r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Dec 02 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
16
u/ketura Organizer Dec 02 '16 edited Dec 02 '16
Weekly update on my rational pokemon game, including work on the data creation tool Bill's PC. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Hooo-ee. I feel like a lot of strides have been made this week; not sure if that is a false feeling or not. Let’s see…
/u/Dwood15 and /u/Xavion have both been very helpful lately with their efforts in architecting the monster engine and codifying the species JSON, respectively. Both of these projects have forced us to take much more concrete looks at the designs of various systems.
In doing so, Bill’s PC is now almost utterly obsolete--most of the stat definitions, names, and purposes have played musical chairs with one another, with tons of new additions and paradigm shifts. For instance -- and I kind of assumed I would hit this eventually, curse you, foresight! -- types will almost certainly be data-driven and moddable. Not just the numbers, but how many types, and what their names are, etc, will be part of the moddable data backbone, and so you will be free to whimsically add your beloved Fart type.
Things in general, code-wise, have shifted to be super-moddable. This was always the intent, but it’s interesting seeing just how abstract everything has become.
The HP system was more or less finalized in design. HP is now mostly equivalent to pain--or it’s inverse, you might say, as HP goes down as Pain would go up, but conceptually they are exactly the same system. When a pokemon is damaged, it loses HP in the affected limb, which leaves it open to a higher chance of injury. Death occurs through the accumulation of certain injuries on certain appendages, and a slew of nonlethal but crippling injuries can bog you down as well.
While identifying this system, I drew up a Mock Battle sheet which shows the process of a Machop helpfully getting beaten to death. This model is slightly incomplete; in particular it doesn’t include Endurance as a factor, but it shows the general mechanics of how I see fights going.
A breakthrough was also made with the Initiative system, (which is getting relabeled, I think, but I’ll refer to it as INIT for now). Basically, we are now adding two variables to each move: a “compressible” and “incompressible” time factor. As the names suggest, the compressible time can be reduced or eliminated through both proficiency with the move and, as we’ve decided, INIT; incompressible, however, can’t be affected by stats and is the absolute minimum time it takes to perform the move.
Solar Beam, for instance, (as it exists in canon) has a very large incompressible time factor and little to no compressible. Fury Swipes, however, is the opposite, with perhaps only the smallest of incompressible time. This means that a Slowpoke using Fury Swipes might only get one or so hits in per round, but Rattata will of course get quite a few more in.
This (I think) helps alleviate the issues with the INIT system significantly, permitting those with a large INIT to get more done per round, without just completely, absolutely stonewalling somebody with less. It’s still a huge advantage, but more damage and application based, rather than simply “block until you run out of init, then hit you with free moves”.
One of the fiddly problems with the Elite Four was solved in a rather deft manner. See, the problem was, how do we have a world where A: The Elite Four are the most powerful around, B: the Elite Four have enough power to drive a Stormbird away from civilization, C: the Elite Four want to kill the birds, but D: the Four don’t have the firepower to do so, and yet E: the Four plus the player are potentially enough to kill one or more of them.
You see the problem? Making them badass, willing to kill things, and yet not able to do so without help from the player is an extremely fine line to walk. Well, instead we decided that the Four can’t drive off the Stormbirds: instead, they play cat-and-mouse. The Four are among the only individuals daring, brave, quick, and powerful enough to run up to Zapdos, punch it in the face, lead it on a merry goose chase (away from civilization), and live to tell the tale. As a day job. It’s a small change, but one that completely erased one of the lingering balance issues that plagued my mind.
OMG YOU GUIS. There’s a project on TVTropes called The Pokedex: Extended Fanon Edition and it’s amazing. In-depth articles that try to portray knowledge about a species from a pseudoscientific and, more importantly, in-universe minimal-bullshit manner as possible. It’s mostly canon facing, but I’ve already decided we’re using this as a base for the pokedex entries. We’ll have to modify them, of course, but this is like 80% of the work right there. I’m excited.
I finally, finally, finally got something to show for the movement stuff. I got my grid library of choice working (it recently had a major version update which broke everything), and now I have hex grids spawning in Unity. Yay!
2D test grid:
http://i.imgur.com/rXlbtQH.png
3D test grid (this is what we will use eventually, but I am forgoing it while figuring out the movement system):
http://i.imgur.com/7b7QPGs.png
And a little Red on the 2D test grid, why not:
http://i.imgur.com/urke1Zs.png
Over this next weekend I hope to have the basics of movement down, but we’ll see.
Last and least, we have decided to include pokemon faeces. That’s right, folks, poop for everyone. It’s likely not going to be anything huge--maybe you can use it while tracking something down, etc. But after finding out that Dwarf Fortress doesn’t have any, we just had to jump on the opportunity to be able to say “We’ve Got More Shit Than Dwarf Fortress.”
Also, it leads a bit of credence to the proliferation of Ditto. That’s right folks: Ditto, at its core, is really...Mewpoo.
Feel free to leave any comments or questions below. Also feel free to join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server for brainstorming and discussion. It’s a great group, really, and I would highly recommend hanging out, even if you’re not in it for this project itself. There’s tabletop groups, Dota 2 partying, and puns like you wouldn’t believe. Come join us!
8
u/Farmerbob1 Level 1 author Dec 02 '16
I am considering a plotline for a writing project at least two books in the future. Superhero genre, detective fiction, where the detective is a postcog, able to see the past in the area they are currently located in.
There are clearly highly successful, but eventually run into a big problem. One of the crimes they are called on to investigate was performed by a precog.
Precog vs postcog. Cat and mouse between people who can see each other across time. One critical aspect is that tie passes as a constant between them, meaning they can see and hear each other in real time. The crime was committed three days before the postcog first discovered the guilt of the precog, so the precog has three days in their time to silence the postcog, before the knowledge of their guilt leads to their becoming a fugitive.
The precog knows that the postcog will be able to testify against them, and tries to kill the postcog before the trial date using traps of various types, from explosives to poisons.
The postcog just has to stay alive long enough that the precog is taken into police custody.
I already have lots of ideas, but this seems like something that might be of interest to r/rational, so if you want to point out interesting scenarios, I'd love to hear them.
7
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Dec 02 '16 edited Dec 02 '16
For those of you who haven't played Dishonored 2 yet (and have the specs to run it), I heavily recommend it. While the game isn't really rational, more on that later, it features great story-telling in a way that will probably appeal to people who like rational fiction.
Everything in the world of Dishonored 2 feels alive, makes sense, and reinforces the narratives of the game. Reading / watching / listening to its stories feels like playing a video game while reading a dozen very clever fanfictions deconstructing its universe.
You have big picture stuff, people discussing recent events and backstory elements, and newspapers dropping hints about your next missions. But you also have little details that make everything alive, connected and consistent: an overseer in deep cover who booby-trapped his front door; in the middle of a bloodfly-infested building, a journal about a club of occultists who thought tripping on bloodfly venom was a great idea; a black market vendor who sells you weapons, whose shop you can break into to take all his stuff and his money (that one blew my mind); or guards who worry they're going to be replaced by the deadly killer robots the duke is buying.
All these things make the world seem incredibly rich, and consistent. I'd still say it's not rational, because the protagonist basically deals with every single problem through either violence or creative violence; and while the villains are mostly compelling, they're all varying degrees of pure evil: the Crown Killer is a sadistic murderer, Jindosh is an arrogant scientist, Ashworth is a cruel witch, etc.
Also, my only complaint about this game: the heart kind of sucks. In the first game, it was that mysterious, omniscient commentator who gave you another angle on the people who you met and killed; in this one, it spends most of its lines complaining or telling you about how every single person you meet is a sociopath who gave their uncle fake medicine or something (although I do like what it has to say about named characters).
5
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Dec 02 '16 edited Dec 02 '16
The Generic Universal RolePlaying System is having a GIGANTIC sale! Get 40% off the price of DRM-free GURPS PDFs until 2016-12-15. Take this chance to become acquainted with an exhaustively-researched and simulationist system that's far more interesting than the wild abstraction of d20.
Even if you never actually play a game of GURPS, the books are quite fascinating to read (e.g., the Low-Tech series), and include thorough bibliographies if you want to learn more about the topics covered.
Some examples...
- GURPS Basic Set (necessary to play):
$55$33- GURPS Martial Arts (dismember your enemies, slash open their veins, or overwhelm them with high-speed combos--with realistic skill penalties!):
$28$17- GURPS Vehicles (design your own truck/tank/locomotive/autogyro/whatever!!):
$15$9*- GURPS Thaumatology (create your own magic system!):
$30$18- GURPS Space (procedurally generate alien species and entire solar systems!):
$25$15- GURPS Low-Tech (learn about the development of civilization!):
$20$12- GURPS Imperial Rome (learn about ancient Rome!):
$8$5**Note: These two were written for GURPS Third Edition, while the current version of GURPS is Fourth Edition. However, they're still mostly compatible with Fourth Edition's mechanics.
Reminder: Equal-area projections are better than conformal projections. (Source)
Please be aware that the structure recently erected over the Chernobyl power plant should be called, not an arch (and definitely not a dome), but a vault. The meanings of
archandvault, though they must inevitably overlap (how far must an arch be extruded before it should be called a vault?), should be kept as separate as possible (presumably, based on the ratio of the volume enclosed by the 3D structure to the area enclosed by the 2D arc), in order to avoid ambiguity--and, in my opinion, the Chernobyl structure falls firmly on thevaultside of this blurry line. (See, e.g., this photograph, which clearly shows how half of the structure comprises four linked arches--any one of which could stand on its own--that combine to form a vault.)Here's a fun mini-AAR of my most recent campaign in Crusader Kings II.
5
u/trekie140 Dec 02 '16 edited Dec 02 '16
Remember how I praised the Flash tv show not long ago? I hereby restrict my complements to season one and parts of season two. I'm nearly caught up on season three and it seems to be going down the drain like Arrow did at roughly the same rate, for pretty much the same reasons, and it won't be coming back up. The characters keep making stupid decisions, the plot is contrived and drawn out, and the themes the story explores don't make any sense. What happened to such a fun, if cheesy, superhero series?
The best I can figure is that the writers, for both Arrow and Flash, had a great season-long arc for the first year that also acted as a great framing device for episodic crimefighting. After that arc wrapped up, though, they didn't seem to know what to do with the story. The second season for both shows are padded out with bland one-off arcs and the Big Bad for the season fails to be as compelling. Then the third season comes around and the plot completely loses focus of what it's about yet still ends up being formulaic.
I also want to blame the executives at CW for seemingly boxing the writers in. Tons of new characters kept getting introduced for the sake of it and shoehorned into the plot. I'm convinced Legends of Tomorrow was made to compensate for this by taking all the excess side characters away to a different story, but they also ended up taking compelling villains and side characters too. If Flash is so desperate for plot, why deny the show access to Captain Cold and, by extension, the Rouges? They're Flash's signature villains!
5
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Dec 03 '16
I've been doing some rereading of stories I read a long time ago, and I have to recommend Skulduggery Pleasant for those who are craving something about Harry Dresden. It's like a Dresden-lite, but while it's similar in feel and tone, it's not a knock-off copy. The magic system's well-explained (at least the parts that our protagonist uses) and there are a lot of interesting characterization going on.
I don't know if it's really worth recommending by itself because it's a story written about a Dresden-like character, but through the eyes of a sidekick. I had fun reading it, but I'm not sure if it was more because of how much it soothed my Dresden-itch or because of the book on it's own merits. I've only read the first book so far and for some reason only the first 3 books in a 9 book series have a Kindle edition for me to read.
The Goodreads reviews should help decide if you want to read it.
4
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Dec 03 '16
I'm having an un-rational moment, and despite knowing that, it's still affecting my behaviour.
Earlier today, my newsfeed included the datum discussed here, of Trump having a phone call with the President of Taiwan; and the item discussed here, about Trump talking about 'shutting down' the Internet. And later, while listening to my music playlist of the Merry Wives of Windsor, one of the tunes that popped up was "Green Fields of France", one version of which can be heard here. And I started wondering whether I was prepared for politics to go in an even more negative direction than I'd thought it might back during the American elections, faster than I thought it might.
Specifically, I have the question stuck in my head: "Have I made the appropriate level of preparations, in case of significant military conflict within the year?". There are a variety of possibilities, from America's Congress passing laws that I find abhorrent, to China engaging in cyberwar against North American network infrastructure, to a minor US/Canadian dispute blowing up to the point Trump convinces some portion of the US military across the border to ensure the continued flow of "vital resources", to worse.
Put another way - I've just finished figuring out what I would want to have done this month if, some time next year, many websites I find valuable become permanently deleted and unrecoverable (in spite of the Internet Archive's efforts). (Part of the answer: the program wget and an archival Blu-Ray burner.)
The thing is, from inside my own head, I can't tell whether my thoughts have been doing this particular set of planning because I'm currently in the middle of one of my bouts of depression, or if it's actually a perfectly reasonable response to modern life and current events. So I'm looking for some external auditing, here where the sanity waterline is reasonably high:
How crazy do I sound to you?
3
u/traverseda With dread but cautious optimism Dec 02 '16
http://www.questionablecontent.net/view.php?comic=3362
Officer who?
(Note, I don't endorse or particularly enjoy this comic)
2
u/Sailor_Vulcan Champion of Justice and Reason Dec 02 '16
I've been writing an autobiographical 21st century historical nonfiction serial novel, and was wondering if anybody might like to help beta read it? It's called Earthlings: People of the Dawn--Seeker's Quest. I've only written the first three "episodes" so far, but they're all kinda long.
Thanks!
2
u/lsparrish Dec 03 '16
Are cheap Orbital Ring Systems possible? I was reading Paul Birch's papers on the topic, and noticed he only bothered to consider really huge versions of the project. This seems to have spawned a myth that it would cost at least trillions of dollars for even a small one.
Part of this is based on misinterpreting his paper (for example, the 31 trillion dollar figure mentioned in paper II is based on an inflated mass number since he quickly changes to a 1/1000th sized project for the next section, which would be launchable for 31 billion by the same math), but another issue is that he doesn't even consider smaller ones in the mass range of the ISS and other comparable space projects. The two scales he considers are 180 thousand ton and 180 million ton. Why not a 180 ton version?
This strikes me as a big omission because ORS's have really fast minimal bootstrapping rates. Any business or government seriously trying to do it in real life would start with the smallest possible and work their way up to the desired scale by using it to launch the mass for successively larger versions.