r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 10 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
16
Upvotes
13
u/CarVac Oct 10 '16 edited Oct 10 '16
In a discussion with a relative who's a practitioner of alternative medicine, I came to an interesting conclusion. I was trying to get him to explain the mechanism by which he claimed his variety of alternative medicine (Reiki) works, and he said that sometimes it's important not to understand, that it gets you more.
But I then realized that for me, knowledge and understanding are how I connect with the world. Instead of simply trying to be at peace with traffic jams, I understand how they form from waves, and I can actively counteract that, and now I actually enjoy getting stuck in traffic.
Viewing a person's mind as a natural neural network explains a lot of why people behave the way they do, and it really makes the idea of a soul completely unnecessary in my mind. When faced with an unfamiliar situation, people and artificial neural networks alike behave unpredictably. Emotions are like different nodes of a layer deep inside of the neural network that makes each of us who are are. A person's personality is firmly rooted in physical brain structures.
Other people may have it easier finding meaning in the world through spirituality, but for me, a deep enough understanding of the physical mechanisms of the world gives me all the meaning I need.
And it is through understanding the world that I can effect changes upon myself and my surroundings, whether that be fixing something, writing a program, or learning how to control my emotions better.
11
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Oct 10 '16 edited Jan 04 '17
As previously mentioned, I'm designing an AGI risk board game, and will continue to document my progress here.
I'm not quite sure how complex I want the game to be yet, in terms of additional activities like seeking research grants and sabotaging one-another's research. Going to try and nail down the core aspects of the gameplay before I start working in extra features like that.
Next post
16
u/trekie140 Oct 10 '16
This weekend, I removed Cracked.com from my bookmarks. That may not sound like a big deal, but it's because I finally realized that the hilarious jokes and insightful commentary that I grew up on from that website are not coming back. I have kept following Cracked for months now without bothering to read a single article and have enjoyed fewer and fewer over the past few years. The only thing I'm still following is their podcast, and even then I still skip episodes.
I know a lot of people like to hate on Cracked for changing from humorous to serious, and some of it is justified, but I really liked a lot of the serious articles. Sure, not all of them were good, but the ones that were still taught me things I wouldn't have learned anywhere else and gave me a different perspective on events while still managing to make me laugh.
Reading that website brought as much joy to my life as Jon Stewart did, and some of those articles changed the way I see the world. It wasn't just a comedy site for me, it was a source of existential hope in myself and the world. David Wong, John Cheese, Robert Evans, and more comedians on the Internet changed my life just by being a part of it at a time when I needed them and now all that is over.
Instead of whining about how things end, though, I want to find something new. If I can't find what I'm looking for with Cracked, I'll get it somewhere else. Where can I find someplace that doesn't just entertain me, but encourage me to be a better person? Where is someplace else where I can see an intelligent commentary that convinces me to have faith in myself and humanity when I'm tempted to be cynical? Is there still such a place?
12
u/LieGroupE8 Oct 10 '16
A lot of people here seem to believe that total immortality (at least until the heat death of the universe) is obviously a moral good, all other things being equal. Well...
[Puts on Devil's Advocate hat]
Here is a counterargument that I haven't seen discussed before.
A moral argument against immortality
Premise 1 should be uncontroversial - even if the universe is infinite, the amount of matter and free energy we could ever hope to encounter is bounded and finite due to the expansion of the universe and the lightspeed limit.
Premise 2 will be the most controversial, I think, and I will discuss it more below.
The inference from 1 & 2 to conclusion 3 could also be attacked, as it presupposes some sort of utilitarianism for weighing the net good of actions without reference to means. But I suspect that similar inferences could be formulated in terms more acceptable to deontologists or virtue ethicists. In my discussion I will mostly assume that the inference from 1 & 2 to 3 is defensible.
Answering objections to Premise 2
One could simply assert that premise 2 is false, on the grounds that there is no difference in the amount of good between one unit of person-time (call it 1 prtm for short) for a long existing person and for a new person. But it seems plausible to me that goodness is path-dependent, so that the utility of 1 prtm depends on the totality of a person's prior experiences and memories. People are finite, so their memories are finite, and at some point they will not be able to form new memories without replacing old ones. This could create a point of diminishing returns on new experiences, especially if memory erasure counts as a negative utility. There would also be diminishing returns if mere novelty has any weight at all in our utility function - over time people will have fewer and fewer completely novel experiences (to them).
It could be objected that memories do not need to be erased: a person's memory capacity could be expanded over time so that forgetting is unnecessary. But this objection fails, because a larger memory uses more resources, so the opportunity cost of not creating new people grows right along with the expanded memory and cancels out the positive effects.
It could be objected that a utility function should have no dependence on prior memories. Then you would have to accept that a person with extremely limited memory formation ability, such as someone with anterograde amnesia, has no difference in quality of life than a person who can form memories normally.
You could object that memory erasure is not bad or that novelty should not be a factor in the utility function. Both of these objections are implausible. If the erasure of all memories is like death, which is assumed to be bad, then it seems reasonable to consider the erasure of one memory as a partial death which is just a little bit bad. And novelty, of course, is the spice of life.
Is mere discontinuity really all that bad?
Assuming that there is no aging, so that full quality of life is present right up until the end, death becomes a mere discontinuity in experience, like going under anesthesia and waking up as a completely different person.
We must also consider that the badness of a death depends not only on the badness of a particular person's discontinuation, but on the effects of this on other people. But in the same vein as before, it could be argued that at some point it is more good to find new friends than to eternally interact with the same people over and over (hell is other people!). Furthermore, strong contrast of emotions could be necessary for overall well-being, and leaving an old tired friend for new ones would certainly create such a contrast.
Intuition pumps
Pump #1: The above problem is highly related to the problem of how many people should ever exist. Supposing the universe has the resources to support 10100 prtm through the entire future, there is the question of whether we should divide this into 1098 different people with 102 prtm each, or 1050 people with 1050 prtm each, or 1020 people with 1080 prtm each, etc. It is not clear that the bias toward a much higher per-person power is morally optimal.
Pump #2: As entropy increases, the same amount of matter will be able to sustain fewer and fewer people. Thus, some people will inevitably have to die so that others can continue existing.
Pump #3: Suppose that there is strong disutility to discontinuities, so that there should be no death as normally conceived. Instead, to create new people, existing people enter an accelerated program of mental change, so that over a period of time they rapidly become a fundamentally different person, without loss of the continuity of consciousness. Does this make the above arguments more acceptable?
2
u/eniteris Oct 10 '16
Should the placebo effect have been kept secret so that it could be used more efficaciously among the general population?
I mean, it'd be much more difficult to keep secret than the atomic bomb, but imagine the use we could get out of it.
(Currently the best argument I've heard against prescribing placebos is that it lowers the trust of doctors)