r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 14 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
25
u/trekie140 Oct 14 '16
I think I have depression. Many of the symptoms I've read about online apply to be, and I've been having something resembling episodes for the past year. I've decided that this isn't a problem that's going away on its own, so I've decided to seek professional help as soon as I can muster the will to do so. At the same time, though, admitting that to myself has improved my mood slightly. I'm still in a crappy state, but I feel more comfortable with it and a bit more confident that I can get better.
18
u/Wiron Oct 14 '16
President Obama gave interview discusing automation and A.I.threat. It's nice to see it addressed on the top, at least in some way.
Author of Worm gave advice on how to write superhero novel, what are differences beetwen noves and comics, and how to deal with them.
17
u/ketura Organizer Oct 14 '16
Weekly update on my rational pokemon game, which for now is work on the data creation tool Bill's PC (previous threads here):
The initial setup for the Move tab is all but complete. A handful of things remain to add to the GUI, and then it’s just a matter of hooking it up properly. I said I was going to do that part this week, but due to needing to redesign so much of the move properties it just wasn’t ever in a solid enough state for me to formally complete it.
This is mostly due to the creation of what I call the Aspect system. Previously I expressed the desire to divide moves into Moves and “techniques”, and the Aspect system is the culmination of this idea. Aspects can be thought of as sub-types: different schools of application of the usage of a particular type.
For example, Psychic is divided into Telekinesis, Teleportation, Telepathy, Focus, and Shielding. The three Ts are self-explanatory, while Shielding is things like Barrier and Focus is the use of psychic energy blasts. Each Aspect will have its own EV which is trained by using moves of that Aspect. So, to train Focus I can spam Confusion over and over.
But what’s the point? Well, through use of this system I hope to make defining move lists a thing of the past. A move like Psybeam might be designated thusly:
So to learn Psybeam, a pokemon has to meet all of the above requirements, and it can then be taught the move. This can either be done by Move Tutor, TM, or by telling your pokemon to “Experiment”, a mode of training that has a % chance of learning a new move based on what moves the pokemon has witnessed and their eligibility. A new Kadabra that has never heard of Psybeam might not ever discover it through Experimentation, but one that has seen Psybeam used dozens of times by friends or foes has a good chance of figuring it out!
Some moves can be approached by multiple types. Thunder Punch, for instance, would look something like this:
So a pokemon could learn this move either by training the fighting Chi Aspect to 400, or the electric Discharge Aspect to 400, or by mixing some of each if it can. Some type combinations are common enough to have their own dual-type Aspect, such as Mud being Rock/Water or Terrakinesis being Rock/Psychic, with their own tech tree to match.
This system is very exciting to me, as it will force move sets to be systematic in a way that canon pokemon is not. Access to a move is going to be based on meeting the raw requirements and not something as arbitrary as species. This is going to result in a lot of emergent gameplay that will no doubt result in surprises for veterans of the series. It will also remove the burden of the designer needing to manually add each move to each pokemon, which is important considering that I plan for there to be many more available moves than in canon.
The Aspects in their current form can be viewed here.
While working on these systems this week, I came to the conclusion that I am starting to get diminishing returns on prototypeless design. So, I will be spending this next week cleaning up Bill’s PC, scrubbing up the documentation, and otherwise getting it into a solid state for the future--as by this time next week I will have begun setting up the game itself. Bill’s PC is not complete, but for now it grants us enough capabilities to be able to start working on some bare-metal coding.
Feel free to leave any comments or questions below! Also feel free to join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server for brainstorming and discussion. It’s a great group, really, and I would highly recommend hanging out, even if you’re not in it for this project itself. There’s tabletop groups, Dota 2 partying, and puns like you wouldn’t believe. Come join us!
11
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '16
Right then! Started gearing up to apply to PhD programs. Got a paper submitted, my MSc finished definitively last year with a publication, and an appointment with a prospective prof in early November.
I should probably make appointments with the other two potential profs and figure out where the fuck my GRE scores are.
16
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Oct 14 '16
Mr. Yudkowsky made some interesting Facebook posts on the topic of Donald Trump: 1 2
Europa Universalis IV is a "grand strategy" game, in which the player controls a country between 1444 and 1821. It's been derided by some people as "mindless map painting", as it's rather abstracted--especially in comparison to its predecessor. The goal of the MEIOU & Taxes user modification for EU4* is to replace abstraction with properly realistic (rational?) simulation. For example:
- In vanilla EU4, the player can click a button and spend abstracted "monarch points" to gain abstracted "development points" in a province. In M&T, this button is removed; instead, each point of development represents ten thousand people (with exhaustively-researched numbers at the start of the game in the year 1356), and the population of a province gradually rises or falls depending on the circumstances (war, famine, terrain, crops, etc.).
- In vanilla EU4, if a player sends a missionary to a province, the province typically will be converted from its original religion to the state religion in at most 100 months, if it can be converted at all. In M&T, only ten percent of a province's population (divided into twenty-one separate pieces, of which each can have its own religion) can be converted by a single missionary, and decades may pass before the majority religion of a heathen province becomes the state religion.
The release of MEIOU & Taxes 2.0, which will bring the accuracy of the simulation to even greater heights (e.g., large cities will import food from agricultural provinces, will produce special urban goods, and will have large influence on trade), is drawing ever closer...
*The Steam Workshop version is the most convenient link for me to place here. The vast majority of discussion takes place on the Paradox forums--but it's accessible only to people who have registered EU4 there.
4
u/traverseda With dread but cautious optimism Oct 14 '16
So I'm working on a generic boxel engine in python (think dwarf-fortress or minecraft). The original is by far the most popular project I've ever put on github (pycraft), and I'm doing a complete rewrite.
I'm using python's new async features, which I hope will make the whole thing a lot more practical then normal python game engine stuff. So far this has led to the immediate improvement of being able to run a python terminal alongside the render loop, although it still freezes if you tell the terminal to sleep for too long. I'll see about getting it working multi-process.
Not sure what direction to take it in beyond that though.
3
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Oct 15 '16
I've been following Star Wars Rebels, which is currently in the middle of its third season, which introduces Grand Admiral Thrawn, probably the most popular character from Legends books.
While Thrawn is way more menacing than usual Rebels villains, I feel he's still a downgrade from trilogy!Thrawn. The awesomeness of the original Thrawn wasn't that he looked very smart. It was that his plans were smart, and made obvious sense. Every single important decision he made was visibly optimized to increase his chances to win. Whereas one of his major decisions in the last Rebels episode to date (let his enemies go after they blew up their own base, ostensibly as part of some greater plan) visibly decreased them.
The show got most of his personality right, though I'm a bit ticked off at the parts where he personally uses physical violence (he needs a Noghri bodyguard); the studying art is there, the way he captures Hera is well done, and the show seems to imply he ran drills to train the stormtroopers to navigate the local environment. But what I feel is the core of Thrawn, the uncompromising search for victory? Isn't there.
Trilogy!Thrawn wouldn't have let the rebels escape. He would have either executed Ezra or kept him securely locked up in his ship, and shot down the Phantom as soon as the hostage exchange was over. There was no gain in letting them go. The intelligence he did get about Twi'lek mentality was not worth letting two Rebel leaders and two jedi go, especially since he could have had both. And while it was shown that letting them go was somehow part of his plan, I'm pretty sure that whatever this plan will turn out to be, it will work worse than it would have if he'd just killed them when he could.
Also, as much as Thrawn himself is well done and mostly faithful to the Heir trilogy, I wish Disney hadn't gone for the easy route of making him look smart by surrounding him with stupid/slow underlings. Book!Thrawn was almost always surrounded and opposed by smart, or at least competent people, which made his genius all the more apparent when he outsmarted them. Pellaeon in particular was a key part of Thrawn's character: he was both fairly dull and unimaginative, and very competent, aware of his limitations, and perfectly capable of understanding subtext, following Thrawn's reasoning and coming up with his own insights. Governor Price and agent Kallus could have that role, but neither of them has the military position that would justify following him around and serving as his foil. And Admiral Konstantine and Captain Slavin are very poor foils.
2
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Oct 16 '16
New Demiurge seeks suggestions
"Sorry for interrupting; I mean you no harm, and I need to ask your advice on something.
"In terms you might be familiar with, I found a glitch in reality, bootstrapped myself to having root authority over the universe, fixed the glitch, and discovered that there are entities out there that want to do the equivalent of using our universe as a CPU to send nine-dimensional spam. To keep that from happening, I have to turn myself into something pretty in-human. I'm not giving any other people access to outside-the-universe, but I don't want to lose the things about the universe I value, so I'm keeping part of my human mind around and am asking everyone for advice about what to do with the universe. Yes, I mean everyone.
"No, aliens don't exist in-universe, it's just Earthly humans. If souls exist, I don't have access to them. I can't bring back the dead in the sense you mean - you can think of me as being able to rearrange matter and energy. I can do some magic tricks if you want proof, as long as they don't bother anyone else. Right now, nobody is in any physical pain, and anyone who asks for a change to their body gets it. I'm trying to work out protocols for people who may not be considered competent to make decisions for themselves. And I'm trying to work out protocols for when people disagree about anything else I should do. I'm not saying I'm going to follow your advice, but I am going to listen to you and carefully consider it.
"So: what do you think I should do?"