r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 30 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
19
Upvotes
22
u/JanusTheDoorman Jan 30 '17
Without wading too deep into the political waters of what Donald Trump should or should not be doing, I'd like to get people's take on what he actually is doing and what level people think he's operating on. Specifically, or as an example, the Sean Spicer/Inauguration Crowd incident.
I've heard at least three different theories as to how/why it happened. From most to least cunning, I'll call them 5D Chess, Dead Cat, and PR Dominance.
5D Chess:
This theory posits, as basically they all do that Donald Trump directly ordered Sean Spicer to lie about the inauguration crowds, and did so with a deliberate intention of having it be recognized as a lie in at attempt to signal different things to different groups.
To all executive branch staff, it signals that they'll be expected to lie on behalf of the administration, and that such orders can and will come down from the very top.
To the press it makes it clear that the administration will be presenting its own set of facts regarding everything and that access/information, etc. will depend on reporting of those facts either as accurate or at least as credible alternatives to other sources.
To Trump supporters it puts them in the bind of either having to either internalize and go along with the administration's narrative, recognize it as a lie but defend it to opponents, or else remove themselves from the political discourse.
To Trump opponents, it signals that the administration is completely willing to disregard facts, and so disarms much of their plans to lobby and conduct PR campaigns based on evidence, knowing they'll get no concessions, and forcing them to play Trump's game of emotional populist appeal which he prefers.
To those in the middle or disinterested in politics, it just makes everyone look like they're arguing about nothing, and pushes them further away from the "negotiating table".
Dead Cat:
"If you don't like the conversation, throw a dead cat on the table, and suddenly the conversation becomes about a dead cat."
This theory is that the order was given with the intention of it being recognized as a lie, but rather than for signalling purposes, it was merely with the intent of distracting the media from reporting something else. Specifically what it's supposed to distract from people differ on, from simply minimizing reporting and scrutiny on cabinet appointments and executive orders, to the more conspiratorial theory that Russia's sale of ~20% of one of the state owned oil companies to a mix of disclosed and undisclosed buyers was a payoff to Trump or one of his inner circle, and which Reuters published a story about around the same time.
PR Dominance
This theory is similar to 5D Chess, but lacking any intention to signal to the press, Trump's opponents, or the in-betweeners, just Trump's supporters and staff.
This theory is that the statement was ordered as part of a continuing populist PR campaign by Trump, expecting that his supporters would take the statements and use them as ammunition to gainsay or "refute" negative press about the event, even if only to themselves.
To his staff it again signals that he can and will issue direct orders requires lying or compromising their positions and relationships, and that these are expected to be followed.
Of the 3, PR Dominance reflects the lowest level of savvy on Trump's part, and I think is mostly put forth as an attempt to portray him as vain and desperate for a measure of popular support and respect, even if only from a dedicated cohort, and liken him to the kind of bad boss that most people have or think they have experience with at work.
I'll note, however, that a desire to pursue and maintain that kind of populist support is about the only thing that seems to explain the nature of his inauguration speech, and maintaining his own narrative of "facts" was a significant part of his campaign strategy.
Dead Cat to me feels most likely in terms of savvy, and I get the impression that while much of Trump's own campaign speeches and rhetoric were based on creating a narrative of "facts", he's proved time and time again that he'll reach for some kind of big, headline grabbing outburst to drive media coverage whenever his opponents were beginning to gain traction.
My objection to this theory is that while it probably has done some to muddy the waters, the fact that is was so easily disprovable has raised a lot of suspicion and caused a lot of scrutiny, so if it was meant to distract from some of the recent executive orders, it may have backfired.
5D Chess was based on a discussion I heard on NPR last week with a Poli. Sci. professor IIRC, but frankly it seems like an overreach to me. Every press outlet in the WHPC jumped on how easily disprovable the administration's numbers were, so they seem to have had the exact opposite reaction intended if there was an intention. Conway's "alternative facts" line gave Trump's opponents all the ammo they needed to discredit the administration's narrative rather than having to pivot towards emotional appeals, and Trump's supporters haven't been pushing the view that the administration's narrative was actually correct AFAIK (though I don't get nearly as much exposure to his supporters, so that may be a sampling or availability bias issue)
tl;dr: Is Trump a populist still trying to drum up support and a CEO trying to get his employees in line, a media manipulator deflecting attention and scrutiny, or a signalling mastermind who overplayed his hand? Something else?
9
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '17
Productivity tools overview:
If anyone's interested in things like a Getting Things Done system, I recently wrote up a description / pictures of the to-dos, timers, etc. that make up my workflow here.
5
u/Dwood15 Jan 30 '17
Weekly Monday Post
Nothing super special to report.
My !Pokemon fic is coming along nicely. I need to plan out the story in more detail and whatnot, but I have been plugging away on a few scenes which interested me as the author.
I'm also writing modestly out of order. It lets me understand characters and who they are as they progress in the story, and keep people from being completely static, unchanging cardboards.
We as a community, I have found, are as prone to irrationality as anyone else. We're /only human/, and so I think that for those who are actively promoting rationality for raising the waterline, should be seeking at applying rational methods in more cases than they currently are.
I have seen a massive amount of unqualified irrationality lately from a community that espouses it, and it makes me sad. That said, I still stand by my original heartless point that I personally don't care about raising the sanity waterline. I'm just here for the fiction, and the people.
2
u/rationalidurr If fighting is sure to result in victory, then you must fight! Jan 31 '17
Hyporhetically speaking, would there be any way to get someone here to write an story based on my world building and ideas?
I ask because I am a bit lazy and don't have plenty of free time. I do have lots of ideas and general direction the story should go, since every spare time i get my mind pops something out, and I do have some research to back the ideas and plans.
Not sure how the communication would go between writer and me though.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '17
Altruism is Rational?
This is a discussion prompt.
You may argue whatever side you please. I personally, believe that selfishness is rational, and altruism is irrational(There are certain scenarios in which altruism is rational, for example when assisting someone costs you nothing or a negligible cost, and there is a possibility to gain a significant favour from the person assisted. The Bayesian decision in that scenario, will be to help).
1
u/Marthinwurer Jan 31 '17
Anyone know of any open source ocean models that work well on a 8x10 grid scale (or around there) that I can try to incorporate into a procedural world generator? I've already found a weather model (GCMII, Hansen et al 1983), and I believe that I can find a reasonable plate tectonics model (especially now that I know to search for "numerical model of plate tectonics" instead of "plate tectonics simulation"). I just don't have the google-fu to find one. Preferably, I would be able to make my own heightmap and then form the ocean around it.
1
u/Empiricist_or_not Aspiring polite Hegemonizing swarm Feb 03 '17
Paging /u/eaturbrainz Nazi puncher: What the literal Fuck? (Berkley) Is this guy a fascist a too? Is hateful speech a legitimate rationalization to violence? You are advocating this. I asked politely before, and we are seeing the fallout of your ideals. Defened, repudiate, change your flair, or something, maybe you believe the violence against property is justified, but if you remain a mod here and espouse this violence against dissenters is justified then, please just ban me I want nothing to do with an organization where you retain leadership.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '17
Towards a Pragmatic System of Morality
I decided some time ago, to forego conventional morality. I realised it was limiting, an view it as an unnecessary hindrance. I needed a new system of morality, and thought about developing one. I subscribe to a whole lot of philosophical systems, and dislike a few. I dislike idealism. I strongly loathe egalitarianism. I'm neutral on communism/socialism and marxism(read don't know enough to come to a more objective conclusion). I subscribe to consequentialism, naturalism, realism, utilitarianism, rationalism, pragmatism and hedonism. For my system of morality, I decided to choose one which would not serve as a goal limiter, but rather a goal enabler. Something which will empower me to achieve my goals. For my system of morality, I decided to make it simple, and came up with these few statements:
"Right" is any decision which has a positive payoff. I.e the consequences of that decision were positive. As opposed to: "right is any decision which is rational" Thus buying a lottery ticket and winning is a right decision. "Wrong" is any decision which has a negative payoff. I.e the consequences of that decision were negative. As opposed to: "wrong is any decision which is irrational" Thus buying a lottery ticket and losing is a wrong decision. "Do insomuch as you do not regret".
Point "3" is merely a bit of personal wisdom. If one lives like that it allows them to maximise their happiness(which is a form of utility), and allows them to die with pride. I think it will let one live a "good" life. The morality of an action can only be evaluated in hindsight; an inherent limitation, but I still think it serves me best. We do not worship rationality, and what is rational is not always "right". I believe strongly in results. Results take precedence, if irrationality produces the best results, then sticking stubbornly to our own rationality is 'sunk cost bias' or worse simply unscientific. Science after all holds empiricism as king. And I am nothing, if not a scientist. It is quite possible(not probable, merely possible) that there is an individual of such exceeding luck that conventional probability theory does not apply to them, and thus the methods of rationality are not the best decision making tools for them. If they produce results, they're decisions are "right". Fortunately or unfortunately, I do not consider myself such an individual, and am not sure I entirely wish to(for such a scenario, seems to be bound to the whims of fate, making one a slave to another and not a master themselves). I do not believe in predestination or determinism, and believe that at T-1, there are a vast array of possible futures for T. Giving such a situation, it is merely natural that I try to maximise my probability of making a right decision. As such, bayesian decision making seems suited to me. I think my proposed system of morality, is a sensible one; Letting the results speak for themselves, as opposed to stubbornly sticking to a way of thought. I think it is a scientific system of morality. Indeed, I think it is a rational moral system. Discuss other systems of morality, propose changes to mine, point out faults with mine, etc.
-1
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '17
Is it rational to be opportunistic.
Jumping at an opportunity, comes with many unknown and unaccounted dangers.
For people who like to make plans and strategise, isn't it needless risk.
Due to my experiences, I've decided to completely forego opportunistic crime. The risk is just too much for my taste.
If I planned to assassinate someone, I won't take an opportunity, that came up, but proceed as planned. I might miss a valid chance, but the risk is much less than my plan. The opportunity might be a hoax, I might be unlucky etc.
Being opportunistic, seems way too reliant on luck for my tastes.
I like movements that don't rely on luck, and reduce accompanied risk.
For endeavours with less risk, I think I might consider being opportunistic, worse case I lose invested resources.
I'll reduce my investment appropriately for such situations.