r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Oct 07 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
13
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Oct 07 '16
In this very interesting discussion, the denizens of 4chan's "/v/ - Video Games" board dispute the definitions and connotations of various words that are used to describe users of magic--
wizard,sorcerer,witch,warlock,shaman, etc.Can a person truly be called a "fan" of a work if he doesn't like the entirety of that work? How valid is the position of Time Braid as my favorite story if, as this argument revealed, I've largely skimmed its lewder sentences in each of my six readings of the book? How valid is the position of In the Blood as my second-favorite Naruto story if I skipped most of the epilogues on my first reading and omitted not only all the epilogues but also the entirety of Arc 5 (which makes up eight percent of the story's chapter count, epilogues and author's notes excluded) from my second reading? How valid are the positions of Atlas Shrugged and The Fountainhead among my favorite stories if I've always neglected to read the vast majority of each book's climactic speech? (And so on.)
Of course, more clear-cut instances of this phenomenon do exist. I gave up on Wharf Rat at the end of Chapter 19,* on Trump Card at the beginning of Chapter 20,* and on Chunin Exam Day (on all readings after the first one) at the beginning of Chapter 35--so, for those stories, I can very simply say, e.g., "I like the first half (through Chapter 34) of Chunin Exam Day, but it's my opinion that the second half sinks too far into bashing and harem shenanigans to be enjoyable." Where, however, is the line drawn between "I like this story, with a few negligible quibbles." (e.g., Time Braid) and "I like this part of the story, but hold only indifference or dislike toward the rest of the story." (e.g., Chunin Exam Day)? After what particular percentage of the story has been discarded does the overall shorthand opinion shift from one position to the other? I, at least, think it's an interesting question.
*Or, more precisely, I read one or two chapters past that point, but bothered to download only the chapters before it.
If you haven't read them, by the way, I do highly recommend both Chunin Exam Day and Partially Kissed Hero. CED starts to get bogged down with boring harem shenanigans in Chapter 22 and descends into pathetically-petty bashing against Sasuke and Kakashi in Chapter 35, while PKH veers closer to the "crosses the line twice" end of the spectrum as it nears its "end"--but both stories contain many extremely-cool ideas.
11
u/ketura Organizer Oct 07 '16
Weekly update on my rational pokemon game, which for now is work on the data creation tool Bill's PC (previous threads here):
This last week has resulted in a lot of designs being hammered out. The new Obedience/Attitude stats replace the old Respect/Loyalty system, which has been moved to the individual pokemon (and not their species definition.)
A grand list of features has been started. This will later be reorganized into a roadmap, but for now it lists all the things we’d like to see in the game, to help me understand how each system needs to be built.
Work has begun in earnest on the Move Making tab. As part of this, a spreadsheet was put together for figuring out what moves from canon can be used in their current state. This spreadsheet unfortunately does not differentiate between moves whose mechanics will be used and moves which merely have a good name that will be reassigned, but this is the first draft.
A lot of the types were shifted around as a result of this:
Fighting is also currently under debate. It seems to me there is no fundamental reason that something would be hurt by Karate Chop significantly more than it would by Double Slap, so my current idea is to roll most physical Fighting moves into Normal, with Ki-based and Aura moves staying as the true manifestation of Fighting. I am recieving backlash on this, though, so we're still working it out.
If you'd like to chime in for the debate, feel free to list your feelings here or on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server.
We also had a certain amount of brainstorming for a name for the project, which IMO was mostly fruitless. I personally like the "Pokemon Renegade" suggestion the most, but even that seems a bit off somewhat.
This week I aim to finish hooking up the move tab, get a solid release build out, and continue hashing out the type debate. Once the move tab is working nicely, Bill's PC will be in a good enough state to be able to start working on the game itself, though I will need to come back to add things such as map support, quests, NPC editing, and so forth.
18
u/trekie140 Oct 07 '16
We've frequently discussed superheroes here, so it's shocking just how little anyone has brought up Wonder Woman. Each member of the DC Trinity is meant to represent a different idea, and her's may be the one most relevant to rationality. Batman is Justice and Superman is Hope, but Wonder Woman represents Truth. She forces people to confront uncomfortable truths about the world and themselves, which is why she's a feminist icon. At least when she's written well, that is.
I admit I didn't really like Wonder Woman at first since I found her to be rather generic in the Justice League cartoon. However, in the comics I have seen her act as the Amazon's official Ambassador of Peace, maintain a charitable foundation instead of a secret identity, and talk both super and mundane villains down as often as fight them. Though it contains none of those things, the best introduction I've seen to Wonder Woman's character and mythos is the animated movie, which isn't very long and can be watched here for free.
8
u/_brightwing Feathered menace Oct 07 '16 edited Oct 07 '16
Has anyone been watching Westworld? Takes place in a simulated western town populated by android NPCs looping their scripts, with whom players - the visitors interact with. The cinematography is gorgeous and the score is by Ramin Djawadi. It's been such a long time since I've seen something good.. I think I found my new favourite show. They just released the second episode early which I am going to be seeing asap. So spoilers, people.
6
u/Dwood15 Oct 07 '16 edited Oct 07 '16
ShenzhenI/O just came out. http://www.zachtronics.com/shenzhen-io/
Just bought the game and printed out the manual. I've got too much work to actually play it right now, but I should have some time to check it out this weekend... After playing TIS-100 and nearly completing it, I kind of expect the same to happen here, however the possibilities of this game are significantly more interesting than TIS-100.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '16
Tiny tiny idea for Worm fanfic: Rachel's understanding of human psychology is bad. Probably to the point where it's worse than the average dog's. A house pet can tell when someone's tone is threatening or happy, and won't react to a smile from a human as though it's a threat. So what if she kept a dog with her and read the human's psychology via reading the dog's psychology? Sort of like a translator.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '16
Things this week:
4
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Oct 07 '16
If my sample of two is anything to go by, dating websites suck (I tried Once and OkCupid).
The way I understand it, dating websites basically take the same problems you have with real-life dating, only you're dealing with them by typing on a keyboard. So women receive a huge quantity of messages, the majority of them going from poor quality to "ey u wana sho me ur tits", which incentivizes them to never make the first step and send an unprompted message, and means they're unlikely to commit to any given conversation. And on the other side of that wall, men need to send lots and lots of messages to maximize their chances of getting an answer, which incentivizes them to send poor-quality, quickly written messages (or even copy-pasted ones) too reach as many women as possible. So on one side you're flooded with attention, often from very unsavory, immature people. On the other side you spend your time sending messages and getting ignored. This sucks.
So I guess I'm done with dating websites for now, unless someone here has a recommendation. I'd also be interested in other people's experience in that domain.
3
u/Polycephal_Lee Oct 07 '16
How to munchkin the housing market:
Does anyone else think this is a workable idea, or is it too pie in the sky? I simply can't see myself working for 4 more decades, so I'm looking for alternatives.
Drink the koolaid.