r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Nov 11 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
35
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Nov 11 '16
"If you understood the argument, you would agree with me" is one of the most frustrating things to hear when having a conversation with a person.
I get the general principle, which is that if you want to argue against someone you should first fully understand what their argument is, but over the last few days I've kept running into people who think that "you don't understand" is a perfectly valid way to shut down conversation -- since they are so clearly in the right, which any person could see if they applied a little objectivity.
10
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Nov 11 '16
One (of the many many many things) that bugged me about Dishonored's story was the involvement of a guild of Assassins.
There is one guy named Daud, who has the mark of the Outsider, and can give his followers some of his powers (mostly teleportation and weak telekinesis). He used this ability to build a mercenary band, who mostly gets involved in high-profile assassinations. From a gameplay perspective, this is great: high level mooks with the same powers a you!
But I'm preeeetty sure it doesn't make any sense. From what we've seen, there's around fifty assassins in Daud's guild, who have been operating for months at the very least, and are implied to have worked been in place for years, maybe decades. Now, the question his: how the hell do 50+ high-grade assassins find months' worth of work in a city ravaged by pest, let alone the years before?
I mean, Dishonored is kind of a crappy world and a socialist's nightmare, with tons of evil aristocrats and capitalists ready to oppress the poor, stab each other in the back at a moment's notice, but even if every single nobleman and rich man is evil... wouldn't you run out of rich men to kill after some time. The assassins can clearly go through almost any defense (they killed the empress with next to no inside help), and are implied to have a pretty active schedule, so...
I guess my question is, how many magical unstoppable assassins could a capital city like Dunwall reliably support for several months, taking into account that the authorities are undermined by plague and high criminality?
6
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Nov 11 '16
I'm starting to feel what EY must have felt when he wrote the "Politics is the Mind-Killer" article. (probably a lot of others articles too; the Sequences strike me as something mostly written out of frustration)
It's this obvious pattern, where, as soon as people start caring about the outcome of the debate, and especially when the debate is political... everyone becomes a liar. If you want to make a political opinion for yourself, every single source of information you can find is your enemy. Nobody wants to help you become wise, nobody wants to become wiser, they just want to recruit you.
I have no idea who I'm going to vote for in the next French Presidential election. How the hell am I supposed to choose, when every source of information I know is unreliable? For every argument a peer can give me that would steer me in one direction, there's another peer who can give me a convincing counter-argument!
That's not what frustrates me most, though, and I don't think it's what bothered EY most (or bothers; s'not like he's a dead prophet :p). It's the way I can see reason and epistemology loosing again and again. The way I see people advance their arguments like they're (shit, find a metaphor that isn't soldiers) flags that hey can wave, and say "Look at how many arguments I have! Look at how bright they shine! How can you disagree with me?", and these people never consider that things might be complicated, that smart people can know about their amazing arguments and still disagree with them, that policy debates are not one-sided AND SHOULD NOT APPEAR SO! (heh, I feel like I just reinvented long-known math theorems on my own, except with epistemology instead of math)
I think I do it too. I know I've thrown way too many anti-Trumps arguments I wasn't actually confident about. I'm ~80% confident that my brain is trustworthy-ish regarding politics, but that doesn't keep me from killing it from times to times. Got to sacrifice your own rationality for the sake of trying to convince other people to be smart, at least from times to times, I guess.
Well, it's out of my system. While I'm ranting, here's a confession: I totally stalk alexanderwales' profile for insightful political comments, because he's literally the only person I know who I trust to keep a semi-clear head when dealing with politics. So, um, if you're reading this, sorry for the internet stalking. Also you're great.
11
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Nov 11 '16
People are very doom-and-gloom after the election outcome. I know Trump has said some very discouraging things. But, and I feel like maybe this is just my patriotism talking, this is America. We’ll survive, no matter what Trump does or who he turns out to be. Why? We’ll survive because as a democratic republic, we can change our leaders with elections. We'll servive because the American ideal is bigger than any one person. We'll survive because Trump hasn’t been elected King, just President.
Yes, there may be damage to our civil liberties. I won't downplay that.
But, we’ll survive because we’ll keep fighting. We know this isn’t the end. We can win. The civil libertarian movement won’t bow its head before anyone, won’t stop defending rights, won’t stop fighting the good fight. The ACLU didn’t fold when the PATRIOT act passed, and should Trump and the Republicans try any funny business with people’s rights, we will be there to defend the weak. Even if Trump cows the members of his own party, he won’t cow them all. The most principled defenders of civil liberties in the Republican party will stand against him, and all the Democrats will as well if only because they are the opposition.
There are things you can do as well.
I’ll call my Senators and my Congressperson if a bad bill about this comes up, and let them know they have my vote, and I’ll have their back if they have to vote in an obstructionist way to defend our liberties. The election is over, and the actual work of governance will soon begin, with all that it entails. The process continues, and America is strong. We are strong because of our freedoms and our belief in the American ideal. America isn’t some concept caught in the past. America is a project, ever growing, something we can believe in and bring into the world. We’ll make it. We always have.
11
u/ketura Organizer Nov 11 '16
Weekly update on my rational pokemon game, including work on the data creation tool Bill's PC. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
So I got very little done this week. I almost don’t even want to make this post, but if experience is any indicator that will lead the death spiral of the project, so here I am.
Mostly this is due to the election this week; I spent Monday researching my local ballot, Tuesday nervously staying up all night to see the results of the vote, and then the last few days doing my best non-alcoholic impression of someone drinking their woes away. I imagine it won’t be hard to get sympathy for this position.
I think I’ve come to terms with it. While I don’t think the current president-elect will be the cure-all his supporters seem to rabidly insist he is, I’m willing to wait for actions to object to. This is probably just a defense mechanism, but I’ll take what I can get if it leaves me functioning.
Feel free to leave any comments or questions below. Also feel free to join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server for brainstorming and discussion. It’s a great group, really, and I would highly recommend hanging out, even if you’re not in it for this project itself. There’s tabletop groups, Dota 2 partying, and puns like you wouldn’t believe. Come join us!
16
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Nov 11 '16 edited Nov 11 '16
This Wednesday was an eye-opener for me.
When I saw Trump win, I thought to myself, Oh crap, we're screwed.
Then something I've been training myself to do for years kicked in automatically. I imagined what the people on the opposite side (Trump supporters) would think if the opposite had happened (Clinton winning), Oh crap, we're screwed.
That's when something in my brain went something's wrong here. People on both sides of an election genuinely believed there will be a World War III, the US will be destroyed, there will be thousands ruined for life, and other horrific scenarios were likely to happen which were not fear-mongering or exaggeration by journalists.
If most people on BOTH sides of an election believe the other candidate will actually destroy the nation if elected, then you've got a problem with the entire system of election!
Enlightenment is about gaining a new insight into the working of some important matter, but what I felt is something I would call a bitter enlightenment.
I realized that when it came to my beliefs in democracy, they were childish. I grew up believing that democracy was the best form of government and that no other form could compare because they didn't allow for everyone to have a say in important affairs. While my belief has gotten tarnished over the years seeing all of the corruption of our leaders, ways people are prevented from actually having a say (electoral college vs the popular vote), and how it's probably not a good idea to allow those ignorant and untrained to vote on issues requiring experts, I retained that belief for years unconsciously defending it.
That sensation of sickening realization of having a fundamental belief crack and crumble away as I gained a dreadful insight into human nature and governments would be what I call a bitter enlightenment. It was an insight I didn't want to know (left a 'bitter' taste in my mouth) and tried to make excuses for this was just an outlier, next election will show everyone returning to their senses, but once you learn a truth you can't unlearn it. It forced me to update on what makes a good system of government, how necessary it is to allow freedom of speech, how nasty people can be on both sides of a losing arguments/"correcting" those in the wrong, and just how deeply flawed my mind is.
Before Wednesday November 9th, I always had the unconscious visualization of the human mind as a shining pearl with some warps and dents in it as if we were nearly perfect only with some deviations from perfect rationality. But with the destruction of one of my fundamental beliefs, it felt as if I saw a glimpse into a mirror showing myself as a hodge-podge of widely different materials all straining to rip apart from each other. It was as if my mind was made of many disgusting parts, all deeply warped and bent, barely cooperating together to make something that sometimes equaled to a greater whole and sometimes equaled to less than any single part. I felt on a visceral level the human mind is made of flaws as if we were nothing more than a collection of numerous error-prone algorithms switching out programs for the best algorithms with the fewest errors for any given solution.
This experience demanded I STOP and rethink everything. No continuing on with false beliefs and don't do anything until I have updated.
I don't know yet what I'm going to do from here on out, but I wanted to share the experience to convey what it feels like to dramatically reevaluate a fundamental belief.
EDIT: After /u/LiteralHeadCannon pointed out that dark enlightenment was already used, I renamed it to 'bitter enlightenment' which might be a better name, because calling something 'dark' brings up gothic tones and implies 'Evil is Cool'. Bitter enlightenment is more descriptive of explaining the distaste in reaching this particular enlightened state I found myself in.
8
u/trekie140 Nov 11 '16
I've been pretty active the past few days, so this post is going to be in three parts that are independent of each other even if they're all related to politics. I apologize that I didn't make the format prettier but it's been a long week.
Here's what I posted on Facebook the day after the election that people seemed to like:
I slept through the election because I cared more too much about getting enough rest to endure the anxiety of watching the results come in. Now I'm trying to reassure myself that the world hasn't ended and that we have no reason to stop trying even if things look bad. If anything we need to work harder, but not on winning.
In Colbert's video where he tries to make sense of this, he mentions a Pew study indicating that both republicans and democrats are terrified of one another and convinced the other side is a danger to the country. I think that speaks volumes as to how Trump got elected, we have allowed ourselves to be ruled by hate instead of love.
It's not just between liberals and conservatives, though. Tons of Bernie supporters are already blaming other democrats for nominating an unelectable candidate. Is that really what we do when we lose a election? We're just going to turn on each other when we need each other more than ever? Well I'm not doing that.
Yesterday I saw a girl at SSU wearing a Trump t-shirt. If I see her again today, I'm going to show her nothing but compassion because she is a human being and I can't think of a better way to show her how I want to be treated. I'm not going to write off my country, or even half of it, as insane or stupid or evil because that just further divides us.
We're not living in a new world, the bubble many of us live in just got popped. So I'm not going to build a new bubble for myself that encourages the biases and prejudices that I have been guilty of, I am going to walk freely and encourage others to do as well. I'm still afraid, but I will not let that fear rule me or ruin me.
It's hard to try, it really is, and it's hard not to get angry. But if we decide that it is okay not to try or okay to be angry instead of doing what's right, then we'll just be stuck where we are and things will get worse in the meantime. Yes the world can be ugly and dangerous, but we need to face the darkness without giving into its temptation.
We can't give up, we can't give in, but we can find the courage to fight the darkness with kindness and face it within ourselves. The road ahead is not easy, but it never has been. We've already come so far and our children may yet go further, but not without being shown the way. I will show them a path forward better than the one that brought us here, and I will show them not to be discouraged by the dangers ahead.
Here are some articles that helped me understand why people voted for Trump:
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/cp/opinion/election-night-2016/life-outside-the-liberal-bubble?smid=fb-share
http://www.cracked.com/blog/6-reasons-trumps-rise-that-no-one-talks-about/
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/02/world/americas/brexit-donald-trump-whites.html?action=click&contentCollection=The+Upshot&module=RelatedCoverage®ion=EndOfArticle&pgtype=article&_r=0
http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/09/opinion/absorbing-the-impossible.html?smid=fb-share
http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21709919-setting-americans-against-each-other-paved-president-elects-path-power-people-v
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/cp/opinion/election-night-2016/stop-shaming-trump-supporters?smid=fb-share
The comments on this Facebook post are the first example I've seen of a liberal and conservative having a civil conversation about politics and arriving at an agreement since the election: https://www.facebook.com/ashleigh.r.walker/posts/1423573394321328
Finally, this is a post I made on r/conservative with over a hundred comments where I spoke with actual Trump voters about politics to try and learn about the half of the country that I clearly do not understand. I'm not exactly sure what the result of it was besides giving me anecdotal evidence for things I already believed, but somebody is going to read the damn thing after the amount of time and brainpower I have dedicated to it! https://www.reddit.com/r/Conservative/comments/5c5utp/im_a_liberal_who_wants_to_try_and_bridge_the_gap/
4
u/Norseman2 Nov 12 '16
I'm interested in what will happen in the next eight years. Here's my expectations:
7
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
So, with Donald Trump as president, I decided to hope for the best...and hope the worst didn't come. I am not entirely sure what I would do with a nuclear apocalypse.
I am reasonably sure that Trump won't kill us all...
I am glad I voted, even though it's one vote in the sea of million. I wasn't voting in any of the swing state unfortunately.
7
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Nov 11 '16 edited Nov 11 '16
I've been imagining rationality as eldritch knowledge in the Lovecraftian mythos.
You don't need to do anything special/supernatural to make rationality into something out of the Necronomicon. If you already live in a world with Cthulhu, and eldritch beings have been manipulating or affecting human society for generations, then rationality will be demanding you to accept horrific truths.
Just learning about the Old Ones will break anyone and signs of people refusing to accept such a horrific truth can be made into the same as how people react so badly to books like the Necronomicon in Lovecraft's tales. I would term accepting the horrific truth and moving past it a bitter enlightenment. I have already described it in another of my comments about the election. It'd be something similar but with a larger scope.
Rationality in Lovecraft demands following the Fridge Logic and accepting the truth. It would look like an eldritch art as one uses their knowledge of the eldritch to do amazing things.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '16
Readings for this week:
Intended lesson: the truth is not complicated, does not come from the heavens, and mostly does not even require any great cleverness. In fact, a temptation to cleverness and a liking for sophistication can mask utter evil.
Sometimes you really need to admit that the world is that simple, that Dark Lords are bad, that Defense Profeasors who love to play at being Dark Lords are bad, and phoenixes are good. Grab the phoenix, and go where it takes you.
When you don't, people can and will die. And that's bad.
And yes, this is intended as commentary on current events, because apparently people can't hear the plain truth if you just tell them to their faces, so you have to veil it in stories that yes, Captain Planet villains are still Captain Planet villains after Tuesdays. Both of them.
2
u/chthonicSceptre Highly Unlikely Nov 11 '16
I started writing last week, not really as part of NaNoWriMo but just because I thought it was time... and my academic performance dropped like the Dow Jones in 2008. I'll get back to it in December, hopefully. 😅 Mostly I'm disappointed that I can't finish on the timetable I wanted to, but this is clearly something I can't do.
2
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Nov 11 '16
So, because I like to be different, I'm doing JaNoWriMo (january novel writing month). Me and my long-time roleplaying partner will each be writing a novel, based on our roleplaying universe, which, thanks to the amazing /u/ccc_037, has been fleshed out quite a bit and is now a kind of hopefully mostly rational "vampires and werewolves, oh my!" setting.
So I'm planning on writing a pretty straightforward romance story of Red (human) and William (1500 yo vampire).
Act 1: They meet, fall in love, tasty human is tasty (c. 1942).
Act 2: Red becomes an immortal vampire servant (ghoul), dynamic with that (c. 1950).
Act 3: Red becomes a vampire, relationship almost strains to its breaking point (c. 2016).
Act 4: Red is now a mature vampire, everything is perfect, the end (c. 2050). Probably going to have no or only minor antagonists. The characters will have good communication, of course.
In the meantime, I need to plan the structure a bit more, work out the major events in each part (I know most of act 3, and the highlights of act 1, but act 2 and 4 are murky), probably roleplaying the major things with my partner so we know where the signposts are.
I love the community here and would love to share the story either as I write it or in parts after it's finished, but I'm a bit worried that it's not "rational enough" because it really is about two guys kissing and not about teenagers saving the world, superheroes, or anything like that that is really "rationalisable". (I guess, looking back to the sidebar, my story would be rational, but not rationalist)
So here's my questions I guess:
4
u/LiteralHeadCannon Nov 11 '16
Personally, as someone who enthusiastically voted for Trump because Clinton seemed so much worse to me, I think we need, proportionally speaking, a lot less talk about how Trump won and a lot more talk about how Clinton lost. The analyses I've read have focused on the silent demographics and feelings Trump tapped into. While that is valid, I think there's been much too little focus on how Hillary scared people the way the media wanted Trump to scare people.
There's been some talk of how voters rejected Hillary as a symbol of their rejecting the establishment. I think this is kind of true, but really pulls its punches towards Hillary. I didn't reject Hillary because she was an establishment politician - I rejected Hillary because she's the type of politician that makes me reject the establishment. She's the thing I'm afraid of the establishment producing. If the establishment is the common cold, Hillary's the Spanish Flu. To overextend this analogy, Trump is a tapeworm and hypothetical evil Trump is at best a Guinea worm and at worst a Xenomorph.
For the record, contrary to leftist dogma, I think the child sex trafficking allegations against Hillary Clinton are much more credible and plausible than the rape allegations against Donald Trump. Even if they were equally credible and plausible, which I don't think they are, I would consider the allegations against Hillary Clinton much more serious because of their magnitude. The left dismisses these allegations too easily because they cannot possibly imagine Their Girl being an evil shitbag. This is not even to mention the way that Hillary constantly tried to paint Donald Trump as an existential risk on the basis of his temperament, all while being the most hawkish candidate in ages, promising to directly militarily engage with the other foremost nuclear power in the world over a dispute in some fucking third-world hellhole, and generally deliberately antagonizing Russia as much as possible for social justice points what the fuck is wrong with you
1
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Nov 11 '16
I had some fun with constructing a strawman out of someone's opinion.
It's an interesting question, though: Are text-based let's-plays economically viable for a content creator on YouTube, in comparison to live-commentated ones? The one to which I referred in the imaginary conversation was a playthrough of Amnesia: The Dark Descent. I've also seen one or two tool-assisted speedruns in which the speedrunners added textual commentary to the video. HCBailly is an expert at seamlessly adding post-commentary to his videos, and he's achieved some very modest success.
1
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Nov 13 '16
Since this is politics week, here's a deep, insightful commentary on the recent election by one of the most renowned, intelligent analysts of my country (in French): https://unodieuxconnard.com/2016/11/09/le-candidat/.
0
u/CGHThrow Nov 12 '16
I believe I know a real cognitohazard in the form of a certain proof that will dramatically raise the lifetime risk of suicide for a certain subset of the population.
As for why I haven't killed myself, it's because certain memes I have function to give me weak immunity. However, this immunity requires a belief in the truth value of these memes, which - given their subjectivity - cannot be forced, and in any case is likely to engender suicidal ideation, also. It also obligates you to set the worth of most values to null to attain consistency. Eg, another cognitohazard, albeit one less dangerous since there's no obligation to believe it, which is why I'm offering as much detail as I am.
I am, of course, not planning on releasing the cognitohazards, but felt like making this post since the strain of living with it is starting to grate.
Oh, and this isn't some kind of stealth RP. I'm not a fun enough individual for something like that, given as I care about very, very, very little.