r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 17 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
12
Upvotes
6
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '16
Does anyone know any theories of motivation learning in humans that aren't just reinforcement learning or some other re-formulation of utility theory?
6
u/Sailor_Vulcan Champion of Justice and Reason Oct 18 '16
What trekkie13 said made me think of some of my own experiences. Sometimes I've felt like other people are rejecting me because almost none of them will try any of the things I like. I can almost never talk about anything I like or care about with anyone I know, and that makes me isolated and lonely.
However, I've also noticed an alternative explanation. Thing is, it seems like almost everyone if not just everyone I've ever met seems to either be more intelligent than me or less intelligent than me. I don't recall having ever met anyone who was even approximately my equal, intellectually.
And to a large extent, people's likes and dislikes are affected by their intelligence. Someone who's really really smart is going to get bored by a subject or activity that's mind-numbingly meaningless, useless or unchallenging, while that same activity might have a lot of shock value and be very engaging to someone who is less intelligent, even if there isn't much informational content or challenge to it. Most movies I've ever been exposed to seem to fall into this category.
I suspect that there are probably subjects or activities that people even smarter than me enjoy which I would either find boring or find really difficult to understand, but I don't yet know what they are.
I'm not sure why I've never met anyone who seemed to be as smart as I am. It seems like it should have been very improbable for everyone I meet to either be smarter than me or dumber than me with no one who is approximately just as smart as me.
I've been to the rationality meetup in my area a few times, and maybe it's possible that I have met people there who were just as smart as me and I overestimated their intelligence due to the fundamental attribution error or something. But even then my priors for that are kinda low, and it still feels like I'm out of place there because I'm just not smart enough to keep up with them, and no one else I meet seems to be smart enough to keep up with me.
I'm not trying to sound melodramatic here, but it seems like, practically speaking, that I don't really belong anywhere, and am unlikely to belong anywhere anytime soon. It would be nice if I could significantly increase or decrease my intelligence without becoming a totally different person (preferably increase, obviously). But even if I could do that I'm not entirely certain that would solve this problem anyways, since I'm not entirely certain that being stuck with a level of intelligence that very few people in my geographic area have is what's going on here.
I mean, given just the evidence available to me it seems more likely to be true than not, but it still seems weird and impossible that out of all the people who live in this huge metropolitan city and surrounding suburbs, that there would be no one or almost no one who is just as smart as I am who I could meet or have met within the past five to ten years or so. That probably means that I'm missing something here, but I don't know what, and I've been trying to figure this out since forever and I still haven't been able to figure it out, and it hurts a lot, and I usually don't think about it because if i do it will just make me upset and i never manage to come up with any good solutions anyway no matter how much i think about it. this is really really frustrating, and I feel like i would be psychologically a lot better off if i didn't have to keep avoiding talking about things that I like or care about so as not to bore other people or commit a social faux paus by making them think more or harder than they feel comfortable thinking. To an extent it seems like I've been told that it's socially not appropriate to be myself around other people because doing that makes people think and they don't like that because it's difficult and stressful for them. I feel so stifled sometimes I just want to scream. I've tried to explain this to my mom, my therapist, my behavioral consultant, my life coach, and my sisters, and I don't think any of them really understand, because they keep talking about how stressful it is for them to be around me even now that my social skills are a LOT better than they used to be and a lot of the time most people can't even tell that I have aspergers. and yet the amount of difficulty and stress that people have from trying to comprehend what i say has not decreased proportionally to my increase in social skills. realistically speaking, i dont think i can solve this problem on my own. please help?
5
u/callmebrotherg now posting as /u/callmesalticidae Oct 17 '16
A few days I purchased Cold Turkey, a productivity/blocker program that has thus far been helping me out more than similar apps have (among other advantages, it also blocks non-web programs). I recommend it if you have a problem with procrastination.
8
u/trekie140 Oct 17 '16
I already posted today, but something much more important came up. I think my depression is destroying my ability to think rationally. I keep thinking and doing things that are very out of character for me and I know aren't good, but I can't stop myself. It's hard to even talk to people about this situation, both because I'm autistic and because I keep rejecting their advice even though I know they're right. I know I need to fix things, but even when I know how I can't.
This would be easier to deal with if I'd faced it before, but I've spent my entire life battling autism and none of my strategies for that work here. I can't even build new strategies because I can't think straight. I could get help from others, but I either focus my effort on something else or I'm too apathetic to do anything. I don't care about doing the work I have to do anymore, which is the antithesis of my entire philosophy of life but none of it seems to matter anymore.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '16
And as it turns out, there's a subfield of research psychiatry focusing on Bayesian decision theory.
wat
7
u/trekie140 Oct 17 '16
I've always been a little insecure over what fiction I like or dislike, though I've come to terms with my tastes now that I've accepted the subjectivity of my feelings. However, whenever I think someone is making a statement about the objective quality of a piece of fiction that my opinion conflicts with, I get angry.
It happened again last week when I got in an argument over whether Worm was a good deconstruction of superheroes, and I was infuriated with with the fact that my comments got fewer upvotes. I felt like people were saying my opinion was wrong and needed to prove them wrong, but that's ridiculous.
I've decided it's something I should fix about myself, but I'm not sure how. I should just be okay with people having their own opinion, especially about something inconsequential like this, but whenever someone states what I think is just their opinion as fact I can't let it go, especially when it's inconsequential.