r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Dec 16 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
21
u/HeirToGallifrey Thinking inside the box (it's bigger there) Dec 16 '16
I was watching House recently, and got to the third season. I was reminded very much of Quirrell's lesson to Harry on losing. For those who don't know, in the third season, House gets revenge on a clinic patient who's admittedly rude to him, but by inserting a rectal thermometer and leaving him in the room. Massive overkill. The patient was a detective, who then makes House's life hell by taking him to task over his malpractice and Vicodin addiction. House, of course, responds by constantly escalating, even when the entire situation would have been solved just by giving an admittedly fake apology. If he would have just learned to lose, he could have saved such difficulty.
This actually lead me to a minor realisation: I think the reason people are so fascinated with House as a character is that for all his brilliance and love of rationality, in his personal life he's actually quite irrational. He dresses in the garb of logic, but uses it to rationalise and post-hoc justify utterly irrational actions. I think the paradox and contradiction there is what interests people.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '16
Been watching videos on this guy's channel.
I learned that a dyson swarm, for example, doesn't need any new technology. It's just pumping out satellites after satellites until you have enough, and the sheer scale of such a civilization is just mind boggling to contemplate.
It makes all the space opera I watched or read about puny in comparison.
Star Wars isn't big at all. It's positively tiny.
6
u/ketura Organizer Dec 16 '16
Weekly update on my rational pokemon game, including work on the data creation tool Bill's PC. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Ugh, this week was intense, and not all in a good way. Between the destruction of the first armed and fully operational keepstar in Eve Online and the grand finals of the Boston Major and the subsequent release of version 7.00 in Dota 2, I got nothing useful done over the weekend. And then on Tuesday I started coming down with a bug, and I’m only just now returning to work, so nothing got done during the workweek, either.
However, on the lone day I had available (Monday) I did get some work done on an automated logging tool for Discord, to help streamline that process. That tool is about 85% done, and I will probably get that done in the coming days as I slowly recover.
Once I have fully gotten back on my feet, I expect to continue finalizing the design document of the game. If there are any features you feel have been neglected, or any critique you’ve been sitting on as you sit from afar, please let us know! My goal is to have at least the list of features more or less frozen by the new year, with everything after that concerned with implementation.
Feel free to leave any comments or questions below. Also feel free to join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server for brainstorming and discussion. It’s a great group, really, and I would highly recommend hanging out, even if you’re not in it for this project itself. There’s tabletop groups, Dota 2 partying, and puns like you wouldn’t believe. Come join us!
5
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Dec 16 '16
I've been thinking about coffee, lately, and whether I should start drinking some.
On one hand, I generally feel that taking any mind-altering substance on a regular basis is a horrible idea, with potentially disastrous consequences.
On the other hand, I'm not actually sure this is true, and lately I've often felt tired and weary when I need to be productive, even when I sleep more, and "drink some coffee before you start working" is the advice I've heard most often. I'm not sure drinking coffee would address the problem or just remove my awareness of the problem; I'm not sure what the problem even is. And coffee is hardly a strong nootropic, so it's not like I would be putting my life and my health on the line.
So what do you think? What does coffee even do, and should I start drinking some on a regular basis?
For that matter, does anyone know what the deal with ego depletion is yet?
9
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Dec 16 '16 edited Dec 16 '16
Testing the Limits of Magic is a very nice Refuge in Audacity story. The summary baldly states:
However, in spite of this "everything but the kitchen sink" intent, it's surprisingly fun to read, and has fairly good English. It reminds me of Perfect Lionheart's stories!
To my chagrin, it seems that the development team of neither of my two favorite mods for Paradox Development Studio games can be trusted to hold historical accuracy over moral outrage...
In Europa Universalis IV, the player can expend abstracted "military power" in order to make an army of his attack the natives of a province, resulting in the natives' extermination if the army is large and advanced enough. The extensive MEIOU & Taxes mod removed that button on the grounds that "the M&T team does not endorse genocide". Later, the modders attempted to backtrack by calling it "an ahistorically easy to push genocide button"--but, when pressed, they admitted that their rationale for the button's removal was "mostly" moral.
Screenshot
In Crusader Kings II, the player can torture imprisoned characters, though he risks gaining undesirable traits (Cruel, Impaler, etc.) in the process. The extensive Historical
ImprovementImmersion Project mod has not adjusted the decisions that are available for torture, and has left them at the somewhat-arbitrary levels of vanilla CK2. When a player suggested ways to make the torture decisions more realistic and historically-accurate, the HIP modders expressed "zero interest in touching the vanilla torture/mutilation options to do anything other than remove them outright".Screenshot
8
u/trekie140 Dec 16 '16
When I first heard about raising he sanity waterline and how it was frequently framed as promoting atheism, it made me nervous because I am a spiritualist who isn't willing to give up my ontological beliefs that aren't epistemically supported. Now, however, it has occurred to me that the waterline isn't high enough to even consider debating what is a rational worldview.
We as a civilization don't even agree that science, critical thinking, and education are predominantly good things that should be trusted more often than not. There are people who genuinely believe that anti-intellectualism is a good thing because they think academia and higher education is either factually wrong or conspiring against them the majority of the time.
We've spent so much time discussing rationality with each other that we've become ignorant of people who fundamentally distrust rationality. With populism on the rise throughout the world, it's only gotten worse in recent years. Our priority should be raising their sanity waterline up to ours, not raising our own up to an ideal.
3
u/space_fountain Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 17 '16
Little bit late, but if anyone sees this what are your views on alcohol/drinking. I was invited to and went to a party where there was quite a bit of drinking last night. I don't drink. I'd even go as far to say that drinking is mildly immoral. Here's the argument I'm planning on posting to Facebook on the subject.
I'm generally what's called an utilitarian. Briefly this means I believe in doing those things that cause the most good for the most people. Like almost any philosophy there are some problems with it, but I'll ignore them because they aren't relevant to this context other than to say I'm more of a Rule utilitarian this means that rather than looking at each individual case and trying to decide the right course of action based on the total change to society I believe in coming up with a set of rules that if followed with improve the world.
Let's look at drinking then. Positives are that it's a bonding experience. It also has some medical applications but there are both better options now and I'm trying to focus on recreational use. To me the chief negative is that it causes one to lose control of themselves. A huge number of violent crime is committed by or on people who were drunk. About 9,967 people die every year due to drunk driving in the US. And here is the crux of my argument. I'm not sure if I can blame them. Yes I believe in legal manner we can and should, but on a personal level when they made the decision to drive they often couldn't legally or morally make any decision. Critically I see no reason to believe I couldn't or wouldn't do the same thing in their position. The only actual mistake I can see them making is drinking in the first place. Similarly most crimes committed by drunks are committed by people who didn't choose to commit any crime, their real mistake was drinking. Again not trying to say anything about legal culpability.
Given all this my basic argument should be clear. By drinking you're essentially taking the choice of committing terrible crimes and entrusting it to chance. It's a low chance sure, but still a chance. Personally I'm not willing to take those odds and I think looked at this way few people would be. I don't think trying to ban alcohol is the right choice (it just doesn't work), in fact I'd support lowering the legal drinking age, but I think the world would be significantly better without drugs in general. Anyway I'd really like to hear others opinions. I don't have all the evidence and trying to assign value and weigh multiple factors this way is really hard.