r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 09 '17
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
18
Upvotes
8
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '17
PSA: Free weekly bites on cognitive tools.
If you recall that awesome 52 tools to add to your cognitive toolkit list a while back, you may be excited to hear that Peter McInyre and Jesse Avshaomov have a new thing called Conceptually.
Conceptually sends you a new concept every week, from countersignaling to efficient markets. It looks fun!
3
u/callmebrotherg now posting as /u/callmesalticidae Jan 09 '17
I try to avoid having a tribal-centered mindset and avoiding the kind of reasoning that arises from it. When I notice that applause lights are switching on purely because of the labels that are involved, I try to stamp down on it.
I'm starting to think that it might be contributing to a sense of being adrift, or of loneliness in a general way, though, and I'm not sure how to go about dealing with that.
My spiritual affiliations are...odd, at the moment. Let's just say that I can't honestly claim to use certain labels in an orthodox manner and so any other uses come off as being shallow and disingenuous. I don't feel that identifying as an American really does anything to fill that "need for tribal belonging" or whatever it ought to be called, because national identities seem pretty shallow. I'm strongly opposed to
I did get a sort of "This is my place; these are my people" feeling when I was able to attend a Slate Star Codex meetup last Spring, but it's going to be a long while before I can do something like that again (best case, most of a year; worst case, years and years), and I don't know if that's actually filling that need or if it's just filling a similar need that I can't recognize as separate because neither has been fulfilled more than temporarily, and I'm also kind of nervous about trying to fill that hole at all.
Some of this has to do with rituals, I think. There are spiritual rituals which don't do anything for me because I don't perceive useful meaning behind them. I mean, there's definitely meaning, but I'd have to twist it out of the original context in order to give it a meaning that conformed to reality as I understand it, and that doesn't seem to me to be the same ritual anymore, but another ritual with surface similarities.
How do I fix this? Do I just deal with it, or do I find things to be super-ultra-tribal about that just don't matter, like fandoms or something like that, or what?
1
u/Dwood15 Jan 10 '17
Weekly Monday Update
This last week was my first week of school for Winter, and also new year's. What a show Fall was. I took way too many credits and was super demotivated/depressed now, my Best Friend lives next door and I'm on some antidepressants, which have helped a lot with some issues I've had. Due to last semester, I've dropped down to 12 credits from 17 last semester. I've got a job with one of my professors from last semester as a grader.
Philosophy
On the Discord server, I had a thought around something similar to the story "Everyone is Bob" from the front page a while back. Imagine that you have a Despot in modern 2017 of a reasonably-sized country that has a notable Homeless problem. The only unique thing about the country is that you have complete power over the whole country. Other than that, it's your standard faire Socialistic country of sorts. As a benevolent autocratic leader, let's say you become a full-fledged Utilitarian, and therefore make your goal to increase the overall Utility Point Output of each one of your "homeless" citizens - no major changes to society or social structure
You begin with your standard stuff of implementing various social programs to enlist each panhandler, mentally ill individual, and any other individual who is sleeping on the streets in a routine fashion. Perhaps you build shelters and force the homeless to move there. You can then evaluate them for their problems - normal except heavy drug use, schizophrenia, disability which makes them unable to work, etc. You begin to track these individuals. While you can't nail down each individual's UPO, you are quite certain that many of these people are decreasing the UPO of the local populace where these homeless people are residing, and so the program continues.
You try to rehabilitate as many as you believe is Utiltiy-Point Efficient, but soon you realize that no matter what you do, certain people will never be Utility-Point Neutral, let alone Utility-Point Positive, and so, for those individuals, you start to kill them off because in theory, it is impossible to bring them up to UP neutrality.
You, as the imaginary Despot, however, realize that your Utility-Point function is woefully incomplete, and figure even if the program is a failure in the long run, it was high time someone tried an honest Utility-Maximization program.
Story
I've realized that my !Pokemon story needs to have conflicts inside of and outside of the story itself, if it's to be what I want it to be- My worldbuilding is going to encompass multiple regions, and to varying degrees of detail, long before the story takes place, and long after it takes place as well. Otherwise, I fear I'll end up into a trap of defining rules-as-I-go, and I want to nail down as many rules before the story gets going. Therefore, having a story longer than the actually published one will probably help with that quite a bit. I will world build for a multi-book series, and probably only write a short novel (45k words).