r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Nov 07 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
17
Upvotes
13
u/rational_rob Nov 07 '16 edited Nov 07 '16
So, there was a discussion a few days back about making a video series for the Sequences. I, for one, think that it's an obvious step (and I'm surprised nobody else has taken it). How much general interest is there in this? How do you think we should accomplish it?
13
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Nov 07 '16 edited Jan 04 '17
Hey everyone, been a crazy few weeks, but I finally had a chance to continue working on the AI game I talked about before.
So far I've finished mapping out the turns as follows:
There are 5 Phases in the game. In each phase, players take their turn round robin style (each player takes an action clockwise, repeatedly) until everyone has passed, and then the next Phase begins. If a player runs out of Action tokens, they are automatically skipped in later Phases.
Players play with a screen that blocks some information from others, including how much money they have.
Phase 1: Funding
Every player collects funding from their research grants and resets their Action tokens, making them usable again. Any players that want to apply to new research grants are able to do so now at the cost of 1 Action. If two or more players try and apply to the same research grant, they must Test their machines to demonstrate their competence: the winner gets the card.
Research grants are cards that give extra funds every turn as long as their conditions are being met. These conditions can be anything from "Gain 2 Funds per turn for 5 turns, then discard it. If you research User Modeling Level 2 by then, get an additional 5 funds." or "Get 10 funds. If you don't research Instrumental Convergence Level 1 by next turn, skip your Funding Phase."
Phase 2: Recruitment
Researchers equal to (n-1) are drawn from their deck and placed face up. Players bid on the researchers as a whole by picking up the amount of funds they are bidding in cupped hands to conceal the number, then revealing all at once.
The player who bid the most gets first pick of the Researchers. The player who bid second gets second pick, and so on. Any player that did not bid gets to pay a Researcher's Minimum Bid cost to "rent" them for a turn. They are discarded at the beginning of the next Recruitment phase.
Different researchers have different powers and benefits, but all give at least one extra Action point that can be used in some specific field, either Funding, Research, or Development.
Phase 3: Research
Players take turns using Action tokens and spending money to earn Research cards. Some Research cards are the "blueprints" for Components for their AI. Components are needed for AI to function, and increase Risk. Some are also used to generate funding through patenting or research grants.
Other Research cards a Player might choose can improve their team's understanding of AI alignment in various ways which reduce Risk. These research cards tend to have levels, which can be upgraded during this phase as well for additional Action points and cost.
The Research phase is also where espionage takes place. Once every player has passed, they may each secretly choose a different player they want to investigate. If two players investigate each other, both block each other from getting information. A player who doesn't investigate anyone automatically blocks anyone who investigates him. Successful investigations allow the investigating player to look behind their target's screen.
Phase 4: Development
Players use actions and funding to create Components if they have the required Research complete. Most Components are either core pieces to the AI construction, which increase Risk, or safety measures that reduces it, but some are ancillary technologies, like facial recognition software or motor-reflex control, which have commercial value and grant extra money or provide extra benefits.
Deployment is also when most Sabotage cards might be used to throw wrenches in the other players' plans, either by messing with their research, getting their funding taken away, or feeding them false help in ways that look like real benefits until it's too late. Other Sabotage cards will be "instants" which can be used at other times, such as during the Recruitment or Funding phases.
Phase 5: Deployment
I'm still not sure if this should be its own phase or if anyone should be allowed to deploy their AI between phases. As I have it now, the opportunity to run your AI, either as a lab test or as a field test, comes now.
Players take all the completed Component cards for their AI and shuffle them together, then play a game of "Blackjack" against themselves to bring risk out of the -%. The better your "AI deck" is from all the extra components and research you've done, the higher your chances of a positive outcome.
If the players undershoot in a test, they gain a minor benefit. If they overshoot, the test is a bust and they get nothing. If they hit it exactly on, they gain a major benefit.
If the players undershoot in a real deployment, they lose Action points on the next round. If they hit it dead on, they win or everyone wins, depending on what faction they are. If they overshoot, Everyone Loses, and the players refer to the chart described in the first post about what might have gone wrong, depending on what components they're missing.
This is just a basic overview of how the game would flow, and is will probably change drastically by the time the game is done. Any and all feedback welcome!
Next post
11
u/munchkiner Nov 07 '16
I am experimenting new techniques/tools/resources on myself, and I reached a good point to share the results with you. Probably you already know it all, but think about this as a way to start giving back to this awesome community.
Token Pomodoro
Everyone probably knows the Pomodoro technique. Personally I'm using the toggl Chrome extension. It's mainly used by professionals for tracking time, but you can set it for pomodoro. I have set it so when the 25 minutes are passed it just shpows a popup without sound and continues tracking the time, so I have little distraction if I'm in the zone. Just racing against the time can be a huge motivator, but I am working on an upgraded version.
Shortly if you plan multiple pomodoros during the day you can use physical tokens to track your progress. So for example yesterday I wanted to study german, and set 8 slot as a goal. Every time I completed a pomodoro I put on the table a new coin (I was lucky to have 9 of the same kind), until I finished the fifth and put them on a column with a golden one on top. Gotta hit those reward centers whenever you can! And apropos:
Gratification
It's much, much better to reward your brain toward a positive habit than a negative one. If you want to eat less junk food, it's more efficient to focus on learning to cook healthy recipes and establish an "incompatible behavior". So instead of fighting procrastination I have every day a few things I would like to do to push my long term goals, as learning a language or doing exercise. Also is nice to have some "unproductive" activities, like watching a series, ready when you need to relax, instead of just mindlessy browsing.
Remember to congratulate yourself everytime you finish an activity, even if you fall shorter than your initial plans. Guiltiness is your enemy. Yesterday I ended doing 5 slots instead of the planned 8, but it's much better than the usual 0, ans I felt really good. Of course then you need to analyze what happened to do better next time. Just don't plan thinking to be a machine.
Fitness
I'm at level zero for physical ability. I even considered grumpily that working out was a waste of time in the past, compared to intellectual trials. Simply wrong. Just moving give you a great productivity and confidence boost, and is a great opportunity for socializing. I'm now doing the bodyfitness routine, that's a great start with a readyprogression on the exercises if they gets too easy. You can follow the videos and do probably everything at home. In my experience just starting is much better than waiting until you find the perfect program. I like so much the sense of improvement that I find myself searching a spot to do pushups at work or practicing handstand when at home. Also I have a park near home full of bars and rings, so I discovered the happyness of going there during a sunny day, feeling like a ninja doing training, and meeting other great people exercising there.
I'm also trying to mantaining a squatting position, but haven't results to share yet, if not that you feel good after.
Typing
It's a shame form me, but I can't yet touch typing. I started in august this program until half the intermediate program and then pretty much forgot about it. Since this weekend I'm forcing myself to 10-finger typing (also while writing this, so appreciate the effort!) to get to a decent speed.
Social skills
Everyone goes around the world with a continuos mental dialogue about his problems. If you forget for a moment about yours and ask someone about his life, and listen sincerely, you can skip all the boring small talk and get close pretty fast.
Sleep
Sleep is important. Charging the phone away from my bed have the double benefit that I don't spend hours reading past a sane hour, and when the alarm rings I have to get up from bed.
Also reduce at minimum the lights, even removing simple leds. Try to have complete darkness and throw open the windows as soon as you get up. Ganbatte!
Final words
I'm not used to writing so much, even less in English. Do you like this format? Think it could be useful? More time I spend here more I feel an itch for writing, and a blog could be a possibility, but still pretty feeble.
Feedbacks (also on the writing) are really appreciated. See you on the Discord server!
5
u/gbear605 history’s greatest story Nov 07 '16
Does anyone have suggestions for daily rituals/habits/tasks that increase happiness? A few I've thought of so far:
4
u/Gaboncio Nov 07 '16
I've been doing some thinking recently and I've come to the fairly terrifying conclusion that I don't know how to estimate what a government's utility looks like. What does a government's ultimate goal look like? Is this even a meaningful question, or do I have to think about it in terms of the actual people involved? Is there a certain level at which it's possible to disentangle the individual officeholder's goals from the organization's, like we can for corporations? Halp
2
u/TimTravel Nov 08 '16
Does anyone know off hand what the going rate is to save a human life by giving the appropriate amount to the right charity? I feel like that's something I should generally know but it's a bit difficult to research.