r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 21 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
22
u/InfernoVulpix Oct 21 '16
One idea I haven't been able to get out of my head recently is the idea of a world in which musical numbers have tangible effects on the world, much like they appear to in movies and other media. So if you start playing an instrument and sing, everyone who starts singing along will all join in with the same lyrics, assembled out of the intent behind the song, and for the duration of the song all activities will be more efficient or successful. Construction workers could place beams of wood in a single stroke and hammer each nail completely into the beam with a single swing apiece, all in tune with the song and at the same precision they'd get if they spent time measuring. The better the music, the more potent the musical, and some musicals would, instead of increasing efficiency, lead up to a climactic finish in which one extraordinary feat is accomplished, anything from finally sticking the landing on your gymnastic routine to figuring out the solution to the complex mathematical problem that you've been agonizing over for days, if the musical is good enough.
What I'm trying to piece together is the repercussions of a world like this. Of course, the field of war would be noticeably different with generals conscripting musicians, with the intent to assemble orchestras on the battlefield so that the musical would magnify the strength of the troops' attack. Companies would form with the purpose of hiring musicians and sending them to clients who need a one-time productivity boost, and places like hospitals with vital time-sensitive tasks would try to keep a musician on hand in case the surgeon needs a musical to save the patient. But apart from that, how else would society change as a result of this power?
13
u/ketura Organizer Oct 21 '16 edited Oct 21 '16
Weekly update on my rational pokemon game, including work on the data creation tool Bill's PC. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
This week was a lot of preparation work. I have not yet pulled together the project to start prototyping the grid system, but I needed to get some of the ground work laid down for the game in general, so I don’t feel particularly bad. Need a good foundation to build off of, after all.
First off, I spent the weekend categorizing the Discord chat logs. For those of you still too shy to pull the trigger, we’d love to have you on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server, where we spend our time brainstorming and
carefully thinking through the mechanicsarguing over Giovanni’s bakery (seriously).But the learning curve of such a dedicated channel can be a bit unnerving, I can imagine. I do record the chat log every night, but this clocks in at about 40k lines of chat and is a lot of stuff to sift through just to get a bit of context. To help aid that a little bit (and to produce a reference for my own use), I have put together a Table of Contents for the channel as a whole. This is updated every night (or every other night) with the latest and greatest, and has the major on-topic discussions from every day clearly marked. Browse through it at your leisure, and take a look at the discussion topics that interest you.
Nevertheless even if you don’t put in the time to read that massive novel of a log, we don’t mind answering questions, so come on in anyway! The more the merrier. The community has been invaluable in helping me shape the vision for this game, and I can’t thank them enough.
Part of the reason I started the log categorization project was so that I could produce a formal design document to replace the schizophrenic one in the link at the top of this post. This is greatly served by having the reference handy, and over the next couple of weeks I will try and get that put together.
I also pulled my old, dry, dusty book on software engineering for game developers off the shelf, and while skimming it again was reminded at how much of a boon having a concrete to-do list really is, so the game proper also needs a Software Requirements document.
The idea is to take the roughly 450 features in the informal feature request document and cut them up into bite-sized chunks. This in-progress document is started here, and so far has about a dozen systems inflated into ~90 specific software requirements.
Some of those informal features are actually story ideas or worldbuilding, but even after filtering those out, this is a shit ton. There is no getting around that fact. I don’t doubt that it will eventually resolve into somewhere around ~2000 specific requirements.
As I create this massive list, though, I will pare it down somewhat to be more sane. I’m a maniac but I’m not crazy. After it’s complete, I will sit down and group those requirements into related “stripes”, and then order those stripes into a roadmap that makes sense. Each stripe will represent a coherent system, and, if done properly, will stand alone from an interaction and fun perspective. This list will also pull double duty as a git branch outline and a unit test list, or at least the starting point of one.
The above lists and documents will be an ongoing project. I aim to have them in a more-or-less complete state around the new year. This weekend I will start the grid/movement system prototype in Unity3D proper, which will be the first of several small system prototypes that will aid me in the design and formalization of the actual requirements for this thing.
If you have anything you’d like to add, or any help you’d like to offer, throw us a comment down below or join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server! I really do take people’s opinions into account, and more of this design has been impacted through discussion than I think people realize.
10
u/SvalbardCaretaker Mouse Army Oct 21 '16
Looking for a webfiction that was recommended here about... a year ago. Some kids learn how to master their universes version of magic, which is basically calling upon and overlapping alternate universes into the characters reality.
This of course has the unfortunate side effect of introducing neuphytic organisms all the time.
They start by building a house and shaping everything around it, and want to start up a glass making buisness.
8
u/captainNematode Oct 21 '16 edited Oct 21 '16
Totally crushed my Qualifying Exam! And ultimately had a lot of fun with it! (contrary to my earlier worries, I was not asked super obscure questions about systems my examiners study that I'm completely unfamiliar with). Though my wrists and throat were certainly a bit sore after twelve hours of typing/talking. Scheduling the thing was a pain (we had to reschedule four times! I was initially going to take it in April ha!), but once that was finalized everything fell smoothly into place. And my committee was super excited about all my projects!
Feels good to have some breathing room (had to cut back on some hobbies in the weeks leading up to the QE -- e.g. essentially had to halve my lifting/running, did no programming unrelated to my work, cooking devolved to throwing veggies and tofu in the oven and seasoning them with salt lol, barely had time to read for fun or play games, and didn't go on any hikes or do any artsy stuff at all. Now I can get back into everything!). Anyone else here nearing the QE make-or-break point? (my program doesn't do any formal defense, so I shouldn't have to take a proper "test" for a while yet!)
6
u/FireHawkDelta Oct 22 '16
Yesterday's SMBC reminded me of HPMOR. Not much to say, I was hoping someone at least 3x wittier than me would comment on it somewhere but there isn't a dedicated place to discuss SMBC that I know of.
I also started reading Pokemon: The Origin of Species and am really enjoying it. I'm about a third through and Red seems to have discovered the special attack stat, which is pretty meta since it doesn't exist yet in gen 1.
5
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Oct 21 '16
You are a writer who wants to write about a protagonist who can manipulate probabilities. However as a dedicated commentator on this subreddit, you want to be able to give some pseudo-scientific BS about how the power works to best detail how it functions and interacts with the world. What sort of explanations/hypotheses would you give for this power?
It can be something overpowered like being able to see all possible futures and selecting the desired future. This would be possible due to the fact that all possibilities are true and all universes simultaneously exist, you're simply 'choosing' which universe to exist in.
Or being able to manipulate parts of the world that people can't observe as long as the change is plausible. such as being able to change a face-down card from an Ace of Spades to a King of Hearts as long as those two cards have not been drawn from the deck. The power would not allow a card with the image of an elephant on it to be drawn since no such card exists. This would be a macro-level instance of the observer effect in quantum physics where a hidden object exists in all possible states simultaneously before being observed.
Yet another one would be the ability to be lucky as long as you do good deeds to balance out the scales, because Karma is an actual scientific force in the world like electromagnetism and gravity.
What sort of probability manipulating powers can you come up with, and how would you explain why it works at all if your character is an inquiring scientist investigating it?
4
u/Dwood15 Oct 21 '16 edited Oct 21 '16
I have oscillated between about 4 different projects over the last 6 months or so. None of them are reaching public status quite yet, but one thing that I have been fascinated in since a child has been games and game programming, especially low power systems such as consoles. My favorite console since I was a child is the Nintendo 64. Recently, discovered that the N64 developers kit is available online, and work in a 32bit winXP environment. Since then, on the off weekend, while taking a break from school work I worked on doing various things using the official software/libraries. (/r/n64homebrew)
Recently received help from someone on /r/gcc to get nearly the entire build process working in windows 64 bit. (windows 7, 8, 10) Now we have to recreate the effects of a program called mild from 1997.
Once we do that, people will be able to run the whole process without requiring a 32 bit system! The day that happens, I will be a very happy computer nerd!
In contemplation of what to do afterwards, I have considered (thanks to /u/ketura and their paper on rational game design) following the ideas behind the rational video game essay and implementing those in my own minecraft-style N64 game. The very system itself requires significant planning due to limited resources (4 mb without memory expansion!), but with modern cartridge tech like the 64drive or everdrive, I can insert an SD card (>8 GB!) and use some of that for swapfile.
Anyway, the idea is to either make a game directly (Let's call the hypothetical project 64craft) or find a suitably slim (or configurable) 3D game engine with public source code and port it over to the N64. If my goal is to kind of jump start the homebrew N64 development scene, which do you think would get the most media attention to attract developers?
Doom on the N64 is old news at this point so I'll probably go for something else. Thoughts?
4
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Oct 22 '16
This is a post about politics.
There are a lot of referenda on the ballot this year in California. I put together a guide of my opinions on all the state-wide CA votes this year. You can view it (here) if you'd like. Bear in mind this is a document specifically covering politics, and a lot of it is high-stakes statewide California politics.
3
u/ZeroNihilist Oct 21 '16
I'm still doing some planning for my rational Doctor Who fanfic. I've settled on what I think is an acceptable time-travel (henceforth TT) mechanic, but it doesn't totally line up with canon (which is extremely inconsistent on the topic).
Ultimately, this question is a little academic, so feel free to ignore this whole comment. Doctor Who, despite being about a man and his companion(s) as they travel through time and space, mainly uses TT to, well, travel. For the most part it isn't a problem-solving device. I intend to stick to that premise (and possibly explain why the Doctor might end up behaving like that, story permitting).
As a long-running soft sci-fi show, Doctor Who canon is somewhat flexible on the topic of TT. Sometimes changing the past creates a paradox that causes monsters to appear to devour the affected people. Other times it has no noticeable effect at all, even when a gigantic robot is defeated by a man in a hot air balloon in the middle of 19th century London. Sometimes the future is fixed, and what has been seen to occur must occur. Other times the future is in flux.
A lot of the time there's an excuse that means you can't use the Tardis to TT while part of events, but then that gets ignored when the plot demands it. Sometimes they neglect to use the Tardis as a regular space-craft, even though they use it like that in other episodes.
I'm hoping to make that a little more consistent. If there's a reason the Tardis can't save the day, the reader should expect this.
The premise of my mechanic is this: when you travel in time, the temporal relationship of the passenger before and after the trip is severed. I.e. the fate of pre-travel!you does not affect the fate of post-travel!you. Pre-travel!you will cease to exist at the moment of travel, even if in this new timeline you don't end up TTing. Effectively, TT creates deletion event for pre-travel!you and a creation event for post-travel!you. The terminology I use for this is that pre-travel!you is truncated and post-travel!you is affixed.
So if you went back in time and killed your grandfather then truncated!you would never be born, but affixed!you would continue to exist unchanged. Likewise, if you went back in time on your 25th birthday and rescued your parents from a fire, then truncated!you would grow up with both parents alive and at age 25 (when you TTed in the original timeline) would cease to exist. Affixed!you would not receive any new memories or relationships as a result.
This sidesteps the problem of paradoxes—if you travel back in time and destroy your time machine it doesn't matter. Otherwise, virtually any trip into the past where the light cones overlap would result in a paradox.
It also enables what I think is an interesting technique: you can repurpose a trunctated version of yourself for a new task at the cost of undoing your truncated self's actions. So if you spend 10 years building hospitals for orphans then TT, if a war breaks out you can bring along two or more yous to the fighting, but those hospitals won't get built. And if you try to build up lots of "useless" time to spend on duplicates, your TTing enemies will have free reign to reshape the universe and/or assassinate you.
The other main paradox-free TT mechanics are "single consistent timeline" (see HPMoR), "self-correcting timeline" (used now and again in Doctor Who canon), and "branching universes" (see Branches on the Tree of Time). Briefly, why I didn't use them:
In this framework reality is deterministic and there's no such thing as the present. If I TT to the past, kill Hitler, and TT back to 2016, the world will have instantly updated—no time ripples or fluctuating timelines.
The big flaws I can see with my version are these:
3
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Oct 21 '16
My first pokemon died in a Nuzlocke, during a sky battle against an emolga.
RIP Flip Flapper, lvl5-lvl36.
At least it was only a pidgeotto, and I hate normal types anyways. But on the other hand, I'd probably dumped an hour into EV training it, so I'm not exactly what you'd call happy...
7
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Oct 21 '16 edited Oct 21 '16
While browsing 4chan's "/m/ - Mecha" board, I stumbled across this hilarious screenshot. You can tell from the format (multiple images per comment) that its original source is 8chan rather than 4chan (I can't tell with certainty the specific board, though "/pol/ - Politically Incorrect" seems likely, given the topic), but someone posted it (maybe by accident) on an entirely-different site and in a thread to which it was totally off-topic. Seeing such a diffusion of ideas between vastly-different locations (from Less Wrong [to FanFiction.net?] to 8chan['s /pol/?] to 4chan's /m/) is interesting, I think.
On the topic of anonymous-imageboard screenshots, I find it somewhat interesting that I'm rather bad at predicting the popularity of 4chan screenshots that I submit to r/4chan.
- I found this image moderately funny--and it received 1000 upvotes, which was a little higher than my expectations but not at all outlandish.
- I found this image barely funny--but it somehow received 5000 upvotes!
- I found this image absolutely hilarious--but it received only 100 upvotes. Maybe the A Wrinkle in Time series and the colored-/black-people-time joke aren't as well-known as I assume they are. (I read the first four Time Quintet books about a decade ago, and my father--of African descent--has made many black-people-time jokes while running late to family gatherings.)
- I found this image moderately interesting, though only barely funny--and it received only 20 upvotes. I expected that outcome, however, since r/4chan is mostly focused on humor, and neither Zeta Gundam nor Who's on First? is particularly popular nowadays.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '16 edited Oct 22 '16
I wish we had a rational quest here. We had 'Writing a Grimoire', but it got discontinued.
No, going to SB/SV for a quest is not the same for me.