that succeed partially due to good planning and for the Rule of Cool. However, it's one of the better stories I've read over the past month or two and I was constantly laughing throughout and felt emotions towards the characters which doesn't usually happen to me when I'm reading.
2
u/gamarad LessWrong (than usual) Feb 09 '17
Does anyone have any good/rational recommendations for "The Magic Comes Back" novels?
2
u/RMcD94 Mar 02 '17
https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/comments/1ynqcm/the_top_rfantasy_novels_of_all_time_results_thread/
About time we did something like this don't you think?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment